Question about disclosures in Pennsylvania (Lycoming County)

Question about disclosures in Pennsylvania (Lycoming County)

Hughesville, PA · Member since 2017 · 2 posts · 0 votes

I have a question about "disclosures". In order to sell a home, next to a neighbor with a "WORKING" outhouse (Seriously, her house was built more of a cabin WAAAY Back when ....). Well, next door lady has never installed indoor plumbing, besides a shower stall. Yeah, I know.

 Any who .. trying to decipher the legal answer to "Do I have to disclose".

Per

http://www.pacode.com/secure/data/049/chapter35/s3... section 8 reads semi-vague. Let me explain way.

House I am trying to sell, is well water (Not "city-plumbed"), and has a septic tank.

Neighbors "outhouse" isn't technically on the property, but fairly close to the house. (In a normal suburban city neighborhood, for example, the outhouse would be as close as your next door neighbors house.)

Okay, so past resident SAID they couldn't notice any odors in the summer. Not sure if that's true.

the county claims they can't do anything about it, as the neighbor is now grandfathered in and they can't force her to do indoor plumbing. Yeah, it's 2017.

So then I tried to look up "Neighborhood Nuisances.

I read, "A nuisance is a noise or odor from a source outside the property that could irritate the property

0Reply
46 views

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Audubon, PA · Member since 2009 · 13k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    9y

    You didn't ask a question, so anybody posting is just going to have conjecture ...

  • Patrick LiskaPro Member
    Investor · Verona, NJ · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 832 votes
    9y

    NO, @Steve Babiak, he is asking if he would have to disclose that the neighbor has an outhouse that may effect the water since it is well water. If you had the water tested, you would have to disclose the results of the test, if not, there is nothing to disclose, you are only disclosing what is your house and the conditions of it.

  • Attorney · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Dave Wommer @Patrick Liska

    Assuming it applies, the Real Estate Seller Disclosure Law requires the seller to make certain disclosures. RESDL has a "catch-all" provision that requires you to disclose any "material defect." I don't have the exact language in front of me, but the statute defines the "material defect" as a problem that would cause: (1) a significant adverse impact on the value of the property; or (2) an unreasonable risk to people that live on the property. 

    I suppose depending on how bad the smell is (and various other factors), perhaps a judge may feel that the seller should have disclosed the existence of the outhouse as a "material defect." Unfortunately I don't think this is an area of the law where there is a clear answer. Not sure if you are the seller or buyer, but I would consult with your attorney to get his thoughts since it is possible that your local Court of Common Pleas may have ruled on a similar issue in the past. 

    There is a relatively recent Pennsylvania case that went all the way to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. I don't recall the exact facts, but I believe the issue there was whether the "catch-all" provision requires the seller to disclose the fact that a gruesome murder/suicide occurred on the property. The PA Supreme Court said that the seller does not need to do so. You can try to find the opinion itself, but I read the reasoning as being that: (1) such murders have nothing to do with the physical safety of the house; and (2) requiring sellers to disclose such facts may lead to sellers having to disclose other "stigmas." 

    You also reference nuisance law. Not sure what your exact question is there, but there are a lot of factors to consider if you are thinking about bringing a nuisance claim (or trying to defend yourself from one).   

  • Patrick LiskaPro Member
    Investor · Verona, NJ · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 832 votes
    9y

    @Chris K. there may be a house next door that is loaded with mold, does that affect your house? Especially if you didn't know it had mold. There has to be some limitation to it, you don't know what is going on in your neighbors house, just like if the water wasn't tested, you don't know what effect the out house would have. On the other hand, as a buyer, I would want to know about that. I had a property that I bought and listed ( later decided to keep it) but the previous owner passed away in it, I was not required to disclose that nor was the realtor, if the buyer asked, it would have had to been disclosed. I also just sold a home - never tested it for radon - so I didn't have to disclose it - it came back at a high level during the home inspection, if the buyers did not purchase the house I would have had to disclose the results from that point on. I do agree that this is a matter for an Attorney to inform you on in reference to what has to be disclosed.

  • Attorney · Nashville, TN · Member since 2015 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    Hi @Patrick Liska: RESDL only requires the seller to disclose defects that the seller knows about. What's more, RESDL also has other protections for sellers as well. For example, RESDL allows sellers to avoid liability if their failure to disclose was caused by their reasonable (but ultimately incorrect) belief that they took steps to cure the material defect in the past. So if you didn't know that the door next door had mold, RESDL would not require you to disclose it even if that mold constitutes a "material defect." 

    Now in real life, reasonable people can disagree on what constitutes "material defect" and "knowledge." For RESDL, the buyer must prove to the fact finder that the seller failed to disclose a "material defect" that the seller "knew" about. That's not always easy.

    But once in a while, you see a pretty strong case for the buyer. Let's say the buyer notices a leak in the ceiling within few months of buying the property. The buyer calls a plumber to look at the problem. The plumber stops by and tells the buyer that: (1) he actually stopped by the home to look at this problem a few month before the sale; (2) he discovered serious issues with the pipe; and (3) seller did not hire him to fix the problem due to the repair costs. The buyer then investigates this further and finds that the seller also contacted other plumbers in the area to get different quotes. All these plumbers are willing to testify on behalf of the buyer. In such cases, the buyer may have a good chance of making his or her case under RESDL (and other related laws). 

  • Patrick LiskaPro Member
    Investor · Verona, NJ · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 832 votes
    9y

    @Chris K. I agree with you completely on that and is what I was saying, If it is known, you must disclose it - the unknown, there is nothing to disclose. So in this case, if the water wasn't tested and there has been no notification from the town that the out house is or could be a problem, then it is an unknown, so there would be nothing to disclose. That's just the way I see it but again, that's up to a lawyer to decide what "should" be done. I would want to know about it if it was a house I was buying.

  • Hughesville, PA · Member since 2017 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    9y

    Thanks for all of the discussions. For clarification, yes, I am trying to "SELL" the house, not buy it. It's already mine. It's a valid point *I* as well would want to know before I bought a house like that. (This was a house that was gifted to me,  and has been int he same family since the 1960's or so...).

    To me, it's a slight eye sore, as well as a potential sanitation issue, if not now, then at some point. Good idea to have the water tested, and basically have that officially disclosed. I am aware, that RESDL is generally aimed at "material defect"'s.  There was no murders or ghosts, ha, so that's not the issue here of course. The county property tax folks has already said that it's "legal" to have it there, based on it being grandfathered in before the law changed. (Oy vey!)

     It sounds as though to make sure, I have to have an attorney to make sure.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.