Investor · Santa Clara, CA · Member since 2015 · 56 posts · 16 votes
I have a STR house in a resort town, but the city's new stricter policies have really cut into my revenue. I'm thinking about switching to MTR/LTR with furniture included. In this area, people usually rent for 1-12 months, and the rent is 30-50% higher than unfurnished LTR. Has anyone else made this switch from STR to MTR/LTR? Did it lead to more damage to the furniture/property and end up lowering your ROI? I got an inquiry from a family with a mid-size dog.
I have a STR house in a resort town, but the city's new stricter policies have really cut into my revenue. I'm thinking about switching to MTR/LTR with furniture included. In this area, people usually rent for 1-12 months, and the rent is 30-50% higher than unfurnished LTR. Has anyone else made this switch from STR to MTR/LTR? Did it lead to more damage to the furniture/property and end up lowering your ROI? I got an inquiry from a family with a mid-size dog.
You will have more wear-and-tear, simply because someone is occupying the house all of the time. With STRs, there are many days out of the year that they are empty. Even when they are occupied, guests are often away at attractions, with the house being more of a sleepover post than something they are living in.
I have a STR house in a resort town, but the city's new stricter policies have really cut into my revenue. I'm thinking about switching to MTR/LTR with furniture included. In this area, people usually rent for 1-12 months, and the rent is 30-50% higher than unfurnished LTR. Has anyone else made this switch from STR to MTR/LTR? Did it lead to more damage to the furniture/property and end up lowering your ROI? I got an inquiry from a family with a mid-size dog.
You will have more wear-and-tear, simply because someone is occupying the house all of the time. With STRs, there are many days out of the year that they are empty. Even when they are occupied, guests are often away at attractions, with the house being more of a sleepover post than something they are living in.
Hey @Sam Liu. It should be very easy to switch out. You just need to make sure you keep up on the maintenance and make sure everything is kept up.
I might also have a 3 or 6 month inspection of the premises. That will help keep thing square with the guests.
Remember that you need to do a full background check etc etc with a regular full lease for the time they are there. They are not really guests, but tenants.
I have always done MTR during the academic year and STR during the summer.
Mostly I have not experienced much wear and tear difference between MTR and STR rentals. The exception was when I rented to a lovely couple who had been living in town for several years. They had friends in town and enjoyed entertaining. The other exception was when I rented to a single mother with a toddler in our unit with high-end furnishings. That was just dumb. I didn't have a lot of high-end furnishings in my own home when we had a toddler. Not sure what I was thinking when I rented to the single mother with the toddler.
We managed to deal with all the wear and tear issues without too much pain, even the toddler.
Many people are finding themselves in the same position as you due to local regulations. It's a fairly easy switch to convert from STR to MTR. LTR is a little bit different. The thing to keep in mind is that people renting your place as an MTR are expecting a hospitality experience, much like in an STR. So if you're used to that, it's an easy switch. Your marketing needs to change a bit but other than that, it's very similar. If you're converting to a long term furnished rental, the expectations are different and so is the day-to-day usage of your place just as you've assumed by your question about wear and tear. In my opinion, MTR is the best of both worlds. You get higher rents than long term and less turnover than short term.
Besides wear and tear on the building and furnishings, remember with MTR you are paying for all utilities, internet, and lawn care, unlike LTRs. And you'll have to make decisions on supplying linens and consumables, which many MTR guests expect to be included. So the 30-50% higher number may not look so good when you run the numbers.
Besides wear and tear on the building and furnishings, remember with MTR you are paying for all utilities, internet, and lawn care, unlike LTRs. And you'll have to make decisions on supplying linens and consumables, which many MTR guests expect to be included. So the 30-50% higher number may not look so good when you run the numbers.
Good to know! Do you recommend going with LTR without furniture? My other LTR is actually doing better than this STR and needs less attention. But we put a lot of effort into getting this STR ready, and I'm not sure what to do with all the furniture. How did you handle the transition from STR to LTR?
I have done it in Indianapolis, IN! We actually recommend MTR to the owners of the properties we manage during the winter months, because of the seasonality in Indy. It works well to have more consistent income, even if it is lower than STR rates sometimes. I recommend MTR if STR isn't working well for you! And if you did it on a trial basis, it is relatively easy to switch it back using certain systems.