Duplex Purchases that don't pencil in the first year due to current rates

Duplex Purchases that don't pencil in the first year due to current rates

Steve CargoPro Member
Investor · Austin Texas · Member since 2026 · 1 post · 2 votes

So I wanted to reach out to people that have bought duplexes in the past. I have handful that I own under my belt and I am having trouble making current purchases pencil mainly due to the interest rates out there now. Is anyone still buying multifamily properties that do not pencil (cash on cash return) after they first year ( and remodel) due to rates? So for example does it still make sense to buy properties and finance them at current rates after remodel, and have them only cash flow after (hopefully) a drop in interest rates (refinance)? Let me know your thoughts.

2Reply
1,627 views

Most Popular Reply

Erik EstradaBusiness Member
Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
2w

Hey Steve,

There are still many duplexes and SFRs that cashflow with the current rates. You may need to increase your search to the mid-west (Ohio, PA, TN, SC, NC, IL). I find that these states have the highest amount of BRRRRs that can still work with an 8% mortgage rate. You may need to look off market or buy homes that need rehab rather than straight forward, rent-ready properties.

LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
See this reply in the discussion

18 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Peoria, AZ · Member since 2026 · 81 posts · 18 votes
    1mo

    Hey Steve, great question, especially since you already own several duplexes and know what it takes to make them work.

    Personally, I’d be cautious about buying a property that only makes sense if rates drop and you can refinance. I’d want to know the deal can survive at today’s financing costs, even if that means carrying it for a few years.

    One thing worth exploring is the financing structure. Depending on your portfolio, conventional financing versus a DSCR investor loan can make a difference. Some DSCR programs even allow properties that don't fully cover the mortgage payment initially. There are also interest-only options that might help with cash flow while you're stabilizing the property.

    I’m a mortgage broker, and one advantage I have is being able to shop multiple lenders to see who can offer the most competitive financing options in this market. Sometimes the right loan structure can make a bigger difference than people realize. I’d be happy to run some numbers and see what options might help make your next duplex purchase work.

    I’m curious, are the duplexes you’re looking at actually negative cash flow after renovations, or are they cash flow positive but just not hitting your target cash-on-cash return? I think that’s an important distinction when deciding whether the deal is worth pursuing.

  • Matthew MorrowBusiness Member
    Investor · PA - NY - NJ · Member since 2019 · 976 posts · 357 votes
    1mo

    @Steve Cargo I'd be careful betting on the refi. You can't control when or if rates drop. If the duplex covers its costs at today's rate and the remodel adds real value, it can still make sense, but I'd want it to survive without the refinance. Keep real reserves so a slow first year doesn't hurt.

    CORE Team | Realty ONE Group Supreme4.950 Reviews
  • James JonesPro Member
    Investor · Collierville, TN 38017 · Member since 2017 · 1k+ posts · 774 votes
    1mo

    I do not buy a deal that only works if rates drop. That is hoping, not underwriting.

    In Memphis I underwrite the refinance on day one at today's money: buy single-family under $100K, rehab, rent, and the rent has to carry a DSCR loan at 70-80% LTV on a 30-year term. If it does not hit close to the 1% rule after rehab, the price is wrong, not the rate.

    A duplex that is negative in year one stays negative when taxes, insurance, or a vacancy hit. Fix the buy price or the rent — add a bedroom, raise the ARV — or pass. A rate drop should be a bonus, never the plan.

  • Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 127 posts · 33 votes
    1mo

    If it doesn't pencil at today's numbers, I'd walk — or renegotiate. I never buy on the promise of a refi. Rates might come down, they might not, and in the meantime you're feeding a property every month hoping the market bails you out. That's not investing, that's speculating with extra steps. On my deals the rule is simple: it has to cash flow on the loan I can actually get today. If a future refi happens, that's upside — a bonus, not the plan. If you love the property, the better move is usually price: get the seller down to where today's numbers work, or move on to the next one. There are always more duplexes. Happy to look at the numbers with you.

