Where to reinvest 1031 exch funds?

Where to reinvest 1031 exch funds?

Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes

Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?

4Reply
115 views

Most Popular Reply

Investor · CO · Member since 2016 · 757 posts · 1k+ votes
2y

@K S.

That would depend on my goals and strategy.

For me, its scaling up into the multi family. If there is nothing on market that will meet the timelines, then I look for SFR in good area for appreciation and that meet my return metrics.

See this reply in the discussion

27 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jake AndronicoBusiness Member
    Realtor · Reno, NV · Member since 2019 · 1k+ posts · 938 votes
    2y

    @K.S.

    Are you outside of the 45-day window? 

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2y

    Need a little more info for good advice…

    Is it too late to do a cash out refi instead of selling?

    How much capital gains tax and depreciation recapture tax are you facing if you don’t do the 1031?

    How much time is left in your 45 day ID period?

    You forgot to put your location in your profile or your post. Is this a good time to buy a property in a no income state that you could eventually retire too?

    And lastly what’s your net selling price (the amount you’ll have to buy to avoid all taxes)and how much cash will you receive from the sale (your required downpayment to avoid any taxes.)

    Ps. If you’d owe a lot if you didn’t do a 1031 you could always do a partial 1031 but every penny you don’t reinvest will be taxed, not a pro-ration. Otherwise yet you can do a cash out refi the day after you close. 

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y

    Thanks Jake&Bill,

    Closing within the next month (TX). I think taxes are $63,000. Reinvesting in CA.
    Federal Taxes at sale: = $50,000 + depreciation recapture of $13,000. 

    That's 330k(sale price) -120k(cost basis) -30k(closing costs) = 180,000 x .28). Depreciation recapture is $13,000. That's 51,000 in depreciation deductions x.25%

    I can't remember if the $25,000 in renovations to get the home sale ready could be deducted from the taxible income?

    One more thing, last year my taxable income was $-8,000 (negative) but I think this year would be even more due to the renovation. Although I think I'm capped at some of the renovation expenses. I'd have to look at my tax book again to see if I can apply the $25,000 in renovation against the 50k in taxable appreciation and 13k in deprectiation recapture. I just don't know at this moment. Plus there's 6 months of vacancy loss as well.

    Lastly, maybe I can purchase an E car for the $7500 rebate, and maybe dump some cash into a Roth (already maxing out my 401k). Not sure how else to eliminate whatever is left.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2y

    So you’d have to spend $300k including all $180k in cash to avoid any taxes. 

    The $25k is either a rental expense this year or a cap ex that would be added to your basis. Either way you save the taxes. 

    The 28% tax bracket seems high if your taxable income was negative last year. The capital gains tax rate should be 15%, is the other 13% assumed state income tax? Maybe you’d only be $27k federal plus $13k recapture or even less?

    In September I did a 1031 to avoid $63k in taxes even though it involved spending $600k. So if you’re really over $60k and can find a $400k property that works it’s probably a good deal. 

    Ps. Are you already a CA resident? (I ask because doing a 1031 into California if you’re not means they will hold their hand out for the taxes for the rest of your life. Even if you exchange out of California…)

  • Specialist · Portland, OR · Member since 2010 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    I was in a similar situation unable to find the property type I had planned on so sunk the money into an almost new (6 months old) quality and saleable condo.

    You could also exchange it into land in a different location and then trade it to a builder for a property already built. Unfortunately having something built to exchange into probably might not work because building can get hung up forcing you to close before completion which is a non starter.

    I figure my condo is good trading material down the road and in the meantime a good rental.

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Bill B.:

    So you’d have to spend $300k including all $180k in cash to avoid any taxes. 

    The $25k is either a rental expense this year or a cap ex that would be added to your basis. Either way you save the taxes. 

    The 28% tax bracket seems high if your taxable income was negative last year. The capital gains tax rate should be 15%, is the other 13% assumed state income tax? Maybe you’d only be $27k federal plus $13k recapture or even less?

    In September I did a 1031 to avoid $63k in taxes even though it involved spending $600k. So if you’re really over $60k and can find a $400k property that works it’s probably a good deal. 

