Westbury, NY · Member since 2017 · 30 posts · 13 votes
I just finished watching the webinar, "How to Buy Your First Duplex, Triplex, and Fourplex!" in which Brandon comments that collecting the rent in cash was "stupid." Can anyone enlighten me on why collecting the rent in cash would be bad?
I have never turned down cash that was owed me. The paper trail is only something the tenant needs. If I landlord claims he did not get the rent. Makes no difference to bookkeeping if it is cash or check.
I have accepted cash, but I tell tenants I don't prefer it. Money orders are the #1 way that people pay me. Electronic via Cozy is the #2 way. I am hopeful that someday electronic will become #1, but I work with lower-income tenants and not all of them have bank accounts.
Thanks @Tom Gimer and @Scott Weaner for input on E-Rent Payment. We were unaffected- however after reviewing things I am going to drop ERentPayment.com and go with Cozy. I really appreciate the heads up.
I still have a number of tenants who will only deal with cash. They would deposit the cash directly into my bank account, but Bank of America no longer accepts cash deposits unless it is the persons own bank account. So now they have to get a money order or I have provided them the means to pay cash at 711 using paynearme.com. I recently discovered that the tenants were getting paid on a prepaid debit card, taking the cash off and putting that money in my account. I use square so I said give me the card number and I can get paid that way, but at a 3.75% fee costs $20 + to pay me rent neither of us want to pay that amount. Paynearme only charges $3.99 to tenant and nothing to me.
There was an instance in the past I heard of where the property management company would go around collecting the rent from those who had not paid yet. Some of these tenants paid a few weeks late but eventually paid.
One tenant always paid late a few weeks but paid in full. The 2nd week went by and nothing. Landlord kept saying they were going to go over and see what was going on. Found out later the property manager TOOK the cash from the tenant and went and paid their own cell phone bill among other things.
The landlord did not find out until they went to the tenants door without telling the property manager and asked about payment. That is when the truth came out.
So paying in cash, check's in the mail, or even certified cashiers check ( some are fake) all can pose big problems.
Even electronic I think how you process payment makes a difference with credit or ACH debit. One the tenant can try to dispute and get reversed.
I guess nothing is 100% fool proof. I do not look at residential investing these days. Too much constant manipulating and games from tenants to deal with.
If you had a big apartment complex you might need an armored car if you collected rent in cash (for example: $800/month*200units=$160,000). I really encourage tenants to pay online, we have a site through Buildium. But I have two retail vapor stores and I will accept cash rent payments at my stores where we have drop safes and a regular deposit schedule.
For me the #1 way I collect rent is through #1 cozy. #2 is check. If you don’t have a bank account then I don’t want you as a tenant. Maybe that line of thinking will change someday but that is where I am at for now.
@Elizabeth Garcia I will take cash, check, cashiers check, money order or electronic payment. In some circumstances cash may be the best option. It is more about knowing how to handle the payment.
- Count the cash while you are standing in front of them. I have been shorted and overpaid once.
- Give them a receipt from a receipt book. You get to keep the carbon copy, so no dispute later.
- Deposit the cash by itself in the bank. Keep the receipt for your records.
- Be smart about where you are picking up cash. There is some robbery risk, so just be smart. My cash goes right to the bank.
- The biggest problem with cash is having to pickup from the tenant. Electronic payment is my first choice out of convenience.
Cash is the most guaranteed payment method. Have you ever seen a business with a “no cash” sign? As long as you handle it properly, there shouldn’t be problems.
@Susan Goldthorp The trouble with PayNearMe is that unless you were grandfathered in, they now require landlords to have a minimum of 100 units, I believe.
@Elizabeth Garcia I will take cash, check, cashiers check, money order or electronic payment. In some circumstances cash may be the best option. It is more about knowing how to handle the payment.
- Count the cash while you are standing in front of them. I have been shorted and overpaid once.
- Give them a receipt from a receipt book. You get to keep the carbon copy, so no dispute later.
- Deposit the cash by itself in the bank. Keep the receipt for your records.
- Be smart about where you are picking up cash. There is some robbery risk, so just be smart. My cash goes right to the bank.
- The biggest problem with cash is having to pickup from the tenant. Electronic payment is my first choice out of convenience.
Cash is the most guaranteed payment method. Have you ever seen a business with a “no cash” sign? As long as you handle it properly, there shouldn’t be problems.
Good points.
I have a number of cash tenants through the years, though now I discourage it. The last one was an excellent tenant of 12 years, and even owned a rental property. He rented from me when he bought a dry cleaners nearby and wanted to have a shorter drive to work.
And for the 1st five years, he bought his rent over in an envelope, with the amount written on the outside, about $1,200 or so, we counted the money at the front door, and issued a receipt. It's usually small bills from his dry cleaners, i.e. 5's, 10's 20's, and it takes a while to count, sometimes more than once. Then for the last 7 years, we trust each other enough, and often she brings it by dinner time, so we don't have time to stop and count it, we would call her later if it's short, or sometimes over.
Then a while back, my younger daughter was in the habit of swiping our money, One morning I counted $1,240 in rent money at the kitchen table, ran out of deposit slips, walked away for a minute to get more, walked back, finished writing the slip, and drove to the bank. After the teller counted the money 3 times, said "sir, you only got $1,200 here". I gave the teller $40.00 from my wallet, called my wife who questioned my daughter who admitted to taking the $40.00.
And collecting rent money habitually in cash exposes you to robbery, see: It was reported that the couple collect rent in cash, had over $5000 rent money, and robbed by people who knew them:
I've been land lording for nearly 40 years, and over a long period, you have to expect accidents and illnesses. Unfortunately both my wife an myself cannot go about our normal business this past winter, me from the lingering aspects of a stroke, and her from pesticide poisoning doing work at one of our rentals. She was hospitalized for a short while. But fortunately we placed current tenants on electronic payment service through ClearNow, and the rents are automatically taken from the tenants account monthly and deposited into ours. We haven't planned on this situation, i.e. being sick, and immobile, but not having to take payments in cash helped a lot.
In view of what happened, we signed up for "FreshDirect" to have groceries delivered, and Uber for rides. I didn't get to installing app on our smartphone to do remote deposits yet, in case we have to deposit checks remotely. One of our current tenants had "insufficient fund" issues, and have to issue replacement checks when ClearNow cannot process the payment.
At least these are the issues I planned on dealing with as an OLD retired landlord.
The risks and hassle don't justify the rewards of taking cash.... I just don't see the upside of doing it. Yes having a big stack of $$ in your hand is a nice feeling vs a check or seeing it online....but the hassle of dealing with a tenant face to face and writing receipts and all that junk isn't worth it...no thanks. I have NO CASH in my lease.....
If you don't have a bank account or half a brain to be able to do it another way, I don't want you as a tenant....I'm not running a drug business here.....