Looking to buy first property and seeking advice
Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 6 votes
Looking to buy first property and seeking advice
Most Popular Reply
Realtor · PInellas County Largo, FL · Member since 2016 · 902 posts · 810 votes
7moI can’t give you specific advice about your area, but I have some thoughts on local vs remote. The farther away any active Real Estate (especially Short-Term) is, the more you can get nickel-and-dimed with little expenses.
Even if you manage yourself, you'll have to pay for trips out to the property for little things. Having a property manager is a great idea for all new investors. Keep in mind that the farther away you are, the more you’ll have to push onto the PM’s plate, which will cause more upcharges.
There are many other reasons to consider local vs remote, but that’s the first that comes to mind. I usually advise newer investors to look a little closer to home unless they know the area very well. Like a vacation area you love to visit, or an area you grew up in, or an area your family currently lives near.
22 Replies
- MD/DC · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes7mo
Hi Henry, welcome. I prefer to do RE things close to home if possible at least initially and would imagine Atlanta has a nice variety of options. What attracts you to STR as opposed to LTR?
- Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 6 votes7mo
Quote from @Jules Aton:
Hi Henry, welcome. I prefer to do RE things close to home if possible at least initially and would imagine Atlanta has a nice variety of options. What attracts you to STR as opposed to LTR?
I'm attracted to STR for the tax benefit to help offset high W2 income. I'm not opposed to LTR but would like at least one STR to start.
- 7moJaron WallingPro MemberRental Property Investor · Indianapolis, IN · Member since 2018 · 4k+ posts · 4k+ votes
Quote from @Henry Stockdale:
Quote from @Jules Aton:
Hi Henry, welcome. I prefer to do RE things close to home if possible at least initially and would imagine Atlanta has a nice variety of options. What attracts you to STR as opposed to LTR?
I'm attracted to STR for the tax benefit to help offset high W2 income. I'm not opposed to LTR but would like at least one STR to start.
Henry, you won't be able to offset W2 income until you get to qualified real estate professional status. Working a full-time W-2 job outside of RE makes it difficult to qualify.
These are investors who spends >50% of their time (and over 750 hours annually) in RE trades or business. Managing a couple units will not meet that threshold. If you buy LTR or MTR properties it's really hands off. Most people get it by going FT as a licensed agent in combination with buying/selling/holding there own properties.
- 7moCollin HaysBusiness MemberProperty Manager · Gatlinburg, TN · Member since 2020 · 3k+ posts · 4k+ votes
Quote from @Henry Stockdale:
Quote from @Jules Aton:
Hi Henry, welcome. I prefer to do RE things close to home if possible at least initially and would imagine Atlanta has a nice variety of options. What attracts you to STR as opposed to LTR?
I'm attracted to STR for the tax benefit to help offset high W2 income. I'm not opposed to LTR but would like at least one STR to start.
To offset income, it will need to lose money. That should be an easy find.
- 7moAndrew GlissonBusiness MemberProperty Manager · Memphis · Member since 2026 · 135 posts · 95 votes
Key things to look at are cleaning fees and turns per month.. cleaning is the biggest expense in STR and you want to model those realistically as possible.
- 7moAndrew SteffensBusiness MemberTampa, FL · Member since 2022 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
I think you have 2 options - you can stop looking on the retail market and look for a fixer upper you could purchase with a bridge loan and then refi into a 30 year. Your forced equity if done properly (BRRR method) will yield a lower loan payment monthly and the numbers will work better on a local STR property. If that is not to your liking then I would search out markets that will yield the intended results. There are a lot of popular submarkets not too far from Atlanta - Northern Florida, GA/TN/SC/NC mountains, etc.
Vacation Rentals of Florida53 Reviews - Realtor · PInellas County Largo, FL · Member since 2016 · 902 posts · 810 votes7mo
I can’t give you specific advice about your area, but I have some thoughts on local vs remote. The farther away any active Real Estate (especially Short-Term) is, the more you can get nickel-and-dimed with little expenses.
Even if you manage yourself, you'll have to pay for trips out to the property for little things. Having a property manager is a great idea for all new investors. Keep in mind that the farther away you are, the more you’ll have to push onto the PM’s plate, which will cause more upcharges.
There are many other reasons to consider local vs remote, but that’s the first that comes to mind. I usually advise newer investors to look a little closer to home unless they know the area very well. Like a vacation area you love to visit, or an area you grew up in, or an area your family currently lives near.
