Developer · Riga, Latvia | Switzerland | Florida · Member since 2026 · 195 posts · 41 votes
A national homebuilder told purchasing to cut $20,000 from every house. It landed on the trades: another round of bids, another squeeze.
Investors do the same when the rehab number looks high. But the best crews walk away, the cheaper crew rushes, and the money comes back as rework.
Question for investors and lenders: is it smarter to pay a crew a fair rate and run more deals with them? Or is the real problem that you can't find anyone you trust without checking every step?
Atleast in Chicago many of the contractors charge insane rates especially the ones who work with lots of retail clients. If you do not have cheap workers you are never going to make any money.
From the rental operations side, I care more about the cost of getting the property genuinely ready than the lowest quote. I'd compare the same written scope, materials, cleanup and completion date, then agree how changes get approved. A fair rate still needs progress checks. The expensive part is discovering at the final walkthrough that both sides had a different definition of finished.
@Matthew Tregoning, thank you! "A different definition of finished" is the most expensive line I've read this week.
On our last bathroom in Switzerland that's exactly where we put the work. Every stage was closed with photos and the proof attached, so "finished" meant the same thing for both sides. After demolition we found additional work nobody could have priced upfront. It went in as a separate line the owner signed before we did it.
We're not the cheapest. We hold our price with structure and order. Just for fun we ran the same bathroom through ChatGPT from photos and size. It's not a builder, of course, but our price landed in the middle of its range.
I'm curious about the human side: how does the approval moment usually go with your owners? Every country has its own habits.
And one question, not an ad :) If you had a tool for this, what would you want it to do, or what would you change, from your experience?
Vladimirs, on Columbus value-add 1–4s I've learned the same lesson: the cheap bid often isn't cheap once change orders and a second crew show up. What works for me is one written scope, materials standard, progress photos at each stage, and changes signed before work continues — then I pay a fair rate to the crew that hits those checkpoints. Are you pricing your first Columbus rehab with a contingency for hidden work after demo, or trying to lock a fixed number before walls open?
@BJ Everson, same lesson here: pay a fair rate to the crew that hits the checkpoints.
On Columbus: a colleague sends us houses, and we price the rehab and put in everything we can before anyone visits. Our weak spot is the structure. From photos I can't judge it well yet, and for us quality that lasts matters more than cosmetics.
In Switzerland we built our model by running real jobs through it. For the US we just need test houses: walking 5-10 of them, or seeing before and after projects with their real numbers.
Would you be open to sharing one or two past Columbus rehabs, before and after with the final cost? We'd run them through our model and send you what it shows.
Atleast in Chicago many of the contractors charge insane rates especially the ones who work with lots of retail clients. If you do not have cheap workers you are never going to make any money.
@Henry Lazerow, thank you! We found a third way between "insane rates" and "cheap workers".
There are a lot of good tradespeople who are great with their hands, but can't find jobs on their own or put together an offer. They just know how to do the work well. Our tool does the rest for them: the job, the offer, the plan. A bit like Red Bull, it gives them wings 😄
In Chicago, where do investors usually find their crews: referrals, Facebook groups, or the same guy they've used for years?
From the agent side, I see this from the other end — the squeeze usually starts before the contractor is ever hired, when a buyer falls in love with a deal whose rehab budget was too tight to begin with. Then every bid looks too high. The investors I see do this well pay a fair rate, but they protect themselves three ways: a written scope with the same materials and finish standard for every bid, milestone payments tied to photos of completed stages, and a contingency — usually around 10 to 15 percent — for what you find after demo. That last one is the key. If the deal only works with zero surprises and the cheapest crew, it's not a good deal, it's a wish. Pay the crew that shows up, document everything, and keep them busy — that's how you stop checking every step.
@Ametria Chaney, thank you! "It's not a deal, it's a wish" - I'm stealing that line 😄
You're right, the squeeze starts on the day of the offer. That's why we price the rehab line by line before the house is bought: a colleague sends us a house, we put in everything we can see, and the buyer knows the real number before he falls in love.
In Memphis, do your buyers usually get a real rehab number before they make the offer, or only after closing?
