Hello,
I am new to this community. I recently started an investment group and have raised enough capital to rehab a property. I am having trouble reaching listing agents and finding a deal that will give me the time of day to hop on the phone. If anyone could help with this or has any direction to point me in, it would be very appreciated.
I hear you on the listing agent struggle. Most MLS brokers dont care about investor offers, especially on first-time deals. That's actually the wrong hunting ground for flips anyway.
Here's what actually works: direct mail to off-market sellers. You grab a list of properties matching your criteria (age, size, neighborhood, condition), send 500-1000 postcards, and let sellers call you. Direct mail costs $500-800 and pulls deals listing agents never see. I run campaigns like this in multiple markets and consistently get 3-5 qualified leads per 1000 mailers. Your goal is one good flip, not a hundred leads.
Second play is driving for dollars in your area. Find the worst blocks, get addresses, pull tax records, and skip-trace the owners. Cold call or mail direct. Takes time but it costs almost nothing. You're looking for out-of-state landlords, estate heirs, or people drowning in a property.
What's your target purchase price and repair budget? That determines which list and marketing strategy makes the most sense.
@Davis Range Do you have a budget to market for your own leads so you can build a pipeline of direct to seller leads? We do 4-6 deals a month but we spend money on direct mail and google ads to capture those deals each month. Check out ListLab.us if you are looking to possibly run a mailing campaign!
Cheers!
@Davis Range Do you have a budget to market for your own leads so you can build a pipeline of direct to seller leads? We do 4-6 deals a month but we spend money on direct mail and google ads to capture those deals each month. Check out ListLab.us if you are looking to possibly run a mailing campaign!
Cheers!
Thank you @Luke Diem, I will look into that today! We have not set up a budget to market leads, but now plan to do so.
I hear you on the listing agent struggle. Most MLS brokers dont care about investor offers, especially on first-time deals. That's actually the wrong hunting ground for flips anyway.
Here's what actually works: direct mail to off-market sellers. You grab a list of properties matching your criteria (age, size, neighborhood, condition), send 500-1000 postcards, and let sellers call you. Direct mail costs $500-800 and pulls deals listing agents never see. I run campaigns like this in multiple markets and consistently get 3-5 qualified leads per 1000 mailers. Your goal is one good flip, not a hundred leads.
Second play is driving for dollars in your area. Find the worst blocks, get addresses, pull tax records, and skip-trace the owners. Cold call or mail direct. Takes time but it costs almost nothing. You're looking for out-of-state landlords, estate heirs, or people drowning in a property.
What's your target purchase price and repair budget? That determines which list and marketing strategy makes the most sense.
I hear you on the listing agent struggle. Most MLS brokers dont care about investor offers, especially on first-time deals. That's actually the wrong hunting ground for flips anyway.
Here's what actually works: direct mail to off-market sellers. You grab a list of properties matching your criteria (age, size, neighborhood, condition), send 500-1000 postcards, and let sellers call you. Direct mail costs $500-800 and pulls deals listing agents never see. I run campaigns like this in multiple markets and consistently get 3-5 qualified leads per 1000 mailers. Your goal is one good flip, not a hundred leads.
Second play is driving for dollars in your area. Find the worst blocks, get addresses, pull tax records, and skip-trace the owners. Cold call or mail direct. Takes time but it costs almost nothing. You're looking for out-of-state landlords, estate heirs, or people drowning in a property.
What's your target purchase price and repair budget? That determines which list and marketing strategy makes the most sense.
Okay Wonderful @Bo Smith. I think I should pivot and try the direct mail then because that sounds a lot more responsive than what I'm seeing now. We are new and have only raised 80k and have the option to go higher if needed. The lender has given us a lot of wiggle room and right now has the repair budget at 100K with room to grow.
OP.
1. Bring the Realtors the deals.
Do some leg work and find your own deals. Pick a Broker and have them act as your Buyer agent.
Sounds backwards! Let them know you're the real deal. Give them free money. Then they will bring you deals in the future. Once they know your Buy Box and you're the real deal, they will bring deals to you. Pick an active agent who handles your Buy Box.
2. Don't chase the same deals everyone else is chasing. Change your Funnel. Couple of examples even if they are not your buy box.
A. 227 W York St, Norfolk, VA. Commercial for "LEASE". it has been listed since 2020. They also have it listed for Sale since 2024. The Owner now understands the Market value. Approach them to "BUY". Do the leg work to see if it fits your Buy Box. Either as Commercial. Or can you do "Subject To" special/conditional use permit to Residential. Great location.
