Analyzed 20 Deals This Week… Is It Normal That None of Them Pencil Out?

Analyzed 20 Deals This Week… Is It Normal That None of Them Pencil Out?

New to Real Estate · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2020 · 14 posts · 20 votes

Hey BP Community, Nick here again.

I’ve been posting a lot more recently and just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s commented and shared advice so far. The feedback has honestly been incredibly helpful and I’ve already learned a ton.

I just posted Episode 2 of my YouTube series where I’m documenting my journey toward buying my first investment property. The whole idea behind the series is to hold myself accountable and show the real process of someone starting completely from scratch. If anyone wants to follow along, I linked the video below.

I’m also planning to post at least once a week here on BiggerPockets as another form of accountability and to get feedback from people who have been through this before.

What I focused on this week

This past week was mainly about deal analysis. I analyzed roughly 20 deals (15 so far) in the Philadelphia market.

My thought process right now is to focus on one market per week so I can get a better feel for pricing, rents, and numbers in a specific area. For example:

  • This week: Philadelphia

  • Next week: likely Lehigh Valley

That said, I’m debating whether 20 deals per week is too many. I may cut it down to 10 deals per week so I can spend more time digging deeper into each one.

Expense assumptions I am currently using.

Based on some of the advice from people here, I adjusted the assumptions I’m using in my analysis:

  • Maintenance: 10% of rent

  • CapEx: 10% of rent

  • Property management: 10%

  • Vacancy: 5%

  • Insurance estimate: $1.50 per square foot

If anyone thinks I’m off on these numbers or has better rules of thumb, I’d definitely appreciate the feedback.

One thing I've noticed

The biggest thing I’ve been running into is that deal analysis feels very repetitive. It seems like I’m analyzing a lot of properties and most of them just don’t pencil out as good deals.

Logically, that makes sense as good deals probably should be rare, but mentally it can feel like you’re spinning your wheels a little.

For those of you who have been doing this longer:

Is that pretty much the process?
Just analyzing a lot of properties until something finally makes sense?

8Reply
907 views

Most Popular Reply

Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2026 · 28 posts · 14 votes
8mo

It’s actually very normal. A lot of people who are newer to investing think they’re doing something wrong when deals don’t work on paper, but in reality most properties on the market won’t make sense as investments. In many markets you might analyze dozens of properties before you find one that even gets close to your target numbers.

Part of what you’re doing right now is really just learning the market. After looking at enough properties you start to recognize quickly what price ranges, rent levels, and neighborhoods make sense and which ones don’t. Over time you’ll be able to eliminate a lot of listings in seconds before even running the full numbers.

Your expense assumptions also look pretty conservative, which isn’t a bad thing. Using solid assumptions early on helps prevent deals from looking better on paper than they are in reality.

One thing that can help is focusing on how the deal would need to change for it to work. Sometimes that means a lower purchase price, sometimes higher rent potential, sometimes adding value through renovation or improving management.

But overall the process you described is pretty much how most people start. A lot of analysis, a lot of deals that don’t work, and eventually you come across one that actually fits your criteria. The repetition you’re experiencing is also what helps build the instinct for spotting opportunities later.

See this reply in the discussion

34 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2026 · 28 posts · 14 votes
    8mo

    It’s actually very normal. A lot of people who are newer to investing think they’re doing something wrong when deals don’t work on paper, but in reality most properties on the market won’t make sense as investments. In many markets you might analyze dozens of properties before you find one that even gets close to your target numbers.

    Part of what you’re doing right now is really just learning the market. After looking at enough properties you start to recognize quickly what price ranges, rent levels, and neighborhoods make sense and which ones don’t. Over time you’ll be able to eliminate a lot of listings in seconds before even running the full numbers.

    Your expense assumptions also look pretty conservative, which isn’t a bad thing. Using solid assumptions early on helps prevent deals from looking better on paper than they are in reality.

    One thing that can help is focusing on how the deal would need to change for it to work. Sometimes that means a lower purchase price, sometimes higher rent potential, sometimes adding value through renovation or improving management.

    But overall the process you described is pretty much how most people start. A lot of analysis, a lot of deals that don’t work, and eventually you come across one that actually fits your criteria. The repetition you’re experiencing is also what helps build the instinct for spotting opportunities later.

