Landlording & Rental Properties

The Biggest Mistake I Made as a First-Time Landlord

Expertise: Mortgages & Creative Financing, Business Management, Landlording & Rental Properties, Commercial Real Estate, Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice, Real Estate Investing Basics, Personal Development
177 Articles Written
woman holding coffee mug in one hand and covering mouth with other hand implying oops

This one’s probably not going to be too much of a shocker to too many people. What’s the biggest mistake I made when I first started out as a landlord? Hands down: I didn’t screen well enough.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Early on when beginning in real estate in Kansas City, there was this unmistakable fear that would come over me if a property sat vacant too long. I remember once when I had 13 consecutive applications fall through for one reason or another.

Even though at least four applicants were approved, the prospects all “ghosted” my company and me once I informed them of their status.

Fear turned into anxiety, and then something close to desperation manifested; I had to get that property leased—to whomever and at whatever cost.

Do not make this mistake! And I should note, the mistake is conceptual. Get it clear in your mind that a vacant property is better than a property that is rented to the wrong person.

Evictions are an expensive affair in and of themselves. In some places, they are time consuming, too. The process can take months.

Want proof? Take this thread on, for example. In it, landlord after landlord discusses how it took them years to evict tenants in New York City.

What’s worse, some tenants will do major damage before they leave. We had one take a hammer and go to town on the drywall throughout the entire unit!

So, say it with me now, “A vacant property is better than one rented to the wrong person.”

Screen Early

One of our first mistakes was not doing much “pre-screening.” This is screening done on the phone or through email when a prospect first reaches out to you.

It’s important for Fair Housing reasons to never say that someone should not apply because they don’t meet your criteria. But you should still ask them if they have any evictions or felonies or if they are employed and make sufficient income to meet your criteria.

Then, use the third person and say something like, “We don’t accept evictions.” If the prospect says that he or she wants to apply anyways, don’t dissuade them. But most won’t bother. What would be the point?

Now yes, some people will lie to you and hope they can squeak through your screening undetected. But most won’t try, and you will save a lot of time on going to show the property or running an application for someone who had no chance of being approved in the first place.

You can also utilize new technologies such as Rently or ShowMojo, which can automate the pre-screening and showing processes.

On a somewhat dark yet amusing note, one time we decided to drop the application fee in order to encourage more applications. You couldn’t possibly imagine how bad some of them were!

One guy yelled at me for having declined his application because his background check had 19 convictions on it—three of which were felonies.

“But that was over 10 years!” he retorted.

How could it have been over less time? I politely told him it was our policy, and there was nothing I could do.

Turns out application fees act as a method of screening, as well. Those who are unlikely to be accepted are rarely willing to pay to find out for sure. If you aren’t passing the fees associated with screening along to tenants, in my opinion, you’re doing it wrong.

Screen Often

It may sound a bit mean, but your screening criteria should be strict. In one of our early debacles, we only refused to accept prospects who had an eviction in the last three years. This was a very bad idea to say the least.

For example, we had one lady who slipped through because she hadn’t been evicted in the last three years. Unfortunately, she had been evicted 10 times before that!

How it’s even possible to have been evicted that many times is beyond me, but she somehow achieved this impressive feat. Needless to say, she stopped paying her rent a few months into her lease, and we were forced to file for eviction number 11.

Your criteria might change from property to property or market to market. And there are some noteworthy exceptions you have to think about, too—for example, Section 8 applicants, prospects with cosigners, renters with pets (including which types of pets are okay and whether you will charge pet rent). The list goes on. Things can get a bit tricky with roommates, as well, particularly if only one has bad credit.

Related: The Compleat Tenant Screening Process: Pre-Screening

business woman wearing white shirt, talking smartphone and holding documents in hands. Open space loft office.

