3 Raleigh NC Suburbs Where Owning is Cheaper Than Rent

3 Raleigh NC Suburbs Where Owning is Cheaper Than Rent

Real Estate Agent · Raleigh, NC · Member since 2019 · 303 posts · 288 votes

I find this topic super interesting because it used to be that owning was nearly always cheaper or equivalent to rent. Now it seems nearly impossible in most cities. Maybe in the midwest? 

There may be more as you go further out from Raleigh or into Durham - but these 3 stood out to me as being cheaper than or equivalent to rent while still being close enough to commute into Raleigh for work and fun. I'm using single family homes on this one btw.


Wendell: $382k/$2200 vs $2250 rent
Zebulon: $325k/$2000 vs $1900 rent
Clayton: $330k/$2000 vs $1900 rent

Let's address the elephant in the room. Only Wendell was actually "cheaper" on paper. BUT....

1) These are averages. You can find super affordable homes here below the median home price that beat average rent in these areas.

2) If you factor in principal paydown, aka the amount of each monthly mortgage payment that goes back to you in the form of equity, AND the opportunity for appreciation, as Raleigh is expected to grow substantially over the next few years thanks to big corporations and swarms of people moving into the area.... you'll find that the math works our quite favorably for owning a home versus renting.

3) When you factor in rate incentives with new construction homes in these areas may be even cheaper. For example, I have seen brand new homes for average market price or lower in Wendell with a fixed 5% rate. Now instead of paying $2200 to rent a used home, you get to own a brand new home for $1900.


Now will these appreciate as fast as other parts of Raleigh? Probably not. But if you're looking to beat rent, get *closer* to breakeven or even cashflow (depending on rent strategy) then definitely check these out and reach out anytime with questions.

2Reply
12 views

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Member since 2024 · 400 posts · 240 votes
    2y

    I am assuming you are comparing mortgage payment to rent?  Does that number include tax, insurance?  What down payment did you use for your example?  Buying would require that down payment and renting would not.

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    2y

    Are you purposely looking for neighborhoods where there shouldn’t be any renters because buying is cheaper? (Ok, maybe people with bad credit who don’t care if you send them to collections or if they damage your property, because they don’t have anything.) What if rates eventually go down? Then more landlords start buying just as all the renters are buying? Increasing supply and reducing demand at the same time? This seems like a recipe for disaster. I want to buy where renting is cheaper.  This is how you get well paid stable tenants that can pay the rent, don’t want their credit ruined, appreciate that they don’t have to repair anything, and stay for 7-15 years.

    Ps. I assume you’re using 25% down payments so what’s the return on an $80k downpayment? ($600/year?). Put that $80k in the bank, get paid $350/mo in interest and suddenly renting is cheaper and you don’t have to pay for any repairs. 

  • Real Estate Agent · Raleigh, NC · Member since 2019 · 303 posts · 288 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Kevin S.:

    I am assuming you are comparing mortgage payment to rent?  Does that number include tax, insurance?  What down payment did you use for your example?  Buying would require that down payment and renting would not.


    Yes it does compare PITI to Rent median data. Renting requires a deposit that you hopefully get back. So does owning, yes higher but the tax savings you get plus appreciation FAR OUTWEIGH the extra upfront cost.

  • Real Estate Agent · Raleigh, NC · Member since 2019 · 303 posts · 288 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Bill B.:

    Are you purposely looking for neighborhoods where there shouldn’t be any renters because buying is cheaper? (Ok, maybe people with bad credit who don’t care if you send them to collections or if they damage your property, because they don’t have anything.) What if rates eventually go down? Then more landlords start buying just as all the renters are buying? Increasing supply and reducing demand at the same time? This seems like a recipe for disaster. I want to buy where renting is cheaper.  This is how you get well paid stable tenants that can pay the rent, don’t want their credit ruined, appreciate that they don’t have to repair anything, and stay for 7-15 years.

    Ps. I assume you’re using 25% down payments so what’s the return on an $80k downpayment? ($600/year?). Put that $80k in the bank, get paid $350/mo in interest and suddenly renting is cheaper and you don’t have to pay for any repairs. 


    There's no right answer and I'm not trying to overcomplicate this. We know that owning real estate in the LONG TERM has benefits that outweigh the easy short-term choice of renting. I'm simply highlighting areas with lower barrier to entry for homeowners and investors. And plenty of people both rent and own in these suburbs. To each their own strategy

  • Member since 2024 · 400 posts · 240 votes
    2y

    I imagine most BP members are investors rather than home buyer?  If you highlight areas/houses that benefit owning over renting what would the post serve?  Just wondering.  

  • Real Estate Agent · Raleigh, NC · Member since 2019 · 303 posts · 288 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Kevin S.:

    I imagine most BP members are investors rather than home buyer?  If you highlight areas/houses that benefit owning over renting what would the post serve?  Just wondering.  


     Mainly house hackers! My favorite strategy. Or somebody doing a live-in flip on a home versus renting. Home ownership is a great gateway into real estate investing! Move in, beat rent for a year, and then move out and keep it as a rental. Many options.

  • Member since 2024 · 400 posts · 240 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Benjamin Carver:
    Quote from @Kevin S.:

    I imagine most BP members are investors rather than home buyer?  If you highlight areas/houses that benefit owning over renting what would the post serve?  Just wondering.  


     Mainly house hackers! My favorite strategy. Or somebody doing a live-in flip on a home versus renting. Home ownership is a great gateway into real estate investing! Move in, beat rent for a year, and then move out and keep it as a rental. Many options.


     Gotcha!  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.