Are We Headed for a Great Depression 2.0?

Are We Headed for a Great Depression 2.0?

Member since 2017 · 62 posts · 60 votes

I have talked about markets correcting for quite some time (actually began posting more in anticipation of a my fears of us spiraling into a depression like crisis). Here and here are two of the previous forum posts where I dove into a few topics specifically related to RE and touched on a few other issues I identified in our current market. I personally underestimated the global implications of the Covid-19 as it is a lot more serious than most of us think. I've talked about demand for real estate in major cities and a few fundamental factors that are being affected by real estate, but today I would like to talk about how serious I think this crisis will be.

As some of you may have heard, we recently injected 1.5 trillion dollars into our system. Was it because of Corona Virus. Yes and no. The money did not go into Corona-Virus stimulus (perhaps a small portion as of now), but rather into a REPO market to continue to purchase its own treasuries in fear of a "liquidation crisis." This is much like what happened to Long Term Capital Management in the late 90s or Bear Sterns in late 2008. I think we are headed for a global liquidity crisis. I believe what is setting up in global markets is a 

This will lead to unanticipated deflation which will drive us into the next Great Depression 2.0. I really hope I'm wrong and this is more like a 1987 stock market sell off where we can see extended growth for another 10-20 years following this correction.

Unfortunately I see a lot of red flags and I urge you all to take protective actions. Below is a quick summary of historical signals that we are seeing that are very similar to that dreadful early 1900s era:

1. Income Inequality is at the highest levels since 1930.

2. Agricultural Depression was extremely similar to 2008 subprime crisis.

3. Roaring 20's is very similar to the stock market run we have seen in the last 10 years.

4. Political Polarity gap is increasing at highest levels since the 1930s (Liberals vs. Conservatives today / Unions vs. Nationalists/Facists in 30s) (I am not insinuating that these parties are similar as conditions were very different, simply reiterating that the gap between both parties is quite extreme. 

5. Issues with monetary systems (Gld Std. vs. King Dollar)

6. Interest Rates at lowest levels since the 40s

7. Debt - GDP at highest levels since WWII

8. Technological advances creating more globalized economies and efficient means of communication (radio/phone mass adoption vs. internet and tech mass adoption).

These are just some of the few uncanny similarities I am seeing between these time periods. I am not saying the world is going to end, but I do think a very rough period is up ahead. Deflation is a beast that Bankers fear as people stop spending and last resort efforts to create inflation after deflation can have grave consequences. 

Contrary to the belief that majority of people have, I think we will see a 60-80% correction in the stock market (getting close), 30-60% in real estate (expect lag). During these times, having cash will be king and making necessary adjustments if you are leveraged will be key. If we see something like the mid 30s with a gold revaluation, then Gold will be key (I recommend everyone to own a small amount of gold just in case). Even if you don't believe me, please have a plan in action in case things were to go south. Some of you will hate to hear this, but this is a reality we must now come to face as the time gets closer. You can choose to be proactive, hope for the best and prepare for the worse or be caught off guard, unprepared having no idea what to do.

We are at a critical period where we should see how this is going to play out over the next few months. But even with the severity of coronavirus deepening, please make sure you have adequate amounts of food, stationary items, simple medical supplies, and immune system boosters (the best way to protect yourself from the coronavirus is to protect your immune system [Vitamin C, Vitamin D, sleep & adequates amounts of vegetables]. 

In terms of protecting yourself from a depression, very similar: Have enough food to get by for a few months, medical supplies, good support system (nothing trumps family), guns (protection is key), and enough cash for emergencies. 

As crazy as I sound, do what you will with this information. I hope you all stay safe and prepare accordingly. Hopefully I am wrong and most of you make fun of me a few months from now if this blows over for being so irrational and extreme (I would be ecstatic if everything ends up fine). My hopes is if this forum post helps even one person, then I have done my part.

7Reply
78 views

Most Popular Reply

Theresa HarrisPro Member
Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
6y

The media needs to stop and think about what they are doing because they are solely responsible for the panic that has been created with regards to the coronavirus.  If they can start reporting the facts (get a scientist to do it who is good with the media as they are less dramatic than the news reporters and better at sticking to the facts) and the politicians act on facts (not concerns about being sued), it would help a lot and solve most of the problems (well not create a cure for the virus).  Until the media lets up, many people who don't know any better are going to believe everything they are told and panic.