  • Lender · Playa del Carmen, México · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8mo
    Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

    Hey BP Community, Nick here again.

    I’ve been posting a lot more recently and just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s commented and shared advice so far. The feedback has honestly been incredibly helpful and I’ve already learned a ton.

    I just posted Episode 2 of my YouTube series where I’m documenting my journey toward buying my first investment property. The whole idea behind the series is to hold myself accountable and show the real process of someone starting completely from scratch. If anyone wants to follow along, I linked the video below.

    I’m also planning to post at least once a week here on BiggerPockets as another form of accountability and to get feedback from people who have been through this before.

    What I focused on this week

    This past week was mainly about deal analysis. I analyzed roughly 20 deals (15 so far) in the Philadelphia market.

    My thought process right now is to focus on one market per week so I can get a better feel for pricing, rents, and numbers in a specific area. For example:

    • This week: Philadelphia

    • Next week: likely Lehigh Valley

    That said, I’m debating whether 20 deals per week is too many. I may cut it down to 10 deals per week so I can spend more time digging deeper into each one.

    Expense assumptions I am currently using.

    Based on some of the advice from people here, I adjusted the assumptions I’m using in my analysis:

    • Maintenance: 10% of rent

    • CapEx: 10% of rent

    • Property management: 10%

    • Vacancy: 5%

    • Insurance estimate: $1.50 per square foot

    If anyone thinks I’m off on these numbers or has better rules of thumb, I’d definitely appreciate the feedback.

    One thing I've noticed

    The biggest thing I’ve been running into is that deal analysis feels very repetitive. It seems like I’m analyzing a lot of properties and most of them just don’t pencil out as good deals.

    Logically, that makes sense as good deals probably should be rare, but mentally it can feel like you’re spinning your wheels a little.

    For those of you who have been doing this longer:

    Is that pretty much the process?
    Just analyzing a lot of properties until something finally makes sense?

    Episode 2 is linked below.

    Feel free to comment here, DM me, or roast my analysis if I’m doing something wrong. I’m here to learn.

    Appreciate all the help so far and looking forward to continuing the journey.

    @Nicholas Scheld Nice work on the YT videos!

    It's not at all surprising that most of the deals you've analyzed don't work as investments. I suspect you're finding most of these on Zillow and/or the MLS.

    And that's the problem: These properties are prices for retail buyers who plan to live in them, not hold them as investments. You can't expect to cash flow if you're paying retail prices.

    You need the "wholesale discount!"

    And, to be clear, I'm not saying you have to buy from a wholesaler. I'm saying the properties that work for us as investors are the ones retail buyers don't want, usually because the condition is rough and scary.

    Retail buyers tend to avoid houses like this, so investors like us can swoop in and grab ourselves a "wholesale discount" of 30-90%, depending on how much work is needed.

    Find yourself properties that "normal" owner-occupant buyers would never consider, and you'll uncover more investment-grade deals.

  • Investor · Blockchain · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 4 votes
    8mo

    What tools or sites did you use to "pencil out" the properties? 

  • New to Real Estate · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2020 · 14 posts · 20 votes
    8mo

    I use the MLS for the listed price/taxes/insurance and zillow/apartments for rent ideas.

    • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

      I use the MLS for the listed price/taxes/insurance and zillow/apartments for rent ideas.

      You don't find deals, you have to make them. More true in 2026 than ever. Usually it's a push/pull: you have to get the sales price down a little and the rent up. And then grind your teeth and accept the remaining gap. That goes back to accepting that you either get a great deal or a great property, you won't get both. And needless to say, long term getting a great property is more important. You can also do a reality check and go back in time to last years deals. Look at the best 20% and add a year of price increases - that's what's realistic.

    • Jay HinrichsBusiness Member
      Real Estate Consultant · Summerlin, NV · Member since 2014 · 45k+ posts · 66k+ votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Marcus Auerbach:
      Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

      I use the MLS for the listed price/taxes/insurance and zillow/apartments for rent ideas.

