first bid won potential disaster

first bid won potential disaster

Margaret ConnorPro Member
Pulaski, Giles County · Member since 2024 · 9 posts · 4 votes

Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?

1Reply
497 views

Most Popular Reply

Don KonipolBusiness Member
Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
7mo
Quote from @Margaret Connor:

Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?

People giving advice on this thread MEAN well; but the advice can be harmfully incorrect for 2 reasons: first, the posters are not legally educated nor trained, nor practice law so they may be incorrectly classifying the subject action; second even if they correctly classify such action they are probably stating how the law in the state(s) they are familiar with treats the situation, not necessarily the same as the state the property is located in.  
You can look to this forum for moral support, but until you (1) verify exactly what the situation is (and isn’t) and (2) speak with an attorney specializing in real estate law in the jurisdiction the property is located in, you’ll be running numerous scenarios through your mind which may in no way apply to your specific problem. 
Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
See this reply in the discussion

16 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Broker · Atlanta · Member since 2024 · 1k+ posts · 608 votes
    7mo

    @Margaret Connor Did you not change the locks? If not, that complicates things because entering without permission after title transferred would be considered breaking and entering, which is a criminal matter, not just civil. At this point, I would strongly recommend getting a local real estate attorney involved ASAP and start the eviction process. Document everything and avoid any self-help removal. Another option may be to offer cash for keys to get him to vacate the property and then re-key immediately.

    • Margaret ConnorPro Member
      OP
      Pulaski, Giles County · Member since 2024 · 9 posts · 4 votes
      7mo
      Quote from @Janice Carter:

      @Margaret Connor Did you not change the locks? If not, that complicates things because entering without permission after title transferred would be considered breaking and entering, which is a criminal matter, not just civil. At this point, I would strongly recommend getting a local real estate attorney involved ASAP and start the eviction process. Document everything and avoid any self-help removal. Another option may be to offer cash for keys to get him to vacate the property and then re-key immediately.


       I just got the deed two days ago. Thank you. First thing in the morning. 

  • Member since 2011 · 152 posts · 113 votes
    7mo

    Actually this is not an EVICTION matter, this is an EJECTMENT. That's  because you've never had a landlord/tenant relationship with this person. So be sure to follow whatever the attorney tells you so that you do not inadvertently create one. Ejectments are easier and faster than evictions which must be navigated in light of the rights of the tenant. The person who must be ejected is presumed to have no rights relating to the property.

  • Ned CareyPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Baltimore, MD · Member since 2008 · 17k+ posts · 13k+ votes
    7mo

    @Margaret Connor Despite claims otherwise, tax sales can be quite risky as you are finding out. Hopefully those reading along can learn from this. This is even worse because you are out of state and you are not there to personally asses the situation. 

    Do you need a lawyer? Well it depends on multiple factors. Is this property in your own name or did you acquire it in an LLC? In some states you can file court cases in your own name (Pro Se or without an attorney.) But if you own the property in an LLC you need to get a lawyer.

    Also the type of case may matter.  This is not your standard "eviction" for non payment of rent, this is what is called in Maryland a wrongful detainer - to remove someone who has no right to be in the house, but is not a tenant. 

    There may  be something in the tax sale laws describing how you do this in a tax sale situation. In Maryland, you file a "Writ of possession" in the tax sale case. 

    Even though you may be able to file yourself with the court, you may need a lawyer just to navigate what kind of case to file and how to file it. 
    So what is the property worth?  If there is big profit here just hire an attorney. If this isn't worth anything then sell it to the neighbor and get your money back. 

  • G. Brian DavisPro Member
    Investor · Hatboro, PA · Member since 2016 · 3k+ posts · 908 votes
    7mo

    Hi @Margaret Connor First step is to start the eviction/unlawful detainer process as soon as the court opens. I would not try to handle it or let the neighbor intervene, keep it clean and legal. Document everything and avoid any direct confrontation. Also an eviction attorney is definitely worth it in this situation to get things moving faster. 