In general, here is our screening criteria:

  • No evictions in the last 10 years
  • No more than one eviction
  • No felonies (other than one DUI) in the last 10 years
  • No violent felonies
  • Three times the rent in income
  • No more than one late pay per year in their rental history
  • No bankruptcies
  • A credit score at least above 500, and unless everything else is good, above 600 

It’s a bit more complicated than that because all of these issues intersect and have nuance. And remember, this criteria must be identical for each applicant. It can change from one property to the next, but that must be in writing and determined before the fact.

Never treat two applicants differently, or you will very shortly be hearing from Fair Housing.

It’s also critical to screen every single person over the age of 18 who will be living at the property. Another early unfortunate experience we had involved screening a woman who applied and seemed decent. But then her boyfriend came in to sign the lease, as well. It slipped through the cracks that he hadn’t been screened; we foolishly signed the lease with them both.

(Note: It’s not an uncommon occurrence for people who aren’t on the lease to move in after the fact. You should always issue a lease violation if you figure out this is happening.)

The couple turned out to be some of the most obnoxious tenants we ever had. Month after month, we receive innumerable complaints about mostly trivial issues. Then one day, the boyfriend got arrested. Soon after, they fell behind on their rent, and we found ourselves going down the eviction path once again.

Screen, folks! Screen like your life depends on it!

Outsource Screening

I also recommend outsourcing your screening if at all possible. We use Red Star Backgrounds, which does the income, job, and rental history verification for us.

Most companies won’t. If you can find one that will, I recommend using them. If you choose to do it yourself, there is a temptation to want to get the property leased even if you have to stretch your rules in order for someone to qualify. Confirmation bias can make fools of us all.

In that same vein, this duty would be the absolute last thing I would assign to an employee. You need to make sure screening is thorough, correct, and not rushed.

I would furthermore ensure that your property management company gets your approval on new leases. In the case of the woman with 10 evictions, I never saw the background check. I had delegated that task to an employee. This person saw that the applicant technically met our requirements, and then just approved her. Many employees will just want to get the property leased so they can stop thinking about it and move on.

Delegation is a good thing usually—but certainly not always! Had I seen the background report, I would have immediately realized we needed to change that criterion. But I didn’t, and we lost a good deal of money on a disastrous tenant because of it.

Related: The Compleat Tenant Screening Process: Credit Check & Background Check


Today, because of our vigorous screening, we very rarely have an eviction. This is true even though most of our properties are in working class or lower middle class neighborhoods.

We’ve saved a lot of money on eviction costs and lost rent (not to mention the damage to the property itself that often comes along with an eviction). That being said, it’s easy to say that screening is extremely important, but it’s not as easy to enact.

Make screening an absolute priority because poor screening is almost always the biggest mistake new landlords make. Heck, it’s often the biggest mistake of veteran landlords, as well.

Do you have any nightmare tenant stories? Had these tenants been screened well? 

Share your story below!

Andrew Syrios has been investing in real estate for over a decade and is a partner with Stewardship Investments, LLC along with his brother Phillip and father Bill. Stewardship Investments focuses on the BRRRR strategy—buying, rehabbing and renting out houses and apartments throughout the Kansas City area. Today, they have over 300 properties and just under 500 units. Stewardship Properties on the whole has just under 1,000 units in six states. Andrew received a Bachelor's degree in Business Administration from the University of Oregon with honors and his Masters in Entrepreneurial Real Estate from the University of Missouri in Kansas City. He has also obtained his CCIM designation (Certified Commercial Investment Member). Andrew has been a writer for BiggerPockets on real estate and business management since 2015. He has also contributed to Think Realty Magazine, REI Club, Elite Daily, Thought Catalog, The Data Driven Investor and Alley Watch.