See this reply in the discussion

13 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Navarre, FL · Member since 2019 · 913 posts · 640 votes
    6y

    @Babek Sandhar You have done your part. I believe anything could happen in the near future and am doing what I can to hopefully be prepared enough. Thanks for taking the time, much appreciated!

  • Member since 2017 · 62 posts · 60 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Michael King:

    @Babek Sandhar You have done your part. I believe anything could happen in the near future and am doing what I can to hopefully be prepared enough. Thanks for taking the time, much appreciated!

     Same, anything is possible. I believe in a times of turmoil and polarity like we have experienced, it has NEVER been more important to stop hating and form unity amongst each other to overcome extreme circumstances ahead.

  • Theresa HarrisPro Member
    Member since 2019 · 15k+ posts · 11k+ votes
    6y

    The media needs to stop and think about what they are doing because they are solely responsible for the panic that has been created with regards to the coronavirus.  If they can start reporting the facts (get a scientist to do it who is good with the media as they are less dramatic than the news reporters and better at sticking to the facts) and the politicians act on facts (not concerns about being sued), it would help a lot and solve most of the problems (well not create a cure for the virus).  Until the media lets up, many people who don't know any better are going to believe everything they are told and panic.

  • Austin, TX · Member since 2019 · 5k+ posts · 5k+ votes
    6y

    Hi Babek,

    On a positive (Negative) note--Coffin sales will be way up.

    The glass is either Half full or Half empty it all depends on how you look at it.

    Life is what you make out of it, and even during a Depression money is still being made (not everyone is down and out).

    Just my 2 cents.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    Idk about great depression, however commercial non residential might get hit hardest, office , retail etc. Good luck!

  • Member since 2017 · 62 posts · 60 votes
    6y

    @Scott Mac agreed Scott. I’m an eternal optimist, but felt it was necessary to at least warn people

  • Real Estate Investor · Tempe, AZ · Member since 2012 · 874 posts · 648 votes
    6y

    No, I don’t.  The Great Depression and Great Financial Crisis were both results of speculative debt bubbles (and other things, but mostly the speculative debt bubbles). 

    Recessions are resets in output.  That’s what we are seeing now.  China shut down for two months.  Production of goods are way down. Shipping is way down. The market panic is related to the uncertainty of how long it will take to recover. 

    Stock prices will reset, in large part because the buybacks that goose EPS to the upside will similarly destroy EPS to the downside.  But this is a destruction of paper wealth, just like the dotcom bubble.  The GFC of 2008 was a destruction of debt, or money itself.  There’s a difference between having less of something (stock losses) and none of something (destroyed debt via default)

    Make no doubt, this one’s gonna hurt.  It already has for most people.  But I don’t see a depression given the current circumstances.  

  • Investor · Milwaukee, WI · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Babek Sandhar:

    I have talked about markets correcting for quite some time (actually began posting more in anticipation of a my fears of us spiraling into a depression like crisis). Here and here are two of the previous forum posts where I dove into a few topics specifically related to RE and touched on a few other issues I identified in our current market. I personally underestimated the global implications of the Covid-19 as it is a lot more serious than most of us think. I've talked about demand for real estate in major cities and a few fundamental factors that are being affected by real estate, but today I would like to talk about how serious I think this crisis will be.

    As some of you may have heard, we recently injected 1.5 trillion dollars into our system. Was it because of Corona Virus. Yes and no. The money did not go into Corona-Virus stimulus (perhaps a small portion as of now), but rather into a REPO market to continue to purchase its own treasuries in fear of a "liquidation crisis." This is much like what happened to Long Term Capital Management in the late 90s or Bear Sterns in late 2008. I think we are headed for a global liquidity crisis. I believe what is setting up in global markets is a 

    This will lead to unanticipated deflation which will drive us into the next Great Depression 2.0. I really hope I'm wrong and this is more like a 1987 stock market sell off where we can see extended growth for another 10-20 years following this correction.

