Why Reviews Should Matter to You as an STR Investor

Question

When analyzing short-term rental (STR) investments, we often talk about cap rate, occupancy, seasonality, and nightly rates. But there’s one underrated factor that directly influences all of those metrics — guest reviews.

Whether you own one Airbnb or a growing STR portfolio, reviews are not just feedback — they’re revenue drivers.

Here's what I've seen firsthand:

✅ A handful of recent 5-star reviews can push a listing higher in Airbnb/VRBO search results
✅ Positive reviews increase booking conversions — even at higher nightly rates
✅ Great reviews build guest trust before they even click “Book Now”

On the flip side, one unresolved negative review can tank your performance for weeks — even months.

So ask yourself as an investor:👉 Are your current/prospective properties review-proof?👉 Do you have a system in place to consistently earn 5-star feedback?👉 Are you choosing markets and management strategies that protect your long-term reputation?

In a saturated market, reputation becomes your competitive moat.And that moat is built one guest experience at a time.

Mike Grudzien · Answer

Not to brag, but 11 years: 4.98.  Guest Favorite and VRBO Premier Partner.

James Carlson · Answer

Don't mean to be snarky, but ... isn't this kind of "duh"?

I mean, even really unsophisticated Airbnb hosts understand that reviews are kind of everything. Good review? Get pushed up the search rankings. Bad review, you fall in the algorithm.

John Underwood · Answer

I think we have collectively said 5 star reviews will definitely help.

We have even recommended new listing lower their price some in the beginning to get more reviews and then work hard to ensure they are 5 star reviews.

Andrew Steffens · Answer

I do not worry too much about the occasional bad review.  Across 66 units our average is right at 4.7.  I have gotten bad reviews because it rained, in Florida, in Summer.  That particular unit still rents extremely well.  That is why I find it important to be on multiple (we are on 18) platforms, properly price the property, and make sure the reviews are consistently good and do not have patterns of "issues" IE communication, cleaning, etc and you will be just fine.  Some people go insane when they get a 4 star review.

Talita Belardo · Answer

Thanks @Andrew Steffens for sharing that insight . One-off bad reviews (especially over things like weather!) won’t break a strong listing.

What I wanted to highlight in my post is exactly what you mentioned — it’s not about chasing perfection, but about consistency and avoiding negative patterns in reviews. Communication, cleanliness, and accuracy are the key drivers behind guest trust and ranking performance.

That kind of operational discipline is what truly "review-proofs" a listing over time.

Appreciate you jumping in!

Talita Belardo · Answer

@Mike Grudzien, Impressive! Maintaining such a high rating for 11 years really shows your dedication and care for your guests.

Michael Baum · Answer

Hehe not in my case @Collin Hays. All 5 stars on both major platforms. When the guests decide to leave a review!

Collin Hays · Answer

Reviews matter. But only 5-star reviews indicates that someone has stuffed the ballot box.

Talita Belardo · Answer

Appreciate the feedback, everyone — great insights.

I agree that most experienced hosts and investors recognize the importance of guest reviews. However, the objective of my post wasn’t just to highlight their value, but to emphasize how reviews function as an operational KPI directly impacting ROI in short-term rental portfolios.

From a performance management perspective, we’re not just talking about reputation — we’re talking about:

• Ranking algorithms (Airbnb’s SEO model heavily weighs recent positive reviews)
• Conversion rates (5-star average listings consistently outperform on pricing tolerance)
• Booking velocity (influenced by review recency and consistency)

In our property management operations, we treat reviews as predictive indicators of future cash flow, not just retrospective guest feedback. And most importantly, we implement systems to control the experience and drive consistency at scale — especially as portfolios grow.

So while the general principle is well-known, the execution — and its role in long-term performance optimization — is often underestimated.

Thanks again for the engagement — always valuable to exchange operational perspectives.

Why Reviews Should Matter to You as an STR Investor

Most Popular Reply