Real Estate Entrepreneur · Mid West, East Coast · Member since 2015 · 3k+ posts · 1k+ votes
Do you want to invest or naw? I am tired of the double douching when it comes to investing OOS. JUMP and figure it out on the way down. I traveled from NY to Milwaukee over a decade ago and bought my first rental and never looked back. I've had countless setbacks along the way but I jumped. Then eventually jumped from my 9-5 I've bought single family, Duplex, Triplex, Fouplexes and even a 10-Unit. Would not have achieved my goals without taking the leap of faith. If I had any advice for a new investor looking to buy and hold OOS. Find the following;
1. A Landlord "Friendly" market
2. A market that you can buy 1.5-2% Price to rent ration deals
3. A Market you can build a team in
4 A Market that has both single and multi families
5. Population above 400K people in it.
6. Ideally the Midwest
7, DO NOT BUY TURNKEY PROPERTIES( you will be leaving so much money on the table)
8. Find a way to buy off market, discounted properties(Major Key)
Add your own metrics to the list above....But once you identify your metrics start analyzing deals and pull the trigger on something. End of my rant!!!!
From my experience, the biggest wins come when you stop overthinking and just jump in, but do it smart. I’d make sure the numbers actually work: aim for at least 8–10% cash-on-cash after all expenses, and make sure it still cash flows if rents dip 10%. Midwest markets like Columbus are great spots to start landlord-friendly, affordable, and full of value-add deals. And I’m with you on the “no turnkey” rule. Light rehabs where you can force a few hundred bucks of rent growth are gold for new investors.
From my experience, the biggest wins come when you stop overthinking and just jump in, but do it smart. I’d make sure the numbers actually work: aim for at least 8–10% cash-on-cash after all expenses, and make sure it still cash flows if rents dip 10%. Midwest markets like Columbus are great spots to start landlord-friendly, affordable, and full of value-add deals. And I’m with you on the “no turnkey” rule. Light rehabs where you can force a few hundred bucks of rent growth are gold for new investors.
Hey Shawn, love your no-nonsense approach, totally agree that action beats overthinking when it comes to OOS investing. The Midwest really fits your checklist perfectly, strong landlord-friendly markets, solid single and multi-family options, and tons of off-market opportunities where investors can get price-to-rent ratios in that 1.5–2% range or better. Building a local team, contractors, property managers, and agents, is the game-changer for scaling without being on-site constantly. Also, for those willing to dig, off-market undervalued deals here can offer incredible cash flow and appreciation compared to turnkey options in high-demand coastal areas. It’s all about identifying the right metrics, analyzing deals, and pulling the trigger when the numbers make sense.
I agree with 3-5. The rest are personal preference. For example I have some rentals in MoCo MD which is not tenant friendly. Have owned the properties ten years and in first two years did not cash flow. Today they cash flow over $250/mo and my equity in them is well into the six figures. If I sold today I would make over $200k for a $200k investment. You typically do not see that in markets that provide 1-2% rent returns as they may cash flow but have very low appreciation.
Love this! Taking the leap is everything—analysis paralysis will only hold you back. Your checklist is gold for any new OOS investor: find the right market, build a team, focus on deals with strong price-to-rent ratios, and avoid turnkey traps. Execution beats perfection—start small, learn, and scale.