B. 2810 Somme Ave, Norfolk, VA. Religious house in Residential neighborhood. 4,000 sqft, nice street, nice neighborhood, great location, etc etc. Who would want to buy that??? You!!!
Do the legwork. No one else will do it for you. Above took 5 minutes. Line the potential deals up. Make 3 day offers that fit your numbers, subject to "whatever". Move on to the next one.
Hello,
I am new to this community. I recently started an investment group and have raised enough capital to rehab a property. I am having trouble reaching listing agents and finding a deal that will give me the time of day to hop on the phone. If anyone could help with this or has any direction to point me in, it would be very appreciated.
Good on you for raising capital first. Thats the backwards way most people approach this, and it shows youre thinking strategically. But heres the reality -- listing agents wont make time for you because theyre not the deal source. Theyre transaction processors. Theyre making 2.5-3% on list price whether its a flip or retail buyer, so they dont care which one buys it.
Your deal flow needs to come from off-market. Direct mail to absentee owners, probate lists, tax foreclosures, or pre-foreclosure leads. Those cost money to run (budget $3-5k/month to get 3-6 actual deal submissions), but youre not competing with every agent and their cousin for the MLS. Id also network into your local REIA or real estate meetups. Get in front of wholesalers and other investors. Thats where the deals actually flow in most markets.
Whats your market? And do you have a team lined up for the rehab side, or are you still building that out?
Hello,
I am new to this community. I recently started an investment group and have raised enough capital to rehab a property. I am having trouble reaching listing agents and finding a deal that will give me the time of day to hop on the phone. If anyone could help with this or has any direction to point me in, it would be very appreciated.
Let's look at this logcically to help you understand what you're dealing with.
You want an agent to spend their time looking for deals for you and then writing offers, right?
How many hours do you expect them to do this for FREE?
Oh wait, they're going to get a commission - only if you actually close on a property!
Otherwise, you waste a lot of their time - and they NEVER get paid🤢
You following this?
How many times do YOU think it takes an agent getting burned by investors, until they learn they're better off ignoring them?
So, now what?
Why do you need an agent to find you a "deal"?
With Realtor and Zillow websites, you have access to everything on the MLS.
Start analyzing properties in reverse - start with ARV amounts and work backwards to figure out what you can offer to make a profit. Then start contacting the listing agents to make that offer.
I appreciate all of your perspectives on this.
Davis, I understand where you’re coming from — from my understanding, it can feel frustrating when you’re trying to get traction, especially when listing agents aren’t as responsive as expected.
Bo, I agree with your point about off-market deal flow. I’ve learned the same thing — real opportunities tend to come from doing the legwork, building relationships, and consistently putting yourself in environments where deals are actually moving, not just relying on listings.
Henry, I also hear you on analyzing deals based on your own numbers and not chasing what everyone else is chasing. I believe that's a major shift — once you start working backwards from ARV and structuring deals around your numbers, everything becomes more intentional.
From my experience, building the right network doesn’t just happen — it comes from showing up, going to local investor groups, doing your due diligence, and treating this like a real business. I used to think similarly early on, but the more I learned and applied, the more I realized I needed to take ownership of the process instead of depending on others to create opportunities for me.
At the same time, I’ve worked with both agents and wholesalers on deals, and I believe they can coexist if it’s done strategically. I don’t expect an agent to do my job — I expect them to do what they’re licensed to do. As long as roles are clear and the deal is structured properly, it can work.
For me, it really comes down to the numbers. I’ll look at a deal both ways — what it looks like working with others and what it looks like independently — so I can decide if it even makes sense to involve additional parties.
And realistically, not every deal is going to be perfect. Some deals are tight, and when that’s the case, you have to leave enough room for the end investor. If the numbers don’t support multiple people in the deal, I think it’s important not to force it.
I also think it’s important to remember that every deal is different. Every experience — whether it’s with an investor, agent, or another wholesaler — should be approached based on the situation. Part of growing in this business is learning how to protect your position while still understanding how to work with others effectively.
I know my approach may be a little different, but I’ve learned that not every deal has to be aggressive to get done. There are definitely people in this space who will try to outmaneuver you if given the opportunity, but I don’t believe the only way to move deals is by being difficult or overly aggressive.
Most of the deals I’ve been able to close or build on have come from simply being fair, being clear, and treating people like people. I focus on making sure the seller is comfortable, the investor sees the value, and my assignment fee makes sense within the structure.
I believe that approach is what builds real relationships — not just one-off transactions — and over time, those relationships turn into repeat buyers and long-term opportunities.