    Unfortunately I see a lot of red flags and I urge you all to take protective actions. Below is a quick summary of historical signals that we are seeing that are very similar to that dreadful early 1900s era:

    1. Income Inequality is at the highest levels since 1930.

    2. Agricultural Depression was extremely similar to 2008 subprime crisis.

    3. Roaring 20's is very similar to the stock market run we have seen in the last 10 years.

    4. Political Polarity gap is increasing at highest levels since the 1930s (Liberals vs. Conservatives today / Unions vs. Nationalists/Facists in 30s) (I am not insinuating that these parties are similar as conditions were very different, simply reiterating that the gap between both parties is quite extreme. 

    5. Issues with monetary systems (Gld Std. vs. King Dollar)

    6. Interest Rates at lowest levels since the 40s

    7. Debt - GDP at highest levels since WWII

    8. Technological advances creating more globalized economies and efficient means of communication (radio/phone mass adoption vs. internet and tech mass adoption).

    These are just some of the few uncanny similarities I am seeing between these time periods. I am not saying the world is going to end, but I do think a very rough period is up ahead. Deflation is a beast that Bankers fear as people stop spending and last resort efforts to create inflation after deflation can have grave consequences. 

    Contrary to the belief that majority of people have, I think we will see a 60-80% correction in the stock market (getting close), 30-60% in real estate (expect lag). During these times, having cash will be king and making necessary adjustments if you are leveraged will be key. If we see something like the mid 30s with a gold revaluation, then Gold will be key (I recommend everyone to own a small amount of gold just in case). Even if you don't believe me, please have a plan in action in case things were to go south. Some of you will hate to hear this, but this is a reality we must now come to face as the time gets closer. You can choose to be proactive, hope for the best and prepare for the worse or be caught off guard, unprepared having no idea what to do.

    We are at a critical period where we should see how this is going to play out over the next few months. But even with the severity of coronavirus deepening, please make sure you have adequate amounts of food, stationary items, simple medical supplies, and immune system boosters (the best way to protect yourself from the coronavirus is to protect your immune system [Vitamin C, Vitamin D, sleep & adequates amounts of vegetables]. 

    In terms of protecting yourself from a depression, very similar: Have enough food to get by for a few months, medical supplies, good support system (nothing trumps family), guns (protection is key), and enough cash for emergencies. 

    As crazy as I sound, do what you will with this information. I hope you all stay safe and prepare accordingly. Hopefully I am wrong and most of you make fun of me a few months from now if this blows over for being so irrational and extreme (I would be ecstatic if everything ends up fine). My hopes is if this forum post helps even one person, then I have done my part.

     Some interesting analysis. I don't think you sound crazy for expecting bad things to come from all this. Frankly, I think it's pretty silly to think bad things will not come from this.

    But when I read your analysis, the potential flaw I see is you appear to assume the future will be as the past, yet the world circumstance today is like never before. Why do you believe the outcome will be as before? Why Great Depression 2.0? Do you suppose it's possible we might see an outcome as never seen before, considering the world is as it's never been before? 

  • Joe SplitrockPro Member
    Moderator
    Rental Property Investor · Sioux Falls, SD · Member since 2015 · 9k+ posts · 18k+ votes
    6y

    @Babek Sandhar reading your post, I feel like you are trying to force fit a narrative here. I don't see these as "uncanny similarities". Some of the things in your list are not even factors that lead to the Great Depression, at least not major factors that are recognized by modern analysis. 

    You are implying that you predicted a market correction, but the market correction here is not the result of cumulative factors. It is the result of fear based on global shut down due to a virus. It is due to forward looking concerns over the impact of high unemployment and low consumer spending for multiple months. 

    The stock market crash of 1929 always appears as the leading cause of the Great Depression, but it was the ripple effects that did more damage. The crash caused a run on the banks. There was no deposit insurance back then and federal policy basically let the banks fail. Not only did people lose their life savings, but they also lost all access to credit. As a result, consumer spending dropped, which led to overall economic trouble and massive unemployment. Unemployment insurance was not in existence, so people had no income when they lost their jobs. That just resulted in even less spending and more job loss.

    Of course many things have changed since then. We now have FDIC to protect savings accounts. We have bank liquidity requirements and stress tests. We have unemployment insurance to pay people for up to 26+ weeks. The modern mortgage system with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac was created during the Great Depression as a way to offload debt from banks.