@Vladimirs Veiss I'm a GC (so my answer is going to be a bit biased!) and I work a lot with investors here in Chicago because I am an investor myself. Here is what I see on the contractor side - the most reliable, efficient crews have more work than they can handle so they will just move on to another job. To your last comment, I think that is spot on, yes, price the rehab line by line but once you've built up trust with someone you've done a couple deals you get a sort of innate idea of where they will land. But quality counts and you don't want to squeeze and then loose in rework, change orders or a delayed rent date.
@Jonathan Klemm, thank you! A biased GC who's also an investor is the best kind of answer 😄
Everyone has the same pain. We solved it a bit differently, with something like a tender. Tradespeople send us their bids, and if someone decides he doesn't like something, there's always someone else ready to do the job.
Crews feel the moment very well. When they understand you won't find anyone else right now, they slow down and start twisting your arm. But our model prices the job, watches it and checks every stage, and the work is run remotely. So there's no arm to twist 😄
We tested it on jobs where the owners were around and where they weren't. One thing is clear: when the owner lives there or comes by often, everything gets harder, mostly the dates start to slide. So we advise everyone to stay out of the way and just enjoy watching the work move, and we build the product for exactly that.
On your Chicago jobs, do the investors come by the site a lot, or do they let you run it?
If you pick the cheapest you spend to much time managing them and there work quality. I find reasonable independent contractors and then respect them and provide an easy (no home owner, no working over finishes, environment at their time of day some sleep in some are super early before other gigs some are here on weekends so they fit me with other jobs. ) and pay quickly so they want to do my jobs in the future and keep the price reasonable.
@Kevin Ivey, I'd say it's not only about reasonable contractors 🙂 The main thing is that they're responsible and bring the plan to life with their craft.
And our job is to be the conductor, keeping every process moving in the right direction.
How do you keep it in order when the early crew and the late crew need the same room?
I'd rather pay a fair rate than squeeze. On a $200K ARV flip with a $40K rehab, shaving 10% saves $4K, but a redo on one trade plus three extra weeks of carry at about $1,900 a month (roughly $1,400) eats most of that. I get two or three bids on a written scope, take the one in the middle, and tie draws to finished work. The crew that gets paid on time is the one that shows up for your next deal, and that's worth more than the $4K.
You've got the right instinct, and paying fair usually pays off twice. The second payoff shows up on the lender side of this. Most of the fix and flip lenders I shop fund the rehab in draws, released after an inspector confirms the work is done. A crew that's been squeezed on price often can't float labor and materials until the next draw clears, so the job stalls while interest keeps running on what's already out. Keeping the same crew across several deals also builds your track record. Many rehab lenders set loan to cost and pricing partly on how many projects you've finished on budget, and a lot of them want the contractor's bid and scope in the file. A crew you keep makes your budget easier for an underwriter to believe. The bid gets the job started, the crew you keep gets you the next loan.
Good day @Noah Wright , thank you for the lender view, it is the part most owners never see.
From our renovation jobs in Switzerland I would add one thing: stalls usually start with additional work nobody scoped, not with the crew rate. When each stage has its own line-by-line price, additional work becomes a new line with a photo and a price, signed before work continues. The finished stage stays clean and nothing waits on an argument.
When additional work appears mid-rehab, do your lenders want it documented before the next draw?
Fair rate plus checkpoints beats squeezing, and your point about post-demo surprises going in as their own signed line is what makes that work with a lender too. Most rehab lenders want the extra work documented before the next draw, because the inspector releases money against the line items in the approved budget, not against what's on site. Unscoped work has no line to draw against. If it fits inside the total budget, many lenders let you reallocate between lines once they have the revised scope. If it pushes the total up, it usually becomes a change order the lender has to approve, and anything past their loan to cost limit comes out of your pocket. Your stage by stage pricing is already close to a draw schedule. Do you hand lenders that breakdown as the draw schedule at closing?