Also, Davis — one thing I’d add from my perspective is that how you present yourself matters, especially on a platform like this. There’s real power in how you structure your message, because that’s how people understand what you’re looking for.
A lot of wholesalers and investors move quickly and tend to skim, so if your message isn’t clear, people may overlook it or question whether you’re ready to move as a buyer. Being direct about your intent, your criteria, and how you plan to move will help the right people find you.
At the same time, deals don’t typically fall into your lap — whether it’s through an agent or a wholesaler. You have to be proactive. BiggerPockets gives you access to a lot of people in one place — agents, wholesalers, and investors — so reaching out directly and starting conversations can go a long way.
From my experience, I’ve actually started doing a good amount of my networking through BiggerPockets recently — not because it’s my only avenue, but because I like to keep multiple channels open. Even just getting familiar with the platform, I was able to connect with several investors quickly, which showed me how much opportunity is here when you use it intentionally.
I’d also say — as someone who works closely with investors — since you’re newer, it may help to have a financial advisor or someone experienced help guide your numbers early on, until you fully understand what you’re looking at yourself. That can help you avoid getting into deals that are too tight or over your head.
I’ve come across a lot of deals from flippers who ended up needing to exit because the margins weren’t what they expected. Some of those deals can still work, but they often come with very little room, and sometimes require flexibility on fees just to get them done.
That’s not always ideal, and it can be time-consuming, especially if the deal wasn’t structured properly from the beginning. But at the same time, every deal is a learning experience, and over time you get a better feel for what to take on and what to pass on.
Davis, I hope this gives you some perspective and helps you move forward with a bit more clarity. If you’re open to it, I’d also be curious to know what your buy box looks like.
Davis — this is specifically for you.
You can read through the full thread, but I want to speak to you directly for a second.
From my understanding, your role right now is to buy — you don’t need to know everything like a wholesaler or agent, but you do need to understand how to work with both.
Also, you’re on a platform like BiggerPockets — that’s a huge advantage. There’s real power in how you present yourself here. If your message isn’t clear about what you’re looking for, people will skim past it or question if you’re ready to move.
Deals don’t fall into your lap — you have to be proactive. Reach out, connect, and be direct about your buy criteria. There are agents, wholesalers, and investors all on this platform you can tap into.
From my experience, a lot of the better opportunities come off-market, and that’s often where wholesalers come in.
Because you’re newer to investing, if you don’t have one already, it’s helpful to have a financial advisor or mentor so you can fully understand your numbers and what makes a deal good or bad — that way you can move confidently and avoid stepping into deals that don’t work for you.
At the same time, it’s important to understand how everyone in the deal gets paid. Wholesalers and agents are compensated through the deal, so naturally, the structure needs to make sense for them as well. But from my understanding, the best deals are the ones where everyone wins — not just one side. That’s what builds real, long-term relationships instead of one-time transactions.
If you’re open to it, I’d also be curious to know what your buy box looks like so you can position yourself more clearly when reaching out to people.
You’re running into a normal wall. It’s not you, it’s where you’re looking.
Listing agents aren’t a deal source, they’re just handling listed properties. They’re not motivated to chase investor offers, especially from newer buyers. That’s why you’re getting ignored .
Real flip deals come from off market.
Direct to seller, wholesalers, driving for dollars, that's where your margin is. MLS deals are usually picked over unless you're very fast or very aggressive.
Also, if you want agents to take you seriously, show you can close. Clear buy box, proof of funds, and move quickly. Once you close one, they’ll start bringing you deals.
Right now, focus on building deal flow, not chasing agents.
If you want, send me your buy box and numbers and I’ll help you tighten it so deals actually start coming to you.
Stevan
Surprised no one mentioned facebook yet.
Join keybuyersclub.com! We love working with first time investors. :)
First off - congrats. Raising capital and getting started is a big move. Most people never get there. On the agent issue, don’t take it personally. They’re not ignoring you - they’re just prioritizing buyers they’re confident will close. You’ll start getting traction if you:
• Get your proof of funds dialed in and ready to send instantly
• Clearly define your buy box (price, area, property type)
• Follow up consistently -that alone separates you That solves the short-term problem.
But zoom out for a second… You mentioned going after a flip - totally valid. Just make sure you’re thinking about what that money does for you long term. A flip can make you $200K–$300K annually … but then it’s gone. No equity, no cash flow, no carryover. That same capital, deployed differently as downpayment on a cash flowing rental it could:
• build a portfolio
• generate monthly income
• and stack real equity over time That’s the difference between
creating income… and building wealth. Not saying don’t flip — just be intentional. A lot of investors wish they had kept a few early deals instead of selling everything.