  • Divin KanyamaBusiness Member
    Accountant · Seattle, WA · Member since 2025 · 704 posts · 302 votes
    1mo

    @Steve Cargo Buying a duplex that only works after rates fall is less an investment thesis than an interest-rate bet. Rates may decline, but the timing and refinance terms are uncertain, and a lower rate may be offset by a disappointing appraisal, tighter lending standards, higher taxes or insurance, or insufficient seasoning and equity.

    A deal can still make sense with weak first-year cash flow if there is a clear, controllable value-creation plan—documented rent upside, a well-supported rehab, favorable basis, or an owner-occupancy benefit—and enough reserves to carry the property comfortably. Underwrite it at today’s permanent financing, include full vacancy, maintenance, capex, and management costs, and treat any future refinance as upside rather than the rescue plan. If the property cannot survive without a rate drop, the price probably needs to come down or the deal should wait.

  • Stacy RaskinBusiness Member
    Lender · Member since 2022 · 1k+ posts · 535 votes
    1mo

    It doesn't generally make sense to buy if the property isn't cash flowing unless perhaps you are buying for other reasons such as appreciation. But you can make an offer on a property with a seller concession where you can use the seller credits to buy down the rate which could potentially get the investment property to cash flow. If a non owner occupied rental property and buying with a DSCR loan, you could potentially use a seller credit for up to 6% of the purchase price depending on the DSCR loan program. For a math example, if you are buying a $300,000 property and using a 6% seller credit, that's $18,000 that can go towards buying down the rate and closing costs. Happy to connect to discuss further.

  • Gregory AcsPro Member
    Lender · MD · Member since 2025 · 293 posts · 102 votes
    1mo

    I wouldn't rely on future rate cuts to make a duplex profitable. If the numbers don't work at today's rates, there's a risk of carrying negative cash flow longer than expected.

    I'd compare financing options and stress-test the deal with current payments, realistic expenses, and some room for vacancies. Refinancing later should ideally be a bonus rather than the only way the investment works.

    Are you finding deals that are close to breaking even, or are financing costs making them significantly cash flow negative?

  • Investor · Milwaukee - Mequon, WI · Member since 2010 · 5k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    1mo

    Nobody buys gold or bitcoin and complains that it does not cash flow. And REI has several other advantages like leverage, appreciation and taxes.

    Year 1 cash flow is a very poor metric. You buy real estate with a 10+ year strategic timeline. If $200/month make or break your finances, you should not be investing in real estate in the first place.

    Rents goes up with inflation, your payment stays flat, the gap widens. Wealth is not created from cash flow, but from long term appreciation.

    7% may turn out to be a great rate, if inflation creeps up to 8%+ driving borrowing cost double digit.. The US government will definitely use in inflation to melt the national debt; a 0.25% rate hike is less than half hearted and they know it

  • Nathan BrooksBusiness Member
    Lender · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2012 · 403 posts · 188 votes
    1mo

    I'd be super careful on buying something that doesn't cash flow ... there are only a few things that I think about in this kind of scenario.

    1 You have a massive income and are using real estate as the store of wealth and tax deduction. If this is the cash, I'd put a little more cash down to have a lower LTV, and I would buy down the rate

    2 Its an incredible deal with a lot of equity, that is in a strong A-B area ... and you own other stuff there, know the area etc. AND ... and, you are ok with it basically not cash flowing for a couple years (and have the cash set aside to do that)

    3 Re-trade on the buy side, and use it as leverage to get a better deal.

    I still don't love any deal that doesn't cash flow (been there, it's not fun paying for someone to live in your house, even if it is equity on your balance sheet / net worth).

    Put a little cash into it, buy the rate down ... or most likely, just don't buy it.

    Ridgeline Capital Group527 Reviews
    View Page
  • Simon W.Business Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Lehigh Valley PA & New York City · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 697 votes
    1mo

    Marcus mentioned taxes without getting into it, so here's the part I'd add. A duplex that's a little negative on cash can show a much bigger loss on the return because of depreciation. On a $400k duplex with about $320k in the building, that's roughly $11,600 a year. So if you're out of pocket $3,000 in year one, the return shows closer to a $14,600 loss.