      You don't find deals, you have to make them. More true in 2026 than ever. Usually it's a push/pull: you have to get the sales price down a little and the rent up. And then grind your teeth and accept the remaining gap. That goes back to accepting that you either get a great deal or a great property, you won't get both. And needless to say, long term getting a great property is more important. You can also do a reality check and go back in time to last years deals. Look at the best 20% and add a year of price increases - that's what's realistic.


      there is not need to run numbers  its just a proven fact over time overhead all in is 40% of rent then deduct mortgage very simple napkin math and pretty darn accurate for those in the bizz that actually track costs assuming one is using leverage or max leverage.. paying cash different story of course. 
    • Investor · Cody WY, USA · Member since 2020 · 50 posts · 31 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

      I use the MLS for the listed price/taxes/insurance and zillow/apartments for rent ideas.

      It's a good starting point - MLS + Zillow/Apartments.com is enough to get reps in early.

      The biggest thing I’d recommend is getting really consistent with your screening framework so you’re not reinventing the wheel on every deal. Even if the rent estimate changes a bit, if you’re running the same assumptions and metrics every time, you’ll start spotting bad deals a lot faster.

      And yes, totally normal that most don’t pencil. That’s kind of the job. The win is getting to the point where you can eliminate weak deals in 5 minutes instead of 45.

  • Member since 2026 · 1 post · 1 vote
    8mo

    I enjoyed your video! 

  • Real Estate Agent · Chicago, IL · Member since 2017 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8mo

    Reality is real estate has changed from being a high cashflow investment to being a wealth builder that takes a lot more patience to payoff. After the GFC was great and then briefly in Covid due to extremely low rates deals had high cashflow. Those days long gone.  

    Wholesale deals are also sent out to groups of investors, you are not getting some great undermarket deal unless direct to owner. In fact majority of wholesale deals are complete junk and worse prices then what get on MLS, often with such fake rehab and arv numbers its almost comical. I have done two BRRRs off MLS deals and had tons of clients buy very good deals off the MLS, I actually posted on here a month or so ago of a MLS deal that appraised $50k over our contract price. Doing value adds is essential and finding stuff where can drastically increase the rents to get the cashflow high as possible.

  • Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    8mo

    The approach I utilized when advising Clients, is to determine, based on your locale, three tiers of potential properties...A, B, C. Each tier identifies a general level of "as is" quality, which in term identifies a separate tier of spending to be RTR (ready to Rent).

    In other words, numbers alone, unless they are very accurate due to sufficient due diligence and investigation, need to take "age" into account. A ten year old property is simply not going to have the same repair/update scope of work needed as a fifty year old property.

    You also need to determine the quality of materials that will be utilized. Cheap, short lived, not very durable products; or mid-priced, with good parts supply support, that provide a reasonable or long useful life; or flashy, top of line, WOW factor finishes and tech. For a long term hold plan, you do not want to go with the "cheap" option. Realistically, most of the labor required to install or apply products is similar across these options. If you "save" now by using cheap products, you will "pay" later when you need to repair or replace in a much shorter period than the serviceable mid priced options.

  • New to Real Estate · Orange County, CA · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 28 votes
    8mo

    I relate strongly with this post. I've been doing the exact same thing in SoCal: grinding through Zillow listings, running numbers, watching almost everything come back red. It's not just you.

    The shift for me was to stop treating monthly cash flow as pass/fail and start looking at the 10-year picture. When I run IRR with DCF projections at different appreciation rates, some deals that look like clear losers monthly actually tell a more interesting story over a longer hold. A property that loses $200/mo but has a 12% 10-year IRR at moderate appreciation is a different conversation than just "doesn't pencil, next."

    The other thing that changed my process was building break-even analysis into every deal. What exact price, rate, or rent flips it from red to green. That tells you how fragile a deal actually is, which is way more useful than one cash flow number.

    On your assumptions, I'd separate capex from maintenance as distinct line items. On older builds especially, a roof or HVAC hit is a different animal than ongoing upkeep.

    Keep grinding. The reps are the point, you're building pattern recognition even when the deals don't work out.

  • Investor · Pacific Northwest · Member since 2026 · 538 posts · 315 votes
    8mo

    @Nicholas Scheld 

    Yes — it’s normal.

    But not for the reason you think.

    Most people will tell you:

    “Good deals are rare, just keep analyzing.”

    That’s only half true.