  • Real Estate Broker · Coppell, TX · Member since 2011 · 5k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    7mo

    #1.  Don't go by rumors, you need to check it out or have a qualified person check out both issues.  Neighbors are not always experts...maybe rarely experts and in my experience often WRONG.  Do you know if the house is on septic or city sewer?  Have you seen it or had it inspected?  Do you have a survey?  Unusual, but could happen.

    #2. Have you verified any of the info they gave you.  Was the previous owner in prison?  How do you know he was dropped off at last known address?  Do you know if he is living in the home?

    #3. If all of this is true, it's just another example I recommend for anyone buying homes and especially out of state.  KNOW what you are buying.  You should know if it is on septic or city sewer.  You should find the tanks potentially before you buy.  I recommend seeing in person the property before you buy, even if you cannot see inside, often you can walk the property from the outside, look in the windows, etc.

    #4.  Are they squatting?  Can they or have they turned on utilities?  Some localities won't let you turn on utilities if the home is not in your name and there is no valid lease or authorization from the owner.  Some municipalities will not allow you to live in a home without utilities?  Maybe you can alert the utility providers to NOT turn on utilities to unauthorized persons.

    #5.  As others have mentioned at this point you don't really know if you have a criminal matter or a civil matter to deal with.  Could be criminal if they broke in....that could be trespassing or breaking and entering which are both criminal.  Email your deed and ID to the officer investigating.  Don't tell them the "rumors" of who is there. It is your house, you have not leased it, you understand someone has broken in.  Don't mention meth lab, prison release, previous owner.  That's all rumor.  In reality you don't know if anyone is there or if there is, who they are.  Let them figure that out.  All of that is also a two edged sword.  Involving the city is just that.  They may refer the case to code enforcement and they start ticketing you for not securing the house, if there was meth lab or heavy meth use, you may get DEA required cleanup notice, the house could get a demo order from the city if there is not a legal sewer system, or broken windows, unsecured entry, etc.

    #6.  Get there ASAP.  Don't wait 3 months.  If you can't go, send someone.  Maybe hire a local realtor.  Maybe hire a property preservation company.  Maybe hire a local inspector.  I've never used them, but I see ads from a couple of different companies called BootsontheGround dot .... They have a network of people who take pictures and walk arounds, etc.

    #7.  In the future....buy what you know.  Buy what you can see.  Buy what you can inspect and manage.  Otherwise you could be buying a liability NOT an asset.  Go to the auctions in person, so you see who is bidding, you hear the talk, you can network with other investors, you can talk to the sheriff, the tax authorities, and sometimes other politicos like the county commissioners who show up.  All those can be a HUGE wealth of information that no google street view or satellite view will ever share.

    • Margaret ConnorPro Member
      OP
      Pulaski, Giles County · Member since 2024 · 9 posts · 4 votes
      7mo
      Quote from @Bruce Lynn:

      #1.  Don't go by rumors, you need to check it out or have a qualified person check out both issues.  Neighbors are not always experts...maybe rarely experts and in my experience often WRONG.  Do you know if the house is on septic or city sewer?  Have you seen it or had it inspected?  Do you have a survey?  Unusual, but could happen.

      #2. Have you verified any of the info they gave you.  Was the previous owner in prison?  How do you know he was dropped off at last known address?  Do you know if he is living in the home?

      #3. If all of this is true, it's just another example I recommend for anyone buying homes and especially out of state.  KNOW what you are buying.  You should know if it is on septic or city sewer.  You should find the tanks potentially before you buy.  I recommend seeing in person the property before you buy, even if you cannot see inside, often you can walk the property from the outside, look in the windows, etc.

      #4.  Are they squatting?  Can they or have they turned on utilities?  Some localities won't let you turn on utilities if the home is not in your name and there is no valid lease or authorization from the owner.  Some municipalities will not allow you to live in a home without utilities?  Maybe you can alert the utility providers to NOT turn on utilities to unauthorized persons.

