Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

User Stats

5
Posts
1
Votes
Marilyn Bredar
1
Votes |
5
Posts

Private money lending

Marilyn Bredar
Posted

I'm new to RE investing!  I have an opportunity for private money lending.  What would be a reasonable rate of return?  Also, is there any downside to my borrower stretching out for 20 plus years.   I'm so grateful for any and all responses.

  • Marilyn Bredar
  • Most Popular Reply

    User Stats

    669
    Posts
    488
    Votes
    Malcomb Stapel
    • Investor
    • Topeka, KS
    488
    Votes |
    669
    Posts
    Malcomb Stapel
    • Investor
    • Topeka, KS
    Replied
    Quote from @Marilyn Bredar:

    I'm new to RE investing!  I have an opportunity for private money lending.  What would be a reasonable rate of return?  Also, is there any downside to my borrower stretching out for 20 plus years.   I'm so grateful for any and all responses.


     Reasonable rate would depend on your goals. But for short term 1 year or less you could be anywhere in the 10-15% range depending on the deal/risk. Research predatory lending rates and make sure you don't break any rules going too high. As for your second question, yes, 20 years is too long unless it's some sort of slam dunk deal that you can live off of the interest and you don't need to invest the money elsewhere. 

    Think about your money as more transactional, you are lending it out, and you want to see it back in 12 months or less with X amount of return. Your time value of money is important here. 

  • Malcomb Stapel
  • User Stats

    669
    Posts
    488
    Votes
    Malcomb Stapel
    • Investor
    • Topeka, KS
    488
    Votes |
    669
    Posts
    Malcomb Stapel
    • Investor
    • Topeka, KS
    Replied
    Quote from @Marilyn Bredar:

    I'm new to RE investing!  I have an opportunity for private money lending.  What would be a reasonable rate of return?  Also, is there any downside to my borrower stretching out for 20 plus years.   I'm so grateful for any and all responses.


     Reasonable rate would depend on your goals. But for short term 1 year or less you could be anywhere in the 10-15% range depending on the deal/risk. Research predatory lending rates and make sure you don't break any rules going too high. As for your second question, yes, 20 years is too long unless it's some sort of slam dunk deal that you can live off of the interest and you don't need to invest the money elsewhere. 

    Think about your money as more transactional, you are lending it out, and you want to see it back in 12 months or less with X amount of return. Your time value of money is important here. 

  • Malcomb Stapel
  • User Stats

    2,293
    Posts
    2,067
    Votes
    Doug Smith
    • Lender
    • Tampa, FL
    2,067
    Votes |
    2,293
    Posts
    Doug Smith
    • Lender
    • Tampa, FL
    Replied

    You bet...do a 12-month balloon to force the refinance to recoup your money quickly and protect you from interest rate risk in a relatively volatile market. We charge from 10%-12.9% right now depending upon the borrower, project, location, and time frame for us to recoup our money. Of course, you could always turn to a good, experienced lender and broker deals through them with our capital. You can let them originate, underwrite, create the docs, and close the deal and then sell it to you. Many individuals who get into lending miss things in the process and get themselves into trouble. It's how we grew a robust lending practice and it gives the investor/lender a better loan that's more likely to pay and meet their yield expectations. Good luck to you. 

    Steadily logo
    Steadily
    |
    Sponsored
    Need property and liability insurance for your rentals? BP Investors trust Steadily for great rates and tailored coverage for short and long-term rentals.

    User Stats

    21,544
    Posts
    19,061
    Votes
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    19,061
    Votes |
    21,544
    Posts
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    ModeratorReplied

    @Marilyn Bredar

    Just remember if you lend for 20 years basically that money is illiquid for twenty years

    Key to private lending is the term and rate. Biggest mistake peopke make is charging low or below market interest rates. Then they realize they need money for something else and try and sell the note only to find they are offered 50 cents on the dollar because the note was written at low interest rates.