- Lender · Marlboro, NJ · Member since 2025 · 239 posts · 146 votes7mo
Analysis paralysis usually means you’re trying to make one market fit every goal at once.
Atlanta can work for STRs, but at a ~$250k budget you're pushing into neighborhoods where appreciation is the story, not cash flow. Vine City / English Ave may upside long term, but STR performance there is very sensitive to regulation, guest profile, and execution. If the deal only works assuming perfect appreciation and strong STR numbers, that's a risk worth being honest about.
One way to simplify the decision: separate strategy from geography.
Ask yourself first whether this first deal is meant to:- Produce cash flow you can stack and reinvest, or
- Be a long-term appreciation bet that ties up capital
If your goal is to scale and add units, I see a lot of first-time investors get farther faster by buying their first STR in a market where the numbers are more forgiving, even if it's out of state. You can always come back to Atlanta later with more capital and experience.
Nothing wrong with continuing to look in ATL, but I'd benchmark it against 1–2 out-of-state markets with proven STR demand at your price point. The contrast usually makes the right answer pretty obvious.
- Real Estate Agent · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2020 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes7mo
@Henry Stockdale, I don't necessarily operate in the short-term rental space, so take this with a grain of salt, but I do generally agree with what Pierre noted above. I understand the proposition around Vine City and English Ave, and I agree there's long-term appreciation potential there; however, operating an STR in those areas comes with real risk, both from a City of Atlanta / Fulton County regulatory standpoint and from a tenant and guest profile standpoint.
Also, to be blunt: if your $250k budget includes acquisition, rehab, and furnishing, that’s going to be very tight unless you’re sourcing off-market deals. On-market inventory at that price point is tough to come by in ATL right now.
If you decide to pursue short-term rentals and are keen to implement the strategy, I’d strongly recommend joining the Atlanta Metro Short Term Rental Alliance on Facebook. Ordinances and enforcement in this space are evolving. One other angle worth considering, especially if you’re currently renting, is a house hack. That can be a more forgiving way to enter the market, learn operations, and still position yourself to scale over time.
Hope that helps add some perspective.
- 7moKerlous TadresBusiness MemberRealtor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2023 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
@Henry Stockdale, if the STR numbers don't work on conservative assumptions (low occupancy, real cleaning/turnover costs, repairs, and a regulation change), I would either switch to a different strategy or buy somewhere else instead of forcing it. I'd recommend you pick one clear "buy box," run the same simple calculator on 10 deals, and only move forward when one still cash flows with a margin.
Kerlous Tadres | Reafco Real Estate539 Reviews - Member since 2023 · 3 posts · 6 votes7mo
Thanks for the replies everyone. After doing more research, I learned that City of Atlanta requires that the owner's primary residence must be one of the STRs in order to get a license. This will not work for me as I live outside of the city.
I think I'm going to have to look at other markets to make an STR work or consider an LTR. I prefer an STR, but I'm not opposed to an LTR to at least get started.
- 7moJimmy LieuBusiness MemberReal Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votesHey Henry, welcome to BP, you’re not alone at all with STR analysis paralysis because a lot of investors are feeling that right now. Atlanta can definitely work long term with the population growth, universities, and tourism, but STR performance has become very neighborhood specific and in many cases the numbers are tighter because of competition, regulations, and higher expenses, so I’d only stay locked into ATL if a deal still cash flows with conservative assumptions. If scaling is your goal, I’d at least compare it to other markets where the entry price makes it easier to repeat deals. I’d strongly suggest looking at Columbus, Ohio too. The macroeconomics are on fire here with strong population growth, job growth, and massive companies expanding like Intel, Amazon, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Honda, LG, and more. You can still find properties in the $120K–180K range that hit the 1% rule and positive cash flow, and there’s a ton of appreciation potential because of how fast the city is growing. It’s also very landlord friendly which helps a lot when you’re scaling. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!
Quote from @Henry Stockdale:
Hi all, I have been thinking about buying an STR property for a long time and I have analysis paralysis. I would prefer to buy a property in the Atlanta area, but it is difficult to make the numbers work. I've been looking at Vine City/English Avenue area because it looks like this area is going to appreciate fairly rapidly with its proximity to downtown and universities. My budget is around $250k, but could spend a little more if the revenue potential is good.
Is it worth continuing to look in ATL or should I consider other areas or out of state investing where the ROI may be higher? ideally, I want to scale and add more units in the future.
