The Hard Question Newbie Wholesalers Should Be Asking Before Jumping In

by |

“If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again.”

“Don’t give up too easily; persistence pays off in the end.”

We’ve all heard these sayings. Many believe these mantras, but most can’t actually live them—especially new wholesalers.

We live in a society of quitters, and I’m here to challenge you to live a life of self-actualization. Do you actually believe you can be successful at wholesaling?

Many newbies quit before they start and my question to you is: Can you start and finish?

There are many reasons—or shall I say excuses—for quitting. Some are not willing to pay the price for the accomplishments they want to see. They don’t want to study their craft, they don’t care to spend time making mistakes, and they’re fearful of what others will say. They evaluate their possible success based on others failures.

So what does this have to do with real estate? I’ve done over 110 free hours of consultation to newbie wholesalers, and our conversations touch on many different aspects of wholesaling. I’ve come to realize that many people really don’t know what they’re doing, and that’s OK, but you have to be willing to go through the process.


So let’s have a conversation, and I want the conversation to start like this:

The 20 Best Books for Aspiring Real Estate Investors!

Here at BiggerPockets, we believe that self-education is one of the most critical parts of long-term success, in business and in life, of course. This list, compiled by the real estate experts at BiggerPockets, contains 20 of the best books to help you jumpstart your real estate career.

Click Here For Your Free eBook!

You Really Don’t Know What You’re Doing, Do You?

During these free consultations, I ask a few questions, and normally, if the person on the other end cannot answer these questions, I say, “You really don’t know what you’re doing, do you?” I ask this question to see what response I receive. Are they being real with themselves, or are they trying to fake their way through?

Related: What Comes First for Wholesalers: The Buyers List or the Deal?

The intention of this question is not to belittle anyone, but to help these new investors think through whether they have a firm foundation so they don’t ruin their career before they get started.

Let’s Be Honest

Ask yourself the following questions, and remember, let’s be honest:

  • Can you accurately comp a property?
  • Do you actually know the price per square foot for a rehab?
  • How many active units are on the market? Are you familiar with local market trends?
  • Do you know where buyers are buying and why?
  • Why did you choose the market you did versus another?

Remember: If you can’t answer these questions or know where to get the answers, you need to do some more homework. I point this out because starting as a wholesaler is not difficult, but it’s the “…and finish” of “start and finish” that kills newbies.

Related: 5 Costly Pitfalls That Catch Wholesaling Newbies Off Guard

So I ask this questions again: You really don’t know what you’re doing, do you?

If you’re willing to be honest with yourself and you need some help answering theses questions, leave a comment below and let’s talk.

I’d rather you find a way to get the answers than set yourself up for failure.

About Author

Marcus Maloney

Marcus Maloney is a value investor and portfolio holder of residential and commercial units. He has completed over $3.3 million in wholesale transactions. Currently, Marcus is a licensed agent who wholesales virtually in multiple states while building his investment portfolio. He has also converted some of his deals into cash-flowing rentals. Marcus holds seven rentals, two of which are commercial units. He’s even purchased a school, which was converted into a daycare center. His overall goal is to turn what is a marginal profit into a significant equity position. He leverages the equity by using the BRRRR (buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat) strategy to increase his portfolio without any money out-of-pocket. Marcus has been featured in numerous podcast such as the Louisville Gal Podcast, The Best Deal Ever Podcast, The Flipping Junkie, and many others. He contributes content regularly to his YouTube channel and blog.


  1. David Saldana

    I feel as if I have a vague idea as to what I’m to do. I know the procedure of comping a property but I haven’t actually done so, and once I do I’ll have a real estate agent double check it for me until I feel comfortable enough with comping on my own. I don’t know the price per sqft but I know investors that I can ask. As for market trends, I know the city I plan to invest in is becoming more and more popular and that the city keeps getting cleaner and growing and has been for the last 10-15 years and they have plans to continue expansion, upping property values. I can’t say I know where and why people are buying though. I also chose this market because it’s my backyard. Maybe I could use a bit more help.

  2. Christopher L Hall

    @Marcus Maloney
    Once again a great article! I have read just about everything you have posted on this subject. I cannot answer all 3 of them questions. The only one I can answer is why this market? the answer is simple and probley the same one you always hear, It’s where I live! I can tell just from what I have read of your’s that you know what you’re talkng about. I would love to connect with you and chat. Thank you for the wonderful knowlage yoy put out there for new Wholesalers. Look forward to conecting with you.


