What’s Your Exit Strategy Before You Buy?

Question

Do you lock in your exit plan before making an offer, or adjust after acquisition?

Jules Aton · Answer

Mine is a bit more rudimentary than @Joe Villeneuve but same principle. I haven’t ever done anything business or personally that didn't have an easy out if needed. With RE I always buy in the best neighborhoods I can afford which usually means compromising on condition but provides near immediate equity upon reno. I will keep it as long as it is cash flowing and not annoying me or until the latest seller’s market is too sweet to resist.

Francisco Centeno · Answer

I'm a real estate agent that mostly help multi-family investor buy rentals, but this is my opinion.

When I talk to investors, I keep it simple and focus on two main rules before purchasing an investing property:

1. The deal should produce at least a 10% cash-on-cash return.

2. Run the numbers that in the worst case scenario if you have to sell, the property is still going to make you money. Your exit strategy should start the moment a deal begins to make sense in all aspects (most of the time) — whether it’s for flipping, renting, or holding for appreciation.

At the end of the day, the numbers determine everything and are what get you to your goals.
Let me know what you think!

At the end of the day, the numbers determine everything and are what get you to your goals.

Let me know what you think!

Bo Smith · Answer

I lock it in before I make the offer. That's the foundation of the whole deal. If I don't know how I'm getting out, I shouldn't be getting in.

For me, exit planning is about optionality. I ask three questions upfront: Can I flip this in 12-18 months if the market shifts? Can I hold and rent it for reasonable cash flow? Can I wholesale it if neither of those work? If I can only do one of those things, the deal has to be exceptional, because I'm betting on one outcome.

In markets where I buy, I know my rental comps and my rehab-to-sell comparables beforehand. I know what a clean resale will bring and what a tenant will pay. That's my math before I ever make an offer. I've seen too many people buy hoping the market will carry them or that "it'll work somehow." It doesn't. Markets turn, carrying costs add up, and hope isn't a strategy.

Where most people get burned is by buying in the wrong neighborhood or overpaying for a property where the exit numbers don't work. You can fix a bad rehab. You can't fix a bad location or a bad purchase price. Those are baked in from day one.

Are you buying in a market where you have good renter demand, or are you more focused on the flip exit?

Kenneth Garrett · Answer

@Kelly Schroeder

I think most of us have defined ourselves as a certain investor: flipper, buy n hold, BRRRR, House Hacker, etc.  when you are evaluating property it’s generally from that lens.  It’s always a good thing to have multiple exit strategies.  You might plan on flipping a property or renting it, but by the time the rehab finished maybe the market shifted and you have to adjust to a different exit strategy.  Always have a plan B, but you need to know your exit strategy when making offers.

Joe Villeneuve · Answer

Locked in.  Always the same:  1 - Buy cash flow with minimum DP (my cost). This is also the equity I buy.2 - Sell property when 2 things occur -   a - Equity from appreciation equals equity I paid for (DP).  b - Cash flow has recovered my cost (DP).

This is the point when the property is at its maximum value.  From this point forward, the property loses money if I don't sell.

Pavel Voroniuk · Answer

I try to define at least two viable exits before making an offer.

For a flip, I’ll look at:

• Recent renovated comps that actually closed (not just asking prices)

• Days on market and price reductions

• Whether I could refinance and hold if resale demand softens

For a buy-and-hold, I’ll ask:

• What cap rate would this trade at if I had to sell in 3–5 years?

• What does the valuation look like if I assume modest or even flat NOI growth instead of aggressive rent increases?

• Is there enough buyer depth at this price point?

I don’t lock into one outcome, but I want the secondary exit to survive conservative assumptions — especially around NOI growth, cap rates, and time on market. If the deal only works under optimistic projections, I usually pass.

Bo Smith · Answer

Always locked in before the offer. If I don't know how I'm exiting in advance, I don't make an offer. For flips, that's pretty straightforward -- estimate ARV, buy at 70% minus hold costs, execute the flip. But even there you need a backup plan. What if you can't sell in month 4? Can you carry it another month? Rent it out? Wholesale it?

For rentals I'm more flexible. I buy in the best neighborhoods I can afford because appreciation and renter quality matter. If a property is cash flowing 300 bucks a month but it's in a neighborhood that's appreciating, I'm fine holding it 10 years. If it's cash flowing 300 bucks and the neighborhood is stagnant, I have a lower bar for selling if the right offer comes in.

The key is being intentional. Don't buy a property and then figure out what to do with it. Know your thesis before you bid. Is this a cash flow play? Appreciation play? Rehab and flip? Long-term hold? They all have different offer prices, different financing needs, different exit timelines. I've made mistakes buying properties that "seemed good" without a clear thesis, and they usually underperform because I'm not optimizing for what they should be.

What's pushing you to define exit strategy? Are you worried about having too much capital tied up in illiquid deals?

Divin Kanyama · Answer

That's an excellent question, @Kelly Schroeder. I make it a priority to establish an exit plan or plans early on, usually during the initial due diligence stage of property analysis. It's always wise to have a backup plan or exit strategy ready in case circumstances change unexpectedly.

Spence W. · Answer

I always lock in the exit plan before making an offer, but my first step is making sure the property data actually supports that plan. As an out-of-state investor looking at the Midwest, I've found the biggest risk to any exit strategy is information asymmetry.

Before I even submit an offer, I spend about 30 minutes pulling county assessor records, checking HUD status, and searching EPA environmental databases. In Kansas City, I've caught major square footage discrepancies and unpermitted additions listed as extra bedrooms just by comparing listings to county data.

Your agent and PM aren't going to pull these public records for you. If you don't verify the baseline data yourself, your exit strategy could easily get derailed by a city compliance issue or an undisclosed environmental hazard. What's your process for verifying a property's background before locking in your plan?

What’s Your Exit Strategy Before You Buy?

Most Popular Reply