    Ps. Are you already a CA resident? (I ask because doing a 1031 into California if you’re not means they will hold their hand out for the taxes for the rest of your life. Even if you exchange out of California…)

    Oh you're right, $27,000 is 15% of 180,000 + the recapture. Perhaps there's more deductions somewhere like opening a Roth, buying an EV, purchasing Tesla solar panels before the end of the year so I can put it on this years tax deduction but I don't think that will work since I don't think they charge you until installation but I'll have to look into it. Taking the tax hit does sound a lot easier and gives me more flexability.

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Jeff S.:

    I was in a similar situation unable to find the property type I had planned on so sunk the money into an almost new (6 months old) quality and saleable condo.

    You could also exchange it into land in a different location and then trade it to a builder for a property already built. Unfortunately having something built to exchange into probably might not work because building can get hung up forcing you to close before completion which is a non starter.

    I figure my condo is good trading material down the road and in the meantime a good rental.

    Jeff, yeah I could buy a condo with 50% down and break even thus relying on appreciation alone which is fine but risky in todays market. I mean the S&P500 hit 19% this year and has averaged 9.75% since 2006. Meanwhile, a condo might hit 4% (average RE appreciation). So I could be going from one bad investment to another equally bad investment SFH to Condo without much leverage. That's what's bad about equity. It's no good if it's always tied up and illiquid and cashouts at high interest rates. I think taking a tax hit could be better than breaking even on a property that might stay flat for years. Selling again would trigger another 30k in closing fees and I wouldn't be able to do a cash out for years at 4% appreciation per year. Correct me if I'm missing something. If I do, I would need to choose a taxless state (thanks for reminding me). Since I'm selling my TX home, I would need to purchase another property in a taxless state like TX or FL. Both are through the roof in prices but at least Austin is top on the list of price declines. So maybe in 6 months we might see bigger drops. I guess I'll wait until the last hour to make my decision based on available land and property prices in TX or FL. 
  • Investor · Washington, DC · Member since 2017 · 428 posts · 205 votes
    2y
    Quote from @K S.:
    Quote from @Bill B.:

    So you’d have to spend $300k including all $180k in cash to avoid any taxes. 

    The $25k is either a rental expense this year or a cap ex that would be added to your basis. Either way you save the taxes. 

    The 28% tax bracket seems high if your taxable income was negative last year. The capital gains tax rate should be 15%, is the other 13% assumed state income tax? Maybe you’d only be $27k federal plus $13k recapture or even less?

    In September I did a 1031 to avoid $63k in taxes even though it involved spending $600k. So if you’re really over $60k and can find a $400k property that works it’s probably a good deal. 

    Ps. Are you already a CA resident? (I ask because doing a 1031 into California if you’re not means they will hold their hand out for the taxes for the rest of your life. Even if you exchange out of California…)

    Oh you're right, $27,000 is 15% of 180,000 + the recapture. Perhaps there's more deductions somewhere like opening a Roth, buying an EV, purchasing Tesla solar panels before the end of the year so I can put it on this years tax deduction but I don't think that will work since I don't think they charge you until installation but I'll have to look into it. Taking the tax hit does sound a lot easier and gives me more flexability.


    Regarding your solar comment - "Residential Clean Energy Credit... You must claim the credit for the tax year when the property [solar] is installed, not merely purchased."  https://www.irs.gov/credits-deductions/residential-clean-ene...

    Also not sure what area you are in, but I'd recommend looking into better quality panels... Google SunPower or REC and compare their panel efficiency, warranty, etc to Tesla/SolarCity.. Happy to help point you in the right direction of a good quality solar installer, if you aren't in my area. 

  • Specialist · Portland, OR · Member since 2010 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    @Kelsy Soderlund your tax bill not too bad. Like they say don't let the tax tail wag the dog.

  • Professional · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2014 · 876 posts · 301 votes
    2y
    Quote from @K S.:

    Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

    I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

    If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?

    Hi K.S. if you are an accredited investor who is seeking to defer your capital gains tax there is an established industry supporting investors with goals like yours. We help real estate investors re-invest their 1031 Exchange proceeds into an investment product called a DST. This is my field. Happy to answer any questions, feel free to check out my blog on BP for more information.

    https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/7993/73151-what-a...

