First time Home Buyer- Quad Plex

First time Home Buyer- Quad Plex

New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
  • For Starters
  • First off, BiggerPockets is an amazing site. I have been one of those lurkers everyday while listening podcast after podcast for almost a year now. Started taking the advice of Brandon and Josh and communicating on the forums more, bought books and have been reading like a college kid cramming for an exam, started specifically going onto the site to learn a specific thing every day and finally decided it was time to stop renting. With that being said, I am excited to hear from everyone and anyone. Just a couple of things I would like on the post. 

  • Guidelines
  • Nobody likes to get all negative stuff or all positive. Basically, if you can, give the flip side to a statement so I and everyone reading can see both perspectives.
  • I am more than open to Direct Messages. I actually would love them.
  • This is a post to help keep my mind in business mode instead of home owner mode. This is a investment for my future and how I view things should be from that perspective.

  • The Briefing
  • Using a VA home loan, offer, counter offer, and (hopefully) acceptance for a 4-plex in South Milwaukee with the hopes no one jumping in and beating me, I'll have my first home to live in while living rent free. We have contingencies in place to see all of the units (I have seen 2 so far) as well as the inspection and appraisal still to come.

Details of Property

Had previous offer, financing fell through, came back onto market.

Asking price $225,000,

 1958sqft, 1 bed per unit, 1 bath per unit, 1 living room per unit, 2 story 

Built in 1922, rubber roof, aluminum exterior, 1 furnace (1995), 1 water heater(not sure on year), 1 water storage tank (was listed on condition report), units are definitely dated and could use some nice touching up (which I plan on doing myself to get some experience). Basement would not blow anyone away, but definitely fits into the 1922 built year type.

Questions- What does this look like to a more experienced investor? What are things I should be considering and be wary of? What are things I should be excited about that novices do not notice?

Current Tenants and Rents

My current rent is $567

Currently have a tenant with his wife who has been the caretaker for 15 years on a term lease till April at $535

Other rents all month to month at $580, $550, $535 total of $2,200 month ( 1 of which I will be taking over so subtract 580) for $1,620 monthly. Anticipated mortgage $1,212,         1620-1212= $408 

Questions - Rentometer says all of the rents are on the very low side, comps have been around $675, how should I work with this? The extra $408 is planned on being saved in case something goes wrong and unexpected or is there something I should be looking to do with it?

Plans

I have $10,000 set aside specifically for improving the place.

Live in for a year or so, try to save as much as possible while working, then move out and rent my current spot, build the portfolio. I am currently trying to network more and more. 

Make sure I have all documentation prepared and legal, basically everything in Managing Rental Properties (I would like to have some references for good attourneys). This is to make systemization and ease with moving forward and having a good foundation to always use.

Additionally

If there is more information that I should provide or that you are looking for that could make this better please let me know. I am excited as all heck to get out of the analysis paralysis. Which is something I believe is a terrible thing, so much so, I am more willing to fail a couple of times then never get started. Which is very hard for my family and friends to wrap their heads around (they have the bad landlord, bad investment, it will go wrong mindset). I prefer to think of it as a great starting point and learning opportunity. Lastly, thanks for reading this and if you do have advice thanks in advance. This process of buying homes is extremely enjoyable even in this ridiculously competitive market, writing this post is scarier. 

4Reply
66 views

Most Popular Reply

Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
6y

@Mayson Madden you need to break down your mortgage payment. Does it include taxes and insurance. I would estimate $200 per month for insurance on a quad. You have not accounted for soft costs( vacancy, repairs and capex(capital expenditures)). These are usually expressed as a % of gross rent. I use 8% for vacancy or 1 turnover per year. Repairs I use 5%. Capex I use 10%. Your capex budget should include roof 25 year life span, floors 10 year life span(carpet only 5 years), appliances and hot water heater 12 years, hvac 20 year life span, bath and kitchen remodel, 20 year life span, etc. Say new appliance set cost $800 per unit or $3200/12 year life span/12 months in a year=$22 per month. Oh oh they are 5 years old, so now you have to recover the cost in only 7 years. $3200/7 years remaining/12 months in a year=$38 per month.

Analyse as if you are renting all 4 units.. There are spreadsheets in the files section of BP that you can input the numbers or BP has calculators that you can use for free 5 times. Learn to love your calculator, the most important tool in the toolbox. Also should include property management. I assume you want to get big enough that you are finding deals not managing tenants. I use 10%.

