Mortgages & Creative Financing

8 Tips for a Successful Lease Option Sandwich

Expertise: Landlording & Rental Properties, Personal Development, Real Estate News & Commentary, Business Management, Flipping Houses, Mortgages & Creative Financing, Real Estate Deal Analysis & Advice, Real Estate Wholesaling, Personal Finance, Real Estate Marketing, AskBP, Real Estate Investing Basics
580 Articles Written

Here are seven tips for making sure that your lease option sandwich goes off without any major issues and that you are able to achieve the most security, income, and fairness for everyone possible.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

8 Tips for a Successful Lease Option Sandwich

1. The longer your contract is with the homeowner, the better.

Three years is better than one, five is better than three, and ten is better than five. The more time you have, the more options you have. Also, ensure that your contract with your tenant/buyer is shorter than your contract with the owner/seller. You don’t want to o er your tenant/buyer a five-year lease but sign just a three-year lease with the owner.

2. Always let the owner know what you are doing.

This is not a strategy you should ever think of using without having everyone on the same page. Don't pretend you'll be living in the home just to get the contract, only to turn around and sublet it to the tenant. Be up front and honest, and make everyone comfortable with the arrangement. Your job as a real estate investor is to solve problems, so do that!


Related: As a Landlord, Should You Use Month-to-Month or Term Leases?

3. Screen well!

Screening your tenant is one of the most important steps you can take to ensure a positive landlording experience, especially with a lease option sandwich. Although tenant-screening practices are beyond the scope of this book, the most important things you can do are as follows:

  • Always run a background check on your tenant. Look for evictions, criminal activities, etc.
  • Make sure the tenant/buyer has good enough credit. Their credit score doesn't need to be 800 for them to qualify, but it needs to be reasonable/improvable for them to be able to get a mortgage to cash you out eventually.
  • Look for stability. A tenant who moves every six months without reason is probably not a great candidate.
  • Don’t discriminate. Doing so could land you in jail, so know your local and federal discrimination laws and adhere to them. For more information on how to do screen tenants, be sure to read the in-depth article “Tenant Screening: The Ultimate Guide” from BiggerPockets.

4. Connect and qualify your tenant/buyer with a mortgage professional, also known as an RMLO—short for residential mortgage lenders and originator.

This individual can sit down with your potential tenant and explain what they need to do to qualify for a loan, to make sure they can reasonably hope to actually qualify. A good mortgage professional can work with your tenant/buyer to create a credit road map to help guide them from where they are now to being able to qualify for a mortgage. Setting up a meeting between the tenant/buyer and your favorite mortgage professional is helpful for both the tenant/buyer and you, and it can also help prove that you are not trying to take advantage of a tenant if you are ever accused of such.

5. Arrange to pay the owner’s mortgage for him.

After all, you don’t want to send the owner a payment each month and suddenly find out the bank is foreclosing on the property because the owner decided to pocket the money rather than passing it on to the bank.

6. Legally record your option contract with the owner at your county administrative department.

By legally recording the option contract, you will put a "cloud" on the title, and the owner will not be able to sell the property until it's cleared. If you do not record the contract, the owner might decide to sell to another investor or a retail buyer, and your only recourse would be a very expensive and stressful lawsuit. Recording can usually be done for less than $100 and normally requires only that the agreement be signed and notarized.


7. Don’t apply any portion of the rent toward the tenant/buyer’s future down payment.

This was a popular method of doing lease options in the past, but since the SAFE Act and Dodd-Frank legislation were passed, there has been legal concern on the part of many investors that portions of rent applied toward the tenant’s future down payment constitutes a “security,” which means many additional rules and regulations must be followed (ones you don’t want to deal with). Additionally, most banks will not allow this credit anyway, so it’s just best to make the rent the rent.

Related: The Lease Option: How I Creatively Structured a Deal With Very Little Down

8. Don’t be a jerk.

Do you remember the scene from Spider-Man where Uncle Ben states, “With great power comes great responsibility”? By this point, you can probably see that there is a lot of potential power in the lease option sandwich, but this same advice that guides Spider-Man should guide you as well, because with lease options, one could very easily be a jerk and take advantage of tenants.