  • Specialist · Scottsdale, AZ · Member since 2014 · 626 posts · 700 votes
    2y

    @K S. if you cannot find a suitable 1031 replacement property, keep in mind an alternative strategy is to seek a passive investment with bonus depreciation. This is an accelerated depreciation strategy sometimes referred to as "the lazy 1031" that combines cost segregation and bonus depreciation. Instead of completing a 1031 exchange with short time restrictions, the bonus depreciation strategy allows investors to take a significant passive loss, which is used to offset gains, and one of the best parts of the strategy is you have the entire calendar year to execute.

    Those passive losses can be used to offset the gains you have incurred (or gains you expect to incur) as long as the gain AND the investment where bonus depreciation is being taken occur in the same calendar year. Any allocation of passive losses you cannot use in that calendar year will carry over, so they can be used in subsequent years.

    Keep in mind, some property types will garner more bonus depreciation than others. Bonus depreciation is derived from the portion of the property's value with a shorter useful life than the buildings themselves. Therefore the property types that are the most favorable to generate bonus depreciation will be those with a high degree of what the tax code refers to as "land improvements". Examples are mobile home parks, RV parks, and golf courses where the value of the property is not primarily derived from building(s) but rather from the improvements to the land. In a mobile home park or RV park, most of the value is in the underground infrastructure, roads, landscaping, amenities, pools, fencing, pads, utility pedestals, etc, while only a small portion of the value comes from a building, like a clubhouse or laundry facility. In a similar fashion, if you can imagine how much landscaping and underground infrastructure is in a golf course as compared to the clubhouse, that will give an indication of why an extremely high percentage of the property's value is allocated to the land improvements. Properly executed, an investment in these types of property can garner significant passive losses, sometimes equal to the amount of capital invested, even in years where the 100% is beginning to sunset.

    As also mentioned in this thread, a few words of caution; be careful not to let the "tax tail" wag the dog. Each real estate type has different intrinsic performance characteristics, so make sure you understand the property type's risks and potential as an investment, separate of the tax benefit. In other words, be careful not to invest in a poorly performing property simply for the depreciation. In that same vein, if you are investing passively in a syndication for bonus depreciation benefits make sure you vet the sponsor and understand the investment vehicle before you invest. Bonus depreciation is great, but when you combine that with the right kind of investment properties that produce cash flow and appreciate, that will be the wining formula.

    Disclaimer: I am not a tax advisor or CPA. This perspective is solely from years of experience managing mobile home park funds and working with the tax experts around us. 

    All the best,

    Jack

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Leslie Pappas:
    Quote from @K S.:

    Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

    I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

    If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?

    Hi K.S. if you are an accredited investor who is seeking to defer your capital gains tax there is an established industry supporting investors with goals like yours. We help real estate investors re-invest their 1031 Exchange proceeds into an investment product called a DST. This is my field. Happy to answer any questions, feel free to check out my blog on BP for more information.

    https://www.biggerpockets.com/member-blogs/7993/73151-what-a...

    I skimmed through it but meh. The trust has a hold date with no info on the termination date. That means it's even more illiquid. Not good for trying to raise funds for a build out. There's no returns specified which leads me to believe they're hiding it for a reason but despite that, my CPA will probably charge me more for the extra complexity. Anything that can't be explained very simply with full transparency is a red flag. Especially considering that some sponsor that you don't personally know is responsible for your investment. 

  • Professional · Millbrae, CA · Member since 2016 · 26 posts · 16 votes
    2y
    Quote from @K S.:

    Thanks Jake&Bill,

    Closing within the next month (TX). I think taxes are $63,000. Reinvesting in CA.
    Federal Taxes at sale: = $50,000 + depreciation recapture of $13,000. 

    That's 330k(sale price) -120k(cost basis) -30k(closing costs) = 180,000 x .28). Depreciation recapture is $13,000. That's 51,000 in depreciation deductions x.25%

    I can't remember if the $25,000 in renovations to get the home sale ready could be deducted from the taxible income?

    One more thing, last year my taxable income was $-8,000 (negative) but I think this year would be even more due to the renovation. Although I think I'm capped at some of the renovation expenses. I'd have to look at my tax book again to see if I can apply the $25,000 in renovation against the 50k in taxable appreciation and 13k in deprectiation recapture. I just don't know at this moment. Plus there's 6 months of vacancy loss as well.