    Whether you can use it depends on income. Rental losses are usually passive, and there's a $25,000 allowance if you actively participate, but it starts shrinking once your income is over $100k and is gone at $150k. If you're above that, the loss isn't gone, it's suspended and carries forward against future rental income or the sale. With a handful of duplexes already, I'd look at the whole portfolio, not just the new one.

    I still agree with Matthew and James that it should survive on its own. The depreciation is a bonus, not the reason to buy.

    Accounting Properties LLC
    View Page
    CFO LLC
    View Page
  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    1mo

    The Real Estate Crash of 2008-2010 caused real estate prices to crash across the country - but didn't affect rent amounts. This caused a historically unique opportunity for investors - they could buy Class A properties and immediately cashflow when renting them out.

    This couldn't last forever, and it didn't, as excited new investors drove up prices. 

    Eventually, Class A property values increased to the point that even increasing rents didn't allow them to cashflow upon purchase.

    So, the flood of new investors switched to buying Class B properties. 

    COVID created a chaotic spike in both the sale & rental markets, attracting even more new real estate investors. According to , in December of 2023, almost 30% of home sales were to investors!

    Investment also spiked in Class A Short-Term Rentals (STR) and investors started paying higher and higher prices based upon anticipated STR rental rates, that exceeded sustainability based upon Long-Term Rental rates (LTR).

    Now we're seeing investors pouring money into buying Class C rentals - but, many are getting burned.

    In our experience & opinion, the main determinant of property Class is not location or even property condition, those are #2 and #3. The #1 determinant is the Tenant Pool.

    If you don't believe us, try putting several Class D tenants in Class A apartment buildings and watch what happens. Or try the reverse - rehab a property in a Class D area to Class A standards and try to get a Class A or B tenant to rent it.

    Unfortunately, many newbie real estate investors are jumping into buying affordable Class C rentals - expecting Class A results.

    In our opinion, Class C tenants have FICO scores from 560 to 620 - where their chance of default/nonpayment is 15-22%. See the chart from Fair Isaac Company (FICO) below:

    FICO Score

    Pct of Population

    Default Probability

    800 or more

    13.00%

    1.00%

    750-799

    27.00%

    1.00%

    700-749

    18.00%

    4.40%

    650-699

    15.00%

    8.90%

    600-649

    12.00%

    15.80%

    550-599

    8.00%

    22.50%

    500-549

    5.00%

    28.40%

    Less than 499

    2.00%

    41.00%

    According to this chart, investors should use corresponding vacancy + tenant-nonperformance factors of approximately 5% for Class A rentals, 10% for Class B and 20% for Class C.

    To address Class C payment challenges, many industry "experts" are now selling programs to newbie investors about how Section 8 tenants are the cure. If only it was that easy. Yes, the government pays the Section 8 rent timely, but more and more tenants are having to pay a portion of their rent. Then there are the challenges with Section 8 tenants paying utilities and taking care of their rental property. 

    Investors should fully understand that Section 8 is not a cure-all for Class C & D tenant challenges, it's just trading one set of problems for another.

    We see too many investors not doing enough research to fully understand all this and making naïve investing decisions.

    Once you understand the above, you still need to find a property. You’ll have to do what investors did before the Great Real Estate Crash:

    1)      Evaluating 100 properties, to identify 10 to make offers on, in the hopes one seller accepts.
    - Yes, this takes a lot of work!

    2)      Network with wholesalers who can bring you “deals”
    - Many wholesalers are also newbies who have no clue what a real deal is and are just time-wasters.
    NOTE: We often see wholesalers re-marketing MLS properties at HIGHER amounts!

    3)      Start using your own personal network to find motivated sellers.
    - Start posting on your favorite social media site what you are looking for – not once or twice, but CONSISTENTLY for 6 months! Give updates on properties you’ve looked at or analyzed to keep your audience engaged, so when they stumble upon a potential situation, you are the first one they think of.

    Good luck!

