Closing on quad #2 today! First time listing a rental

Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 723 votes

Congrats on quad #2 — now the listing part matters more than the renovation part.

Two pieces of advice. First, screen harder than you list. Write your criteria down before the first showing — income, rental history, eviction history — and apply the same criteria to every applicant in the same order. Most bad placements start with making an exception for a nice conversation. Second, price it right the first week. A unit priced too high sits, and every vacant week costs you more than a small price cut would have.

What makes a rental stand out is not the finishes. It is clear photos in daylight, all the numbers in the listing — rent, deposit, fees, lease length — and fast replies to inquiries. Good tenants have options. They pick the landlord who responds.

2 Reply

Sophia Hayden
OP
Rental Property Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 7 votes
2w
Super helpful! I am grateful for the insights! :)
0 Reply

Ametria Chaney

Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 378 posts · 133 votes

2w

Congratulations on quad #2 — that's a big milestone! As a Realtor, the listing itself is where I see first-timers leave money on the table, so a couple of thoughts to build on what's already here.

First, photograph like you're selling, not renting. Bright daylight shots of every room, highlight those renovations and the EV hookup, and make the curb appeal shine. Strong photos widen your applicant pool, which gives you more choices when you screen.

Second, write a listing that answers the questions good tenants actually ask: exact rent, deposit, what's included, pet policy, parking, and how to reach you. Vague listings attract vague applicants.

And a bonus: reply to inquiries fast. The best tenants keep shopping while they wait, and a quick, professional response sets the tone for the whole landlord-tenant relationship.

2 Reply

Sophia Hayden
OP
Rental Property Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 7 votes
2w
I love this! Thank you! Would you recommend photos with my things staged before I move out or vacant?
0 Reply

Clever Mukori

Member since 2026 · 46 posts · 19 votes

2w

Congrats! Two things that haven't come up yet. First, do a move-in condition report with dated photos of every room and have the tenant sign it, because that's what settles deposit disputes when they move out. Second, call the previous landlord yourself using a number you look up, not the one on the application, and ask whether they'd rent to this person again. And since you'll be living right next door, put in writing early how repair requests get submitted and what counts as an emergency, so being close by doesn't turn into being on call for everything.

2 Reply

Sophia Hayden
OP
Rental Property Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 7 votes
2w
This is awesome! I definitely need to come up with a formal move-in report with the dated photos for them to sign. Love that!
0 Reply

Leo SteinBusiness Member

Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 309 posts · 76 votes

2w

@Sophia Hayden congrats on quad #2. Two pieces of advice from the operating side. First, decide your screening criteria in writing before the first showing: income multiple, rental history, eviction and credit thresholds, pet and occupancy rules. Then apply them in the same order to every applicant. Most bad placements start with an exception made after a pleasant conversation.

Second, price and time the listing around your turn. Photograph the unit when it's actually clean and finished, publish with a firm available date, and take the first two weeks seriously, because that's when you get the best applicants. If you wait to list until you've moved out, you're paying for vacancy you could have shortened.

Beyond the LVP and EV hookup, what makes applicants choose a place is usually responsiveness: fast answers to inquiries, a simple application, and clear next steps. Since you'll be living next door, set boundaries on how and when tenants reach you, and keep everything in writing from day one.

Happy to compare notes by message.

[email protected]949-391-1019

Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews

Website View Page

2 Reply

Sophia Hayden
OP
Rental Property Investor · Bentonville, AR · Member since 2025 · 13 posts · 7 votes
2w
Yay! I love this guidance! Thank you so much! I will get her listed ASAP to reduce vacant carry costs! <3
0 Reply

Divin KanyamaBusiness Member

Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 700 posts · 297 votes

2w

Congratulations, @Sophia Hayden —two fourplexes in your first year is a huge milestone, and the fact that resident experience is central to your plan says a lot about how you are building.

My two pieces of advice: First, decide your written screening criteria before the listing goes live and apply them consistently—income, credit, rental history, occupancy, pets, deposits, and required documentation. Second, do not let vacancy pressure rush the process: verify income and prior housing, contact references independently, document each step, and follow applicable fair-housing and local rental rules.