Thanks for any advice. If you know of any investment friendly real estate agents in the downtown area, please let me know.
Jimmy Lieu, Red 1 Realty4.9120 Reviews - Specialist · Member since 2026 · 53 posts · 25 votes7mo
It sounds like you’re running into two different questions at once: does this area appreciate? and does this deal actually work as an STR today? Those can get blurred together pretty easily.
With STRs in particular, I think it’s better to underwrite very conservatively — assuming lower occupancy, realistic nightly rates, regulation risk, and higher operating costs — and then asking whether the deal still feels comfortable without leaning too heavily on future appreciation. In markets like Atlanta, that tends to be where the friction shows up.
If the numbers only work assuming strong appreciation or best-case revenue, it might be worth pausing rather than forcing a local deal. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with looking out of state if it gives you cleaner cash flow and a more repeatable path to scaling, but I’d personally prioritize durability over trying to pick the “next” area.
- 7moArman AhmedPro MemberReal Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 912 votes
Atlanta can be exciting for appreciation, but if the STR numbers don't work on day one it becomes a risky hold rather than a scalable investment. Many investors end up growing faster by choosing markets with lower entry prices and stronger rent-to-cost ratios, where cash flow is more predictable and you can add multiple units instead of waiting on appreciation. It may be worth comparing your Atlanta deals side by side with a few Midwest options using very conservative revenue assumptions before making the call.
- Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes7mo
First of all, you have to ask is real estate investing in 2026 meeting my expectations, or am I being unrealistic? If you are looking for cash flow that changes your life, this is not going to work. If you want to create net worth and have a 10 year horizon, go ahead.
Second, you don't need to make all your money on your first deal. Instead of looking for $50 more cash flow, you should be looking for low risk and low headaches. That means buy a good property in good neighborhood that is desirable and in good condition. You will have good tenants, they will be quiet, actually pay rent every month and treat the property well.
So my advice to analysis paralysis, use math to map out your buy box. But then but a property that actually looks good and you could see your self move in. Because your renters will feel the same way.
- Realtor · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 95 posts · 31 votes7mo
Totally get the analysis paralysis — STRs can look amazing on paper, and then the “yeah but…” list starts stacking up fast.
If Atlanta is where you want to get started, I wouldn’t write it off yet… but I would widen the lens a bit so you can compare ATL vs. alternatives with the same math and assumptions. Here are a few things to consider:
1) Keep ATL on the table, but validate the numbers with STR data tools
Before you fall in love with a neighborhood (or a Zestimate), run a quick “reality check” using:
- AirDNA (demand, ADR, occupancy, seasonality, comps by neighborhood)
- Rabbu (revenue estimates + nearby comp performance, helpful for quick screening)
The goal is to confirm:
- What similar listings are actually earning (not just what you hope to earn)
- Whether demand is steady year-round or heavily event/weekend driven
- How competitive the listing environment is (amenities, parking, # bedrooms, reviews, etc.)
2) Don’t overlook the hidden “entry cost”: furniture + setup
A lot of STR deals "work" until you add the real startup costs. Make sure your model includes:
- Furnishing/design + housewares (this can be a big chunk, especially if you want it to compete visually)
- Security system / smart locks / thermostat
- Consumables + linens + duplicates
- Professional photos
- Initial repairs + inspection surprises
- Permits/HOA rules (if applicable)
Even a modest setup can materially change your cash-on-cash return in year 1, so it’s worth pricing this upfront.
3) About Vine City/English specifically
You’re thinking in the right direction on appreciation drivers (downtown proximity, universities), but with STRs you’ll also want to factor in:
- Guest comfort/perception (this can affect conversion rate, ADR, reviews)
- Insurance costs and any risk premium
- Property condition and ongoing maintenance expectations
In other words: it might be a strong long-term play, but run both the cash-flow case and the appreciation case separately so you're not forcing STR cash flow to do the heavy lifting.
4) Should you consider other markets?
If your priority is higher ROI + faster scaling, it can be smart to compare ATL to:
- Nearby Georgia markets with lower entry price + solid demand
- Out-of-state STR markets where regulations are clearer and returns are stronger
I’d frame it like this:
- If you want appreciation + long-term equity growth: ATL can still be a good bet if the STR numbers are realistic.
- If you want strong cash flow to scale quickly: you may find better ROI outside ATL (or outside GA), depending on regulations and demand.