See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden you need to break down your mortgage payment. Does it include taxes and insurance. I would estimate $200 per month for insurance on a quad. You have not accounted for soft costs( vacancy, repairs and capex(capital expenditures)). These are usually expressed as a % of gross rent. I use 8% for vacancy or 1 turnover per year. Repairs I use 5%. Capex I use 10%. Your capex budget should include roof 25 year life span, floors 10 year life span(carpet only 5 years), appliances and hot water heater 12 years, hvac 20 year life span, bath and kitchen remodel, 20 year life span, etc. Say new appliance set cost $800 per unit or $3200/12 year life span/12 months in a year=$22 per month. Oh oh they are 5 years old, so now you have to recover the cost in only 7 years. $3200/7 years remaining/12 months in a year=$38 per month.

    Analyse as if you are renting all 4 units.. There are spreadsheets in the files section of BP that you can input the numbers or BP has calculators that you can use for free 5 times. Learn to love your calculator, the most important tool in the toolbox. Also should include property management. I assume you want to get big enough that you are finding deals not managing tenants. I use 10%.

  • New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @Tim Herman This is exactly what I was looking hoping for. Thank you for replying with in depth information. I am going to try to see if I am following your explanation.

    Mortgage Payment does include Taxes and Reserves. However, I did not factor in property taxes which are rounding up $3,800. So I should include that into the monthly factor as well?

    Making sure I understand, I would take my added up rent $2,200 and multiply by 23% 

    2,200 x .23= 506 a month towards, 

    Vacancy 8%-$41 

    Repairs 5%-$25

    Capex 10% - $51(which is the roof, Furnace, water heater, floor, kitchen and bath appliances). Would it be wise to break these into even specifics for each type of appliance?

    Yes at some point I will be using property management, however, before that step, I want to learn the basics of land lording. Milwaukee is a diverse area in Wisconsin, so having exposure to tenants will help me grow.

    Also Tom, rents are under market by nearly $100, how should I address that? Any sort of recommendations?

  • Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden You mortgage payment includes taxes and insurance so PITI is $1212+ soft costs of $506=$1718 outgo. Rent is $2200-$1718= $482 positive cash flow with out PM. I don't break each individual appliance out. Some may last 6 years some may last 20 years. You just want to have a reserve so it doesn't come out of your pocket. You need to build a reserve of at least 1 1/2 times your most expensive capex item. Could be floors or roof. Say it is 5k to replace. So until you have 7.5k saved any money over the mortgage payment goes into the reserve account. After that you can start saving for another DP. If you have a vacancy and it takes $1500 out of your reserve then you stop saving for the down payment and replenish your reserve. I like to keep my rentals slightly under fair market rent. Turnover are the killers of profits. I would gradually increase rents over a couple of years. You have to follow the leases already in place. I assume you will get an estoppel certificate signed by the owner and each tenant outlining rents paid, security deposits and any verbal agreements.

  • New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @Tim Herman That reserve idea you have is a wallet saver. Thanks for that heads up. Do you use the soft costs and cash flow to build up the reserve right away? 

    I've entertained the idea of paying off the mortgage as fast as possible, but I can't imagine myself keeping it through the 30 year loan.

  • Real Estate Broker · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 121 posts · 81 votes
    6y

    Tim definitely has some great insight, though his insurance costs are slightly high. You'll need a commercial insurance policy which will typically run about $900 for that building, plus a $150 renter's policy for your unit.

  • New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @Jeremy Trad

    Thanks for the info Jeremy!

    Is the reason for commercial insurance because of 4 units or does that apply to all types of Multi-families?

  • Real Estate Broker · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 121 posts · 81 votes
    6y

    There are a lot of companies that will sell you a policy without full coverage (Progressive would cover my 3 unit as a single family as long as it was owner occupied.) The problem is that non-commercial insurance products cover the house, not the business. Traditional policies rarely cover you for loss of income and/or temporarily housing a tenant in the event they can no longer stay at the property (ie: if you have to put them in temp housing due to a fire.)

  • Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden reserves are so important. You never know when an expense will occur. I had my sewer line collapse this past summer. 8k and it was repaired in a couple of days. Prorated the rent on the house. 

