Landlording & Rental Properties

4 Things You Should Never Tell Your Tenants When Selling Income Property

4 Articles Written
Tenants and Selling Income Property

Investors who own and operate income property, whether it's single family homes or small to mid-market multi-family buildings, tend to fall into two categories when it comes to feeling a sense of obligation to their tenants, they either do or they don't. There's usually not too much gray area with this one. Neither is right or wrong. Real estate is a business but it's a people business and relationships with tenants can get in the way of monetary business decisions.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

When you decide to sell an investment property, the potential for tenants to be impacted negatively is high.  From allowing access to the property for potential buyers to dealing with uncertainty about their futures, tensions can run high for your tenants.  But they don’t have to.

The key is to clearly inform your tenants of what your intentions are and how they might be affected if a sale takes place.  Making sure you or your broker relay that information clearly and thoughtfully ahead of time, will make a big difference.

Here are four things you should never tell your tenants:

1.) It Will Be Up to The New Owner to Decide What Happens to Your Leases.

True, but only with regard to renewing or extending leases.   Your tenants have rights and those rights granted by the leases will be transferred with the sale.  The new owner will be obligated to honor the terms of the existing leases.  It’s important to be very clear when it comes to discussing leases with your tenants.  What might be just an income producing asset to you, is their home and people tend to get uneasy with uncertainty when it comes to their homes.

2.) No Repairs Will be Made Prior to Selling

This is something that might be “inferred” as opposed to “said.”

Outstanding maintenance issues that exist while you are trying to sell your property are best repaired ahead of time, or immediately if they pop up during the process of selling.  I try to avoid buyers interacting with tenants as much as possible because you never know what a tenant is going to say, good or bad.

If you have outstanding maintenance issues, just imagine how that conversation will go.  The price either just went down or you lost a potential buyer.  It’s that fast.

3.) You Can Re-up Your Lease Now Before I Sell

Never do this if you are trying to maximize the sale price and you have below market rents. The only reason someone would want to re-up a lease prior to a sale, is to lock in something that is providing a benefit.  If they have a kids in the local school system or simply don’t want to move for a while, that is one thing to consider, especially if they are paying market rent.

If you have long-time tenants, on a month to month basis or at the end of a lease and they pay below market rents, raise the rents to a market level or just a tick under.  Remember, if someone is paying you below market rent, you are subsidizing their cost of living at your own expense.

4.) We’re Not Going to Return Your Security Deposit

True, you are not going to return the security deposit to your tenants, but you will do so indirectly when you sell the property and the security deposit funds transfer to the new owner. This has the potential to scare a lot of tenants, as it leaves the door open for them to get jammed by the new owner for repair costs associated with wear and tear to the unit upon moving out. In theory, the buyer is purchasing "as is". Any improvements or repairs needed will be considered in the final sale price. Relay that to the tenants.

If you have issues with tenant uncertainty regarding their security deposit and it’s causing significant problems, you might consider creating an addendum to the lease that photo documents the current condition of the unit and notes that no funds will be retained from the tenant security deposit to upgrade the current condition upon moving out. 

Make sure this addendum is agreed to by the buyer before the closing and signed by the buyer at closing.  That’s truly going above and beyond, but maybe you fall into the category of having a sense of obligation to your tenants.  Not a bad thing.

What would you have added to this list?  Have you had any recent experiences dealing with tenant relations (good or bad) while selling?
Photo Credit: left-hand

Brent Hall specializes in sourcing unique buying opportunities for his client base of real estate investors, rehabbers and residential developers. Brent i...
Read more
    Alex Craig
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Agree. This is always a touchy subject. We actually had 2 tenants move out because the property sold. The first time we hid the fact that we were selling the tenant occupied house, but when the tenant found out, she accused me of “selling the property out from under her.” I found that response strange since she had lived in the house for 3 years and never expressed interest in buying the house. So the next time we were up front and honest about our intentions and explained the new owner wanted to keep her, she told us “This happened to my cousin and she had to move out a week later.” She moved out on us. It is a touchy situation and must be handled very delicate.
    Brent Hall from Chicago, Illinois
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Yep, best to play it safe. Guessing that tenant who moved out after you told her you were selling prob would have moved anyway. Thanks for adding that Alex.
    David H
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    As an investor I would hope the tenant knows about the sale. I would prefer not to have a bad start with the tenants upon taking ownership. Obviously their lease will remain in force but I believe going in as the new owner with the tenants informed will put the tenants at ease, maybe reassuring them that they are not about to lose their home. If there is a long term tenant in the home and they have an interest in purchasing the home then notifying them gives them an opportunity to place an offer, maybe saving the owner a commission.
    Jim Pratt
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    One good tool is tell the renters that you’ll give them a month free rent if they help you. Also that if they have to move upon the sale, they’ll have 60 days to find another place.
    Brent Hall from Chicago, Illinois
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Thanks Jim. Offering free rent is a generous proposition but an effective one, I’m sure.
    Jonny E
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    In the Washington DC market tenants have the right of first refusal when you sell, so you have to let your tenants know that you are selling otherwise you can be in big trouble. DC is also one of the few markets that has rent control rules. This may affect the sale of your property if it is subject to such rules. For details visit ->
    Brent Hall from Chicago, Illinois
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Thanks for sharing the specifics in DC. That’s interesting that DC gives tenants the right of first refusal on all property. In Chicago, tenants only get right of first refusal if you convert a multifamily to condo. This process can definitely delay the sale if you aren’t proactive in getting the tenants to waive their right to purchase.
    Wayne G.
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Baltimore city also has a right of first refusal.
    Adam Weber
    Replied almost 7 years ago
    Just based on my experience this varies market to market as far as local laws and ordinances. While you do not want to rock the boat and kill your own deal, transparency might be best, especially if you have built up any type of relationship with any of your tenants and you own other properties in the immediate market.
    Shana Cooper
    Replied about 4 years ago
    We are getting ready to sell an investment property that we became “accidental” landlords to back in 2010 when we relocated 2000 miles for a job transfer. Being a landlord is complicated and no fun, especially from across the country and without a property manager. It sounds like you can sell a property with a tenant still in it and while this might help with paying the mortgage, it seems more complicated than it’s worth. Thank you for your article and insight.