Hi y’all!! Newbie investor here 😬 I want to make sure I’m running my numbers correctly.
Listing Price: $74,900
Down Payment: 25%= $18,975
Monthly Expenses: $700/month
So my ROI is:
cash flow = 1400-700= 700x12(for the year)= 8400
8400 divided by 18975 = .442 x 100 = 44.2%
Am I getting this correct? In a perfect world.. this would be a great investment right? Thank you in advance!!
I’m assuming expenses include mortgage, taxes, insurance, vacancy, maintenance, capex, etc. There is no rehab to be conducted? A mortgage of around 50K is difficult to get for many lenders.
@Kenneth Garrett yes, the only thing I did not include was renovation costs because I’m not sure what that would be at the moment. The property is in great condition and just needs cosmetic work.
@Kenneth Garrett I’m not sure what capex is though?
Capex is for major improvements and the life span of large ticket items. Everything has an expiration date. Roof, furnace, a/c, etc. You can also calculate kitchen and bath renovation that would need to be done in 10 years. You might use 10% for an average number. If the roof only has 5 years left you would increase that number to cover the repair.
@Kenneth Garrett got it, thank you!!
Rookie as well, but I would include closing costs such as inspection, appraisal, title fees, anything else you pay as the buyer in your state. Regardless that would appear really solid! Maybe search around for a few other sources to estimate rent, is that actually what they're getting or is that proforma after some type of repairs/rent increase? NY has a cap on rental increase per year, right? So, are there tenants paying less than that, when does their lease/s end, and can you even increase the rent to $1,400 with them still there or do you need to wait?
With that said, if you're confident it'll rent for $1,400 once you put new tenants in then biting that bullet for a great deal most likely is worthwhile to you in the end.
@Nick Cafaro it’s a duplex, $1400 would be the combined income. It’s also the lower end of the rents. Other places in the area with similar sizes are renting for $775-$850. I just used $700 to do the numbers. I will definitely include more numbers though. Thank you!!
@Xiomara Davila what is your COC (Cash on cash ) ?
@Montez B. in this example it would be 44% because she included the mortgage payment in the monthly expenses
@Montez B. roughly $8100/yr
@Chris C. Thank you!
Your expense numbers are too low for a duplex. At that rent price for a duplex, the 50% rule is likely fairly accurate to slightly aggressive, but does include PM.
The calculations are only as accurate as the numbers used in the calculations. In this case the calculations appear fine, but the numbers used in those calculations are too aggressive.
Cap ex/maintenance should not be a percentage of rent as it is not primarily a function of the rent but the features (bathrooms, detached vs attached, root type, foundation type, yard, hardscape, etc.). In this case there are two kitchens. My cap ex/maintenance per kitchen is $50/month on small rental size kitchens. In my pro forma, the kitchens maintenance/cap ex alone would be $100/month.
50% rule: $1.4k - $700 (expenses) - $165 (P&I, 30 year 3.25%) = $535. $535/2 = $267/unit not including mortgage paydown, tax advantages, etc. $535 * 12 = $6420.
$6420/$18725 (note there will be closing costs, maybe points) = 34%.
If you want to be more conservative, run the numbers at 55% expense ratio
Question: is it worth it to you to have 2 units at $267/month per unit cash flow (I would pass if this was expected to be the primary source of long term return)? What is the appreciation (property and rent) outlook?
I suspect a lot of new investors would be quite happy with this investment if these accurately reflect the reality.
Free eBook from BiggerPockets!
Join BiggerPockets and get The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing for FREE - read by more than 100,000 people - AND get exclusive real estate investing tips, tricks and techniques delivered straight to your inbox twice weekly!
- Actionable advice for getting started,
- Discover the 10 Most Lucrative Real Estate Niches,
- Learn how to get started with or without money,
- Explore Real-Life Strategies for Building Wealth,
- And a LOT more.
Sign up below to download the eBook for FREE today!
We hate spam just as much as you