Should You Buy a Rental Property If You Have Existing Debt?
Real estate often plays a catalytic role in improving finances and helping families achieve financial freedom. But if you already have existing debt on the books, you need to do your due diligence prior to taking on any more.
Want more articles like this?
Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inboxSign up for free
Good Debt vs. Bad Debt
Before diving too deep into the discussion of whether or not it’s smart to invest in rental properties when you have existing debt, it’s important that we discuss the nuances of debt. In particular, we need to examine the difference between what financial advisors call “good debt” and “bad debt.”
Good debt is generally considered debt that you have against an appreciating asset—such as a house or business. Ideally, this debt creates cash flow for you. At the very least, the asset’s value appreciates over time and puts you in a stronger financial situation.
Bad debt is debt that you have against things like credit cards, car loans, and student loans. With bad debt, there is no appreciating asset. There also tend to be high interest rates, which makes it easy to fall behind on payments.
As the old saying goes, good debt will make you rich, while bad debt will make you poor. This is obviously an oversimplification, but you get the picture.
Investing in Real Estate With Debt
Very few Americans are totally debt-free. There are plenty of people who have gotten rid of their bad debt, but even those people typically have some good debt on the books. Thus the question arises: Can or should you invest in real estate while in debt?
The answer to this question isn’t as straightforward as you may like. While you certainly can, you’ll have to do some careful analysis to determine whether or not you should.
For starters, if you’re drowning in bad debt—i.e., credit cards, vehicles, and student loans—it’s not smart to think about adding more debt to the equation (even when it’s good debt). Your money is much better spent paying down these debts and digging yourself out of the hole you’re in.
But what about those who have very small amounts of bad debt or strictly good debt? This is where the discussion gets interesting.
Before getting too far along in your research, you'll need to make sure you even have the option of bringing on more debt. While lenders don't require you to have zero debt to qualify for a loan, they do want to see your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio to understand how much of your monthly income is going toward debt.
“Lenders care about your DTI ratio because they want to make sure you have enough available income to cover your existing debts plus the mortgage,” RISE explains. “In other words, they are trying to determine your ability to repay the loan.”
For a first home, the maximum DTI lenders are comfortable with is usually somewhere in the range of 36 to 50 percent. For a real estate investment or second mortgage, that number is probably a lot closer to 20 percent.
If the numbers line up and you think your finances will qualify you to buy a rental property, the next thing to think about is the practicality of making a deal.
The biggest pro to investing in real estate is that it provides you with additional cash flow. This money can then be used to pay down debt, which accelerates your ability to build wealth. Of course, there’s always the downside of having vacancies in your property or experiencing an economic collapse that kills property values and leaves you over-leveraged.
The biggest downside to investing in real estate when you’re already in debt is that your monthly payments only increase. This leaves you with less discretionary money and hurts your flexibility in the short-run. It also enhances your stress, since you’re only one problem away from a total disaster.
It’s a Personal Decision
At the end of the day, it’s impossible for someone to tell you whether or not you should invest in real estate while carrying existing debt. In some situations, the answer is clear. However, most instances require lots of research and due diligence.
Make sure you spend plenty of time analyzing the details of any deal before proceeding. Wealth building is a slow and steady game—don’t rush it.
Weigh in below!