Chicago IL and greater midwest vacation rentals!

Chicago IL and greater midwest vacation rentals!

Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes

Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.

7Reply
320 views

Investor-friendly agents in Chicago, IL

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in Chicago, IL.

Most Popular Reply

Ryan FlanaganPro Member
Accountant · Naperville, IL · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 27 votes
6mo

If you're looking for STR investing, Miller Beach is often overlooked because of the Gary address (it actually used to be a separate city that was annexed decades ago). It's a little enclave nestled in the Indiana Dunes National Park... thank you Mike Pence for this designation. It's highly seasonal business, but deals can be profitable if done right.
There are $1M+ houses on the beach but if you go a few blocks out, prices come down considerably. The Miller STR market has become much more saturated in recent years, probably because other cities that overlap with the Indiana Dunes don't allow STR.

For BRRRR investing Hammond and East Chicago are great but you need to vet tenants carefully (really this is true anywhere, but especially so here). These are B- to C neighborhoods depending on location with great rent to price ratios (esp if renovating). I have some buy and holds in Crown Point and Cedar Lake as well. These are considered more desirable neighborhoods with good schools and nicer downtown areas.

See this reply in the discussion

21 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Aaron ZimmermanBusiness Member
    Accountant · Chicago, IL · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6mo

    Welcome!! I'd encourage you to go to the local meetups in and around chicago and listen to the straight up Chicago investor. On their website, you'll find the listing of local meetups. 

    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      6mo
      Quote from @Aaron Zimmerman:

      Welcome!! I'd encourage you to go to the local meetups in and around chicago and listen to the straight up Chicago investor. On their website, you'll find the listing of local meetups. 


       Thank you - I will do that!

  • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6mo

    What's up @Philip Wrigley - Glad you came out from the understairs and made your introduction!  Welcome to the Chicago BP community, many good people on here are willing to be a resource for you!

    Was your accidental short-term rental in Chicago?  What are your future plans for real estate, and how can we help?

    I'd echo @Aaron Zimmerman, and highly suggest getting involved in some of the local meetups.  Here is where you can find some of the local ones on BP:  https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/521-real-estate-events-...

  • Ryan FlanaganPro Member
    Accountant · Naperville, IL · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 27 votes
    6mo

    Welcome. Don't sleep on Northwest Indiana! I run a few Airbnbs out there that do well. It's also a target rich environment if you like value-add investing. DM me anytime if you want to know more.

    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      6mo
      Quote from @Ryan Flanagan:

      Welcome. Don't sleep on Northwest Indiana! I run a few Airbnbs out there that do well. It's also a target rich environment if you like value-add investing. DM me anytime if you want to know more.


      I haven't ventured out into Indiana as yet. There are some huge tax perks there compares to IL. What areas have you invested in? Valparaiso and Chesterton I often hear about! 

  • Jake YuskaitisBusiness Member
    Lender · New Jersey, USA · Member since 2022 · 254 posts · 68 votes
    6mo

    If you want to buy in Chicago right now, lending is VERY tough in that area. Making it even more difficult is the STR constraint.

  • Ryan FlanaganPro Member
    Accountant · Naperville, IL · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 27 votes
    6mo

    If you're looking for STR investing, Miller Beach is often overlooked because of the Gary address (it actually used to be a separate city that was annexed decades ago). It's a little enclave nestled in the Indiana Dunes National Park... thank you Mike Pence for this designation. It's highly seasonal business, but deals can be profitable if done right.
    There are $1M+ houses on the beach but if you go a few blocks out, prices come down considerably. The Miller STR market has become much more saturated in recent years, probably because other cities that overlap with the Indiana Dunes don't allow STR.

    For BRRRR investing Hammond and East Chicago are great but you need to vet tenants carefully (really this is true anywhere, but especially so here). These are B- to C neighborhoods depending on location with great rent to price ratios (esp if renovating). I have some buy and holds in Crown Point and Cedar Lake as well. These are considered more desirable neighborhoods with good schools and nicer downtown areas.

    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Ryan Flanagan:

      If you're looking for STR investing, Miller Beach is often overlooked because of the Gary address (it actually used to be a separate city that was annexed decades ago). It's a little enclave nestled in the Indiana Dunes National Park... thank you Mike Pence for this designation. It's highly seasonal business, but deals can be profitable if done right.
      There are $1M+ houses on the beach but if you go a few blocks out, prices come down considerably. The Miller STR market has become much more saturated in recent years, probably because other cities that overlap with the Indiana Dunes don't allow STR.

      For BRRRR investing Hammond and East Chicago are great but you need to vet tenants carefully (really this is true anywhere, but especially so here). These are B- to C neighborhoods depending on location with great rent to price ratios (esp if renovating). I have some buy and holds in Crown Point and Cedar Lake as well. These are considered more desirable neighborhoods with good schools and nicer downtown areas.


      This is very insightful! I truly agree about vetting tenants carefully. One of the reasons I got into STR is because of the difficulties I had faced in the past with some of our longer term tenants. Especially in the C neighborhoods. We tend to buy in A / B neighborhoods now to avoid some of those headaches.

  • Jonathan KlemmBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Contractor · Chicago, IL · Member since 2016 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    5mo

    Hey @Ryan Flanagan - Curious how long you have been on the NW Indiana game?  Do you invest at all in Chicago or the suburbs?

    Sounds like an interesting play with the short-term rental at Miller Beach.  How many do you have in that area?

    • Ryan FlanaganPro Member
      Accountant · Naperville, IL · Member since 2020 · 41 posts · 27 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Jonathan Klemm:

      Hey @Ryan Flanagan - Curious how long you have been on the NW Indiana game?  Do you invest at all in Chicago or the suburbs?