5) A simple next step to break the paralysis
Pick 3 zip codes/neighborhoods in ATL + 2 alternative markets, and run the same model across all five:
- AirDNA + Rabbu revenue range (low/base/high)
- Conservative expenses
- Furnishing/setup budget
- Mortgage + reserves
The “winner” usually becomes obvious when all five are judged the same way.
6) Agent referral
On the agent piece: you’ll want someone who is actually investor-friendly and understands STR constraints (zoning, HOAs, permitting, rental comps — not just sales comps). You definitely don't want to buy a property in an area and find out later that STRs aren't permitted. Take a look at Marietta and Roswell. Both are STR-friendly, near parks, attractions, major employers, easy access to downtown ATL, shopping, and entertainment.
Hope this info is helpful!
- 7moJeremy MelloulPro MemberReal Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2022 · 83 posts · 83 votes
Analysis paralysis is real.
But don’t be afraid to fail. We’ve all taken L’s. That’s part of the game.
Run your numbers. Do your due diligence. Trust the math, not the emotion. If it works on paper and you’ve vetted the risk, pull the trigger.
Sitting on the sidelines is the only guaranteed loss.
Personally, if ATL isn't penciling, I'd look out of state. There are stronger ROI markets out there. Happy to chat through a few solid out-of-state plays if you want.
You’ll be ok — just get after it.
- Atlanta, GA · Member since 2026 · 5 posts · 5 votes7mo
Atlanta can definitely work for STR, but right now it's hyper submarket specific.. especially with regulations evolving and certain pockets getting saturated.
Vine City / English Ave does have appreciation upside long-term, but I'd personally run a mid-term rental comparison too (travel nurses, corporate stays near downtown + universities). In some areas, the ROI ends up being more stable than pure nightly STR.
At a $250k purchase price, I’d pay close attention to:
• Local STR regulations and enforcement trends
• True occupancy patterns (not just projected revenue)
• Seasonality dips
• Insurance + turnover costs in that zip code
• Your exit strategy if you ever pivot to long-term
Out-of-state can look stronger on paper, but it adds layers operationally unless you already have reliable boots on the ground.
If your goal is scaling, I'd focus more on operational predictability and repeatable systems over chasing the highest projected ROI.
Happy to share a little more of what I’m seeing in ATL from the operations side if it helps.
- 6moMelissa HaworthBusiness MemberReal Estate Agent · The Panhandle | The Emerald Coast | Panama City Beach | Destin · Member since 2017 · 257 posts · 100 votes
Henry, totally understand the analysis paralysis. Your first STR feels like a big swing, especially when you're trying to balance appreciation, cash flow, and scalability.
I’ll give you a perspective shift that might help.
If the numbers aren't working in Atlanta at $250k, that's your market giving you feedback. Vine City and English Avenue are interesting long term from a redevelopment standpoint, but STR success is less about "future appreciation" and more about current demand drivers, zoning stability, and year-round booking strength. Proximity to downtown and universities sounds great on paper, but you really need to dig into short-term rental regulations and actual AirDNA-style revenue data to see if hosts are consistently hitting occupancy.
If your long-term goal is scaling, your first deal should prioritize strong, repeatable cash flow over speculative appreciation. Appreciation is a bonus. Cash flow is what allows you to buy the next one.
This is where looking out of state can make sense. In some established vacation markets, the demand is proven and seasonal patterns are predictable. For example, along the Emerald Coast in places like Panama City Beach, there are properties in the $250k to low $300k range that are already operating as STRs with clear income history. It’s not appreciation speculation. It’s buying into an existing vacation machine with documented performance.
The tradeoff is you’re not betting on neighborhood transformation. You’re betting on beach tourism that’s been consistent for decades.
If you want to scale, ask yourself:
Would you rather own one speculative urban play that might appreciate, or one property with strong trailing revenue that can help you qualify for the next loan?Neither is wrong. They’re just different strategies.
As for investor-friendly agents, I’d recommend looking for someone who owns STRs themselves or actively underwrites them. An agent who can talk cap rates, occupancy assumptions, and regulation risk will serve you much better than someone who just says “this area is up and coming.”
If you'd like, I'm happy to help you think through what a $250k STR would realistically need to gross to hit your scaling goals.
- Real Estate Agent · Member since 2019 · 569 posts · 257 votes6mo
Try to find a studio or 1 bedroom condo very close to the beach if you are considering the emerald coast. I know of several on okaloosa island and Panama City beach.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.