Rental Property Investor · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2018 · 16 posts · 7 votes
Interested in a portfolio lender that would be able to bundle all of these properties into one portfolio loan. My existing three loans on these properties are with a local bank with two rate locks having already expired and the third expires at year end. I am currently working with the same local bank that currently has had these for the last 5 years but would also like to check out some DSCR lenders if available to lend. I understand there might be some difficultly getting these all on one loan as they are in different states and one the properties is a commercial unit. Also they are in a mix of rural areas and a small micropolitan area. My goal is to take out some equity in cash and get a new 20-30 term on these.
Here is some information on the portfolio:
4 unit Commercial Building in Chautauqua County NY: about $210k
Five rentals in the McKean County, PA area: $48k–$135k each, about $393k total
Total value about $603k
Current debt
$90.9k at 7.50%, (Floating)
$32.9k at 7.50%, (Floating)
$96.6k at 5.13%, (Expires at end of year, then floats)
Total about $220k, roughly 36% LTV
Does anyone have experience with a DSCR lender on a deal that has a similiar setup like this? I'm wondering what benefits, if any, of going with a DSCR lender vs. a local lender.
I mean, DSCR is (should) keep things a little cleaner and won't hammer your credit/DTI in the same way which could be really helpful if you are running multiples.
Plus there might be a few smaller value DSCR groups that would allow you to keep things separate which would give you the downstream flexibility that a true portfolio wouldn't give.
Happy to run through any numbers if it would be helpful! Doesn’t look like you will sacrifice too much on the rates given where they are at right now, so even as a cash out you should be in good shape.
Good luck! Like I said, happy to connect and brainstorm if it would be helpful
Zack, the one loan for everything is the hard part here. A blanket across two states with a commercial building in the mix narrows the field alot, and some DSCR lenders get picky on rural properties too. Ask about that upfront before you pay for appraisals.
The low value PA houses are the other thing. Plenty of DSCR lenders have a minimum loan amount, so a $48k house on its own might not work. Thats why bundling them, or just staying with a local portfolio bank, sometimes wins.
DSCR vs your bank: DSCR usually gets you a long fixed term and doesnt care about your DTI, but expect a higher rate than a bank portfolio loan and usually a prepay penalty. Your bank knows you and these properties, which counts for a lot with rural stuff. I'd get a DSCR quote and a bank quote side by side and compare the fixed term and prepay, not just the rate.
At about 36% LTV you have plenty of room. Most DSCR cash-out programs go to 70-75% LTV, and rural properties often get capped closer to 65-70%, so on ~$603K of value you're likely looking at roughly $390-450K total before paying off the $220K.
A few things that will shape where you land:
• Is the Chautauqua building 4 residential units, or does it have a commercial space? Four residential units fits standard 1-4 unit DSCR; any retail or office space pushes it to commercial or mixed-use pricing.
• Rural is the bigger filter than loan size. Many DSCR lenders exclude properties the appraiser marks rural or with few comps, so ask about that up front.
• Blanket vs. separate loans: a blanket keeps it to one closing, but each property usually still has to meet its own DSCR and a per-property value minimum. Separate loans can price better if a couple of the PA rentals are small.
• Have current leases and a rent roll ready. Most lenders want DSCR at 1.0 or better, and 1.2+ gets better pricing.
Local banks and credit unions in those counties are worth a call too, since they portfolio rural rentals, but they usually cap terms at 20-25 years with a balloon.
Not always necessarily true that you need everything on one loan - a lot of the time the cleaner play here is splitting it up. Portfolio/blanket DSCR loans do exist across states, but most of them have a per-property minimum loan amount (and minimum value, usually somewhere around $75k+), so the $48k-type houses in McKean County tend to be the ones that get kicked out, and "rural" designations generally knock the max LTV down 5-15%. The other big question is the Chautauqua building - if its 4 residential units thats pretty standard DSCR, but if any of it is actually commercial/mixed-use the lender pool shrinks a lot.
As for DSCR vs. the local bank, the big benefit is a true 30-year fixed with no personal income/DTI review instead of floating rates and 5-year resets, the tradeoff is generally a higher rate and a prepay penalty (though PA actually prohibits prepays on 1-2 unit loans under about $329k, so all of your PA ones would be prepay-free). Is the Chautauqua building 4 apartments or is there retail on the ground floor?
The cross-state part is the real hurdle here — most DSCR lenders I know want single-asset loans, and the commercial unit plus the rural locations narrow it further. A portfolio lender that does blanket loans across state lines is probably your best shot for keeping it all in one loan, but expect them to underwrite each property's cash flow separately. The 36% LTV works in your favor though.
What are the rents looking like across the six properties, and are they all in your name or an LLC? That'll tell you pretty fast whether DSCR pricing beats what your local bank is offering.
Hi Zack, this is a very workable setup. At roughly 36% LTV with rents covering the debt, DSCR and portfolio lenders are a good fit, and I work with several that do small balances and mixed residential/commercial. The main thing is structuring the multi-state mix: some lenders will bundle everything into one loan, others do separate loans cross-collateralized, and it's worth comparing both before your year-end expiration. Full disclosure, I'm a mortgage broker. Happy to run your numbers if you want to DM or connect. – Stephen
Zachary, the multi-state mix and the commercial 4-unit are what's tripping people up. A lot of DSCR lenders won't touch balances that small or won't put NY and PA under one blanket loan. Splitting it into two loans, one for the PA rentals and one for the NY building, is usually easier to get done than one portfolio loan, and you can still pull cash out of each.
