How is your new construction going?

How is your new construction going?

Johnathan TrimbleBusiness Member
Real Estate Agent · Kansas City · Member since 2020 · 19 posts · 59 votes

I have really been wanting to get into new construction. At this point I have flipped around 20 houses and Brrr'd several more. I always hear such mixed things about new construction (same with flipping too though). I would love to hear from some recent smaller builders how things have gone for them and what to expect with tariffs and that affecting price of construction for new build? 

I had a piece of land under contract to build 3 affordable homes on ($275-325k in my market, 3 bed 2 bath with 2 car garage), had the land under contract for pennies, but it was problem after problem discovering the seller did not own the lot behind it like they stated (backed up to another street) and a mortgage had recently been pulled out on it. Retention pond encroached on the lot more than originally anticipated and the very slight slope we learned was needing stim walls put on it, in addition to 2 set of telephone pole easements. We ultimately backed out. 

I would love to hear what peoples strategy has been, what profits have been like, if you went affordable, or luxury, townhouse, multifamily, or single family, and what that experience was like. Any information would be greatly appreciated!

2Reply
56 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
1y

Thanks for posting this. That's a great question (much better than many I've seen on here lately). I flipped my first home in 2008 taking advantage of cheap deals during the last big crash. We did really well at first, but made our mistakes. I had the advantage in that I had been a lender for many years prior to that and my wife's degree was in a construction/design-related field, so we had a lot of things going for us. Over time, we went into new construction of SFRs. My lending company also started financing them, so we've seen it from a lot of other investor/builders' perspectives as well. The cycle for new construction is obviously much much longer. There is more risk and permitting can be a bear. That being said, it's "rarified air" in that fewer people are doing it. I always thought, like you, that affordable housing was where we could make a dent. We found that doing higher-end stuff (not mansions, but $750K - $1.2K) was a sweek spot from a profitability standpoint. At that price, the properties still moved, but there was more margin there. I think a massive key is having the right contractor. Our lending side has 2 investor/borrowers right now that are having to go after their contractors because of scope of work/financial hanky-panky issues. If you ever want to chat and pick my brain, I'm happy to jump on a call some time to discuss the good, bad, and the ugly. I know I wish I had more people to bounce questions off of when we started. Good luck to you. 

See this reply in the discussion

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    1y

    Thanks for posting this. That's a great question (much better than many I've seen on here lately). I flipped my first home in 2008 taking advantage of cheap deals during the last big crash. We did really well at first, but made our mistakes. I had the advantage in that I had been a lender for many years prior to that and my wife's degree was in a construction/design-related field, so we had a lot of things going for us. Over time, we went into new construction of SFRs. My lending company also started financing them, so we've seen it from a lot of other investor/builders' perspectives as well. The cycle for new construction is obviously much much longer. There is more risk and permitting can be a bear. That being said, it's "rarified air" in that fewer people are doing it. I always thought, like you, that affordable housing was where we could make a dent. We found that doing higher-end stuff (not mansions, but $750K - $1.2K) was a sweek spot from a profitability standpoint. At that price, the properties still moved, but there was more margin there. I think a massive key is having the right contractor. Our lending side has 2 investor/borrowers right now that are having to go after their contractors because of scope of work/financial hanky-panky issues. If you ever want to chat and pick my brain, I'm happy to jump on a call some time to discuss the good, bad, and the ugly. I know I wish I had more people to bounce questions off of when we started. Good luck to you. 

    • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Doug Smith:

      Thanks for posting this. That's a great question (much better than many I've seen on here lately). I flipped my first home in 2008 taking advantage of cheap deals during the last big crash. We did really well at first, but made our mistakes. I had the advantage in that I had been a lender for many years prior to that and my wife's degree was in a construction/design-related field, so we had a lot of things going for us. Over time, we went into new construction of SFRs. My lending company also started financing them, so we've seen it from a lot of other investor/builders' perspectives as well. The cycle for new construction is obviously much much longer. There is more risk and permitting can be a bear. That being said, it's "rarified air" in that fewer people are doing it. I always thought, like you, that affordable housing was where we could make a dent. We found that doing higher-end stuff (not mansions, but $750K - $1.2K) was a sweek spot from a profitability standpoint. At that price, the properties still moved, but there was more margin there. I think a massive key is having the right contractor. Our lending side has 2 investor/borrowers right now that are having to go after their contractors because of scope of work/financial hanky-panky issues. If you ever want to chat and pick my brain, I'm happy to jump on a call some time to discuss the good, bad, and the ugly. I know I wish I had more people to bounce questions off of when we started. Good luck to you. 


      I am with Doug on this one  move up market semi custom works well for us.

      ivyridgeestatescanby.com is my current 90 home project  started a few years ago with beginning prices at 550 to 650  we are at the tail end and we are basically 675k to 1 mil . 2k to 2500sq ft . the reason we did well is our competition is reginal or national builders at 100k or more less than us for same sq ft.. but no where near teh quaity and they would not allow customization other than the 3 choices of finishs no substitution we allowed folks to go wild and of course we charged for it.. so we got 20 to 100k in uprades on top of it with 100% mark up on upgrades ..  

      Currently broke ground on 6 F st charleston SC going to go out at 875k ish  1800 sq ft.. I built 20 F st right down the way and that sold 6 years ago for 500k.. Charleston is great city for infill.  Even though I do a ton of bizz in KC I have not tried new builds I cant see how i can compete the locals build so cheap .. The nice thing about a city like KC is lots are all over the place you can roll into town and buy a few lots that will work in a matter of hours.. Charleston it took me 18 months to finally land 6 F st.. that was after building 5 to 6 new builds a year their for 8 years then 2 years ago lots went into the stratosphere.. I paid 250k for 6F st.. 20 F street I paid 80k for.. 

      but its a natural progression and I highly encourage you to give it a go if you can make it all work.. 
  • Cassidy BurnsBusiness Member
    Investor · Alexandria, VA · Member since 2016 · 863 posts · 460 votes
    1y

    @Jay Hinrichs great insights. Just looked up both projects.  

    What are you currently building at price / SQ FT in CHS? 

    We have our 1st spec build going on now in Augusta County, VA, this is our market we typically buy fix & flips / a large portion of our multifamily portfolio. We are currently negotiating on 3 infill lots in a community in our market, along the I-81 Corridor. Each lot is around $70k, assuming we will get each lot for $65k, our outsells for each is $495k. Approved layouts in this community at 2,400-2,600 SQ FT. We are underwriting at $150/SQ FT to build.

    My question is, with new development and 1-3 offs, are you operating at lower margins? WE standardly only purchase interior cosmetic flips at 18%+ All in MARGIn.  

    • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
      1y
      Quote from @Cassidy Burns:

      @Jay Hinrichs great insights. Just looked up both projects.  

      What are you currently building at price / SQ FT in CHS? 

      We have our 1st spec build going on now in Augusta County, VA, this is our market we typically buy fix & flips / a large portion of our multifamily portfolio. We are currently negotiating on 3 infill lots in a community in our market, along the I-81 Corridor. Each lot is around $70k, assuming we will get each lot for $65k, our outsells for each is $495k. Approved layouts in this community at 2,400-2,600 SQ FT. We are underwriting at $150/SQ FT to build.

      My question is, with new development and 1-3 offs, are you operating at lower margins? WE standardly only purchase interior cosmetic flips at 18%+ All in MARGIn.  


      whats 1- 3 offs mean ?   new construction profits generally are 10% of gross to 20% with 12 to 15% being quite common. Of course returns vary as to leverage and cost of capital.  So if you can put up 70 cash for the lot finance the rest make 15% on 500k thats 75K net or double your money cash on cash hopefully within in 1 year which is generally our time frame.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.