The landlord lesson I didn’t expect to learn from a hurricane…

The landlord lesson I didn’t expect to learn from a hurricane…

Lender · Tampa/Saint Petersburg, FL · Member since 2014 · 356 posts · 148 votes


Two years ago, hurricanes rolled through in Florida and we had damage at a couple of our properties.

We had insurance, so obviously we filed a claim and figured that was what insurance was there for.

Insurance paid out on one of the properties and unfortunately, two years later and insurance still hasn’t paid out on the one that had the most damage. 

No, the properties are not in a flood zone. Yes, we hired a public adjuster. And yes, it’s now in the legal process. Hopefully it eventually gets resolved.

But in the meantime, the property doesn’t just wait around while you fight with insurance. Repairs still need to happen, bills still need to get paid, tenants still need a functioning property.

And that’s probably been one of my biggest lessons as an investor of why reserves are SO important.

It’s really easy when analyzing a deal to want every dollar working. Especially when you’re growing. I remember thinking cash sitting in an account wasn’t really doing anything for me.

After this experience, I feel very differently now and always need to have heavy reserves. 

Sometimes the emergency isn’t even the expensive part. It’s how LONG you may have to carry the expense before getting reimbursed… assuming you get reimbursed at all.

So when a lender requires reserves, or when you’re deciding how much cash to keep after closing, don’t automatically look at that money as wasted capital, it's not. 

Curious for the other investors here, is having enough reserves something you thought about before buying your first property or did you learn the importance of them after something went wrong?

2Reply
131 views

2 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
    2mo

    Reserves are part of the game plan.. basically if you are light on those you have an under-capitalized business and under capitalized business's fail all the time.

  • online · Member since 2026 · 99 posts · 45 votes
    2mo

    The timing point is the part people underrate most, you said it well. Everyone models the emergency as a dollar amount, way fewer people model it as a duration, and duration is what actually breaks people, not the number on the invoice.

    To your question, I learned this the boring way rather than the hard way, before ever having an insurance dispute drag on. What clicked for me was realizing a flat reserve number doesn't really capture this either, it's usually sized around "what if something breaks" but not "what if something breaks AND the money to fix it is delayed for months." Two very different numbers. sounds like your properties survived the gap because the reserve was already there before the hurricane, not scrambled together after. That's really the whole argument for having one in the first place, it has to exist before you need it, or it doesn't do its job.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.