Hello Everyone - Newbie here(obivously). I'm trying to break into real estate. Money isn't an issue per se as we just downsized our primary so we have money from that. I get the 4 pillars and honestly the STR tax loophole is very appealing as I still have W2 income. BUT, for the life of me I cannot find any STRs that actually cashflow with a mortgage. For example the place will be $600K and generating say $40K in revenue?? Am I just doing it wrong? Any pointers would be awesome as I'm almost ready to just give up.
Is this not possible and I need to hope for the other 3 pillars to outweigh the lack of cashflow? I've looked in Frisco, CO, Traverse City, MI, Ellicottville, NY.
Congrats on starting on the road to freedom with real estate.
Question: What's more important than finding your 'perfect' deal? Answer: patience and timing.
Without being patient, staying consistently on the hunt for a good opportunity, you might be able to stumble onto a winner--but that won't keep you in the game long term.
Always be looking, and when you do find the deal, pounce. That's the timing aspect; having your ducks in line so you are able to pull the trigger when you do spot the opportunity.
I've found that the most important part of real estate (besides your knowledge) is your mental attitude. Don't quit, stay encouraged, and NEVER give up. Every potential deal that doesn't work gives you more street smarts and brings you a step closer to that next big beautiful deal.
Lastly, real estate is a neighborhood business. As a beginner, maybe concentrate on the area that you feel most comfortable with. Become an expert in that one area you choose, and speak to as many investors, agents, contractors, sellers, and even buyers as you can. You'll be amazed how leads will come from totally unexpected places.
Hope this helps you a bit. Looking forward to hearing about your first deal! Best of luck!
Hey Ryan! Don't mean to echo anyone in here, but how are you sourcing your deals (on market, wholesalers, direct to seller, etc.)? What's your "buy box?" Buying right/Value add is one of the easier approaches to generating cashflow. I'd be more than happy to chat with you about this.
Hello Everyone - Newbie here(obivously). I'm trying to break into real estate. Money isn't an issue per se as we just downsized our primary so we have money from that. I get the 4 pillars and honestly the STR tax loophole is very appealing as I still have W2 income. BUT, for the life of me I cannot find any STRs that actually cashflow with a mortgage. For example the place will be $600K and generating say $40K in revenue?? Am I just doing it wrong? Any pointers would be awesome as I'm almost ready to just give up.
Is this not possible and I need to hope for the other 3 pillars to outweigh the lack of cashflow? I've looked in Frisco, CO, Traverse City, MI, Ellicottville, NY.
Hey Ryan! Totally hear you—this is a super common challenge right now with STRs. A lot of those highly desirable STR markets have seen prices rise way faster than rents or nightly rates, so even though the STR tax benefits are solid (especially with cost seg + bonus depreciation if you're materially participating), the actual cash flow with a mortgage is rough. You're not doing it wrong—it's just the numbers aren't penciling in a lot of these high-demand STR areas unless you're putting a big chunk down or buying cash. If strong cash flow is a priority, I'd suggest looking at more affordable metros where long-term and mid-term rentals can still cash flow and STRs might be an optional bonus. I'm in Columbus, Ohio, and it's a totally different picture here. Price points are way more manageable—you can still pick up solid single families or small multis in the $120–180K range that hit the 1% rule, even with financing. Plus, the market fundamentals are strong—huge population and job growth, big employers like Intel, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, etc. moving in, and there's still solid appreciation potential. STR regs are also not as intense in most neighborhoods here, and some investors are doing well with MTRs near hospitals and colleges. Might be worth broadening your search and seeing how your capital could go further in a different type of market. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!
@Ryan Berg You're not doing anything wrong, you're just facing what many first-time STR investors run into: high purchase prices, rising interest rates, and oversaturated markets that make it tough to cash flow out of the gate. The STR model can absolutely work, but to make it pencil today, especially with a mortgage, you'll need to adjust one of three variables: market, price point, or strategy.
Here’s where you can tighten things up:
Revenue Estimates: Make sure you're using actual STR comps, not average Airbnb listings. Use tools like AirDNA or Rabbu to analyze seasonality, occupancy, and average daily rates in your target market. $40K gross on a $600K property likely won't cash flow after expenses and debt service.
Financing Structure: If possible, consider putting more down or using a DSCR loan that evaluates the deal based on income, not your personal DTI. Even small changes to leverage or interest rate can shift a deal from negative to break-even or better.
Market Type: Some popular STR markets (like Frisco or Traverse City) are highly competitive and priced in for appreciation, not cash flow. Look for lesser-known drive-to destinations, or pivot to mid-term rentals where demand is driven by traveling nurses, workers, or relocations, not just tourism.
Tax Strategy as ROI: You're right that the STR loophole is powerful. If you materially participate, your depreciation (especially with bonus depreciation and cost segregation) can create paper losses that offset W-2 income. That tax benefit alone can turn a break-even or slight negative-cash-flow property into a net-positive investment after taxes.