Beyond renovations, strong photos, a clear floor plan, transparent total move-in costs, quick communication, and a clean, well-lit showing usually make a property stand out. The EV hookup is a useful differentiator, but your strongest advantage may be the systems and responsiveness you already bring. You are not an impostor—you are simply doing a part of the business for the first time. Congratulations again on closing day!

[email protected]

WEMBO CPA532 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

John RacinePro Member

Rental Property Investor · Casselberry, FL · Member since 2008 · 214 posts · 110 votes

2w

Congrats Sophia! Great advice here on screening and photos already, so I'll add two things from my own early landlord days in Orlando that nobody has mentioned yet.

1. Collect the move-in money in certified funds and make sure it has cleared before you hand over keys. No personal checks for the deposit and first month. That's a rule I learned the hard way.

2. Settle how rent gets paid before your first tenant moves in, not after. That means the due date, how they pay, and what happens when it's late. Put it in the lease and go over it at lease signing. In my early duplexes we were loose about payment schedules, and I spent far more time chasing rent than managing the property.

On your photo question for Ametria, I'd go staged. Look at any of the makeover shows on HGTV or the other networks: the homes are always staged for sale. Carrying that over to a rental gives a prospective tenant a sense of the space and how they might live in it.

1 Reply

Leo SteinBusiness Member

Property Manager · Orange County, CA · Member since 2025 · 309 posts · 76 votes

2w

Sophia, listing early to cut vacant carry is the right instinct. John, collecting move-in money in certified funds and letting it clear before handing over keys is a good rule, and settling how rent gets paid before move-in saves a lot of chasing later. Divin, thanks for adding the independent reference checks. Sophia, will you write the late-rent steps into the lease before the first showing?

[email protected]949-391-1019

Real Property Management Optimal 521 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

Matthew MorrowBusiness Member

Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 967 posts · 349 votes

2w

@Sophia Hayden 13 in 13 is a great goal. Since you'll be living in the building, I'd be extra careful to keep it professional from day one. Written lease, rent paid through a platform rather than handed to you in the hallway, and repair requests in writing. It's a lot easier to start that way than to fix it later. Price it right the first week too, because one month vacant can wipe out most of a year's cash flow on that unit. Keep us posted on how it goes.

[email protected]484-791-6200

CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme548 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

Stacy RaskinBusiness Member

Lender · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 531 votes

2w

For rental screening, making sure you collect financials such as the last three months of pay stubs or if self employed, bank statements, tax information as well as doing a background and credit checks. I would also call listed references and confirm past rental payment besides asking for financial documents that confirm past rental payments.

On the advertising side, I have found professional photos to be completely worth the money if you work with a photographer who is good at phtographing real estate. When I was working in this space, I got a lot more inquiries when the photos were well done. Then it's up to the property to deliver on the photos when the prospective tenants arrive to visit.

[email protected]818-770-0340

Bright Skyline517 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

Drew SygitBusiness Member

Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes

2w

Advice:

1) Build systems BEFORE you need them!

What will you do when (not if) a tenant doesn't pay?

2) Learn to figure out what's the worst that can happen and then work backwards to plan for it.

Then you are prepared!

3) Start doing detailed, narrated walk-thru videos before tenant Move-Ins and for Move-Outs.

Video gives more details than pics, your narration will also be better than your memory.

[email protected]248-209-6824

Logical Property Management4.9465 Reviews

Website View Page

0 Reply

Muyees Ayilara

Lender · Boynton Beach, FL · Member since 2026 · 242 posts · 112 votes

2w

@Sophia Hayden — Congrats on quad #2! Closing today + 3 for 3 renewals in year one is huge — you're building exactly like a business.

For your two questions from what I learned rebuilding my filtering system in Delray:

1. Two pieces of advice:

Screen on systems, not gut — same process every time. Have a one-page checklist before you list — application criteria written down, income verification, landlord reference script, same background check for everyone — log Last_Checked_Date + Reason + Next_Review_Date — saves you later. When I started logging every pull with reason codes, my wasted work went from 60% to 8% — same idea for tenants — write it before you need it.