    Why pay down your loan faster. The tenants are doing the work. Save for another DP. Look at this scenario. Have 100k to invest. Buy 1 paid off house or 4 houses with 25k DP. Assuming rent is 1k per month. Assume no rent increases for 30 years. Using the 50% rule which is half of monthly rent goes to expenses and half to mortgage pay down and profit. Paid off house generates 6k income. 30 years from now, you will have received 180k. Look at the leveraged house. Using my trusty calculator a 75k mortgage will be $360. $500-$360=$140 profit per house*4=$560 per month. $560*360 months = 201k.  You will generate 21k more income and have 4 paid off houses. Your net worth is 400k vs 100k.  Now assume a 2% inflation. Your 1 paid off house is worth $181k and your 4 leverage houses are now worth $724k. "What's in your wallet"

  • Real Estate Broker · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2016 · 121 posts · 81 votes
    6y

    @Tim Hermon

    Spot on again... especially considering interest rates are typically under 4% and inflation is roughly 1.8%. Leverage your nest egg to acquire investments that will build your net worth while you sleep.

  • Member since 2018 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden reserves are so important. You never know when an expense will occur. I had my sewer line collapse this past summer. 8k and it was repaired in a couple of days. Prorated the rent on the house. 

    Why pay down your loan faster. The tenants are doing the work. Save for another DP. Look at this scenario. Have 100k to invest. Buy 1 paid off house or 4 houses with 25k DP. Assuming rent is 1k per month. Assume no rent increases for 30 years. Using the 50% rule which is half of monthly rent goes to expenses and half to mortgage pay down and profit. Paid off house generates 6k income. 30 years from now, you will have received 180k. Look at the leveraged house. Using my trusty calculator a 75k mortgage will be $360. $500-$360=$140 profit per house*4=$560 per month. $560*360 months = 201k.  You will generate 21k more income and have 4 paid off houses. Your net worth is 400k vs 100k.  Now assume a 2% inflation. Your 1 paid off house is worth $181k and your 4 leverage houses are now worth $724k. "What's in your wallet"

  • Real Estate Agent · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2018 · 50 posts · 45 votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden who is paying for heat and water? Unless you left those details out, I only see 1 furnace so 1 heating source. Is this a furnace or a boiler? South MKE tends to have a lot of properties with boilers, in which case, you’ll have a heating bill to pay every month. You can RUB the costs of this onto the tenants. Same as water. But you’ll want to understand your annuals and break them down to see what a fair payment is without bludgeoning them right away when you first take over. Think gradual as Tim mentioned, but you’ll definitely want to cover that cost or you’ll be flowing red from the start with this one. With a flat roof, you’ll also have to factor in a higher repair budget - I always use 10% because contractor pricing is ever increasing. And in a 1922 home, which probably hasn’t seen much love, there will be more repairs to handle in the 1st few years. Whenever I walk a property for myself or for a client, I love when the tenants are home because I ask them - what doesn’t work? What has your landlord neglected? What leaks? How often does your heat cut out in the winter? - you’ll be surprised at how much they open up the more you ask, and when they do, keep them going. You’ll know right away what kind of maintenance attention was given to the property and what you’re in for.

  • New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @Tim Herman When the numbers are right in front of me it makes it a lot easier to decide. 

    @Matthew Meunier Electricity is the only utility tenants pay currently. I am considering working on my own lease to include a split between all units for the other utilities. That is a fantastic idea that will definitely be used.

    *Offer was accepted* 
    Already looking for a home inspector.

    The appraisal follows.

    3 of the tenants are month to month which is good because I want to live there. Does anyone have a recommended attorney that could help write up a lease and all other types of documentation? Some people prefer to write their own, but I do not want to risk it when just starting out. I do have "The book on Managing Rental Properties" and all of forms in it. I was thinking of using them as a starting point. Any suggestions continuing forward?

    Also, to all of you Tim, Matthew, and @Jeremy Trad, you have already provided me with exceptional insights and I am grateful and thankful to you. Thank you for your time and words so far.

  • Investor · Killeen, TX · Member since 2020 · 6 posts · 5 votes
    6y

    Congrats on the accepted offer!! I love this strategy and am currently living in a quad for which I used VA.

    A big consideration with quads is the neighborhood. Scope out the neighborhood both at day and night, especially if the area is quads only!

    With a property that old, I’d walk through all the units with a GC before closing. Find a great GC who can point out any possible gremlins inside/underneath the surface. Show him the inspection report and get his opinion on anything discovered. Best to find those hidden issues and get a quote prior to closing. 

