Rental insurance going up after claim - need advice

[Sebastian Naczas]

All,

  One of my tenants broke her hand while walking on the icy driveway.  I made a claim with my insurance company.  Now they are raising my rate by over 10%.  I'm with Erie and I'm wondering if it's time to switch.

  Which companies are you guys using?  And what is your deductible?

Thanks,

Sebastian