    What’s actually happening is you’re analyzing listings, not opportunities.

    By the time a deal hits the open market in a competitive area like Philadelphia, it has already been:

    Seen by dozens of investors

    Underwritten by brokers

    Priced against recent comps

    Adjusted to market expectations

    So you’re not early — you’re last in line.

    At that point, your analysis becomes repetitive because the outcome is already baked in.

    That’s why everything starts to feel like:

    “Almost works, but not quite.”

    “Close, but numbers are thin.”

    “Would work if X was different.”

    That’s not a coincidence. That’s the market doing its job.

    The shift isn’t analyzing more deals.

    It’s understanding where in the timeline you’re entering.

    Early in the lifecycle, deals look messy:

    Incomplete information

    Operational problems

    Unclear pricing

    Human issues behind the property

    Later in the lifecycle, deals look clean — but the margin is gone.

    So yes, analyzing 20 deals and having none pencil is normal if you’re sourcing from the same place everyone else is.

    The pattern you’re feeling (repetition) is actually useful.

    It means you’re starting to recognize what “market-cleared” deals look like.

    The next step isn’t just going deeper on analysis.

    It’s asking:

    Where do deals look like this before they look like listings?

    That’s where things start to change.

  • Investor · Hendersonville, NC · Member since 2016 · 498 posts · 286 votes
    8mo
    Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

    Hey BP Community, Nick here again.

    I’ve been posting a lot more recently and just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s commented and shared advice so far. The feedback has honestly been incredibly helpful and I’ve already learned a ton.

    I just posted Episode 2 of my YouTube series where I’m documenting my journey toward buying my first investment property. The whole idea behind the series is to hold myself accountable and show the real process of someone starting completely from scratch. If anyone wants to follow along, I linked the video below.

    I’m also planning to post at least once a week here on BiggerPockets as another form of accountability and to get feedback from people who have been through this before.

    What I focused on this week

    This past week was mainly about deal analysis. I analyzed roughly 20 deals (15 so far) in the Philadelphia market.

    My thought process right now is to focus on one market per week so I can get a better feel for pricing, rents, and numbers in a specific area. For example:

    • This week: Philadelphia

    • Next week: likely Lehigh Valley

    That said, I’m debating whether 20 deals per week is too many. I may cut it down to 10 deals per week so I can spend more time digging deeper into each one.

    Expense assumptions I am currently using.

    Based on some of the advice from people here, I adjusted the assumptions I’m using in my analysis:

    • Maintenance: 10% of rent

    • CapEx: 10% of rent

    • Property management: 10%

    • Vacancy: 5%

    • Insurance estimate: $1.50 per square foot

    If anyone thinks I’m off on these numbers or has better rules of thumb, I’d definitely appreciate the feedback.

    One thing I've noticed

    The biggest thing I’ve been running into is that deal analysis feels very repetitive. It seems like I’m analyzing a lot of properties and most of them just don’t pencil out as good deals.

    Logically, that makes sense as good deals probably should be rare, but mentally it can feel like you’re spinning your wheels a little.

    For those of you who have been doing this longer:

    Is that pretty much the process?
    Just analyzing a lot of properties until something finally makes sense?

    Episode 2 is linked below.

    Feel free to comment here, DM me, or roast my analysis if I’m doing something wrong. I’m here to learn.

    Appreciate all the help so far and looking forward to continuing the journey.


    Analyzing 20 deals a week isn’t unusual when you’re just starting out, but the key is knowing when to pivot from quantity to quality. I’ve found that going slower and really digging into fewer deals helps you identify nuances others miss, especially in local rent comps and rehab costs. Also, keep an eye on municipal code violations or properties with notice of violations—they sometimes flag owners who might be motivated to sell. Deal flow can feel exhausting at first because most deals won’t work, but it’s part of the process to build a reliable pipeline. Eventually, those deeper dives will save you time and help you avoid spinning your wheels.

  • Joe VilleneuvePro Member
    Plymouth, MI · Member since 2013 · 13k+ posts · 19k+ votes
    8mo

    Stop tracking the numbers of properties you analyze as if it matters at all.  It doesn't.  You analyze properties until you find deals, however long it takes.  If you find that it's hard to find deals, then change your market, not your criteria (never change that), change your market until you find one(s) that do work.