    Lastly, maybe I can purchase an E car for the $7500 rebate, and maybe dump some cash into a Roth (already maxing out my 401k). Not sure how else to eliminate whatever is left.


     Your taxable income outside of this will be negative? Is that what you are saying in your posts?

    It is possible a significant part of your capital gain might be taxable at a 0% tax rate for federal income tax, then the remainder at 15%. You might not want to avoid that. But don't forget state income taxes.

    The car credit is not refundable. If you have no tax liability, it's not going to help.

    You really need to run a projection.

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Michael Lynch:
    Quote from @K S.:

    Thanks Jake&Bill,

    Closing within the next month (TX). I think taxes are $63,000. Reinvesting in CA.
    Federal Taxes at sale: = $50,000 + depreciation recapture of $13,000. 

    That's 330k(sale price) -120k(cost basis) -30k(closing costs) = 180,000 x .28). Depreciation recapture is $13,000. That's 51,000 in depreciation deductions x.25%

    I can't remember if the $25,000 in renovations to get the home sale ready could be deducted from the taxible income?

    One more thing, last year my taxable income was $-8,000 (negative) but I think this year would be even more due to the renovation. Although I think I'm capped at some of the renovation expenses. I'd have to look at my tax book again to see if I can apply the $25,000 in renovation against the 50k in taxable appreciation and 13k in deprectiation recapture. I just don't know at this moment. Plus there's 6 months of vacancy loss as well.

    Lastly, maybe I can purchase an E car for the $7500 rebate, and maybe dump some cash into a Roth (already maxing out my 401k). Not sure how else to eliminate whatever is left.


     Your taxable income outside of this will be negative? Is that what you are saying in your posts?

    It is possible a significant part of your capital gain might be taxable at a 0% tax rate for federal income tax, then the remainder at 15%. You might not want to avoid that. But don't forget state income taxes.

    The car credit is not refundable. If you have no tax liability, it's not going to help.

    You really need to run a projection.

    My tax home is TX so I won't pay CA state tax.
    Oh I thought the 63k taxable income could also be knocked down with more expenses. If that's what you're getting at.
  • Investor · CO · Member since 2016 · 757 posts · 1k+ votes
    2y

    @K S.

    That would depend on my goals and strategy.

    For me, its scaling up into the multi family. If there is nothing on market that will meet the timelines, then I look for SFR in good area for appreciation and that meet my return metrics.

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y

    Nobody mentioned UPREITS. Anyone do this? The money is more liquid as in I can take it out when needed. i.e. split it up over two or more years and pay much less to no tax.

  • Morris County, NJ · Member since 2020 · 5k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    2y

    @K S.

    Well, DST's were mentioned... I know they have some DST's where they "park" funds and don't get much of a return. But, they you take them out when you find something. One way to buy time instead of buying a bad deal. But, stil not sure how that helps you access the funds for your build. But, it shouldn't cause more consternation from your accountant --- well, mine is fully aware of them and they provide them as an additional service..

    Funny you mentioned upREIT.  I was just mentioning that in another post.  I never investigated it fully since I didn't think I had anyhting ot offer.  However, my understanding of the mechanics is the reit purchased the property via 1031 and you receive shares (or whatever its called for this structure).  The, you sell off your shares getting your money and leaving the tax liability behind.

    Do you have any capital assets to tax loss harvest against the depreciation (if you don't do the 1031)?

    Was your property still in 'service" when you reno'ed?  If it was, it the reno costs might have to be depreciated, so you don't get the deduction.  But, if you can claim the property was out of service (e.g. the tenant was out and you were no longer renting it), then is should be applied to your cost basis.  Of course, consult a tax professional.

  • Sean O'KeefePro Member
    CPA | Accepting new clients | 50 States · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 871 votes
    2y

    In a like-kind property

  • Financial Advisor · San Juan Capistrano, CA · Member since 2024 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    2y

    @David M.

    As it relates to 721 UpREITs, I always say the opportunity itself is only as good as the underlying REIT that's acquiring you. Assuming the REIT is strong, the 721-UpREIT structure comes with many attractive features/benefits that appeal to investors today. Here are a couple of articles that outline the cons/pros of 721 UpREITs.

    https://perchwealth.sharefile.com/d-s556dbdb44b3b436c93a0ce1... 