In short: yes, it’s still possible, but you may need to shift your expectations on market or cash flow, and factor in total return (including tax savings and appreciation), not just net cash flow. Keep going. Most people quit right before they find their first great deal. Let me know if you want help modeling a deal or finding markets that still pencil. This post does not create a CPA-Client relationship. The information contained in this post is not to be relied upon. Readers should seek professional advice.
To echo some of the other comments and provide some clarity I think a lot of people, especially STR influencers, are actually executing a fix and STR strategy but it all gets lumped into STR/Airbnb. In the markets we work in I haven't seen a house that can be purchased at todays prices/rates, furnished, and short-term rented at a profit. It's probably worse when looking to buy existing/turnkey STRs. The deals I see that work are people buying ugly/dated/problem houses, fixing them up, and turning them into incredible STRs. That takes a lot of skill, vision, construction, decorating, amenities, etcetera. It's a lot more than most people want to do.
Think about the houses with the ugly/dates front facade. Important for homeowners, insignificant for STR (just don't use it as a cover or top 5 photo). Amenities book in the markets we're in. Pools, hot tubs, game rooms, theatre rooms, fire pits with string lighting. In my mind if all of your top 5 photos are amenities your property will perform better. That's what gets people excited. Everyone knows its going to have a kitchen, beds, and a living room with a TV they can see all that after you've gotten them excited with the first 5.
Oh, one more thing. Look for gaps within the market. Go to Airbnb and search for 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 bedrooms and run a little spreadsheet subtracting to find out how many of each there are. I did this recently for part of our market and noticed there were half as many 3 bedrooms as 1's and 2's and in the downtown area very few 4 and 5 bedrooms. If you find that go look at all the 4 and 5 bedrooms. Are they performing well? Are they competitive? Are there any ugly duckling 4 or 5 bedroom homes for sale that could be turned into rock star properties bursting with amenities that would outperform for large groups? Filter for pools, there might be very few if any. Now go to Zillow and create a search for 4 and 5 bedrooms with pools. Onto the next market. Bait lots of hooks like that and wait to see what bites.
You're not doing it wrong—maybe you are not looking in the right markets. Cash flow is tough there with today's rates. Try less competitive areas or mid-term rentals, and don't underestimate the tax perks—they help a lot if you're W2. And check out services like STR Insights to find cash flowing markets based on your investment criteria and budget. Don't give up, the right deal's out there!
Hello Everyone - Newbie here(obivously). I'm trying to break into real estate. Money isn't an issue per se as we just downsized our primary so we have money from that. I get the 4 pillars and honestly the STR tax loophole is very appealing as I still have W2 income. BUT, for the life of me I cannot find any STRs that actually cashflow with a mortgage. For example the place will be $600K and generating say $40K in revenue?? Am I just doing it wrong? Any pointers would be awesome as I'm almost ready to just give up.
Is this not possible and I need to hope for the other 3 pillars to outweigh the lack of cashflow? I've looked in Frisco, CO, Traverse City, MI, Ellicottville, NY.
Hello Everyone - Newbie here(obivously). I'm trying to break into real estate. Money isn't an issue per se as we just downsized our primary so we have money from that. I get the 4 pillars and honestly the STR tax loophole is very appealing as I still have W2 income. BUT, for the life of me I cannot find any STRs that actually cashflow with a mortgage. For example the place will be $600K and generating say $40K in revenue?? Am I just doing it wrong? Any pointers would be awesome as I'm almost ready to just give up.
Is this not possible and I need to hope for the other 3 pillars to outweigh the lack of cashflow? I've looked in Frisco, CO, Traverse City, MI, Ellicottville, NY.
Its because real estate is a dying game if cashflow what you're after. Even for STR. Don't fall for it but you're about 4-5 years late to the party. Look into buying a small stable business instead. The same headache but MUCH more return.
Hello Everyone - Newbie here(obivously). I'm trying to break into real estate. Money isn't an issue per se as we just downsized our primary so we have money from that. I get the 4 pillars and honestly the STR tax loophole is very appealing as I still have W2 income. BUT, for the life of me I cannot find any STRs that actually cashflow with a mortgage. For example the place will be $600K and generating say $40K in revenue?? Am I just doing it wrong? Any pointers would be awesome as I'm almost ready to just give up.
Is this not possible and I need to hope for the other 3 pillars to outweigh the lack of cashflow? I've looked in Frisco, CO, Traverse City, MI, Ellicottville, NY.
Its because real estate is a dying game if cashflow what you're after. Even for STR. Don't fall for it but you're about 4-5 years late to the party. Look into buying a small stable business instead. The same headache but MUCH more return.
Like every other investment class, real estate has its bull and bear markets.