Pull them out of auto-campaign same day they reply. We had auto-texts still firing after someone replied — looks like a bot and you lose trust. When a good applicant replies, pull them out of auto-follow-up that same day and go manual — personal, responsive, owner nearby — that's what you already do well.

2. What helped stand out beyond LVP / light fixtures / EV hookup:

Your EV hookup + care and responsiveness + owner lives nearby + making home feel like home — that's the differentiator — list that story, not just finishes. Photos of clean, bright LVP help, but the line "owner nearby who cares" plus quick response time + move-in ready process + 3 families onboarded with a repeatable system — that attracts good applicants who want stability.

You already built onboarding 3 families to stabilized — that's the hard part — listing + screening is just the next system to write down once and repeat.

Excited for you — quad 2 of 13 — you're ahead of schedule!

0 Reply

Jimmy Samaha

Staten Island, NY · Member since 2013 · 145 posts · 71 votes

2w

Congrats on number two. My two pieces of advice would be write your screening criteria down before the listing goes live (income around 3x the rent, credit, rental history, whatever you pick) and apply it the exact same way to every applicant, in the order they apply. It keeps you consistent, keeps you out of trouble, and makes saying no a lot less personal. Second, do a really detailed move in walkthrough with dated photos and video of every room and have the tenant sign it. That one document settles 90% of deposit fights later.

As far as standing out, the stuff that moved the needle for me was cheap: great photos taken in daylight, a fresh coat of paint, new light fixtures and outlet covers, and being fast. If you answer inquiries same day and can show it within a day or two, you get the better applicants before the slower landlords even call them back. Pricing it right at market instead of 100 bucks over also gets you a bigger pool to pick from, and a vacant month costs way more than that 100 a month ever makes you.

0 Reply

Ametria Chaney

Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 378 posts · 133 votes

2w

I would take the staged photos before you move out, if you can. A furnished space photographs warmer and gives renters a sense of scale — how a bed, a table, and a sofa actually fit — while a vacant room can look smaller and colder on a screen. Tidy up, open the blinds, and let in as much natural light as possible, and a professional photographer is worth it if the budget allows. If you do end up listing it vacant, ask your photographer about virtual staging for the main rooms so the listing still shows renters how the space can live. Either way, get the photos done while the place is at its best, because that first scroll through the listing is when most renters decide whether to keep looking.

0 Reply

Richard F.

Honolulu, HI · Member since 2008 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes

2w

Screening is your single most important task as a rental manager. Sadly, not one of the prior posts mention investigating applicants Courtroom history. Traffic Court, Family Court, Criminal Court, Small Claims Court, there are multiple venues in most jurisdictions, and all provide different types of information. Yes, some "Credit" reports include a few small pieces of Court info, depending on the CR source, but you should be checking every (as in EACH adult occupant, not just Head of household) persons Court history as well as financial and other areas too, and everyone signs the rental agreement. Rules are Rules, if the applicants are not following common laws, why would you think they will follow your rules?

Many jurisdictions now have online access to records, but again, they are not likely to be all accessible on one site. Depending on what info is available locally, you set bars for each type of Court. A couple minor traffic issues...speeding 10 over, an expired tag, on their own no big deal. But what if year after year there are expired tag, expired insurance, or speeding 25 over? Or 2 DUI's in three years? Hard no's for me. Family Court- TRO's or Domestic Violence within past few years? Hard no. Currently active eviction, or prior eviction within several years? What are the specific circumstances? You need to know. Criminal Court- recent incarceration? How long, what for? Type of crime? All very important. You do need to know local law concerning these records, some locales restrict how you can use them in relation to housing, but typically if you see bad habits in these different Court venues, the applicants will have many more bad habits that will disqualify them.

I'm not saying people can't change, but that is why you must look at the entire picture of their past. Maybe they had issues in their 20's, but had a life changing event and cleaned up over the past 3 - 5 years. Its possible. Sometimes people do mature, sometimes they do not. It's up to you to figure it out so you don't get burned.

