I keep hearing people say short-term rentals are “passive income,” but the more I learn and talk to other hosts, the more I wonder if that’s ever really true.
For those of you with multiple Airbnbs (or even just one!), when did it really hit you that it’s more of a business than “set it and forget it”?
Was it a certain number of properties? A guest horror story? Or did you hit a point where you had to bring on help?
Curious what made you shift your mindset — I feel like these are the stories new hosts never hear about until they’re deep in it!
I keep hearing people say short-term rentals are “passive income,” but the more I learn and talk to other hosts, the more I wonder if that’s ever really true.
For those of you with multiple Airbnbs (or even just one!), when did it really hit you that it’s more of a business than “set it and forget it”?
Was it a certain number of properties? A guest horror story? Or did you hit a point where you had to bring on help?
Curious what made you shift your mindset — I feel like these are the stories new hosts never hear about until they’re deep in it!
everyone has a different assessment of Passive.. one person passive is anothers too much work for me STR was TOO MUCH WORK.. LOL
Haha — I totally get that! It’s wild how “passive” means so many different things depending on who you ask.
Out of curiosity, what part pushed you over the edge? Was it guests, cleaning, pricing, or just all the moving parts?
Always curious what the final straw is for people who decide STR isn't worth the grind — there's so much to learn from the "never again" moments!
I am in the Real estate business Lending building etc.. I am not in the hotel business to me STR is hospitality.. If I wanted hospitality I would buy a hotel :) And since I say at least 25 nights a year in hotels I think I could be pretty good at it.. I get it though for those that are in STR espiecally those that got in with great pricing etc etc.
Fair point — it definitely takes a sharp operator to see through all the “easy passive income” hype people love to sell.
Curious though — if you knew it wasn’t passive from the start, what made you get into it anyway? Was it the cash flow, the appreciation, or just wanting to try something different from long-term rentals?
I love hearing what pulled people in, even when they knew it would be work!
Fair point — it definitely takes a sharp operator to see through all the “easy passive income” hype people love to sell.
Curious though — if you knew it wasn’t passive from the start, what made you get into it anyway? Was it the cash flow, the appreciation, or just wanting to try something different from long-term rentals?
I love hearing what pulled people in, even when they knew it would be work!
I have STR vacation rentals. These are nice properties where I also like to visit.
We are listed on Vrbo and Airbnb but we are in a higher class then what I perceive people to call an Airbnb.
That makes total sense — there’s definitely a big difference between a “vacation rental” and what most people picture when they hear Airbnb.
Sounds like you’ve got more of a true second home setup — beautiful properties you’d actually want to stay in yourself. That must make hosting feel a bit different too, since you’re attracting guests who treat it more like a vacation than a cheap crash pad.
Do you find Vrbo works better for your style of property? I always hear higher-end hosts say they get better guests that way — curious if that’s been your experience too.
Its only passive income if you are in fact cash flowing and you have a full service manager. If you have a limited service manager and/or are self managing, its not passive income.
STRs can be active or passive. It depends on how it is being used and how you are participating in the management of it. Here below are two reasons the STR can be passive instead of active:
1. If you are not actively participating in the management of the property at least 100 hours per year and more than anyone else or any other entity.
2. If the average of the year's rental days is more than 7 days. It does not matter how many days you actively manage the property, it is a passive property.
This is a great breakdown — I appreciate how clearly you laid that out. It’s true, a lot of people lump all STRs together without understanding those key distinctions.
That second point especially — the average stay being over 7 days — really shifts the dynamics of what’s considered active vs passive. I’ve seen a few investors structure their listings that way intentionally just to stay within the passive category.
Have you personally leaned into one model more than the other? Or do you work with both depending on the property? Curious how you apply this in real life.
This is a great breakdown — I appreciate how clearly you laid that out. It’s true, a lot of people lump all STRs together without understanding those key distinctions.
That second point especially — the average stay being over 7 days — really shifts the dynamics of what’s considered active vs passive. I’ve seen a few investors structure their listings that way intentionally just to stay within the passive category.
Have you personally leaned into one model more than the other? Or do you work with both depending on the property? Curious how you apply this in real life.
Thank you for the complement.
Over the years, I have been a commercial real estate broker and an investor primarily in commercial real estate. At this point in my life, I have divested from my commercial properties and currently have a mid-term rental. Each person's situation can be different.
Because each person's investment goals are personal, it is to your advantage to be talking to a tax consultant to maximize your tax benefits and cash flow. Then, the consultant working with your real estate savy CPA/tax professional can guide you in what is best in your specific situation.
Think of CPAs/tax professionals as your medical GP. They have a broad knowledge of their subject. When you have a broken leg or a heart attack, you will want a specialist whose knowledge is deeply focused on surgery or heart issues. As a specialist in real estate taxation, strategy and available cash flow opportunities, I work with your CPA/tax professional to maximize your benefits in this complex area of tax laws and regulations at no cost to you.
STR is just like everything else. It got saturated where plenty of unskilled operators have saturated the market, making it not really viable anymore. Also, just like any other form of investing, these people ran in, with a notion it was passive and easy. My goodness, without a manger, how could anyone on earth see this as passive. It's a hospitality business with dozens more moving parts than MDR or LTR.
