Question about Investing

Question about Investing

Rental Property Investor · Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 7 votes

HI this is a sort of unorthodox question: 

I live with my partner (unmarried) and our child. We are building an ADU in our backyard. I am financing most of it with a HELOC and we are both putting in some cash. We are wondering how to structure our agreement so that it feel clear and protects us from any possible future changes in our relationship (which is also unorthodox and more of a friendship). Basically we want the deal to be clean and work in case we separate so we are looking at it as a business deal vs being married.

I own the house and pay most of the mortage and all utilities (she chips in a little)

She will put in a chunk into the ADU and from that get a percentage of the net income from that ADU based on her investment.

We are also wondering if she should get a small percentage of ownership/equity in the overall property vs just own a % of the ADU.

This  seems like it makes sense as the ADU is adding value to the overall property. However if she's buying into the overall property than it would make more sense for her money to get a net income from the TOTAL net of the property not just the ADU, right? That gets complex though with our current structure  and she would then be making way less cash per month (as it would be a smaller percentage of the total property value vs a larger percentage of just the ADU). 

We were thinking of doing this: Giving her 30% (her investment) in the ADU for cashflow (so 30% of net cashflow) plus giving her 3% equity in the house (worth 1Million). But she'd only get rent from the ADU portion even if we moved out but 3% if we sold. Does that make sense? 

I know this is maybe a bit weird and a lot of details - I'd love to hear anyone else's perspective if you've done anything like this, or what makes sense for you. 

Thanks! 

0Reply
159 views

Most Popular Reply

Greg MalangaPro Member
Property Manager · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 8 votes
7mo

not unorthodox at all — this is just smart planning. You're basically structuring a real estate JV between two people who happen to live together.

You're already sensing the tension here. If she buys into the overall property, then yes, logically her return should come from the total property net income, not just the ADU. But like you said, that dilutes her monthly cash flow because her percentage of the whole property is tiny compared to her percentage of just the ADU. It also drags in your existing mortgage, your equity history, appreciation you earned before she was involved — it gets messy fast.

keep her interest scoped to the ADU only. It's cleaner, easier to calculate, and easier to unwind. Think of it like she's investing in a specific asset that happens to sit on your land.

Hope this helps you pointed in the right direction. 

See this reply in the discussion

6 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 7 votes
    7mo

    PS I forgot to change the title of this to be more specific and it won't let me edit it. It should say "question about investment structure in ADU with partner"

  • Greg MalangaPro Member
    Property Manager · Member since 2026 · 10 posts · 8 votes
    7mo

    not unorthodox at all — this is just smart planning. You're basically structuring a real estate JV between two people who happen to live together.

    You're already sensing the tension here. If she buys into the overall property, then yes, logically her return should come from the total property net income, not just the ADU. But like you said, that dilutes her monthly cash flow because her percentage of the whole property is tiny compared to her percentage of just the ADU. It also drags in your existing mortgage, your equity history, appreciation you earned before she was involved — it gets messy fast.

    keep her interest scoped to the ADU only. It's cleaner, easier to calculate, and easier to unwind. Think of it like she's investing in a specific asset that happens to sit on your land.

    Hope this helps you pointed in the right direction. 

  • Dan H.Pro Member
    Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
    7mo

    Some thoughts:

    - in virtually every market, ADUs add less value than the hands off dots of the ADU addition. NAR pulled their ADU resale data 2 months ago on the premise that it was outdated. I believe the reason NAR pulled the data is that it depicted a narrative not favorable to NAR. The data showed in virtually all markets the ADUs have far lower value than their addition. Building a single small unit is the most expensive residential development.

    - are you thinking for the partner's investment in the ADU they should get equity beyond the ADU investment. What is the thinking there. See the next puller.

    - a primary reason ADUs have good rent to cost ratios is because the land is already purchased.   This implies if you split the cash flow without consideration of the resulting land value, the partner is getting more than their contribution contributed to the cash flow.