Investors, lenders, realtors et al don't dictate what is a fAiR rate lol. Legit Contractors run businesses, COGS and what the market will bear dictate rates regardless of whatever some Investors or realtors think.. period.
depends on the market to a certain extent.. in markets that fixer houses are dominated by wholesalers many rehabbers are forced into the cheapest to make any money as @Henry Lazerow points out. U know non licensed etc etc the key there is having trusted cheap labor if you can find it. Its the wholesalers that are causing these issues if they were not in the middle of these deals there would be more money to hire better contractors.
Also so many venture into C class which is really D and your top contractors wont even work in those neighborhoods because of theft and risk to life and limb.
these are not first line subs or contractors you would have to personally experience it to understand it.
now if your building new builds with top line sub base who has their insurance and their bonds and licenses current thats a whole nother sub base from the mom and pop rehabber doing 20 to 30k rehab jobs.
99% of small contractors don't do anything with pre liens or do any bother with lien waivers. its a slippery slope with the small rehab jobs and the small rehab contractors.
where you going with this is how I pay my subs in new construction. Where I have a sub trade for each specific task and they front all materials and bill us by the 25th and our checks go out on the 10th each month.. along with Lien Waivers if its a larger sub the lien waivers are generally required by title companies especially coming out of the GFC when so many lenders and banks got burned by contractors not paying their suppliers and all the liens that came after the fact. However these subs are on a whole different level than your D C B class reno jobs at the 20 to 70k range.. Where the those guys pretty much need to be paid weekly and many times you have to help them buy materials as they have no credit. Its an issue trying to get your rehabs at a price point that will match your proforma to create the cash flow your dreaming of on your BRRR project.
@Jay Hinrichs, weekly pay and help with materials is what crews without credit need.
When each stage's materials are paid to the supplier directly, the supplier-lien risk you describe from the GFC is closed, and the crew is paid weekly for labor on the lines finished that week.
On the 20 to 70K jobs, do you buy through your own supplier account, or reimburse the crew against receipts?
I started with cheaper crews out of necessity as we all kind of grew up and found our way. There were issues, generally time frames, rather than quality of work, due to contractors over extending but the delays were costly. As I made more and could afford to hire more professional contractors the time frame issues have essentially resolved. If the plumber said he will be there on Wednesday they are there on Wednesday. My time frames have run over by a few weeks at times rather than a few months. As for the original question I haven't ever tried to negotiate on the bid price. There have been times when I had to remove or adjust features to make the price work but I either pay what they ask or accept another bid. I don't want them to start the job feeling undervalued.
I try to do 1 and done with my rehab projects. Most times the feature is off the table as these are generally items that I have over-reached on to begin with such as replacing functioning sliders with French doors in a STR for aesthetic value.
@Jules Aton, thank you, that is clear. A nice-to-have cut before the crew starts costs nothing. The same cut after the work is open is paid twice, for the work done and for closing it up.
On your STRs, which upgrade do guests mention most in the reviews?
Exactly. Squeezing contractors is a classic case of tripping over dollars to pick up dimes.
The real bottleneck isn't finding the absolute lowest bidder it's managing execution risk. When elite crews walk away because of race-to-the-bottom bidding, your project timeline stretches, holding costs compound, and quality control collapses.
Paying a fair, top-tier rate to a trusted, accountable crew ensures speed-to-market (lower DOM) and zero post-closing warranty callbacks. In this business, margin is protected by accurate up-front underwriting and clean property acquisition, not by grinding down the guys swinging the hammers.
Agreed, and you've put your finger on why schedule beats price. A late trade doesn't cost his bill, it costs every day the rehab loan sits open with interest running. The cut feature has a second cost people miss, though. If the appraiser's after repair value assumed that feature, dropping it can pull the as completed value down, and that value is what the exit refinance or cash-out gets sized on. So a cut made before the loan closes is clean, and one made halfway through can shrink the refi along with the scope. When a feature comes out after closing, does your tool send the revised stage pricing back to the lender, or does it stay between owner and crew?
@Noah Wright, it goes to the lender. A cut feature becomes its own changed line with a new price, visible to the lender before the next draw, the same as to the owner and the crew.
So the lender sees what the cut does to the scope before it is approved, not at the refi.
Would your lenders rather approve such a cut upfront, or is a view before the draw enough?