I do DSCR, small commercial and portfolio refis in both NY and PA, so I'd be glad to look at the rents and current payoffs and tell you what makes sense before those locks get worse. Give me a call, my number's in my signature below.
With $125k gross on about $603k of value, rent isn't what limits you, value is. That's roughly a 20 percent gross yield, so the DSCR test should clear with a lot of room, and the cash you can pull comes down to the appraisals and each lender's LTV cap.
On ballpark rate, the two things that move it most on this deal are the commercial unit and how far you push leverage. Pricing usually improves in steps as LTV comes down, and with rents this strong you don't need max cash out to cash flow, so pulling a bit less can buy a better rate.
Even at 60 to 70k, the two single families sit under the minimums that keep coming up, which makes them the natural ones to leave on a bank loan.
Hey Zachary, send me a connect request when you get a chance! I know a solid lender doing tailored real estate financing who could be a great resource for your pipeline.
@Zachary Finnegan, I'd separate the financing decision into two buckets before trying to force one blanket loan. The Chautauqua mixed-use building will be underwritten differently from the PA houses, and the rural valuations and minimum loan sizes may make a single package less flexible than it looks. I'd compare a local portfolio-bank proposal with DSCR proposals on property-level DSCR, fixed term, amortization, prepayment, recourse, reserves, closing costs and the ability to release or sell one asset later. Then decide how much cash-out you actually need and which property should support it. One closing is convenient, but it can also tie six exits together.
Zack, at about 36% LTV across six properties you've got a lot of room to work with, even with the rural spots and two states in the mix. We do portfolio and blanket loans on mixed setups like this, so send me a message and let's look at it.
Zack, the 36% combined LTV and roughly $10,965 in monthly gross rent give you a strong base, but the cleanest structure may be two facilities rather than one blanket loan. I would price the New York mixed-use building separately from the five Pennsylvania rentals, then compare that result with any cross-state portfolio option. That avoids letting the commercial unit, rural classifications and lower-value houses eliminate an otherwise workable file. I'm Kris with EquityNest Capital. If helpful, I can review the current payoffs, rent roll, taxes, insurance, property values and year-end timing and help compare a split structure with a single portfolio refinance. No pressure, and I would confirm lender minimums before you spend money on appraisals.
Hi Zachary, your portfolio looks like a good candidate for a portfolio DSCR loan:
1. Fit. Six properties worth about $603K with about $220K owed puts you around 36% loan to value, so there's real room for cash out, and $10,965 a month in rent should give strong debt coverage.
2. Small balance properties. Some lenders won't include properties valued under $75K to $100K. Ask about minimum property values, since a few of yours are near $48K.
3. Mixed use. The commercial space in the Chautauqua building may push it into a commercial loan. Some portfolio lenders accept it if it's mostly residential.
4. Terms. Expect a fixed period of 5 years or more on a 30-year amortization, with a prepayment penalty. Ask about release clauses so you can sell one property later.
5. Timing. With the 5.13% loan expiring at year end, start now. A portfolio loan with six appraisals can take 45 to 60 days.
Hi Zack — your setup is workable, and the thread has already covered the main tension: one blanket loan across two states with a mixed-use building in the mix narrows the lender pool, so it's worth pricing the blanket and a two-loan split side by side before your year-end expiration forces the timing.
You've posted most of the file already — the values, the three bank loans, total rent of $10,965/month, and that the properties sit in your LLC. What's still missing for me to run real numbers:
Your credit score range
How much cash you're looking to pull out (or the total loan size you're targeting)
The rent roll — rent per property, especially how the Chautauqua building splits between the commercial unit and the three residential units
Annual property taxes and insurance, total or per property
On the three bank loans: the monthly payments, and whether any of them has a prepayment penalty
The property addresses (DM is fine)
Roughly how much in liquid reserves you'd hold after closing — a range is fine
Send what you have and I'll run both structures against each other — blanket vs. split — with actual numbers, not ballparks.
Hi Zack — I'm Marcos Guevara, an advisor with the Legacy Capital Alliance team, evaluating investor loan profiles (not a direct lender). Your setup is workable on paper — ~36% LTV with $10,965/mo in gross rents gives a lender room — but the pieces that decide it are the ones you flagged: a blanket across NY and PA, the commercial unit in the Chautauqua building, rural locations, and the two smaller PA houses sitting under most lenders' minimums. Splitting it into a PA loan and a NY loan is often easier than one portfolio loan, and the small houses may be better left with your local bank. DM me per property: address, value, current balance/rate, and monthly rent, plus your credit range, and I'll check honestly whether a portfolio/DSCR structure fits before any application or credit pull — especially with that third lock expiring at year-end. No rate or approval promised, just a straight fit check.
Zack, the income story on yours is strong — $10,965 a month in gross rent across six properties, about $220K owed against roughly $603K in value, so around 36% LTV — is exactly what DSCR and small-balance commercial lenders say they want. The hard part is the shape: one loan across two states, a mixed-use building in Chautauqua County (1 commercial + 3 residential), and a couple of small rural PA houses that sit under a lot of lenders' minimums.
I place borrowers with investor lenders and I am happy to ask two of mine whether they would price this as one portfolio loan or as a PA/NY split, and what their per-property minimums do to the two smaller houses. No promises, it is a real constraint, but the question is worth asking with your numbers. If you want me to, tell me how much cash you are looking to pull out and I will run it this week.