  3. Brett Pointer

    I see tremendous opportunity for my market, yet I cannot answer these basic questions. I am anxious to speak to a seller, but have only been able to find properties owned by LLC’s or people who refuse to speak with me. I really believe there is potential, but I need a game plan.
    For now I will keep reading.
    Hope to hear from you soon.


  4. Rob C. Lacey

    Prior to reading this blog I thought I had a fair sense of what I was doing, now i see clearly I have very , very little idea what I am actually doing. Although i am studying daily i am still swimming in a pool of foreign information.

    PLEASE HELP. Any assistance is greatly appreciated.

  5. Paul Cody

    This is a great article that really makes me think. I have done a ton of research. I am really unsure if the market I live in will be a successful market for a beginner. I don’t really know where to get the information on my market. I also am struggling to find information on how to comp and estimate rehab costs.

    Any help would be incredible. Thanks!

  6. Harold Avery

    I could not answer all the questions you asked but I think I have a idea of knowing how to comp. I have two rentals homes,one in which I did a lot of the work. But even with that opportunity, I still feel stuck and short of knowledge when it comes to whole selling the right way. NEEDLESS TO SAY I NEED HELP to move on in real estate whole selling.

  7. Dave Everett

    Right up front I can only answer the comp question and the cost to rehab question. We are trying to work an expensive market. We’re 30 miles down valley from Aspen CO. Most of our inventory is at or above $500k and will ARV in the high 6’s or low 7’s. Is this a reasonable area to find buyers for wholesale deals?

  8. mauricio davila


    I am new to Bigger Pockets and especially new to the Real Estate Industry. I’ve been reading, listening, and consuming information lately.

    I admit there are a lot I still need to learn. I don’t have the answers to all the questions you asked. I am planning on attending the next local REI Meetups in my area in the next couple of weeks to network and learn.

  9. James Dyas

    Hey Marcus
    Thanks for being transparent , I’m glad you started with asking us to be honest with ourselves.
    Now that you have put us under the microscope , how can we get further instructions and build the right way!
    Looking forward to hearing from you

  10. Julie Mitchell

    Hello I did my first wholesale deal on a rental property really didn’t have a clue of what I was doing but the deal closed I made $2000. I am having trouble finding properties would like a little kick in the A- – to get me started any input would be appreciated!!

  11. Kevin Duncan

    Hi Marcus… Great article here that identifies the TRUTH behind this subject for newbies such as myself. I too have been reading a lot, listening to podcasts, audiobooks and need guidance on wholesaling. Not knowing what to do or what I’m doing is an understatement. I’ve also offered my photography skills in my area in exchange for knowledge but so far it’s not getting traction.

    Finally; I will NOT give up! But I truly need help in understanding what I need to do. Currently I have a buyer that reached out to me and I’m putting in the work of marketing and in search for a seller.

    PLEASE HELP… Thanks in advance for your awesomeness

  12. Donovan Jones

    Hi Marcus,

    I’m a newbie, pushing daily to get the ball rolling. I definitely have some gaps in kniwledge and experience, but I’m constantly looking for ways to improve. I’d really appreciate if you wouldn’t mind giving me some guidance on how to ge my first deal

  13. Scott Rose

    I believe I know the mechanics, but figuring out how to execute each step has been my barriers, many, I will admit, are probably self imposed. Part of the issue is that I don’t feel my local market (Hawaii) is right for Wholesaling. Not only are the prices high, but there are particular “distressed property” laws that can prevent the process from being executed, which would waste peoples time and give some false hope. I’ve also spoken with a local investor friend of mine who admits that there is a market here, but the wholesalers he has encountered actually make the process harder and have actually given the art of Wholesaling in a Hawai’i a bad name. With all this, I’ve been trying to look into trying this remotely, but building a team I can trust has become an additional barrier. I know it can be done.

  14. Vanessa harpel

    I have no idea what I am doing, also no clue about real estate! Very interested as you can see. Been listening to podcasts and watching youtube videos but have no clue how to get my feet in. Also, do you need money to start? If you can message me back and answer my questions that’ll be great!

  15. Christopher Douglas

    Hey Marcus,

    Thank you for the wholesaling information. I am having some difficulties getting started, but can answer some of the questions posed for the market where I have an interest. Any specific tips or details you can provide will be greatly appreciated.

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here