    My point is so much as changed and the underlying factors are completely different. I am not saying we won't have major economic problems, but I don't the see the direct comparison. It is an interesting discussion.

  • Rental Property Investor · Concord, GA · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    6y

    I think this financial panic (maybe due to lack of toilet paper) to be relatively short lived. I do think the market is going to correct to a lower overall amount but not stay where it is now. It has been volatile for sure but once the stores get restocked after all the binge buying and things return to a more normal situation as far as availability, I think the market will begin to creep back up. I haven't sold anything. Took a beating for sure but it's happened before and will again in the future. Not sure how the rental market will shake out but I'm sure going to find out... I closed on two occupied rentals today that were in the works before this all hit the fan. Steady as she goes.

  • Rental Property Investor · Twin Cities, MN · Member since 2019 · 122 posts · 150 votes
    6y

    @John Teachout

    After reading this thread:

    I'm going to watch back to the future tonight, count rolls of toilet paper then buy chevron cvx. It pays a 6.19% dividend and is an energy company with little levered debt.

    Then I'm going to have nightmares about Franz Ferdinand, a flu like illness and Bernie Sanders stealing from me.

    Tomorrow, I have to go to work - and then we have an inspection on a 5 plex we just put under contract.

    My ham radio says there is a safe zone somewhere up in Maine.

    Good luck everyone. Wash your hands.

  • Member since 2017 · 62 posts · 60 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Joe Splitrock:

    @Babek Sandhar reading your post, I feel like you are trying to force fit a narrative here. I don't see these as "uncanny similarities". Some of the things in your list are not even factors that lead to the Great Depression, at least not major factors that are recognized by modern analysis. 

    You are implying that you predicted a market correction, but the market correction here is not the result of cumulative factors. It is the result of fear based on global shut down due to a virus. It is due to forward looking concerns over the impact of high unemployment and low consumer spending for multiple months. 

    The stock market crash of 1929 always appears as the leading cause of the Great Depression, but it was the ripple effects that did more damage. The crash caused a run on the banks. There was no deposit insurance back then and federal policy basically let the banks fail. Not only did people lose their life savings, but they also lost all access to credit. As a result, consumer spending dropped, which led to overall economic trouble and massive unemployment. Unemployment insurance was not in existence, so people had no income when they lost their jobs. That just resulted in even less spending and more job loss.

    Of course many things have changed since then. We now have FDIC to protect savings accounts. We have bank liquidity requirements and stress tests. We have unemployment insurance to pay people for up to 26+ weeks. The modern mortgage system with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac was created during the Great Depression as a way to offload debt from banks.

    My point is so much as changed and the underlying factors are completely different. I am not saying we won't have major economic problems, but I don't the see the direct comparison. It is an interesting discussion.

     These are actually amazing points you made Joe. I'll make an attempt to respond to all your points (very good ones).

    I do not think what I expect to happen is anywhere near to what we've seen so far in markets. I agree, right now this is a correction and we can very well move up from here (many could have seen this coming covid or not). I acknowledge that I may absolutely be wrong, as I also thought it would begin in late 2018. A correction is more like what we saw in 2016, 2018, and where we are now. Right now we are in "correction" territory. 

    However, this is where things get very murky. The coronavirus was an unexpected anomaly that has put the world at a standstill. I believe that something much worse is to come as a ripple effect to the Coronavirus. You've the case that the stock market crash did not do as much damage as the aftermath in the great depression and I'll make the case that there will be a ripple effect from the effects of covid-19.

    The case I am making is coronavirus could be that same catalyst the stock market crash was in 1929. We are seeing so much liquidity leave the system, that the Feds have been forced to inject 2T into the market and cut rates to 0 (how many of us thought we'd never see these rates again). If you pay attention to stocks, they are actually instilling circuit breakers so there can't be massive sell offs in the stock market. Why would corona virus has this type of an effect on the market where we had to cut interest rates a whole 1% and inject 2T into our system? Also if nothing was wrong in the first place remember all those rate hikes we had been doing in 2017-2018, why did we suddenly start cutting rates again? 