  • Adam BartomeoBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Cape Coral, FL · Member since 2015 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    8mo

    LOL! I look at minimum of 100 a day (but its probably closer toe 300/day) and maybe find 1 -2 a WEEK where I would submit an offer. Over time you will get much faster at underwriting deals and therefore make more offers and therefore close on more deals.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    8mo
    Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

    Hey BP Community, Nick here again.

    I’ve been posting a lot more recently and just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s commented and shared advice so far. The feedback has honestly been incredibly helpful and I’ve already learned a ton.

    I just posted Episode 2 of my YouTube series where I’m documenting my journey toward buying my first investment property. The whole idea behind the series is to hold myself accountable and show the real process of someone starting completely from scratch. If anyone wants to follow along, I linked the video below.

    I’m also planning to post at least once a week here on BiggerPockets as another form of accountability and to get feedback from people who have been through this before.

    What I focused on this week

    This past week was mainly about deal analysis. I analyzed roughly 20 deals (15 so far) in the Philadelphia market.

    My thought process right now is to focus on one market per week so I can get a better feel for pricing, rents, and numbers in a specific area. For example:

    • This week: Philadelphia

    • Next week: likely Lehigh Valley

    That said, I’m debating whether 20 deals per week is too many. I may cut it down to 10 deals per week so I can spend more time digging deeper into each one.

    Expense assumptions I am currently using.

    Based on some of the advice from people here, I adjusted the assumptions I’m using in my analysis:

    • Maintenance: 10% of rent

    • CapEx: 10% of rent

    • Property management: 10%

    • Vacancy: 5%

    • Insurance estimate: $1.50 per square foot

    If anyone thinks I’m off on these numbers or has better rules of thumb, I’d definitely appreciate the feedback.

    One thing I've noticed

    The biggest thing I’ve been running into is that deal analysis feels very repetitive. It seems like I’m analyzing a lot of properties and most of them just don’t pencil out as good deals.

    Logically, that makes sense as good deals probably should be rare, but mentally it can feel like you’re spinning your wheels a little.

    For those of you who have been doing this longer:

    Is that pretty much the process?
    Just analyzing a lot of properties until something finally makes sense?

    Episode 2 is linked below.

    Feel free to comment here, DM me, or roast my analysis if I’m doing something wrong. I’m here to learn.

    Appreciate all the help so far and looking forward to continuing the journey.


    How much can you offer on each to make your ROI work?

    How many offers did you make on those properties at YOUR number?

    If none, how do you know how motivated the sellers might be?

    Welcome to real world investing...

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2021 · 796 posts · 510 votes
    8mo

    @Nicholas Scheld - Not sure what your target areas are in Philadelphia, but like any large MSA there are submarkets that are likely more enticing to investors based on rent/price ratios. Even in "better" zip codes for investing I think the good old fashion ration of underwriting 100 deals to make offers on 10 so that you can acquire 1 at a decent price still holds true. I would spend some time thinking through the specific submarkets that might support investment properties more so than other zip codes. I invest in the Philly suburbs so happy to connect!

  • Valhalla, NY · Member since 2013 · 132 posts · 84 votes
    8mo
    Hey best of luck on the investing journey. I remember analyzing deals for a couple of years before I made my fist purchase. As for the numbers penciling out always remember that every property has a price that can make it a deal or fit your “buy box”. List price on MLS almost never will reveal an easy deal that doesn’t need value add or solid management. Maybe you make an offer to a seller who would take “seller financing” and now you get the property 1-2% lower on the mortgage side. Keep on practicing the analysis but things will get more interesting when you submit offers.
  • Don KonipolBusiness Member
    Investor · The Woodlands TX / Avon, CT · Member since 2009 · 6k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    8mo
    Quote from @Nicholas Scheld:

    Hey BP Community, Nick here again.

    I’ve been posting a lot more recently and just wanted to say thank you to everyone who’s commented and shared advice so far. The feedback has honestly been incredibly helpful and I’ve already learned a ton.

    I just posted Episode 2 of my YouTube series where I’m documenting my journey toward buying my first investment property. The whole idea behind the series is to hold myself accountable and show the real process of someone starting completely from scratch. If anyone wants to follow along, I linked the video below.

