UPDATE: Branson STRs in 2026 – What Market now?

Question

I wrote a post on BiggerPockets a couple of years ago about the Branson STR market, and wow… things have changed!

I’m a local Realtor here in Branson, but I’m also an investor myself, so I get to see this market from both sides. And right now, I genuinely think there are some really interesting opportunities for buyers.

We are firmly in a buyer’s market. Properties are sitting longer, there’s more inventory to choose from, and we’re seeing sellers reduce prices and become much more open to negotiation.

Some investors who bought during the craziness of 2021–2023 are also deciding it’s time to move on. In some cases, they’re willing to sell for less than they originally paid.

Does that mean every STR in Branson is suddenly a great deal? Definitely not. If anything, I think investors need to be more selective now.

I’m spending a lot of time with my investor clients looking at actual rental history, HOA/COA financials, management costs, amenities and realistic expenses rather than just looking at a projected gross income and getting excited.

There’s also a LOT of competition for guests now. The average property isn’t necessarily going to perform simply because it’s in Branson and allows nightly rentals. The properties doing well tend to have something that makes them stand out, like great views, pools, hot tubs, lake access, larger sleeping capacities or simply really good presentation and management.

One thing I really like about today's market, though, is that buyers can finally take their time.

You can compare properties. You can ask questions. You can negotiate. And you can walk away if the numbers don't make sense.

I’m still very bullish on Branson long-term. We have millions of visitors, Silver Dollar City, Table Rock Lake, golf, shows and a huge drive-to tourism market.

But I think the question has changed.

A couple of years ago it was: “Where can I buy a Branson STR?”  In 2026, it’s: “Which Branson STR is actually worth buying?”

And honestly, I think that's a much healthier market for investors.

Michael Eskenasy · Answer

The part I’d be most interested in is whether the “buyer’s market” is actually creating bargains or just finally repricing properties to what the operating business underneath them can support.

A property selling below its 2022 purchase price isn’t necessarily cheap if ADR, occupancy, management costs, insurance, HOA expenses, and guest acquisition have all moved against it since then.

You mentioned the better performers have a reason to be chosen — views, pools, lake access, capacity, presentation. That feels like the real dividing line now. The generic STR may have lost pricing power, while properties with an actual demand advantage still own something defensible.

Are you seeing that separation clearly in the trailing rental histories yet — where the differentiated properties are holding occupancy/ADR while the average ones are getting punished?

John Underwood · Answer

Sounds like a very similar market to Pigeon Forge where I am.

Mike Grudzien · Answer

Yes, many popular resort destinations got flooded in the '21, '22 gold rush.  Now is time for market correction.  "I should have bought 4 years ago!"

Lisa Lister · Answer

Totally agree Jay. Some investors bought thinking Branson is an easy market, yes on paper properties make sense, but how those STRs are run and hosted makes all the difference. My husband and I self manage, so there are the benefits to our bottom line there, but a cash cow is harder to find. My outlook is, if the property is paying for itself and offers me the tax incentives to take advantage of, why would I leverage out of Branson at this time?

Lisa Lister · Answer

Great question, and as a Branson investor myself, I’m actually not seeing a significant drop in gross rental revenue on my own properties.

My borrowing costs have certainly increased over the last few years, along with some operating expenses, but not to the point where they’ve significantly hurt my bottom line.

I think that’s part of what still makes Branson interesting. We continue to see over 10 million visitors a year, yet our property prices are still relatively affordable compared with many established vacation markets, which can create a pretty attractive price-to-rent ratio.

Where I absolutely agree with you is the separation between the generic STR and one that gives guests a reason to choose it. I think that’s becoming increasingly important. For me, the opportunity right now is finding a property that already has strong amenities OR finding one where there’s an opportunity to create that differentiation. Whether that's internally through design, sleeping capacity and unique features, or externally by adding amenities where the property and COA allow it.

So I don’t necessarily see the buyer’s market as “everything is a bargain.” I see it as buyers having more opportunity to purchase the right property at a better basis and then make sure it has something that helps it compete.

Michael Eskenasy · Answer

That actually makes this more interesting to me, because what you're describing isn't really a market-selection problem anymore. It's an underwriting problem.

You're trying to distinguish between a property that already has an advantage, one where an advantage can realistically be created, and one where you'd just be spending money trying to make a commodity look different.

If you're game, send me one property you're currently looking at for an investor — preferably one that's not an obvious yes or no.

I'll run it cold from the buyer's side: acquisition basis, actual rental history if we can get it, competitive set, what guests are paying for nearby, amenity gap, COA/HOA constraints, and what I'd actually spend money changing versus leave alone.

Then we can compare my read with yours as the person actually operating in Branson.

I think that would be a much more useful test than us debating the market in the abstract.

Lisa Lister · Answer

Absolutely - great idea! I have a couple of off markets, which are tricky to easily share, but this listed condo is one I have 2 clients interested in pursuing. This one does come with a garage, which seller is happy to exclude from the sale (valued at around $50K) and there is money to put into this one too - furnishings, flooring. However pulling in $55,000 gross with insane views of Table Rock Lake. Let me know your thoughts - https://www.flexmls.com/share/EXQK7/200-Majestic-Dr-412-Bran...

Collin Hays · Answer

Branson is a twin of the TN Smokies market in many ways.

Jay Hinrichs · Answer

probably the natural pendulum swing of the next shinny object that STR seemed to be in that time frame.. The better operators will do just fine the ones that thought they would jump in but are not on top of it will be the ones that phase out.  IMHO

UPDATE: Branson STRs in 2026 – What Market now?

Most Popular Reply