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @David M.:

    @K S.

    Well, DST's were mentioned... I know they have some DST's where they "park" funds and don't get much of a return. But, they you take them out when you find something. One way to buy time instead of buying a bad deal. But, stil not sure how that helps you access the funds for your build. But, it shouldn't cause more consternation from your accountant --- well, mine is fully aware of them and they provide them as an additional service..

    Funny you mentioned upREIT.  I was just mentioning that in another post.  I never investigated it fully since I didn't think I had anyhting ot offer.  However, my understanding of the mechanics is the reit purchased the property via 1031 and you receive shares (or whatever its called for this structure).  The, you sell off your shares getting your money and leaving the tax liability behind.

    Do you have any capital assets to tax loss harvest against the depreciation (if you don't do the 1031)?

    Was your property still in 'service" when you reno'ed?  If it was, it the reno costs might have to be depreciated, so you don't get the deduction.  But, if you can claim the property was out of service (e.g. the tenant was out and you were no longer renting it), then is should be applied to your cost basis.  Of course, consult a tax professional.

    Yes tenant was out when I did the 25k renovation but that finished in late december and the house is closing in a few days in January, so that's last year. Pretty crappy timing. 
  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Benjamin Carmona:

    @David M.

    As it relates to 721 UpREITs, I always say the opportunity itself is only as good as the underlying REIT that's acquiring you. Assuming the REIT is strong, the 721-UpREIT structure comes with many attractive features/benefits that appeal to investors today. Here are a couple of articles that outline the cons/pros of 721 UpREITs.

    https://perchwealth.sharefile.com/d-s556dbdb44b3b436c93a0ce1... 

    Sounds like the 721 UPREIT requires me to sell my home to the UpREIT in exch for shares. So nobody has done this? 
  • Financial Advisor · San Juan Capistrano, CA · Member since 2024 · 4 posts · 0 votes
    2y

    @ K S.

    If you have 1031 exchanage proceeds (presumably from sale if investment property) that you are looking to invest, you can invest in DSTs that are predetermined or designed to get acquired by a REIT via 721-UpREIT. For example, Cantor Fitzgerald, an investment sponsor/syndicator, currently has a 721-UpREIT structured multifmily DST offering avaialble for investment. An investor who invests in this multifamily DST today goes into the investment knowing that in 2-3 years, Cantor Fitzgerald's 1B+ private REIT intends to buy the DST at which point investor ownership interests in the DST are converted to common shares of the underlying REIT. This is an attractive strategy for many investors today as the REITs provide for greater diversification, typically more income, and also enhanced liquidity optionality.

    We have and continue to invest capital in 721-UpREIT structured DST offerings. Happy to discuss further if interested. Thanks.



  • Real Estate Consultant · Cleveland · Member since 2020 · 6k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    2y
    Quote from @K S.:

    Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

    I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

    If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?


     Buy rental properties. I know someone buying 4 SF with 10% net caps, about 425k, 

  • Attorney · Columbus, OH · Member since 2023 · 193 posts · 145 votes
    2y
    Quote from @K S.:

    Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

    I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

    If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?


     I'd connect with a team that specializes in bringing off-market deals to investors. That way you can roll your equity into another cash flowing asset and push off paying the capital gains tax.

  • Member since 2021 · 401 posts · 254 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Jason Allen:
    Quote from @K S.:

    Looking for ways to turn this into non taxable cash or just purchase something to avoid taxes.

    I'm on my second 1031 exch but later found out that I can't use the funds to improve on already purchased land so I'm a little stuck finding something to purchase to avoid the hit on taxes and at the same time assist with the build if possible. I could purchase a condo and pull cash out using a HELOC?

    If there's nothing one can do, would you just buy more land in cash to build on later or a small shack in the mountains for a 2 ADU Duplex build. Any advice?


     I'd connect with a team that specializes in bringing off-market deals to investors. That way you can roll your equity into another cash flowing asset and push off paying the capital gains tax.

    Does off market mean cheaper?. Could just be avoiding his x wife. But agreed, I asked my agent already. I'm probably off base here but DSTs give me time share vibes.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.