      #5.  As others have mentioned at this point you don't really know if you have a criminal matter or a civil matter to deal with.  Could be criminal if they broke in....that could be trespassing or breaking and entering which are both criminal.  Email your deed and ID to the officer investigating.  Don't tell them the "rumors" of who is there. It is your house, you have not leased it, you understand someone has broken in.  Don't mention meth lab, prison release, previous owner.  That's all rumor.  In reality you don't know if anyone is there or if there is, who they are.  Let them figure that out.  All of that is also a two edged sword.  Involving the city is just that.  They may refer the case to code enforcement and they start ticketing you for not securing the house, if there was meth lab or heavy meth use, you may get DEA required cleanup notice, the house could get a demo order from the city if there is not a legal sewer system, or broken windows, unsecured entry, etc.

      #6.  Get there ASAP.  Don't wait 3 months.  If you can't go, send someone.  Maybe hire a local realtor.  Maybe hire a property preservation company.  Maybe hire a local inspector.  I've never used them, but I see ads from a couple of different companies called BootsontheGround dot .... They have a network of people who take pictures and walk arounds, etc.

      #7.  In the future....buy what you know.  Buy what you can see.  Buy what you can inspect and manage.  Otherwise you could be buying a liability NOT an asset.  Go to the auctions in person, so you see who is bidding, you hear the talk, you can network with other investors, you can talk to the sheriff, the tax authorities, and sometimes other politicos like the county commissioners who show up.  All those can be a HUGE wealth of information that no google street view or satellite view will ever share.


       This is very thorough, thank you. 1. The house has septic, but the tank is on a bordering property. I have seen the house, but not inspected it as the owner was living there at the time. 2. The previous owner was arrested and in prison. I read the newspaper articles. I have a screenshot of the neighbors text to his landlord- yes it can be fabricated, but I do not think it was. 3. I fully intended on living near by before the redemption period ended, but... can't change that now. Noted for future buys. 4. I do not even think they were aware of the sale. From what I read in the paper, he was supposed to be in prison for a few years. I thought I had time to fix and flip before that. I do not think utilities are on since it has been vacant for months. Will call in the morning. 5. spoke to an officer this morning and emailed all pertinent documents. I don't think he was runing anything in the house... fingers crossed there. 6. Was planning on sending someone as soon as I had deed in hand (which was yesterday), but now with him on property... I can't just go change locks. 7. I only plan on buying in this county which I will be living in and they only do online auctions, but I assume I will get to know lots of the county clerks and such to network as much as I can. Thank you for your thoughts.  

  • Jimmy LieuBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus, OH · Member since 2019 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7mo
    Quote from @Margaret Connor:

    Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?

    Margaret, this is one of those situations where it feels chaotic, but the path forward is actually pretty standard from a legal standpoint. Since the former owner is now physically occupying the property, law enforcement is right that it’s a civil matter unless there’s clear evidence of trespass after notice or criminal activity. Even though you hold the deed, you generally can’t just remove someone without going through the eviction (unlawful detainer) process, especially if they were the prior owner or occupant. Your next step is to file for eviction as soon as the courthouse opens—many investors handle this themselves if the process is straightforward in that county, but given the added complications (tax sale, redemption period, prior owner returning, septic issue tied to another parcel), this is one of those times where hiring a local real estate attorney is worth it to avoid delays or mistakes. In the meantime, document everything, keep communication with the neighbor but don’t rely on their info alone, and do not attempt any “self-help” eviction like changing locks or shutting off utilities, as that can backfire legally. Once the eviction is filed, timelines will depend on the county, but having clean documentation of your deed and the expired redemption period will be key. Also, before selling to that neighbor, you’ll want to fully understand and disclose the septic issue since that could impact value or even title clarity. Situations like this are messy but not uncommon with tax deed properties, and they usually resolve cleanly once the legal process is followed.
  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    7mo
    Quote from @Margaret Connor:

    Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?

    People giving advice on this thread MEAN well; but the advice can be harmfully incorrect for 2 reasons: first, the posters are not legally educated nor trained, nor practice law so they may be incorrectly classifying the subject action; second even if they correctly classify such action they are probably stating how the law in the state(s) they are familiar with treats the situation, not necessarily the same as the state the property is located in.  
    You can look to this forum for moral support, but until you (1) verify exactly what the situation is (and isn’t) and (2) speak with an attorney specializing in real estate law in the jurisdiction the property is located in, you’ll be running numerous scenarios through your mind which may in no way apply to your specific problem. 
    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
    • Bruce WoodruffPro Member
      Contractor/Investor/Consultant · San Diego / Phoenix · Member since 2021 · 12k+ posts · 15k+ votes
      7mo
      Quote from @Don Konipol:
      Quote from @Margaret Connor:

      Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?