    I’m also planning to post at least once a week here on BiggerPockets as another form of accountability and to get feedback from people who have been through this before.

    What I focused on this week

    This past week was mainly about deal analysis. I analyzed roughly 20 deals (15 so far) in the Philadelphia market.

    My thought process right now is to focus on one market per week so I can get a better feel for pricing, rents, and numbers in a specific area. For example:

    • This week: Philadelphia

    • Next week: likely Lehigh Valley

    That said, I’m debating whether 20 deals per week is too many. I may cut it down to 10 deals per week so I can spend more time digging deeper into each one.

    Expense assumptions I am currently using.

    Based on some of the advice from people here, I adjusted the assumptions I’m using in my analysis:

    • Maintenance: 10% of rent

    • CapEx: 10% of rent

    • Property management: 10%

    • Vacancy: 5%

    • Insurance estimate: $1.50 per square foot

    If anyone thinks I’m off on these numbers or has better rules of thumb, I’d definitely appreciate the feedback.

    One thing I've noticed

    The biggest thing I’ve been running into is that deal analysis feels very repetitive. It seems like I’m analyzing a lot of properties and most of them just don’t pencil out as good deals.

    Logically, that makes sense as good deals probably should be rare, but mentally it can feel like you’re spinning your wheels a little.

    For those of you who have been doing this longer:

    Is that pretty much the process?
    Just analyzing a lot of properties until something finally makes sense?

    Episode 2 is linked below.

    Feel free to comment here, DM me, or roast my analysis if I’m doing something wrong. I’m here to learn.

    Appreciate all the help so far and looking forward to continuing the journey.

    Lots of good advice posted here; I’m going to give you some actual examples of how the listing price is not very relevant; sometimes you’ve just got to get a “feel” that you can negotiate a deal with the seller, or acquire the property in some other way. 

    1. Auto repair facility asking price $300 000. I purchased the property thru BK court 4 months later for $115,000

    2. House in Ct listed for $1.3 million.  2 yers later I purchased house for lot value - $275k and flipped it to a builder for $350k.

    3. Bank selling note with UPB of $4 million and asking price of $3.6 million.  We purchased note for $1.875 million

    4. 1/2 interest in warehouse building. Seller asking $200k for  his interest.  Offered $10k with 24 hour closing and he took it. 
    Private Mortgage Financing Partners, LLC
  • New to Real Estate · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 6 votes
    8mo

    I'm in the exact same boat but in Atlanta looking at duplexes. I've run maybe 15 through the BP calculator and nothing comes close to cash flowing either. Does it change anything if you're planning to house hack and live in one unit? I keep wondering if I should be calculating it differently since my living expense would be covered.

  • New to Real Estate · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2026 · 11 posts · 6 votes
    8mo

    .

  • Stuart UdisPro Member
    Attorney · Philadelphia · Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    8mo

    @Nicholas Scheld  Expanding on what Greg wrote, Philadelphia is a city of neighborhoods, and even within those neighborhoods there are significant variations in value, rent, occupancy rate and many other metrics.  Because of that, the idea that you can spend a few days underwriting 20 deals in Philadelphia and then move on to a broad region like the Lehigh Valley and repeat the same process is, in my view, an inefficient use of time.

    You cannot realistically develop a strong enough understanding of any one local market to make informed investment decisions using that approach. I would take a step back and reassess your objectives before continuing down that path.

  • Specialist · Greeley, CO · Member since 2026 · 36 posts · 18 votes
    8mo

    Hello Nick, the repetitiveness is the process — you're building pattern recognition. After 50-100 deals, you'll be able to glance at a listing and know in 30 seconds if it's worth a deeper look. That "spinning your wheels" feeling goes away once you have enough data points in your head to filter fast.

    On your expense assumptions — a few thoughts:

    Vacancy at 5% is aggressive for Philadelphia. Philly vacancy varies a lot by neighborhood. Some areas in Center City or University City might justify 5%, but neighborhoods like Kensington or parts of North Philly can run 8-12%. I'd look at what actual vacancy rates are in the specific zip codes you're analyzing rather than using a flat number. If you're analyzing 20 deals a week, even a 3% swing in vacancy can flip a deal from "works" to "doesn't work."