  • Noah WrightBusiness Member
    Lender · USA, Nationwide · Member since 2024 · 632 posts · 179 votes
    3w

    A deal that only works after a refinance is really a bet on the refinance, so price the exit along with the purchase. The prepay is the reason. Most DSCR loans carry one, commonly 3 to 5 years stepping down. If you buy with short-term money for the remodel and then go into a DSCR loan, that step-down starts with the DSCR loan, not the day you bought. So the prepay structure you choose up front decides whether a rate-drop refi in year two or three is even worth doing, and a shorter prepay usually costs some rate. Interest-only typically comes with a higher rate and builds no principal, so it delays the cash-flow problem rather than solving it.

  • Member since 2020 · 27 posts · 4 votes
    3w

    Hi Steve, I'd be careful with any purchase that only works if rates drop, because nobody can promise when that refi will happen. A few ways I see investors making duplexes pencil right now: underwrite at today's rate and treat a future refi as upside, not the plan; get more of the value in the buy price or the remodel so the post-rehab appraisal does the work; and if you'll hold long term, a DSCR loan qualified on the rents (some lenders offer an interest-only period) can ease year one while the units stabilize. Then stress test it: if rates stayed where they are for three years, could your reserves cover the gap each month? If the answer is no, I'd pass and keep looking.

  • Member since 2021 · 16 posts · 4 votes
    3w

    Steve, one thing I'd add from the financing side: the future refinance gets sized on that day's numbers, not today's. Before buying on a refi-later plan, it's worth asking two or three lenders a few questions in writing:

    - Do they size the loan off your signed leases or the appraiser's market rent?

    - How long do you need to own the property before they'll use the new appraised value?

    - Is the cash-out loan-to-value lower than on a purchase?

    - What prepayment penalty would apply if you refinance again?

    Full disclosure: I broker investor loans, so these are the questions I'd want answered before relying on a future refinance.

  • Lender · Dallas, TX · Member since 2024 · 34 posts · 12 votes
    3w

    Steve, waiting on rates is a gamble, not a plan. Rates are flat to up right now, and to make a real difference on a deal like this they'd have to drop a lot. That's a long-term play.

    I've had people tell me since 2022 that they're waiting for rates to drop. Imagine all the deals that could have gotten done in that time.

    The deal has to work with today's numbers. I'd shoot for at least a 1.0 DSCR, meaning the rent covers the full payment and you're breaking even. Lenders like us can go as low as 0.75 with a bigger down payment, but that's negative cash flow, and it's not something I'd personally advise.

    I run a lender, so weigh that.

  • Erik EstradaBusiness Member
    Lender · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2022 · 7k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    2w

    Hey Steve,

    There are still many duplexes and SFRs that cashflow with the current rates. You may need to increase your search to the mid-west (Ohio, PA, TN, SC, NC, IL). I find that these states have the highest amount of BRRRRs that can still work with an 8% mortgage rate. You may need to look off market or buy homes that need rehab rather than straight forward, rent-ready properties.

    LuxePrivate Investments LLC 571 Reviews
  • Ryan KellyBusiness Member
    Real Estate Broker · Austin, TX · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    4h

    Steve, you're in my lane. Duplexes and small multifamily around the Austin metro is most of what I do, and I own rentals myself.

    I agree with the thread that a deal relying on a refinance is a bet on the refinance. What I'd add is where the room actually is right now, because it usually isn't in the rate.

    It's in the buy. Longer marketing times mean the sellers who have been sitting have real motivation, and days on market plus price-change history will tell you which ones. That is where I spend my search time.

    It's in the rent, which is the half most people underwrite the least carefully. Pull actual leased comps in that submarket instead of a metro average, and get the unit rent-ready fast. A unit that sits 45 days costs more than most of the rate differences people are chasing.

    On tenant-occupied ones, valid leases stay with the property, so you're inheriting them. I pull the leases, ledgers and any addenda during the option period and read them before the deadline. In-place rent below market isn't automatically a problem, but it is the number your first year actually runs on, not the pro forma.

    One more before you offer: check the tax rate for that exact address. The swing between taxing districts out here is big enough to change whether a duplex works.

    What submarkets are you looking in right now?

    Ryan Kelly Group - Keller Williams5112 Reviews
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.