0 Reply

J CastroBusiness Member

Lender · Florida · Member since 2025 · 776 posts · 269 votes

2w

Quote from @Sophia Hayden:

Today I’m closing on my second fourplex! 🥹👏

One year into my journey towards my moonshot of 13 quads in 13 years. I love making home a home for my residents. That is what motivates me most: it’s so fulfilling for me.

I’ll be moving out of the owner-occupied unit I’ve called home for the past year and into a unit being delivered vacant in the new quad. Moving across the backyard for the next chapter!

I’ve built systems and have an amazing team, so onboarding three new families and getting the property stabilized feels like a process we can repeat. Now comes a new learning curve: turning my current unit, listing it, screening applicants, and placing my first tenant.

My goals for this year were:

✅ Successfully handle lease renewals: 3 for 3. Boom!
✅ Buy another quad: closing today!
⏳ Learn how to find and place a good tenant: up next!

I’m so excited and nervous. The impostor syndrome is hitting, but I’m determined. I love being in this zone of discomfort because it means I’m growing.

I renovated my unit with LVP, new light fixtures, and an EV hookup in the garage. I plan to highlight those in the listing, along with the care and responsiveness I bring as an owner who lives nearby. Making home feel like home matters to me.

For those who remember your first tenant placement:

1. If you could give a rookie just TWO pieces of advice, what would they be?

2. Beyond renovations, what has helped your rental stand out and attract good applicants?

Thanks, y’all! Excited to keep learning from this community. 🫶🏻

Congratulations on closing on your second fourplex! 🎉 It's inspiring to see you turning your long-term vision into reality, one property at a time.

I especially like that you're focused on creating quality homes for your residents while building repeatable systems for managing and growing your portfolio. That combination of resident satisfaction and operational efficiency is essential for long-term success in multifamily investing.

If I could offer two pieces of advice for your first tenant placement:

1. Don't rush the screening process. Verify income, rental history, references, and credit in accordance with applicable fair housing laws and your screening criteria. Finding the right tenant can save you significant time, money, and stress down the road.

2. Focus on the resident experience. Clear communication, responsive maintenance, and a well-maintained property can help attract quality applicants and encourage long-term tenancy. As an owner living nearby, your personal involvement could be a real advantage.

Your approach to highlighting the upgrades is smart, too. However, don't underestimate the value of professional photos, a compelling listing, and competitive rental pricing based on comparable properties.

At JCREIG Capital Funding, we appreciate investors who approach real estate with a long-term vision and a commitment to building sustainable portfolios.

Thirteen fourplexes in thirteen years is an exciting goal, and you're already proving that consistent action and solid systems can turn big ambitions into tangible results.

Congratulations again, and best of luck with the new property and your first tenant placement!

JCREIG Capital Funding

Website View Page

0 Reply

Simon W.Business Member

Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 695 votes

2w

Congrats, and good advice on screening already. One thing I'd add on the books side: when you move out of your current unit and rent it, the date you start renting is when it generally starts being a rental for tax purposes. I'd write that date down and have the unit's depreciation start from it.

Open a rental bank account too, and run rent, deposits and repairs through it, not your personal account. Security deposits should sit in their own account since they're a liability, not income. Collect, say, $1,200 rent plus a $1,200 deposit, and only the first counts as income.

Keep the receipts for the LVP, fixtures and EV hookup, since those are likely added to the property cost instead of being expensed. Having them organized on day one makes tax time a lot easier.

Accounting Properties LLC

View Page

CFO LLC

View Page

0 Reply

Randy Schell

Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 287 posts · 46 votes

1w

Huge congratulations on quad number two, that's a big day and you should enjoy it. Since you care so much about making a home for your residents, walking each unit with fresh eyes before listing, as if you were the new tenant, often shows the little touches that make people feel welcome.

Randy, Bunklow

0 Reply

Closing on quad #2 today! First time listing a rental—what should I know?

Closing on quad #2 today! First time listing a rental—what should I know?

Most Popular Reply

21 Replies