The Plight of an Accidental Landlord: Tips & Advice

by |

If you hang out on the BiggerPockets forums you know that at least once a week a brand new landlord… mostly a person who was forced into the landlord role just to cover the mortgage on an investment that went wrong, will make a post… actually it is more of a plea asking for help with a critical tenant issue.

If you have taken the time to read through these pleas… your heart almost goes out to the individual because it seems that the more they discuss their plight, the worst the situation seems to be.

As was the case with a recent post from a very stressed landlord who was nervous about having to evict a tenant who was several months behind in their rent and had this poor landlord literally tap dancing to their tune.  This person very clearly was an “accidental landlord”!

Perhaps you know an “accidental landlord” and have watched them struggle to find and manage their tenants.  Perhaps you are or were one!

“Accidental landlords” don’t start out with the notion of becoming a landlord.  They end up backing into that role. 

How… you may ask?  Simple…  This is the person who paid waaaaay too much for a rehab property.  Or, perhaps they gilded the lily regarding the renovation or busted the renovation budget due to inexperience in either estimating the repairs and their costs or poorly managing the contractors.  Or, perhaps they just mis-read the market and got caught!

Regardless the end result is that they can’t sell their property without taking huge losses and so they decide, with no knowledge or experience, to become a landlord!  An “accidental” one at that!

While I could write chapter and verse how not to find yourself as an “accidental landlord”… instead, and in hopes of helping out any investor who finds themselves on this slippery slope, I am going to focus on just a few of the basics that should be adhered to by any person who finds themselves heading down the path of being a landlord for any reason.

Tips for Potential “Accidental” Landlords

  1. Realize that owning rental properties is a very different animal then rehabbing and selling or wholesaling.  There are many, many landord/tenant laws and they are different in every state, county and city.  Before you jump in or are pushed into becoming a landlord spend some time figuring out what these rules are.  They can be found online, through real estate agents, municipalities themselves and in many larger cities through landlord/tenant organizations.  Also, seek out and participate in your local Property Owners Association.
  2. Expanding on number 1 above, you have certain rights as a landlord… and guess what… so does your tenant.  Know what those rights are!  For instance, in most jurisdictions you can’t turn the power off to the property or change the locks just because the tenant has stopped paying rent.  In fact, in Baltimore, Maryland that action would most likely end up with you in jail. 
  3. Find a lawyer who specializes in landlord/tenant issues and come prepared with a ton of questions and a request for a lease that will protect you and comply with local laws.  The list of questions –  first and foremost, includes “how does the eviction process work?”  What is the timeline and what are the costs?  In some places going from non-payment of rent to eviction is a matter of weeks.  In others, it is a matter of many long months. 
  4. Seek out and hire a professional property manager.  As much as it pains me make this recommendation, the bottom line is you may not be ready or able to be an effective landlord.  My litmus test is the following: If you can evict a tenant in December, you have what it takes to make the tough decisions to be a landlord.  If you can’t evict in December, hire someone who will!
  5. Remember that your job as a landlord is not to become friends with your tenant.  You may be friendly, cordial and respectful, but this is a business relationship — one where if you are lucky, you will get paid rent regularly and if you are not so lucky, you will find yourself becoming very hardened towards people.

I am sure there are many other things you need to know when heading down the path to becoming an Accidental Landlord, but for now, know what you are up against and then make the conscious decision –> Do I want to be an Accidental Landlord or not? 

Best of luck!

Photo: Steven Depolo

About Author

Peter is an active and successful real estate investor in the Baltimore Maryland region for the past 8 years and is one of the founders of The Club Mastermind a real estate investing coaching program focused on local coaches helping investors to perfect their game.


  1. Peter
    Excellent blog, great advice. Let me add, ‘accidental’ landlords should not wallow in their failure. That is the cause of many a failed real estate investors. If real estate investing is not for you, no harm/no foul. But, you have also just finished BOOT CAMP of real estate investing and if the accidental landlord has learned the wrong way to do things, then the next time should end up in a much better situation.

  2. What happened to the end of this article? It ends with:

    I am sure there are many other things you need to know when heading down the path to becoming an Accidental Landlord, but for now, know what you are up against and then make the conscious decision . . .

    Conscious decision to what? Just fell asleep on that sentence? LOL!

  3. Treat landlording as a business. Be professional in dealing with tenants in every manner. Written rules, documents, notices ect. If you come off as an accidental landlord or a mom and pop operation, some of these tenants will eat you alive.

    They will dictate to you how and when they will comply with the rules. See, many “renters” are what I would like to refer to as professional renters. All they do is rent houses from “accidental landlords” or landlords who don’t treat their rental as a business. They settle for tenants paying rent late or whenever they are able to pay.

    Professional renters can smell landlords who don’t treat their rental as a business a mile away. They feel they have the upper hand because you are reluctant to file for eviction when rent is in late status. You have to set the tone as soon as ANY rules on that lease is violated.

    Whatever you do, just get all the information you can about landlord/tenant law and follow it to the letter of that law. You both have rights.

  4. Domenick T.

    Great Article Peter! This is exactly how I got started (I even named my blog

    My situation was a little different. I purchased my condo at a great price and when it came time to move, I was in a position to cash flow from a rental. I made the decision to become a landlord so I treated it as a business from the very beginning. I think that helped me set the tone from the start and avoid a lot of hassles.

    I would also suggest using a local realtor when starting out. They will know how to price the unit, what paperwork needs to be completed, what lease clauses to add, etc. In my town, the tenant pays the commission so it’s a no brainer, but I would recommend this to anyone starting out even if they have to split the commission or pay it themselves. You don’t want to learn Landlord-Tenant laws the hard way!

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here