      Sounds like an interesting play with the short-term rental at Miller Beach.  How many do you have in that area?

      Hey! I've been doing deals in NWI since about 2014. I've got 2 STRs in Miller and 4 more annual lease places in the Miller area. 

      Yeah, I invest in IL too.  I've got stuff in Logan Square, Pilsen, Albany Park, South Shore, Bolingbrook and Naperville.

      I've temporarily paused my buying to focus on building outsourced accounting and finance solutions for real estate professionals.  But I'll be back at it soon enough.

  • Investor · Hendersonville, NC · Member since 2016 · 498 posts · 286 votes
    5mo
    Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

    Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.


    Ryan’s comment is a good breakdown. I’ve found the “looks good on paper” C-neighborhood deals can get expensive fast if tenant quality and management aren’t right./

    I get why STR or better A/B long-term areas can become more appealing after dealing with some rougher tenants.

    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Dominic Mazzarella:
      Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

      Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.


      Ryan’s comment is a good breakdown. I’ve found the “looks good on paper” C-neighborhood deals can get expensive fast if tenant quality and management aren’t right./

      I get why STR or better A/B long-term areas can become more appealing after dealing with some rougher tenants.


      100% - I learned that some deals are a time / emotional drain. But that can also be true of some STR markets too!

    • Investor · Hendersonville, NC · Member since 2016 · 498 posts · 286 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Philip Wrigley:
      Quote from @Dominic Mazzarella:
      Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

      Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.


      Ryan’s comment is a good breakdown. I’ve found the “looks good on paper” C-neighborhood deals can get expensive fast if tenant quality and management aren’t right./

      I get why STR or better A/B long-term areas can become more appealing after dealing with some rougher tenants.


      100% - I learned that some deals are a time / emotional drain. But that can also be true of some STR markets too!


      Completely agree. STRs can look cleaner because you avoid some long-term tenant issues, but they bring their own headaches: guest expectations, cleaning, seasonality, local rules, and constant little operational stuff.

      Different kind of stress, not no stress. 

  • Arman AhmedPro Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus Cleveland Dayton, OH · Member since 2024 · 2k+ posts · 975 votes
    5mo
    Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

    Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.


    That’s honestly one of the best ways to get into real estate, accidentally starting with one property and then realizing the model actually works. The operators who survive long term in short-term rentals are usually the ones who get good at systems, guest experience, and renovations, not just buying properties. Midwest vacation markets are interesting right now too, because some investors are pairing cash-flow-focused long-term rentals in places like the Midwest with selective vacation rentals for higher upside and diversification. Sounds like you’ve already built real operational experience, which is the part most people underestimate.
  • Real Estate Consultant · Ann Arbor, MI · Member since 2022 · 477 posts · 266 votes
    5mo

    Hi Philip from Chicago!

    Congratulations! You are a short-term rental investor looking to connect with others in the short-term rental investing space including in Michigan.

    Short-term rentals are a great asset class and we help investors around the country invest in Michigan. From along Lake Michigan, to inland lakes, to college towns, to city centers. There are many areas that perform well.

    To Your Success!

  • Victor SoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 326 posts · 193 votes
    5mo
    Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

    Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.

     Hey @Philip Wrigley ! Welcome! I run some STR stuff (combined with rent by room stuff) in Chicago. I've thought about investing in Galena but I know there's a huge waitlist for STRs there. Do you still run STRS in Chicago and Galena?

    Victor So Real Estate LLC517 Reviews
    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Victor So:
      Quote from @Philip Wrigley:

      Hey everyone, I’m Phil based out of Chicago. I originally got into real estate through short term rentals almost by accident after buying one property that snowballed into a full time business over the years. Most of my experience is in vacation rentals, renovations, guest experience, and figuring things out as I go like most of us probably are. My first attempt at a hello got deleted as I made the rookie mistake of adding the name of my business! :P I’ve spent a long time lurking on BiggerPockets so figured it was time to finally introduce myself. Looking forward to connecting with other investors, especially anyone in the Chicago, Galena, or Southwest Michigan areas.

       Hey @Philip Wrigley ! Welcome! I run some STR stuff (combined with rent by room stuff) in Chicago. I've thought about investing in Galena but I know there's a huge waitlist for STRs there. Do you still run STRS in Chicago and Galena?


      I do - I am a bit of a self-described Galena STR expert now :P Happy to answer any questions about deals there!

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago & NWI · Member since 2015 · 860 posts · 521 votes
    5mo

    Hey @Philip Wrigley 

    nice to meet you! Chicago and Northwest Indiana (East Chicago, Gary, Hammond) are great areas to invest in, too! agree with @Ryan Flanagan

  • Lender · Lake City, MI · Member since 2019 · 118 posts · 42 votes
    5mo

    Welcome Phil — the "figuring things out as you go" part is probably the most relatable thing in real estate. Curious what your biggest surprise was going from 1 STR to doing it full time?

    • Property Manager · Chicago, IL · Member since 2026 · 45 posts · 35 votes
      5mo
      Quote from @Bryce Fairburn:

      Welcome Phil — the "figuring things out as you go" part is probably the most relatable thing in real estate. Curious what your biggest surprise was going from 1 STR to doing it full time?


       Great question! I am guessing the need to have systems in place and a good tech stack was not something I considered when I started out but is actually hugely important!

  • Investor · Raleigh, NC · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 3 votes
    5mo

    Welcome, Phil.
    The fact that you started with one property and turned it into a full business already puts you ahead of most people here.A lot of investors underestimate how hard STR management and guest experience really are. Glad to see someone building through real experience instead of social media hype.Chicago + Midwest vacation rentals is an interesting niche right now.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.