Buying & Selling Houses

How to Sell an ‘Unsellable’ Home

3 Articles Written
Unsellable house

You just have to find the right buyer. This is not a slight-of-hand answer. This is a core truth.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Shift your mindset. In sales and marketing, we have a motto: “You have to meet your audience where they are.”

This is an extremely powerful fact to imprint on your selling consciousness. It reminds you that your audience is not always someone like you.

You Are Not Your Customer

It is very common to craft a sales plan, look at it, and think, “Yeah, I’d buy that!”

But to reach your strongest selling position, you need to understand your product from your target buyer’s point of view. This may differ a little or a lot from your own point of view. When you are selling, you need to get out of your own head. You need to think like your potential buyer, who might be—and very likely is—nothing like you.

So, if you think the house is “unsellable,” that tells you that you are looking at it from your personal point of view—the angle of why you would not choose to buy it. And if you only focus on pitching the sale to an audience of buyers who think, act, shop, and buy like you, then you are absolutely right, it WOULD be “unsellable” to someone like you.

Don’t pitch the sale to you. Find the buyers who would want that house. Position the product you are selling, in this case a house, to the buyers who would value what that product offers.

hoarder property filled with junk

Shift Your Mindset

To do this, you have to step away from the limitations you placed on that house. Change your mindset so you begin seeing it as a highly sellable house. Think outside the box and brainstorm who might want the property with the “flaws” you perceive it has—or better yet who would not even consider those things “flaws” and might even perceive them as strengths.

Now, I am not speaking about issues of pricing here. You can always change a price. So, if you are judging a house to be “unsellable” solely based on the issue of pricing, that fix simply requires altering your mindset about what kind of profit or loss you are willing to accept.

I am addressing broader issues about a property that can cause it to seem undesirable or to be seen as a potential liability (for reasons of location, condition, rehab-gone-wrong, etc.).

Let’s talk about how perception of a property affects its value, negotiations, equity, and success. At the same time, I’ll give you a little twist on the idea of “unsellable” and how that works differently depending on how you pivot the concept.

The Story of the Forgotten Carriage House

An investor I know, Tim, found a property that had been on the market for about 12 years. (Yes, you did read “12 years.”) If you saw the property, you would understand why it was on the market for that length of time.

It had originally been a carriage house, a term coined to describe buildings where literal carriages were stored in prior centuries (essentially a garage for horse-drawn carriages). Often there was a living area above it that was occupied by the coachman. The horses themselves were usually housed in a separate barn building.

Nowadays, the term is used to describe buildings on a property that were used as additional quarters for various purposes.

This particular carriage house had once belonged to a much larger estate. Over the years, parcels of the estate had been acquired by different developers and multiple neighborhoods had gone up on that land. But this carriage house had been left out of the mix.

So, it sat for decades, a deteriorating eyesore outside all these lovely neighborhoods of various ages.

Related: How to Think Like a Buyer When Getting Your Property Ready to Sell

Eventually whoever last owned it passed away, and no one inherited the property. It reverted to being city-owned, where it sat on the books for a very long time. At a certain point, the city decided they should get on with selling the property. They listed it for sale on a city-maintained website. That is where it sat for 12 years.

During this time, the property had fallen into a state of complete disrepair. Tim drove by the house frequently over the years, each time thinking of the unique ways this building could be refurbished.

But his curiosity about the house and his search for the owner led him to the city’s website. He submitted a bid.

Now, here is the original stance on the mindset of “unsellable.”

As the listing had been sitting on the city-maintained website for 12 years, the city had come to view the property as “unsellable.” In truth, however, they were not thinking creatively about how to market it to attract an appropriate buyer. So, with each passing year, it actually became more and more difficult to sell. A vicious cycle, their perception that it was “unsellable” caused them to shut down their creativity and with it any unique possibilities.

How a Buyer Can Use “Unsellable” to Their Advantage

Because the city had come to perceive the carriage house as “unsellable,” Tim was able to use their own negative perception of the property in his negotiations. Hence, Tim negotiated the purchase of the property for less than 5 percent of the asking price.

Tim did not view the property as “unsellable.” He viewed it as having “incredible potential.”

Tim was correct. He bought it for $1,800.

At that price—and with a solid plan for the building—it was easy to get financing for a complete rehab. He brought in a partner. They made changes to the existing house, turning it into a thriving multi-unit short-term rental property in the heart of the city.

The equity value is currently 244 times what Tim paid for the property. The carriage house is now valued at $440,000.

In addition, as a short-term rental, the house is currently turning more than a $100K a year in profit.

All this from an “unsellable” property.


Learning from the City’s Errors

What the example of the city’s experience teaches us is that, once you place a label on something, you will respond and act upon it with the label you have assigned to it. Don’t make the same mistakes the city made.

Once they assigned the label of “unsellable” to the carriage house, the city began to believe and act on that perception, causing them to commit the following errors in judgment:

  • They relied on limiting assumptions about how to value the property
  • This blinded them to the potential value of the property
  • Thereby, this caused them to judge the property to be “worthless”
  • This eliminated any attempt they might have made to market the property effectively
  • Which, in turn, allowed an investor to pick it up for a song

The “unsellable” label they assigned the property limited their vision and therefore their potential for profits.

Kicking “Unsellable” to the Curb

What the example of Tim’s experience teaches us is to look at the property with fresh eyes. Make a very detailed list of all the pros and cons of the house and the surrounding yard.

Be objective. Be specific. Be alert. The more detailed you are, the greater your chance of finding the hidden marketing gems you might otherwise miss.

