Investor · Wolcott, CT · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 9 votes
Real talk. Lots of people talk about cap rate like it's the whole deal. It's not at least not for us.
When we underwrite, we're solving for returns, not a cap rate. 16%+ IRR. 18%+ AAR. 6%+ cash-on-cash. If the deal clears those, we're interested. If it doesn't, the cap rate doesn't save it.
Cap rate tells you what the market thinks today.
It doesn't tell you what the deal does for your investors over five years.
I'm not saying cap rate is useless. I'm saying it's not the decision.
What's the first number YOU look at when you underwrite? And is there a number that'll make you walk away no matter how good the rest looks?
I like how plainly you put it: cap rate tells you what the market thinks today, but it doesn't tell you what the deal will do for your investors over five years. Solving for 16%+ IRR, 18%+ AAR and 6%+ cash-on-cash also makes the conversation with your investors a lot clearer.
I don't underwrite deals myself, so I'll leave the first-number question to the people doing it every week. What I'd add from the operations side is that all three of those returns are only as good as the rent roll and the trailing 12 they're built on. If I were in your shoes, I'd have every seller's T12 and rent roll read side by side before the model is even opened, flagging any unit where the rent on the roll doesn't match the deposits or the lease, and any expense line that jumps from one month to the next. That kind of slow, line-by-line reading is something AI is really good at, and it means the 16% you're solving for is built on numbers you've actually checked.
I do not underwrite to cap rate either. The first number I look at is rent, because rent is what pays the loan. I check the 1% rule first: can a house I buy under $100K rent for close to $1,395 to $1,950 for a 3-bedroom or larger on Section 8? Then I check ARV, $180K to $265K on my Memphis single-family deals, and DSCR at 70 to 80% LTV. If the rent does not clear those, the cap rate does not save it. The number that makes me walk away is a rent that only works if everything goes right. I want a deal that still works with a vacancy and a repair in the same year. Deal flow is the bottleneck, not finding a cap rate to justify a bad deal.
Solving for investor returns first makes sense, and on the lender side of this the first number is the one sitting under all three of yours, the debt service coverage ratio. That's the property's income divided by the loan payment at the rate the deal can actually get. Most DSCR lenders want somewhere around 1.0 to 1.25, and if the deal falls short they commonly size the loan down until it fits. So if your model pencils in a rate lower than what lenders quote when you're actually closing, the loan shrinks, more equity has to come in and your cash-on-cash takes the hit. The hard stop at a lot of the programs I see is coverage under 1.0, and the few that go below it cut the leverage. Your return targets are only as solid as the debt assumption behind them. What rate are you penciling in for the debt?
Willie, agreed that cap rate isn't the decision. I just land somewhere different.
On value-add storage I don't care much about going-in cap rate either. Some of the best deals look ugly on today's numbers because of bad management, below-market rents, or empty units nobody is marketing.
What I solve for is stabilized value. What does this place net once it's full at market rents and run properly? My max offer is 75% of that. The gap is my cushion if lease-up takes longer than I hoped.
IRR targets are fine, but they're only as honest as the exit assumptions behind them. What exit cap are you plugging in to get that 16%?