    - I suspect the cash flow is not nearly what you think it is. Portland, like a lot of markets that are not below national median, has poor cash flow. With the current rates, the cash fliw is even more challenging. You like need monthly rent ratio to be over 1% at high LTV to have real cash flow after allocating for vacancy and sustained expenses. Note prop tax is 8% of rent at 1% ratio.

    Good luck

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 7 votes
    7mo

    HI @Greg Malanga thank you for taking the time here. And I appreciate your thinking, which was in line with my own. indeed, when you think about having her investment be a part of the overall property it begins to get messy. A note, this unit is not an official ADU, it's an addition, so I would not be able to consdier it a seperate asset.

    I think you are on point, though with keeping things separate and looking at her investment as getting equity in the addition percentage of the overall property, and the cashflow from that. Thanks! 

  • Rental Property Investor · Portland, OR · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 7 votes
    7mo

    @Dan H. Really appreciate your thoughts and taking the time here. Thank you. 

    I hear you on ADU's being the single most expensive investment. A couple points of clarity:

    1. We are actually permitting this as additional living space, so it's not a separate unit (only physically). And won't ever be able to be re-sold (I am planning on keeping this house forever pretty much, though, whether to live or rent)
    2. Half of our incentive for building it is lifestyle (a place for parents to rent as it will have two units in it). So it's not purely financial, though that is a necessary component. 

    Because she is putting cash into the addition, and it's a part of the overall property, the thinking was that she gets equity in the overall property since she is addiing value to it - but like i mentioned (and Greg reiterated "that dilutes her monthly cash flow because her percentage of the whole property is tiny compared to her percentage of just the ADU." 

    I appreciate your point about the land value being considered. The new partner is not having to purchase that or be liable for the loan on it. thanks for reminding me. 

    Portland has poor cashflow, yes agreed. I am solid on what i can rent this for as a long term rental and it pencils OK. I have a 3% loan on my property so I have some leverage there. 

    Ok thanks for your input

    • Dan H.Pro Member
      Investor · Poway, CA · Member since 2015 · 7k+ posts · 8k+ votes
      7mo
      Quote from @Robin A Jackson:

      @Dan H. Really appreciate your thoughts and taking the time here. Thank you. 

      I hear you on ADU's being the single most expensive investment. A couple points of clarity:

      1. We are actually permitting this as additional living space, so it's not a separate unit (only physically). And won't ever be able to be re-sold (I am planning on keeping this house forever pretty much, though, whether to live or rent)
      2. Half of our incentive for building it is lifestyle (a place for parents to rent as it will have two units in it). So it's not purely financial, though that is a necessary component. 

      Because she is putting cash into the addition, and it's a part of the overall property, the thinking was that she gets equity in the overall property since she is addiing value to it - but like i mentioned (and Greg reiterated "that dilutes her monthly cash flow because her percentage of the whole property is tiny compared to her percentage of just the ADU." 

      I appreciate your point about the land value being considered. The new partner is not having to purchase that or be liable for the loan on it. thanks for reminding me. 

      Portland has poor cashflow, yes agreed. I am solid on what i can rent this for as a long term rental and it pencils OK. I have a 3% loan on my property so I have some leverage there. 

      Ok thanks for your input

       I am not an expert in Portland rental laws and recognize like coastal CA are liberal including living arrangements.

      However, not building it as an ADU and just as additional living space can limit rental options. Even if that is not the case today, it may limit in the future.

      Do your permits show the new “unit” as having a kitchen or kitchenette?   Some jurisdictions use this as the criteria on separate unit or additional living space.   It is somewhat arbitrary and meaningless if they allow rent by room, multi family habitation, etc.

      Basically I am reminding you to make sure you understand the ramification of any decision you make. I think having an official ADU may be the lowest risk option but recognize jurisdictional variation.


      good luck

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.