Technology · NY · Member since 2026 · 32 posts · 12 votes
Hey everyone, I'm looking at a potential rental property in [miami] and I'm trying to run the numbers, but I keep hitting a wall with the insurance costs.
The property is a 3/2 SFH, purchase price around $250k, expecting $1,800/mo in rent. I ran a quick DSCR calculation using a free tool (I can share the link if anyone wants to check the math), and at a 7% interest rate, the DSCR looks okay on paper.
BUT, when I factor in the current property tax and the new insurance quote (which is almost double what the seller is paying), the DSCR drops below 1.0.
For those of you investing in high-tax/high-insurance states right now, how are you making these deals work? Are you just walking away, or are you finding lenders who are more flexible with the DSCR calculation?
Would love to hear how you're stress-testing these numbers.
You can get a DSCR loan with less than a DSCR 1 ratio. The rate and the LTV will be impacted. More on DSCR loans and what impacts rates. DSCR loans won't use your income to underwrite the loan.
DSCR loans are based off of down payment, credit score and either actual or market rents so it helps to supercharge an investor's real estate goals and net worth.
Here's a bit more in detail about how rates are calculated for DSCR loans:
1. Credit score- the higher the best. 760-780+ generally gets best pricing for investment property loans with most lenders. From there every 20 point increment affect pricing differently. So for example, a 761 credit score will be in the 760-779 credit category, then going down to 740-759 and so on.
2. Loan to value ratio: The higher the loan to value ratio (LTV) is, pricing takes a hit. So your pricing will be higher for a 80% LTV loan than for a 60% LTV loan.
3. Prepayment penalties- usually 1-5 year terms. The shorter the prepayment term has an impact on increasing the rate.
4. Are you cash flowing the property? More on how that is calculated below. Is your DSCR ratio greater than 1-meaning are you cash flowing (according to the lender's criteria of mortgage, property taxes and insurance (and HOA) if applicable). Many lenders will not do a DSCR loan unless cash flowing. If they will do a loan with less than 1, the pricing takes a hit. This criteria is for 1-4 and 5-8 unit programs. I've included an example below to help illustrate this.
So different lenders have different rates (which do vary even for DSCR loans) but these are factors they all consider.
See example below:
DSCR < 1
Principal + Interest = $1,700
Taxes = $350, Insurance = $100, Association Dues = $50
Total PITIA = $2200
Rent = $2000
DSCR = Rent/PITIA = 2000/2200 = 0.91
Since the DSCR is 0.91, we know the expenses are greater than the income of the property.
DSCR >1
Principal + Interest = $1,500
Taxes = $250, Insurance = $100, Association Dues = $25
Total PITIA = $1875 Rent = $2300
DSCR = Rent/PITIA = 2300/1875 = 1.23
If a purchase, you also generally need reserves / savings to show you have 3-6 month payments of PITIA (principal / interest (mortgage payment), property taxes and insurance and HOA (if applicable). If a cash out refinance, many lenders will allow the cash out to satisfy the reserves requirement.
DSCR lenders generally let you vest either individually or as an LLC. It's a great way to increase your net worth and these loans can also be used to pull cash out of a property as it appreciates allowing you to reinvest money into new deals. Happy to connect to discuss further.
Worth running it line by line, because most DSCR lenders divide gross rent by PITIA (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, HOA).
Rough example: $250k with 25% down is a $187,500 loan. At 7% over 30 years, P&I is about $1,247/mo. If taxes come in near 2% of the price ($417/mo) and insurance is $4,000/yr ($333/mo), PITIA is about $1,997. $1,800 / $1,997 = 0.90 DSCR.
To hit 1.0 you'd need rent near $2,000; for 1.20, about $2,400.
Two things to check before walking away:
Florida reassesses at sale, so use the tax on your purchase price, not the seller's (possibly homestead-capped) bill.
A wind mitigation inspection and a higher deductible can lower the premium noticeably on older SFHs.
Putting 30% down only gets you to about 0.94, so unless rent or insurance moves, I'd treat this as a price problem rather than a lender problem.
Not tax or lending advice, just how I'd stress-test it.
In this situation if you feel like you've exhausted all the insurance quotes that you can and specifically hone in on the flood coverage that is required for that particular DSCR lender (my guess as to why its a little higher), then I would ask for clarification on what the different Interest-only programs might be if you wanted to make it fit.
Obviously raising the rent is one option, but most DSCR lenders have some kind of Interest-Only period that they offer with a standard amortization schedule afterwards. You can structure the financing around the DSCR of the interest-only period with anticipation of refinancing down the road or even around standard appreciation after the 5-10 years or however long it might be.
Outside of that, the other things I'm seeing:
Increasing the Down Payment (lower leverage and rate to make DSCR fit)
Raising the rent (checking 10-07 market rent schedule to see if it would fit)
Asking about Rate Buydowns
Working with a broker to give a better idea on exact rate
The last one is more of a thought if you are trying to make this fit. 7% is a pretty good rate in this market, so if you are already snug on DSCR, I might suggest working with someone who can get an accurate view of financing right now so that you can get what you need.