For me, this is one of the biggest concerns for someone looking to engage in a lease option agreement. Because the vast majority of lease option tenants never end up actually purchasing the home, the lessee may be primed for failure from the beginning. Many lease option investors know this and proactively take steps to make it nearly impossible for the lessee to ever close on the deal. They charge huge up-front fees for a totally unqualified tenant to move in, give them a short time frame in which to buy, kick them out, and then repeat the process. The tenant, on the other hand, ends up in a far worse financial position than they were in originally. I believe this kind of unethical behavior is what gives the real estate investing industry a bad name. Don’t add to the problem.

Treat your lease option agreements as a chance to create a win-win-win scenario and help others get what they want as well. Use your power for good, not evil. This means only entering a lease option with tenants who could very reasonably obtain a loan within several years, without charging an exorbitant option fee. I want to be fair and have all parties happy with how things turned out at the end of the transaction, whether the tenant officially buys the property or not.

Finally, the government knows this is a problem and frowns on landlords who take advantage of people. The SAFE Act and Dodd-Frank legislations were enacted, in part, to help deal with these problems. Not only can you give landlords a bad name, but you could wind up in prison. Don’t be a jerk.

[This article is an excerpt from Brandon Turner’s The Book on Investing in Real Estate With No (and Low) Money Down.]

Have you ever used a lease option sandwich?

Let me know your experiences with a comment!

Brandon Turner is an active real estate investor, entrepreneur, writer, and co-host of the BiggerPockets Podcast. He is a nationally recognized leader in the real estate education space and has tau...
Read more
    Tameka Herring Rental Property Investor from Eufaula, AL
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Hi Brandon, Thank you for the information regarding lease options. I don’t have much knowledge about this area of investing. Can you point me to some books that cover this area, or will you be doing a webinar in the future about it? Thanks!
    Tameka Herring Rental Property Investor from Eufaula, AL
    Replied over 3 years ago
    I see now that this was an excerpt from your book.
    Matthew Law from Clermont, FL
    Replied over 3 years ago
    Great advice! I’d never thought of the “jerk” method. What a terrible way to do things. If my business doesn’t help people, what’s the point? The Dodd-Frank and SAFE act applications are huge. This makes a lot of information put out by the gurus outdated. Thanks again for the post. I’ll make it a point to read the rest of your book.
    Casey Gray Licensed Attorney and Real Estate Broker from Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
    Replied about 3 years ago
    I just handled one of these transactions for a client and found that the legal risks are very high. Make sure you seek legal counsel when doing these types of transactions.
    Joe Yobaccio Specialist from Pasadea, CA
    Replied over 1 year ago
    @Casey Gray, what are the legal risk you came across? Was your cient the investor?
    James Dickens from New Iberia, LA
    Replied almost 3 years ago
    Brandon, I’m curious about point #7 in reference to podcast 185 with Bill Powers where he does exactly what you say not to do. In that podcast, he says that they take the first and last months rent, a security deposit and $150 from each month’s rent and allow the person leasing the house to use that money to help close at the end of the lease. it really sounds like a great way to help someone out who might not be able to get into a house otherwise. Is Dodd-Frank really that restrictive and can the deal be structured not to be what someone would consider a security?
    James Dickens from New Iberia, LA
    Replied almost 3 years ago
    I wish you could edit posts 🙂 I should add that Bill does buy his property’s and does not lease them and that may be the difference.
    Ayodeji Kuponiyi Investor from King of Prussia, Pennsylvania
    Replied over 2 years ago
    Very timely and needed. Thanks for sharing this Brandon!
    Leah B Foxworth
    Replied about 1 year ago
    I am looking to invest my 2019 tax return into my first investment rental property. But I'm needing to do a Lease to Purchase Option due to poor credit. I could sure use some contacts with others who typically sell properties this way.
    Don Gurganus from Gulfport, MS
    Replied 9 months ago
    Leah, Search for properties with "rent to own" in the descriptions. We are getting into this in the Gulf Coast region of Mississippi. Good luck, Don
    Curt Smith Rental Property Investor from Clarkston, GA
    Replied 4 months ago
    Any tips for marketing for lease option, subject to sellers? Buyers easier: post rent to own ads in zillow on the address you have, craigsist and facebook market place. Lots of tenants want to own. Its finding wiling sellers? I'm experienced, yes FSBO, expireds, or >60 days on market are the main areas, but my area the FSBOs are 95% wholesalers / flippers. The stuck low equity soon to be seller needs to be found. IE since covid a new area if the leads can be bought are a list of those who took forbearance and are now at the end of their period. IE most likely in July where all missed payments need to be paid back in one lump (LOL - not). Those folks will be prospects but thats out in July and still need to buy that list.