Also, be willing to step outside yourself and your own perceptions. Call in a friend, mentor, or colleague who you know can always find the good in everything. (By the way, if you don’t have anyone like that in your life, start cultivating those relationships.) Positive thinkers and outside-the-box thinkers will spark creativity.

Walk the property with them. Get out of your own way. Listen to what they say.

If they say they like some aspect of the property, whether the yard or the house, don’t bring up objections! Ask them why they like that item or feature. Delve into what benefit or value that detail adds to the property for them.

Next, let go of the idea of “problems.” Every problem is an opportunity.

So, look carefully at the “cons” or the negatives on your list. This is when your true creative power switch gets turned on. Open your mind and come up with a positive slant for EVERY “con” on your list. I mean it.

And if any one of those “cons” really stumps you, pull in that positive-thinking friend again—maybe even make them a partner.

No matter the reason(s) for perceiving a house as “unsellable”—whether you think your property is in an undesirable location, someone died in the house, there are condition issues (deferred maintenance, pet smells, water damage, mold, lead), there’s a lack of amenities, it’s inconvenient architecture, has outdated appliances or decor, or any other “unsellable” feature—let go of viewing it as a limitation. Shift your viewpoint.

Related: How to Save Your House Flips When They Don’t Sell

It’s Your Choice

Stop assuming a challenge is a barrier when it is only a hurdle. Jump over it, go around it, go under it, maybe just smash through it. But look for the opportunity.

As we say in marketing, find the hook. Find the take. Find the slant.

In other words, find the opportunity.

Keep your eyes open and your creativity flowing. This is the beauty of real estate investing: One person’s shanty is another person’s castle. It is all in the perception.

Change your attitude and you change your options!

Do you agree or disagree with my points about perception? Can you think of an instance in the past in which you could’ve benefited from adjusting your viewpoint? 

Weigh in with a comment below.

B.L. Sheldon is a foremost authority and world leader in communicating the ways climate change and global weather events impact our real estate and business investing profitability. She is an active investor, consultant, speaker, and mentor in the areas of innovative negotiation, climate change risk identification and analysis, property management, landlord/tenant relationships, real estate investment analysis, creative real estate financing, and personal and professional development. She's also the author of FEARLESS: Real Estate Investing in the Era of Climate Change. You can find her at

    Enrique Gonzalez Investor from El Pueblito, Querétaro
    Replied 22 days ago
    Thank you so much for this insights. They are "Law of Attraction" views without the woo-hoo part that repels entrepreneurs making them miss a lot of opportunities. You are right on and very useful education valid for all venues of life.
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 22 days ago
    Hi, Enrique, thanks for that perspective, I hadn't actually thought of that. I tend to focus on looking at situations by acknowledging the realities and then capitalizing on the possibilities. It is a positive attitude approach. Glad it connected for you!
    Adrian Ayub
    Replied 21 days ago
    Thank you sooo much. If there is one thing that I have that is an advantage I guess to my peers is an unfettered optimism in that there is a buyer for every product.
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 21 days ago
    Right on, Adrian! I agree. I find that focusing on possibilities expands our vision, our options, ultimately improving our opportunities for success!
    SHELIA Mickle from Crystal Springs, Mississippi
    Replied 21 days ago
    I have an ugly house and it does not seem easy to get financing..." it was easy to get financing for a complete rehab". What did they do/
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 20 days ago
    Hi Shelia, great question! Let me ask you, what are your future plans for the property?
    SHELIA Mickle from Crystal Springs, Mississippi
    Replied 21 days ago
    ? I called hard go...
    Robin Chartier
    Replied 20 days ago
    What a great post! I love the mindset you inspire.
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 20 days ago
    Thank you, Robin! I believe when we bring our creativity and a desire to make positive things happen we are essentially programming that "supercomputer" that is our brain to respond as we've programmed it. ;)
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 20 days ago
    Hi Shelia, great question! Let me ask you, what are your future plans for the property?
    Annette Aurelio
    Replied 20 days ago
    Change the way you look at things and the things you look at change!
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 16 days ago
    That's the formula, Annette! You are correct!
    Christopher Smith Investor from brentwood, california
    Replied 18 days ago
    I would be somewhat careful with this approach. As Warren Buffett has indicated many times, ugly ducklings don't normally grow into beautiful swans, but ugly ones. However, he has also noted some of his greatest profits were derived from patients only moments from full cardiac arrest. But you better be a pretty shrewd operator in these situations, have a comprehensive understanding of exactly what you are getting yourself into and the ability to navigate these waters with nerves of steel or you're gonna end up getting clocked.
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 16 days ago
    Hi Christopher, your reflections are accurate. And I enjoy Warren's wisdom. The Oracle of Omaha is a gem. The key here is to understand your capabilities. You must have a strategic plan, as the example in the article indicates. Because, you are correct, if one just jumps in without a plan they will find themselves in a world of hurt.
    Wenda Kennedy JD from Nikiski, Alaska
    Replied 14 days ago
    I've always dealt in ugly properties for my investments. Or, they ugly when I start with them. Now I own just about all mobile homes in my park. This article brought one of them to mind. When I was rehabbing one of them, I had to gas company come out and turn on the natural gas so we could have some heat. The rep for the gas company told me that my mobile home was so bad that I should tear it down. I just laughed. That was 16 years ago. We cleaned it up and finished our work. I've collected my rents just about every month since I did that project. Since then, we've added a nice deck to the front, and a shed roof over the mobile home and the addition. My tenants who rent there, love it. It's an affordable, clean rental. Seeing the value just takes a little bit of vision.
    BL Sheldon Investor from Colorado
    Replied 14 days ago
    That's the vision, Wanda! Congratulations on decisions well made and creativity elegantly displayed! :)