      People giving advice on this thread MEAN well; but the advice can be harmfully incorrect for 2 reasons: first, the posters are not legally educated nor trained, nor practice law so they may be incorrectly classifying the subject action; second even if they correctly classify such action they are probably stating how the law in the state(s) they are familiar with treats the situation, not necessarily the same as the state the property is located in.  
      You can look to this forum for moral support, but until you (1) verify exactly what the situation is (and isn’t) and (2) speak with an attorney specializing in real estate law in the jurisdiction the property is located in, you’ll be running numerous scenarios through your mind which may in no way apply to your specific problem. 

      What @Don Konipol said ^^^^^^

  • Investor · Baltimore County, MD · Member since 2014 · 466 posts · 439 votes
    6mo

    @Margaret Connor where in TN is this? I have not read all of the other answers but we just did a foreclosure and sold the property on owner financing through a realtor so I may at least be able to point you in the right direction. 

    • Margaret ConnorPro Member
      OP
      Pulaski, Giles County · Member since 2024 · 9 posts · 4 votes
      6mo
      Quote from @Jamie Bateman:

      @Margaret Connor where in TN is this? I have not read all of the other answers but we just did a foreclosure and sold the property on owner financing through a realtor so I may at least be able to point you in the right direction. 


       I got a lawyer in town who handles these things often. Looks like I will break even on the deal, but I sure did learn a lot. 

  • Investor · Rochester, NY · Member since 2016 · 576 posts · 358 votes
    6mo

    @Don Konipol your answer is much less fun to read than many of the previous answers.

  • Chris SeveneyBusiness Member
    Moderator
    Investor · VA · Member since 2015 · 21k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    5mo
    Quote from @Margaret Connor:

    Ok. I won my first bid for a property in Tennessee a year ago- purchase price 10k. The one year redemption period has passed and I now have the deed in my name. I was contacted by the neighbor next door who is interested in purchasing it for 12,500. He mentioned septic issues. I researched and it turns out the septic tank was placed on a separate parcel owned by a third party. This morning I got a call from the same neighbor informing me that the previous owner (who had been in orison for selling meth) was released today and dropped off at his last known address. He is now in the home. I live out of state and will not physically be there for three months. I have informed the local police department and they will swing by there today, but have told me that this is now a civil matter. Today is Sunday so I can't get in touch with the courthouse to file for eviction- any suggestions? Should I file myself or do I need a lawyer? Next steps?


     so what did you end up doing in this situation? what is the status? what are the lessons learned?

    7e investments4.34 Reviews
  • Margaret ConnorPro Member
    OP
    Pulaski, Giles County · Member since 2024 · 9 posts · 4 votes
    5mo

    I got a lawyer who filed a writ of possession and got the person out. Right now the next door neighbor is looking into buying it from me, but I will likely have to get a quiet title for that to happen. I thought this was a great experience because anything that could have happened did. I will totally be trying this again with other properties. 

  • Specialist · Bristol, CT · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 11 votes
    4mo
    Quote from @Margaret Connor:

    This is exactly the scenario that keeps me up at night when I think about how many investors walk into auctions without pulling the full lien picture first.A few questions worth working through right now depending on what you won:

    First, was this a tax deed sale or a tax lien certificate? That changes everything about what you actually own and what your exposure is.

    Second, pull the grantor/grantee index for that property on the county clerk site right now if you haven't. Look for anything recorded after the delinquency started, IRS liens filed separately from county records are the most common disaster because they can survive a tax sale if proper notice wasn't given to the IRS before the sale.

    Third, check the redemption period. Depending on your state you may still be in a window where the original owner can reclaim the property, which affects every dollar you spend on it right now.

    I spent 15 years in mortgage underwriting reviewing exactly these kinds of title situations before loans could close. The good news is most of these problems are solvable, they just cost more the longer you wait to address them.What state is the property in and what specific issues came up after you won?

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.