Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
Followed Discussions Followed Categories Followed People Followed Locations
Insurance
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

User Stats

8
Posts
1
Votes
Spencer Cox
1
Votes |
8
Posts

Best way to get insurance

Spencer Cox
Posted

What is the best way to get insurance quotes? I have 1 commercial building ($2M), 2 x condos ($700k and $300k), and 3 x SFH ($800k, $800k, and $355k). Every year I am shocked at how different the quotes are. I would say that there's a variation of at least 200% on the SFHs and a variation of 300% on the condos. The commercial building is the only place where I get consistent quotes across different companies. I normally go to USAA, Progressive, and Farmers. This year I also went to AllState and they had some good quotes. Is there a better way to be getting quotes? I want the absolutely cheapest insurance because it's unlikely that any insurance claim would justify the increased cost from a history of claims. These are also very new (less than 15 years) properties so everything is up to modern code.

Most Popular Reply

User Stats

671
Posts
259
Votes
Owen Rosen
  • Professional
  • Clinton Township, MI
259
Votes |
671
Posts
Owen Rosen
  • Professional
  • Clinton Township, MI
Replied
Quote from @Spencer Cox:

What is the best way to get insurance quotes? I have 1 commercial building ($2M), 2 x condos ($700k and $300k), and 3 x SFH ($800k, $800k, and $355k). Every year I am shocked at how different the quotes are. I would say that there's a variation of at least 200% on the SFHs and a variation of 300% on the condos. The commercial building is the only place where I get consistent quotes across different companies. I normally go to USAA, Progressive, and Farmers. This year I also went to AllState and they had some good quotes. Is there a better way to be getting quotes? I want the absolutely cheapest insurance because it's unlikely that any insurance claim would justify the increased cost from a history of claims. These are also very new (less than 15 years) properties so everything is up to modern code.


 I would just add that it's not only pricing that varies. Coverage varies greatly.  Most Allstate policies I see are missing vital coverages. This happens due to poorly trained or order-taker agents for the most part.

I understand your desire to find the "cheapest" insurance but typically you get what you pay for. What you should be looking for is the best overall value.  Only a knowledgeable Independent Agent can consistently provide this.

  • Owen Rosen
business profile image
Royal Oath Insurance Group
4.9 stars
201 Reviews

Loading replies...