Commercial Real Estate

New to Multi-Family Valuation? This Awesome Program Can Help!

Expertise:
14 Articles Written
multifamily_investing_valuations

If you’ve been around the proverbial BiggerPockets block a time or two, you’re aware of the fact that commercial multi-family properties are valued differently than single-family homes.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Whereas a single-family home is valued based on the comparable properties (a.k.a “comps”) around it, commercial multi-family properties are valued based on the income that they produce.

This is done by applying a capitalization rate (a.k.a "cap rate") to the Net Operating Income to determine its value.

Scenario

Say you find a property.

According to the seller’s pro forma, it nets $50,000/yr. You then do a bit of research and find that it is located within a market where the cap rate is 8%. Since you know the market cap rate and you know the NOI, you can derive the property value based on the current market.

Cap Rate = NOI / Market Value

0.08 = $50,000 / Market Value

Market Value = $625,000

So let's assume that you put in an offer for the property at $600,000 and it is accepted. Congratulations! You just got yourself a steal!

Until, of course, you realize that your NOI was off.

In fact, the NOI is actually only $45,000. But that’s not too bad, right? Just a $5,000 difference.

Well, lets run that math again.

Cap Rate = NOI / Market Value

0.08 = $45,000 / Market Value

Market Value = $562,500

Uh oh.

Related: Interview With a Bi-Coastal Investor: Why I Purchased My First Multifamily Property Thousands of Miles Away

Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM)

I’m not a seasoned multi-family investor like many of the people on BiggerPockets.

So when I decided to make the leap into commercial property, I couldn’t exactly refer to my own Excel spreadsheets and experience in order to know how much everything cost.

What are typical vacancies for a multi in my city?

How much are other owners spending for repairs every year?

What does electricity typically cost for common areas?

I had no idea.

Commercial real estate is a completely different game from single-family homes. Therefore, I wanted to make sure that I had all of my ducks in a row before I put an offer on anything.

I learned about The Institute of Real Estate Management in Steve Berges’ book The Complete Guide to Buying and Selling Apartment Buildings. This was a huge find and really helped me get a grasp on determining NOI.

The IREM Income/Expense Analysis program has been around for 59 years now. It started out as a brief survey of 200 apartment complexes and has evolved into a massive undertaking of approximately 10,000 properties throughout the United States.

After this data is acquired, 1,000 pages of analysis are published in 5 different volumes.

Although these reports start at a not-so-cheap $145, I couldn’t be more happy that I bought it.

IREM Income/Expense Report

As we saw in the above example, even a small error in the calculation of NOI can drastically change the value based on cap rates.

So how awesome would it be if you could see a list of real world values for apartment complexes in your city?

Enter IREM.

The income/expense items in the report are listed based off of the HUD Chart of Accounts in order to ensure consistency. Values are shown in the following three ways.

  • Percentage of Gross Possible Income (%GPI)
  • Dollars per Square Foot ($/SQFT)
  • Dollars per Unit ($/Unit)

Here is a sampling of some of the line items listed on the report.

  1. Rents
  2. Vacancies
  3. Management Fee
  4. Heating
  5. Water
  6. Security
  7. Repairs
  8. Insurance

How Do I Use the Data?

1. Analysis

Is this property a good deal? Where can we improve the value? Can we raise rents? Can we decrease expenses? Most importantly, will the local market support these changes?

Answers to many of these questions can be found within the income/expense analysis report. It's kind of like having a mentor who lets you peak inside his books from time to time.

Related: 6 Reasons to LOVE Multifamily Investments Over Single Family Homes

2. Valuation

What is the current value? If we were to raise rents to market and lower expenses, what could our future value be?

Armed with this data, you’ll have more confidence in your numbers when you present to investors, brokers, partners, or lenders.

3. Yearly Review

Are we managing effectively? Are we charging enough for rent? Are we seeing more vacancy or less vacancy than other apartments?

This resource, since it is published every year, is a great way to stay on top of your business. The income/expense analysis report can be used as a yearly “gut-check” in order to make sure that your investment is at the very least consistent with others in your neighborhood.

For those seasoned multi-investors out there, what other ways do you think this information can be used? Are there any other resources out there which provide similar information?

Please feel free to leave a message in the comments. Cheers!

Tyler is a pilot by day and aspiring entrepreneur by night. He started investing in April of 2014 and acquired three properties in the first 8 months. His goal is to become financially independent ...
Read more
    Daniel Ryu Investor from Irvine, CA
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Tyler Great resource! Between this and Brandon Hall’s article on CAFR to analyze a city, as an out of country investor, I feel more confidence doing initial due diligence. I’d love to hear from other investors who use these reports – how accurate do the numbers seem?
    Tyler Flagg Investor from Pensacola, FL
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Thanks for the comment Daniel. I agree, I liked Brandon’s CAFR article as well…great stuff. Glad I could help!
    Ben Leybovich Rental Property Investor from Chandler/Lima, Arizona/OH
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Nice article, Tyler. Welcome to the blog! I’ve looked at the HUD numbers and was unimpressed. IREM is a good resource to find a PM who’ll have the answers, but one still needs to kiss a lot of frogs to get to the prince 🙂 Your thinking is right, though!
    Tyler Flagg Investor from Pensacola, FL
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Thank you for the kind words. I’ll definitely look in to using IREM to find a PM in the future. I appreciate the comment!
    AJ P. Residential Real Estate Broker from Napa, California
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Nice article! Very interesting read, thanks for sharing.
    Tyler Flagg Investor from Pensacola, FL
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks AJ!
    Jason Mittenzwey from Homestead, Pennsylvania
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Excellent post. I have been looking into multi family for awhile and this program seems to have all the answers that would take me hours to find. Thank you!
    Tyler Flagg Investor from Pensacola, FL
    Replied over 5 years ago
    You’re very welcome Jason. Thanks for the post!
    Brendan M. New to Real Estate from Colorado Springs, CO
    Replied over 5 years ago
    Nice post! Always great to hear about the resources available to us investors. Knowledge is money in this game.
    Minh Le Investor from San Jose, CA
    Replied about 5 years ago
    Tyler, No numbers? We’re investors. Numbers would be helpful. Thanks for sharing what you have found.
    Gianni Laverde Investor from Corona, NY
    Replied about 5 years ago
    Very useful resource Tyler. Thanks for sharing!!!
    Jim Biggs Investor/Syndicator from North Aurora, IL
    Replied about 5 years ago
    @TYLER FLAGG GOING TO ORDER ONE TODAY.WILL LET YOU KNOW WHAT I THINK!
    Jim Biggs Investor/Syndicator from North Aurora, IL
    Replied about 5 years ago
    PUTTING THE BOOK YOU NOTED ON MY READING LIST