    Great advice from the other posters about reserves. Plan ahead.

    So excited for you! Keep us updated and feel free to reach out if you have any specific questions as the process progresses!

  • Insurance Agent · Norwalk, CT · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Mayson, In the northeast we have several companies that will insure a 4 family under a homeowner policy. I would check around with independent agents to see if they have companies that will do it. There are a couple of things that may be an issue. You mention a rubber roof which makes me think you have a flat roof. Some companies don't write them but not all. The other two things that could be an issue are the wiring and Lead paint. Because of the age of the building you should make sure there is no Knob & Tube or Aluminum wiring. If so, it will be much harder to get insurance. Lead paint is also an issue. Some of our companies are requiring "Lead Safe" certification even for owner occupied multi-family dwellings. Another item that could cause issues is dogs. If any of the tenants have a breed of dog that the company does not insure that could be a problem. Hope this has helped. Good luck with the purchase.
  • Professional · Anaheim, CA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 686 votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden

    I own 4plexs in Las Vegas. The best advice I can give is to get a home warranty for the 4plex. The first year is most commonly paid for by the seller. There is an introductory price of around $600-700. Use the first year as a gauge if it is worth it or not. In my experience, in Las Vegas, the HVAC is the most crucial for hot summers and cold winters. Just one AC or heater bill will cost around $300. Imagine times that by 4 due to the number of units. The home warranty also covers roof, appliances, water heater, plumbing, etc. There is a deductible each time you call around $75. 

    I think its worth its weight in gold.

  • Real Estate Syndicator · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 907 votes
    6y

    Sounds like a good first deal.  You definitely have room to raise rents by $100 or so.  I would complete a light rehab on the units and exterior and raise rents.  You will also want to make sure that you are being conservative on expenses.  The older building and location will usually lead to higher expenses.

  • New to Real Estate · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2020 · 17 posts · 8 votes
    6y

    @John Mocker Do home inspections cover those types of issues you mentioned? No current tenant has a dog.

    @Terry Lao can I ask you for a way figure out how to get a home warranty or where to start looking? Especially for Wisconsin winters, that could be a life saver.

    @Brock Mogensen I am glad to hear that! My hope is to start working on it as soon as I move in. If I could ask, do you have any suggestions on things that catch the eyes of South Milwaukee tenants?

  • Professional · Anaheim, CA · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 686 votes
    6y

    @Mayson Madden

    I have used HSA and Choice Home Warranty. The difference is choice home warranty services all 4 AC's, while H.S.A. limits to 2, unless you pay more. Note, the seller should pay your first year. You should request that in your contract, unless your agent did not put that in your contract. 

    https://www.onlinehsa.com/

    https://www.choicehomewarranty.com/

  • Rebecca KnoxBusiness Member
    Specialist · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2014 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Congratulations on your pending purchase. Lots of solid advice here. I think I read in a previous post that the property is in South Milwaukee which is a great area in my opinion---close to Milwaukee but also not far from to Racine. People are typically advertising on the most popular channels such as Zillow, Trulia, Craigslist, Hotpads, Facebook marketplace and Facebook local buy/sell, real estate and landlord groups.  

    The CITY OF MILWAUKEE landlord class is free and gives very good pointers. You might also check out the landlord class the AASEW has which Atty Tristan Pettis leads. I use Atty Taylor Rens to draft land contracts, subject to's, partnership agreements and other things--he does a lot for local investors and is affordable. If I were looking to have someone help me with lease templates and systems along with basic landlord knowledge, my top choice would be reaching out to Christy Cooper Librizzi--she is not a lawyer but is a PM and sits on the AASEW board and is extremely knowledgeable about tenant/landlord matters and has probably seen most of the situations that happen in the rental world. Good luck in your REI adventures and hope to see you at one of the local events around town.

    Captain Save-A-Home LLC
  • Insurance Agent · Norwalk, CT · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Mayson, a good home inspector should report on the wiring. They can only report on what they can see. I would also ask that question of the current owner. The Lead paint testing can be done by the home inspector but to get a Lead Safe certification you may have to get it test by some certified to give that determination. Your Insurance agent or the State EPA may be able to give you more info. Like the flat roof, the lead safe certification may not be an issue depending on the company. Feel free to PM me if you need any further info.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.