Happy to connect and talk through some options if it would be helpful
Tomas, a DSCR under 1.0 isn't automatically a no. A few things that actually move the number:
1. The rent figure. On a purchase, most lenders use the appraiser's market rent (the 1007), not your estimate. If the comps support $1,900 to $2,000, that alone may get you to 1.0.
2. The insurance number. Lenders use the premium on your actual quote. In Florida, roof age and a wind mitigation report drive that premium more than almost anything, so get quotes with both in hand before you assume double.
3. Programs below 1.0. Some lenders go down to about 0.75 DSCR, usually with a lower max LTV, a higher rate, and stronger credit and reserves. Some also qualify on the interest-only payment, as AJ mentioned.
If it's still under 1.0 after all that, I agree with Luuk that it's a price problem. Work out the purchase price that gets you to 1.0 and offer there.
Work the insurance number before you shop the loan. It's the one line in your DSCR you can still move, and you already did the hard part by pricing a fresh quote instead of trusting the seller's. A seller's premium often reflects an older policy that has been renewing in place, so yours is the honest one to underwrite.
In Florida the big drivers are roof age and a wind mitigation inspection, which can earn discounts for things like roof straps, shutters and impact glass. A higher hurricane deductible also lowers the premium, as long as it stays within what your lender allows. At $1,800 rent on $250k, a better quote can be the gap between under 1.0 and over it. Walk away only after a re-quote with the mitigation report in hand.
How old is the roof? It's usually the first thing Florida carriers price.
Stacy covered the lender side, so I'll add what the same property looks like on the books. Say $250k with 20% down is a $200k loan at 7%, so about $1,331 a month in principal and interest. Add roughly $450 a month in taxes and $400 in insurance and PITIA is about $2,180 against $1,800 of rent. That's a DSCR near 0.83, and about $380 a month out of pocket before repairs or vacancy.
The tax return tells a different story. Interest is around $13,900 the first year, taxes and insurance about $10,200, and depreciation on, say, $200k of building is about $7,300. On $21,600 of rent that's a paper loss near $9,800, even though the cash loss is closer to $4,600. And that paper loss is usually suspended as a passive loss, so it won't offset your W-2 income.
So I'd run it as a cash number, not a DSCR number, and keep taxes and insurance as their own lines so you can see them as a percent of rent. If it needs a reserve account just to stay even, that's a red flag.
@Tomas Jems we see the same thing closer to the Gulf here in Texas. The seller's premium is almost never what you'll pay. Before walking away, I'd get quotes on the exact address with the roof age the carrier is using, ask what a higher wind deductible does to the premium, and see whether a wind mitigation inspection gets you any credits. Then rerun the DSCR on the real quote. If it still doesn't work, it's probably a pass, not a lender problem.
Hi Tomas — I'd pass at $250K, and it's the price, not the DSCR loan itself.
$1,800 in rent against $1,900 in PITI is negative before vacancy, maintenance, and capex — and a DSCR lender underwrites on the rent, not on optimism about the area. Insurance is the swing factor in Florida, so get a real quote in writing before going further. A seller's estimate or a statewide average won't tell you what this house actually costs to insure.
The way I underwrite my own buy-and-holds (17+ units in Massachusetts) is simple: the deal has to cash flow on today's numbers, with real taxes, insurance, and reserves. If it only works if insurance comes in low or rents jump, it's not a deal yet — it's a hope.
Renegotiate hard or walk away, and keep the powder dry for one that pencils on day one. Happy to connect if you want to compare underwriting notes.
Tomas, that insurance jump is really common in Florida right now. The seller's premium is usually an old policy on a renewal, and your quote is what the house actually costs to insure today. Before you give up on it, I'd ask the listing agent for the 4 point and the wind mitigation report. If the roof is newer and there are hurricane straps, shutters or impact windows that nobody documented, a fresh wind mit inspection can bring the number down a good bit. Also double check whether your quote includes flood, since that's sometimes a separate policy the lender is requiring. And run the taxes off your purchase price, not what the seller pays now, because they'll reset after you buy. If it still doesn't get to 1.0 after all that, I'd probably pass or renegotiate the price rather than stretch.
A few things that usually move the needle on a Florida DSCR deal like this:
1. Get an insurance quote on the exact address with a wind mitigation report and the roof age in hand. In Florida those two items often swing the premium more than anything else, and a higher wind deductible can bring it down further.
2. Re-run the tax line using the reassessed value at your purchase price, not the seller's current bill. Florida resets the assessed value on sale, so the seller's number is usually too low.
3. Many DSCR lenders will go below a 1.0 ratio, but typically with a lower max LTV, a pricing adjustment and more reserves (often around 6 months of PITIA). Interest-only options can also lift the ratio, since many lenders qualify on the interest-only payment.
4. Lenders size the loan off the appraiser's market rent (Form 1007), so pull rent comps on renovated 3/2s nearby to see whether $1,800 is conservative or optimistic.
5. If the deal only works at a sub 1.0 DSCR with no cash flow, the cleaner fix is usually price. Use the real insurance and tax numbers to support a lower offer.