Real Estate Horror Stories
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback
Almost 2 years in and haven't made any money (via cashflow)
Hey BP - Want some advice/perspective on my situation.
Back in 2022, I had a strong desire to get into REI to diversify my investments and pursue a new side hustle. I envisioned real estate investing as a way to make extra money on the side and continue to build my wealth. I signed up for a mastermind class that teaches you how to invest in STRs and pulled the trigger on a 2BD/1BA house in Pittsburgh, PA to operate as an STR. This was my first real estate purchase and the final sale price was $166.5K which I purchased using a 10% down second home loan. I then proceeded to dump a ton of money into capital improvements in order to make it a competitive STR (details below).
Since owning the property, my total cash investment is about $130K for initial acquisition, capital improvements, the mastermind course and floating negative cashflow. Here is the breakdown: Closing Costs ($30K w/ $16.5K down payment), Furniture, Setup & Design ($35K), New Electrical ($14K), New HVAC ($12K), New Roof ($9K), New Landscaping ($1K), Mastermind Course ($10K), and the remainder is floating negative cashflow ($19K).
I've been operational through 17 months (March '23 - July '24) and the following metrics are throughout this 17-month time period. My total gross income on the property is $37K and my operating expenses have been $32K, leaving me with a NOI of $5K. After factoring in debt payments of $24K ($1,400/month), my cashflow (before any capital expenses) is a total of $-19K. Averaged over this 17-month time period of operating the STR, I'm averaging a negative cashflow of about -$1,100/month.
To reiterate, I've put $130K cash into this deal. From a cashflow standpoint, I've obviously generated no return. The current Zillow Zestimate for the property is $193K, which means I'm sitting on roughly $45K of equity. If I were to sell anytime soon, with selling fees, I'd be realizing upwards of a 6-figure loss assuming the Zestimate is accurate. It may not be, as I've made a ton of capital improvements and I've seen comps sell for over $220K in the same neighborhood. Either way, selling doesn't paint a good picture.
In April '24, I hired a full-service PM which has helped tremendously with bookings and appears to have started turning the cashflow ship in the positive direction. I have been consistently within +/- $100 of breaking even for the first 4 months of the PM operating the STR. Since we have gotten momentum with the new listing on Airbnb, I am booking out well into Sep/Oct/Nov at the time of writing this post and I anticipate that the next few months will produce some positive cashflow. Over time, I also anticipate that the cashflow will improve slightly as the listing continues to excel (26 out of 27 reviews have been 5-star) and book out into the future.
My current plan is to give the PM a full year to establish the listing and then revisit what my cashflow scenario looks like. As of now, I (obviously) do not want to invest any more cash. I am a far cry away from the dream of building my wealth and it feels like I did absolutely horrendous on my first real estate investment.
Let's assume we take the happy path with my cashflow situation improving and over time, I average $500/month in cashflow after things stabilize with the new PM ($6K annual cashflow).
The estimated rate of appreciation since I purchased 17 months ago ($166K -> $193K) is roughly $26K over 17 months (about $1,500/month). It seems unlikely that this will continue into perpetuity and let's say a more conservative estimate is 3% annually, which would equate to about $6K annually in appreciation.
So on paper, it would take me 10.8 years ($12K in cashflow + appreciation) to net out the $130K in total cash invested.
What if the cashflow situation doesn't improve, but continues to break even or even worse begins to dip negative again? What should I do? Any help, guidance, critique, insults, etc. are welcome. I just want some discussion and perspective around this as I don't have a close network of investors to bounce ideas off of.