Residential Real Estate Broker · Richmond, VA · Member since 2012 · 63 posts · 3 votes
We have a tenant who is having roommate issue, and we are in the process of screening a new applicant to take over his lease. He emails me every other day or so to complain about the noisy roommate.
Today's email is requesting me to install a lock on his door so he can lock his room, because he is going out of town over the weekend, and doesn't want his roommate's friends to sleep in his room, or accidently damage any of his personal items.
Should I agree to do that for him? If not, will I be liable for damaging to his personal properties? I do have terms in the lease saying that we are not responsible for tenant's personal properties.
Really getting frustrated with overly picky tenant.
@Sophia Wang I'd tell him to go to Lowes or Home Depot and pick up a lock for 6 or 7 dollars. Takes a screwdriver (two screws) to install it himself. I don't see why this should be YOUR problem, frankly.
Not knowing the full situation makes it hard to suggest a course of action.
From your comments, it appears as if you may rented part of the house (or apartment) to two separate unrelated people. If that is the case, then I believe you some responsibility for the safety of the tenant and his property and should provide the lock. On the otherhand if you rented the place to the tenants jointly (friends, couple whatever) and they have been having a lover type squabble avoid the situation and do not renew the lease with either one.
@Edward Burns It is a joint lease to two friends. However one of the two is a bar tender and works late hours, have ton of friends, loves to party, and doesn't like to pick up after herself.
I tried not to get into resolving roommate issues, but I also know I won't get any peace if I don't help finding a replacement roommate.
I think I will take @Andrew S. advice and send him to Lowes or Home Depot.
If you are leasing the property and not renting by the room, it is not your issue. We had a similar request recently - one month into the lease - and our response was they should have exercised a little more diligence in selecting their roommates. We did give them a referral to a local family/relationship councillor.
In our student boarding houses where we rent by the room, you expect to deal with such matters - though surprisingly they do not occur there. When we lease an apartment or house to a group of 2-4 individuals, managing group dynamics isn't included in the lease. :)
You might want to check local zoning. A landlord here got into trouble with the codes people, they shut him down, made him empty the building and he ended up selling the property.
There were 2 different code violations that applied here:
1. No more than 3 unrelated people by blood or marriage can reside in a house in a SFH zone.
2. If there are locks on the bedroom doors, they the codes people defined the property as a "rooming house", which is not a permitted use in the SFH zone.
They selected each other. Not your problem. They should work it out or if one moves out they find their own replacement or be responsible for the rent for the rest of the lease term.
If they wish to change to a keyed entry lock, they can do that at their expense. Make sure you get a copy of the key or you will be locked out.
We've done this several times for our daughter's roommate issues during her college years and also when we shared a beach house with her for 8 months. She couldn't stop roommates from "borrowing" her things, so we simply got permission from the landlord to install locks with the understanding original would be put back before walk-thru at end of lease. With our lease together, she was there full-time and we came down most weekends, but I did not feel comfortable leaving my rooms open to possible parties, sleepovers, etc. While I trust my daughter, this alleviated any pressure she would feel to let friends stay in our rooms. While I understand no locks on a private bath as access for emergency plumbing issues is required, I totally understand bedroom privacy in a roommate situation.
Who LIED and said this is an easy job????((&#%)(Y#_**_
Very funny, @John Thedford ! my daughter, who had not previously been familiar with what a screwdriver does, just installed one on her door at college.... Unless there is something I don't know about, I don't think she inherited any special handyman genes from her dad......
1. No more than 3 unrelated people by blood or marriage can reside in a house in a SFH zone.
2. If there are locks on the bedroom doors, they the codes people defined the property as a "rooming house", which is not a permitted use in the SFH zone.
Here it is no more than 4-unrelated persons per dwelling unit and, locks on bedroom doors are also interpreted as a "rooming house" ... not just by the bylaw officers, but by appraisers as well {i.e. it can affect your financing).
Put me in the they're grownups, they leased together, not your problem camp. Ditto on the buy your own lock and keep mine somewhere handy front.
One time... One TIME... I let myself start to get sucked into this kind of problem. Then I came to my senses and told them they were big boys and girls, everyone on the lease was responsible for all damages; work it out.
I would further suggest you tell him the house is in the condition you agreed to when you rented it and send all his messages to voice mail. You can sort them for real emergencies and skip the dramatics.