    • Chris Seveney
    business profile image
    7e investments
    5.0 stars
    3 Reviews

    User Stats

    5
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Marilyn Bredar
    1
    Votes |
    5
    Posts
    Marilyn Bredar
    Replied
    Quote from @Malcomb Stapel:
    Quote from @Marilyn Bredar:

    I'm new to RE investing!  I have an opportunity for private money lending.  What would be a reasonable rate of return?  Also, is there any downside to my borrower stretching out for 20 plus years.   I'm so grateful for any and all responses.


     Reasonable rate would depend on your goals. But for short term 1 year or less you could be anywhere in the 10-15% range depending on the deal/risk. Research predatory lending rates and make sure you don't break any rules going too high. As for your second question, yes, 20 years is too long unless it's some sort of slam dunk deal that you can live off of the interest and you don't need to invest the money elsewhere. 

    Think about your money as more transactional, you are lending it out, and you want to see it back in 12 months or less with X amount of return. Your time value of money is important here. 

    Thank you for your response Malcomb,  I appreciate your time.   I sent you a separate text to chat further.
  • Marilyn Bredar
  • User Stats

    5
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Marilyn Bredar
    1
    Votes |
    5
    Posts
    Marilyn Bredar
    Replied
    Quote from @Chris Seveney:

    @Marilyn Bredar

    Just remember if you lend for 20 years basically that money is illiquid for twenty years

    Key to private lending is the term and rate. Biggest mistake peopke make is charging low or below market interest rates. Then they realize they need money for something else and try and sell the note only to find they are offered 50 cents on the dollar because the note was written at low interest rates.


    Thank you Chris,  I understand this money would be illiquid, but couldn't I still borrow against it?

  • Marilyn Bredar
  • User Stats

    5
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Marilyn Bredar
    1
    Votes |
    5
    Posts
    Marilyn Bredar
    Replied
    Quote from @Doug Smith:

    You bet...do a 12-month balloon to force the refinance to recoup your money quickly and protect you from interest rate risk in a relatively volatile market. We charge from 10%-12.9% right now depending upon the borrower, project, location, and time frame for us to recoup our money. Of course, you could always turn to a good, experienced lender and broker deals through them with our capital. You can let them originate, underwrite, create the docs, and close the deal and then sell it to you. Many individuals who get into lending miss things in the process and get themselves into trouble. It's how we grew a robust lending practice and it gives the investor/lender a better loan that's more likely to pay and meet their yield expectations. Good luck to you. 


    Thank you Doug,  You've given me some things to think about.  It's all pretty confusing at this point and I see I have much more to consider.

  • Marilyn Bredar
  • User Stats

    21,544
    Posts
    19,061
    Votes
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    19,061
    Votes |
    21,544
    Posts
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    ModeratorReplied

    @Marilyn Bredar

    Chances of borrowing against it are almost zero. No bank will lend against it so you would need to find a private deal which may be higher Interest then you are getting and it would be a short term loan / balloon

    • Chris Seveney
    business profile image
    7e investments
    5.0 stars
    3 Reviews

    User Stats

    5
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Marilyn Bredar
    1
    Votes |
    5
    Posts
    Marilyn Bredar
    Replied
    Quote from @Marilyn Bredar:

    I'm new to RE investing!  I have an opportunity for private money lending.  What would be a reasonable rate of return?  Also, is there any downside to my borrower stretching out for 20 plus years.   I'm so grateful for any and all responses.


    I think what I didn't clarify is that I will be the private lender.  In doing so, I would be taking out a loan, and the buyer will be paying the mortgage with an additional monthly cash flow to me.  It looks good on paper, but I know I'm not seeing the whole picture.

  • Marilyn Bredar
  • User Stats

    21,544
    Posts
    19,061
    Votes
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    19,061
    Votes |
    21,544
    Posts
    Chris Seveney
    • Investor
    • VA
    ModeratorReplied

    @Marilyn Bredar

    You are doing subject to is what it sounds

    If that person defaults then you are stuck holding the bag because the loan is in your name.

    • Chris Seveney
    business profile image
    7e investments
    5.0 stars
    3 Reviews