    Christopher Smith Investor from brentwood, california
    Replied 8 months ago
    This is something a well selected PM can do for you in their sleep, just one more dirty job you don’t need to do yourself and it serves as an excellent liability mitigation tool as well.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Perhaps my next article will be on my experience with property management companies, which has generally been terrible.
    Christopher Smith Investor from brentwood, california
    Replied 8 months ago
    Need to up your due diligence game then.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Or perhaps start our own property management company, learn a few costly lessons up front and then save money while maintaining better control over our properties. There’s more than one way to make it work in real estate.
    Dave Rav from Summerville, SC
    Replied 8 months ago
    Very good post. I recently up’d my screening game. Like you, when I first started out I was just glad to get my vacancies rented quickly. Thankfully, I never had anything too crazy happen, save for one couple who had some domestic disputes. They did break one of my windows, but that was all. Worse things could have happened. Anyways, you mention screening over the phone (pre-screening). Super helpful and a time-saver. You can learn alot just in conversation, and in HOW folks respond. Hesitation, reactive questioning, and other responses divulge much.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Pretty much every investor I know upped their “screening game” at one time or another no matter how important they knew it was going in.
    Julian Mares
    Replied 8 months ago
    Very good article Andrew. As I get closer and closer to making a deal to buy and hold, this info will prove to be priceless! Thanks again.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Thank you Julian and good luck getting that first one!
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Thank you Julian and good luck getting that first one!
    Mary D. Rental Property Investor from Salem, NH
    Replied 8 months ago
    Great post! I need to be reminded, as I dont have as many properties & dont have to go through this as much, that I need to screen like my life depended on it! I too have way to many times did not screen thoroughly and always came back to bite me some way or another. And had that same fear that I NEEDED to get the property rented ASAP. When I should have took a couple extra days to really screen good. I think my worst was I let a CEO of a local company rent without proper screening because I knew the owner… They let their dog urinate on the hardwood floors as well as the bedding and couches. So you never know :/ He did end up paying 10K to repair and redo all the hardwood floors. I made sure of it! I did mention him that I dont think the company would appreciate knowing how my property was treated.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Thanks Mary and I think it’s pretty much the same for every investor at the beginning. It’s almost just a phase you have to get through or something like that.
    Della R. Williams Rental Property Investor
    Replied 8 months ago
    This was a great article. It reenforced my decisions to wait for the right tenant. It took a long time to find my first tenant, but she has turned out to be a gem. I only rent to section-8 individuals (personal commitment) so I have to be extra careful. With the placement of each tenant, my process gets tighter and tighter. Thanks for the information.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    That’s definitely the right way to do it Della. And there are plenty of good Section 8 tenants, just don’t reduce your criteria (other than income of course) just because the government is coming some or all of the rent.
    Mary D. Rental Property Investor from Salem, NH
    Replied 8 months ago
    Would love to see an article about the management companies. As my next venture is 1-2 multi famlies a year for the next 5 years. Still do a fix & flip here and there, which is my all time favorite!
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    Hey Mary, here are some articles I’ve written on property management you might find helpful: You might also find my brother’s presentation on property management helpful:
    Elaine Christian from 1950 Port St Lucie Port St Lucie, FL
    Replied 8 months ago
    Very good article. As a licensed real estate agent and property manager for the last 30 years, I would like to comment that just as in any other occupation, there are excellent, dedicated, conscientious, committed property managers and unfortunately some not so. Please don’t avoid considering a property manager based on the horror stories we have probably all heard. Interview a property manager just as carefully as you would a prospective employee for a job opening or tenant for your rental property. Self-managing your properties may not be your strongest skill as a real estate investor or the best use of your time and energy. Landlording is not for everyone and that’s where hiring a good property manager can save you time, money and problems.
    Andrew Syrios Residential Real Estate Investor from Kansas City, Missouri
    Replied 8 months ago
    I would agree. There are definitely good managers out there. You just got to vet them carefully (and of course know that it will cost you money you could save by managing yourself).
    Memo Hernandez from Las Vegas, Nevada
    Replied 7 months ago
    Just bought my first investment property, now reading about tax deductions, and how to Landlord. This weekend I’ma open up a checking and savings account just for the property. This is great advice . Thanks