    CapEx as a percentage of rent can mislead you. A $1,200/month rental and a $2,500/month rental in the same building need roughly the same roof, HVAC, and water heater. I'd estimate CapEx based on the actual age and condition of major systems rather than a flat percentage. A quick rule: add up replacement costs of roof ($8-12K), HVAC ($4-6K per unit), water heater ($1-2K), and divide by their remaining useful life. That gives you a monthly CapEx reserve that's grounded in reality.

    Insurance at $1.50/SF is a fine starting point but get actual quotes once you're serious about a deal. Philly has some flood zones and older construction that can push insurance higher than expected.

    On the "one market per week" approach — solid idea. You'll start seeing patterns within a market that you'd miss if you scattered across 5 cities. Stick with it.

  • Real Estate Consultant · Ann Arbor, MI · Member since 2022 · 479 posts · 266 votes
    8mo

    Hi Nicholas from Philadelphia, PA-

    Great question! You analyzed 20 deals this week and none of them pencil out with the numbers not working and you asked if this is normal.

    Yes, not all deals are a good deal and it's easy to get into a bad deal if you are not underwriting your deals well, getting emotional about the investing decisions, or not working with an experienced team.

    One big variable is where you are looking. Many places have become unaffordable and do not cashflow or they cash flow the first year and then the property taxes or insurance pop up and now you have a skinnier or upside down deal. Add a vacancy or unexpected large repair and you can easily be negative cashflow.

    What to do? Think about expanding your search to more affordable markets working with an experienced team. That is what we help investors do in Michigan.

    To Your Success!

  • Member since 2021 · 86 posts · 79 votes
    7mo

    Your assumptions are fine — the market is the problem, not your spreadsheet.

    One angle I haven't seen mentioned: that 4-bed in Philly that doesn't work at $1,800/month whole might work at $850-1,000/room rented individually to travel nurses. Jefferson, Temple, Penn Medicine, and Einstein cycle contract staff on 13-week assignments constantly, and most of them are searching Furnished Finder for furnished rooms with utilities included. A property that's -$200/month traditional could be +$800/month by the room after covering utilities and turnover.

    Not every deal fits that model, but it's worth running the second set of numbers before you throw a property out.

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    7mo

    Brandon Turner used to pretty often say, and I tend to agree, that every deal works at some point.  Its up to you to find the value of the deal to you, and find a seller that will sell you that asset at a price/value that coisides with that.

    the ask is just that, the ask, especially these days.  Its also true that deals are made not found.  The people doing this right now, are consistently making offers and consistently setting appointments, sure their numbers and underwriting may change based on different factors, but the fundamentals generally win out.  

  • Lender · Tampa, FL · Member since 2013 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    7mo

    That's really why, back 15 years ago, we stopped buying property at the county foreclosure auction. We were spending tons of time doing due diligence on the bids we were making, but found we were only winning about 1 out of every 400 we looked at. Lots of banks would bid more than the property was worth and newbie investors got so excited that they, too, overbid. We still look at tons of deals, but I will admit we are very picky on what we buy. Looking at 20 and not doing anything doesn't shock me...it's actually the norm for us. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2015 · 483 posts · 362 votes
    7mo

     one thing I’ve seen happen to a lot of people starting out is that they get stuck in a loop of running spreadsheets over and over on listed properties. The analysis itself is useful, but if that’s the only approach it can turn into an endless loop.

    At some point the limiting factor usually isn’t the spreadsheet — it’s market knowledge , understanding local patterns and access to deals.

    Spending  time connecting with people who are already operating rentals in philly can accelerate things dramatically. It helps you learn how to find opportunities and how deals that look marginal on paper sometimes become workable — and how investors are finding opportunities that never show up in the listings.

    I created something that’s very Philadelphia-centric — a place where local landlords share practical resources, real experiences, and referrals specific to operating rentals in this city. As someone who invests in multiple markets I find Philly to be a place that you really need to understand.

    Find someone who has already been doing deals here for years - it will shortcut months of trial and error. A good local expert can look at the same deals you’re analyzing and quickly explain why they work or don’t — and what kinds of opportunities you should actually be targeting in this city. A lot of people want to sell right now.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.