Couldn’t agree more — you really nailed it. So many people jumped in thinking it was plug-and-play, only to find out it’s basically running a mini hotel without the staff.
The market saturation part is so true too — it feels like the barrier to entry got so low that everyone with a spare room or second home piled in at once, skilled or not.
Out of curiosity, have you shifted your own strategy because of the saturation? More direct bookings, longer stays, higher-end guests, or just sticking to what works and filtering harder?
I always love hearing how seasoned hosts adapt when the “easy money” hype crowd moves on!
Couldn’t agree more — you really nailed it. So many people jumped in thinking it was plug-and-play, only to find out it’s basically running a mini hotel without the staff.
The market saturation part is so true too — it feels like the barrier to entry got so low that everyone with a spare room or second home piled in at once, skilled or not.
Out of curiosity, have you shifted your own strategy because of the saturation? More direct bookings, longer stays, higher-end guests, or just sticking to what works and filtering harder?
I always love hearing how seasoned hosts adapt when the “easy money” hype crowd moves on!
I have 2 at a ski resort and my manager does it all. Its a lot going on at our location, but ever all they are pretty good. I got in before it was so saturated. My expenses are high like everyone else, but it's lower than many coming in now. I have tons of equity in them as well. However, if i were managing them, Id sell. Just too much work.
Any type of rental is going to take management and have expenses. Eventually they realize, running any type of rental especially multiple STR's or multi family is a business and requires hands on 24/7. If its 3am and someone clogs their bathroom or falls asleep drunk with the stove on it becomes your problem. Eventually you can work up to hiring a pmc.
When you compare a STR to a LTR on the same property, you will find that the STR usually has a better ROI. Nevertheless, the amount of work that goes into a STR to qualify as an active investment rather than a passive investment is far greater for the STR. It is your choice.
Of course, if you qualify as a RE Professional, both STR and LTR will be active investments.
Before I actually purchased a property with the intent to do STR. That said in my decades of small investor activities I have not found any type of RE to be anything close to passive income. Even with an excellent property manager the buck, responsibility and liability still lands in your lap.
Haha — spot on! Gotta love those “gurus” selling the dream of passive riches while they’re the ones getting paid up front.
You’re right, though — if it were really passive and easy, everyone would do it and there’d be nothing left on the table for people who actually treat it like a business.
Out of curiosity, what’s been your biggest real-world edge in staying profitable when so many newbies flame out? Better guests, better ops, better pricing? Always love hearing what keeps a real operator ahead of the “course buyers.”
I keep hearing people say short-term rentals are “passive income,” but the more I learn and talk to other hosts, the more I wonder if that’s ever really true.
For those of you with multiple Airbnbs (or even just one!), when did it really hit you that it’s more of a business than “set it and forget it”?
Was it a certain number of properties? A guest horror story? Or did you hit a point where you had to bring on help?
Curious what made you shift your mindset — I feel like these are the stories new hosts never hear about until they’re deep in it!
Mine is passive income but I have a manager. He takes a lot of the cut, though. If I had to manage it myself, I would never have thought it was passive income
That makes total sense — having a good manager really does make the difference between “owning a rental” and “running a hotel yourself.”
The tradeoff is real, though — that cut definitely eats into the ROI, but sometimes it's worth every penny for the sanity alone!
Do you feel like it’s been worth it overall for you? Or do you ever think about switching managers or tweaking how it’s run to keep more of the pie? Always curious how people balance peace of mind vs profit.
That makes total sense — having a good manager really does make the difference between “owning a rental” and “running a hotel yourself.”
The tradeoff is real, though — that cut definitely eats into the ROI, but sometimes it's worth every penny for the sanity alone!
Do you feel like it’s been worth it overall for you? Or do you ever think about switching managers or tweaking how it’s run to keep more of the pie? Always curious how people balance peace of mind vs profit.
It is tough to say. I think if I could go back and do everything again, I would build out my own processes and manage properties myself.
It was a tradeoff though. I was able to free up time to focus on other things that made me a lot of wealth
Rentals, whether short term or long term, are not passive-all require some work. Short term rentals require a lot more work as you are effectively running a very small hotel.
Absolutely — that’s such a clear way to put it. At the end of the day, you’re either managing people or managing problems — and with STRs, it’s both every single week!
I always find it interesting how many new hosts underestimate just how hands-on it really is — especially when they’re used to LTRs where a good tenant might stay for years.
Out of curiosity, what’s been the biggest “small hotel” headache for you — guests, turnovers, maintenance surprises? Always interesting to hear what really eats up the time!
Absolutely — that’s such a clear way to put it. At the end of the day, you’re either managing people or managing problems — and with STRs, it’s both every single week!
I always find it interesting how many new hosts underestimate just how hands-on it really is — especially when they’re used to LTRs where a good tenant might stay for years.
Out of curiosity, what’s been the biggest “small hotel” headache for you — guests, turnovers, maintenance surprises? Always interesting to hear what really eats up the time!