    Very simply put, the US is in a difficult position where if they raise rates, debt becomes harder and more expensive to pay off. Many defaults will occur on variable interest rate loans and either restructures on debt is needed (refinancing) or defaults. So instead their only option is to find a way to print their way out of it or monetize their debt by lowering rates because higher rates would cause massive deflation (like the great depression). This is why we have been lowering rates and printing money, to prevent this exact event from occuring. It's the only way we can keep markets propped up and growth continuing. Had the concerns been inflationary then we would be raising rates to tame inflation (see the 1970s period to understand what was happening in the world then & check out the Volcker shock to understand how it ended). 

    The central banks have been trying so hard to prevent deflation (it seems hard to believe as stock markets and real estate are at all time highs). 

    I find the stress tests of the banking systems quite weak. Ask yourself this, if these banks were so safe, why were they on the brink of failure in 2008 to the point they needed massive bailouts all around? Sure CDOs played a big role, but do we not have the same thing in Mutual Index funds (crap and good stocks mixed together in a fund and sold to a third party)? The amount of money in index funds will bleed out the system. Michael Burry who predicted the housing bubble is talking about this as well. Here's a link if you are interested in reading this

    Are our debt levels not higher than before? GDP - Debt? The recklessness of banks put us in this spot in the first place so I don't buy that argument at all. Here's an in depth article talking about these failures of stress tests released by Stanford.

    The factors above were not causes but rather similarities we saw in both economies during each respective time period. This isn't to say this is the cause, but rather this is the effect of such effects. The mass psychology of humanity forces us to act in similar patterns this has been noted throughout history (dating back to the Romans). 

    You made a great point with the stock market crash not really being the cause of the great depression but rather it was the after effects. The stock market crashed forcing many into debt and poverty because they had everything invested in "debt." Is that not what we are seeing right now? Helocs, household debt, consumer debt, and national debt is at all time highs. How easy is it to get a house putting less than 5% down? Very easy.

    However, it's important to keep in mind what we have seen over the past several decades. 

    We have seen historically low interest rates, over several years and near 0 rates over the last 10 years. We've seen essentially massive growth in the stock market since 1987 and as we climb higher it's only psychologically reasonable we begin to see higher and higher levels of volatility (like we are seeing right now). 

    In terms of bank runs, we have a system that is on the verge of a liquidity crisis. Look at costco lines for basic essential goods, now imagine what will happen when they say banks are going to close because of this virus? I'm not saying this will happen, but in major metro areas where majority of wealth lies, we can easily see bank runs again. 

    What happened after 2008? How hard was credit after this crisis? Is this not possible again? If so why? As I said stress tests holds no merit, but rather an indicator to keep consumer confidence up. Did people not lose their life savings in 2008? Did Freddie & Fannie not require enormous bailouts to stay afloat. Money isn't free and this will either come down on tax payers or higher prices for everyday goods. High unemployment and low consumer spending = deflation. This is exactly why I consider this as a Great Depression 2.0. Liquidity Crisis force people to take cash stash it and wait anticipating lower prices. This is exactly what you explained, so I honestly feel you have answered your question with your response.

    But I agree with you here, our central bank has the policy and tools to change the outcome as there is no peg to the gld std and we can print our way out of this as long as the dollar serves as a safe haven asset and I think we have quite some time left before that changes. Here's another academic article out of Stanford (just read the abstract and conclusion since this is quite long, I've read many shorter explanations but this coming out of Stanford is most credible) explaining this shortage in dollars in more detail. I think this will serve as a problem to the upcoming liquidity crisis and hence the extreme predictions I have.

    Just from what I have seen in the last 3 weeks and the volatility in the stock market, this is so scary the amount of volatility we are seeing. It's really not a good sign which has increased my urgency to get this message across ASAP.

    I actually loved your answer and you made some great points as I said. I respect the hell out of your knowledge.

  • Member since 2017 · 62 posts · 60 votes
    6y

    That being said, I joined bigger pockets and learned so much from all of you reading these forums even if I don't comment as much. I am determined to get my first properties soon. And I want them at a major discount. Perhaps I am greedy, but I see something really scary coming up, but for some it can be the opportunity of a lifetime.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.