BRRRR vs. New Construction

I'm looking to invest in my first long term rental property and am struggling deciding which route to take. My husband and I are fairly handy but I'm worried about biting off more than we can chew. We have a lot of new construction/ cookie cutter homes going up for the same price point as any BRRRR I would buy. So Im starting to feel that buying something that is turnkey would be the better option for us. I do know that the quality of work in these homes isn't the best, but just looking at what's best for getting started.

Open to hearing any and all opinions!