I’m exploring opportunities to invest in a short-term rental property in Santa Rosa, CA and would love to hear from folks with experience in the market. Specifically, I’m looking to understand:
What's the current demand and overall sentiment in your STR market?
Is Santa Rosa STR friendly? How hard or easy would it be to secure STR license.
Are there any recent or upcoming regulatory changes (Airbnb/STR laws) I should be aware of?
What areas are still investor-friendly for STRs in terms of returns and local policies?
I’d also appreciate any recommendations for agents or brokers who specialize in STRs — folks who understand both the numbers and the local regulatory landscape.
Feel free to DM me or drop your thoughts here — thanks in advance for sharing your experience!
Also this will be my first STR - in Santa Rosa or anywhere else, and any additional guidance will be very much appreciated.
From what I've gathered, Santa Rosa is not STR friendly, nor is Sonoma County in general because of a strict county wide ordinance. Which gives you an idea of how most residents feel about it. For that reason the performance of the existing stock is pretty good because they are grandfathered in. Not sure if it's even possible to legally enter the market at this point.
If you are set on the area then give the STR ordinance a look and maybe you will find a zoning code designator or part of the county where it's allowed and you can search for properties with that in mind.
To be clear I do not invest in the area but I used to live up that way and travel there frequently. Good luck with your search.
City No Longer Accepting Applications for Non-Hosted STRs:
To
apply for a Hosted STR, the property owner must live and sleep on the
property, and the property must be the owner's principal residence
(where the owner resides for more than one-half of the year)
So unless you plan to live in the place you are short term renting, Santa Rosa is a no go.
City No Longer Accepting Applications for Non-Hosted STRs:
To
apply for a Hosted STR, the property owner must live and sleep on the
property, and the property must be the owner's principal residence
(where the owner resides for more than one-half of the year)
So unless you plan to live in the place you are short term renting, Santa Rosa is a no go.
thank you all, which would be good places to invest in CA for STRs? Given this is gonna be my first STR, I want to be somewhat more involved in the beginning.
I agree with those above, CA is tough! Though our design company has had quite a handful of new STR owners coming in from Wine Country and Coachella so I do know it is possible.
If you haven’t already, definitely connect with a local agent who specializes in STRs someone who knows both the regulatory map and what guests are booking.
I agree with those above, CA is tough! Though our design company has had quite a handful of new STR owners coming in from Wine Country and Coachella so I do know it is possible.
If you haven’t already, definitely connect with a local agent who specializes in STRs someone who knows both the regulatory map and what guests are booking.
Hi Sushil, welcome to the STR world! I'm an investor and a short-term rental specialist agent based in California, so here's my take.
Santa Rosa: For a first STR, I'd be cautious. The city is no longer accepting new applications for non-hosted (whole-home) STR permits, and the number of existing permits is shrinking as they lapse. Unless you plan to live on-site and run it as a hosted rental, the main route in is buying a property that already holds an active non-hosted permit. Even then, confirm with the city that the permit will stay valid after the sale. Unincorporated Sonoma County has its own rules, with exclusion zones and caps, so check those carefully as well. Demand in wine country is solid, but the regulatory path is narrow.
Better options for a first STR in California:
Oakhurst (Yosemite south gate): Steady national-park demand, lower entry prices than coastal markets, and county-level permitting that is still workable.
Three Rivers (Sequoia/Kings Canyon): A small, park-driven market with less competition than the big names. Permitting has been manageable.
Coachella Valley (Indio and the east valley): With Palm Springs capping permits and La Quinta restricting new ones, demand is spilling east. Coachella and Stagecoach festival weekends, plus golf and snowbird season, make high season very strong.
Joshua Tree: Competitive, but well-designed properties with space, views, and amenities still perform. Average properties are where owners struggle.
General advice for a first STR: Confirm permit eligibility with the city or county before you make an offer. Check HOA rules. Underwrite on conservative, year-round numbers rather than peak weekends. And budget for furnishing and a slow ramp-up period.
Happy to answer any questions via DM or analyze a property for eligibility for you!