DSCR loan pitfalls or fine print to be aware of?

Question

new member here: I have just recently learned of the DSCR loans. Until now I've cash funded any of our real estate purchases, which has made them a slow process (since I started with nothing). Are there any pitfalls to using the DSCR loans? Do they have the right to call a loan due at anytime? what are the typical length of terms a lender will hold the loan? what are the typical interest rates used (including fees) when calculating if you plan to purchase with DSCR loan (assume excellent credit , cash flow, and LTV ratios). thanks for your help- Brandon in Idaho

Eric Goldman · Answer

typically DSCR loans are 30 years fixed across the board. there are armed products if really wanted but dont really make sense most of the time. 6%+ rates will be dependent on credit, loan size, property type, LTV/ loan to value and how well the deal cash flows (DSCR). things to watch out for: does your lender allow a 2nd to go on? what is the PPP if any (this will go for paying off/refi or selling. there will be fees and points they will range. Does the lender actually close loans or put your through the mud to get there if you even end up there. different dscr lenders have different guidelines... one may approve you the other may not or at a lower loan amount. Finding the right team, lender, insurance agent, real estate agent and title company will help you better navigate buying using a loan.

Drew Sygit · Answer

Have seen DSCR loans that require annual info from the borrower, that have negative repercussions if not submitted in time.

Ray Williams · Answer

Brandon, the prepayment penalty and default-clause points above are the big ones, so I'll add something nobody has mentioned that fits your situation specifically.

Since you've been buying with cash, you may already be sitting on your fastest source of capital. Most DSCR programs offer cash-out refinances on rentals you own free and clear, commonly up to around 70 to 75% (sometimes 80%) of appraised value depending on credit, the DSCR ratio, and property type. Some will also do delayed financing, where you pull your cash back out shortly after a cash purchase instead of waiting out a long seasoning period. Ask each lender what their seasoning requirement is, because it varies a lot and decides whether they value the property off your purchase price or the new appraisal.

When you run DSCR for your own analysis, use the full PITIA: principal and interest, taxes, insurance, and any HOA. Lenders divide the market or lease rent by that number, and 1.0 to 1.25 is the usual range they want. Insurance is the line that most often comes in higher than people budgeted, so get a real landlord policy quote early.

Two smaller things to ask about. Minimum loan amounts matter, since a lot of programs won't go below $75k to $100k, which can rule out smaller rentals. Also ask whether they lend to your LLC, because most DSCR loans close in an entity with a personal guarantee.

I am a mortgage broker and see a lot of cash buyers find out they had more borrowing power sitting in their existing doors than they expected.

Stacy Raskin · Answer

The biggest differences with DSCR loans compared to conventional is that they are not underwritten by a borrower's personal income or DTI ratios but by the actual or projected property rents, they are not regulated the same as conventional and they have prepayment penalties. They are non owner occupy rental property loans.

They are not regulated like conventional loans and rates and fees can change at any point during the loan process for no reason at all so important to do your research so you lower the chances of working with someone who will change the rates and fees for no reason.

Terms or fees will vary quite a bit so good to talk to more than one mortgage professional. As of the date of this posting, the rates are in the 6s to 8s.

As far as calling the loan, important to read the paperwork but generally I have only seen issues when the borrower repeatedly didn't make payments.

There are 30 year fixed loan options. Happy to connect to discuss further.

Dan Duenas · Answer

Good questions, Brandon. A few pitfalls from the lending side that actually kill deals:

1. Prepayment penalties. This is the big one. Most DSCR loans carry one, and it's usually structured so the longer the penalty period, the better the rate. If you think you might sell or refi in the first few years, price that in before you sign, not after.

2. The DSCR ratio minimum itself. Plenty of lenders require the rent to cover the payment by 1.0 to 1.25x, and if the property falls short, the deal dies even when the cash flow works fine in real life. There are programs with no ratio requirement at all — worth asking about if a property you like keeps failing the ratio test.

3. Lenders who can't actually close. DSCR is business-purpose and lightly regulated, so anyone can hang a shingle. Ask how many DSCR loans they closed last month, not last year.

4. On the call provision: no, they can't call it just because. The loan docs spell out the default triggers — usually missed payments, transferring title, or converting it to your primary residence. Read that section before you sign.

On terms: 30-year fixed is standard. Rates move with credit, LTV, and how the deal cash flows — anyone quoting you a number without those three is guessing.

Ryan Spath · Answer

Welcome! DSCR loans are great, the best thing about them is the approval is based on the property not the individual. No the loans do not get called, these are business purpose loans so you PG them, so if everything goes wrong the bank can come after you. The one thing to look out for are the pre-payment penalties. I have found the longer the pre-payment penalty the lower the rates. If you want to send me a DM with your email I can connect you with a local DSCR lender that is all they do

Chris Seveney · Answer

Every answer to this is, it depends. They will have a loan agreement that outlines the terms and includes what those defaullt provisisons are. They cannot call the loan due typically unless you are in default. But it is more than just missing a payment.

Other things to consider are the prepayment penalties, that is something many are not familiar with.

Erik Estrada · Answer

Hey Brandon,

Every lender has their own set of guidelines and your answer will look very different.

Something to keep note of is that this industry is not as regulated as consumer purpose loans (FHA, Conv., QM loans) Basically anyone could set up shop and broker business purpose (DSCR, Hard Money, Commercial loans) without a license if the state does not require one. My best advice is to narrow your search to reputable lenders/brokerage firms, preferably one that holds a license. You do not want to be caught holding the bag at the last minute and not close on a deal, spend thousands of dollars on appraisals, or close on bad terms.

Generally DSCR rates are in the high 6s to 8% range depending on prepayment penalty terms,, points, ARM or 30 year term, credit, loan amount, and etc.. Fees will also depend on how the loan is priced. (No points = higher rate)

The lender does have verbiage in their loan documents that does state any clauses where a loan might be due. I generally see this if the borrower is using a DSCR loan to owner-occupy, changes vesting afterwards, and etc.. But its rare..

The prepayment penalties are what get most investors. Some lenders allow you to pay the principal balance up to 50% others do not allow it at all and require you to make only your regular payments until the penalty expires.

Adam Summerer · Answer

Biggest DSCR gotchas after a cash-only career: prepayment penalties (1/3/5 or step-down — get the schedule in the term sheet), DSCR floor math (lease vs 1007 market rent; ~1.0x vs expanded ~0.75–0.80x tiers that cut LTV), and reserves/experience overlays that show up late. Also watch interest-only vs amortizing payment used for qualification, and whether they force a rate-reset/ARM story you didn’t budget. Read the PPP and default clauses before you stop paying cash for everything.

Robin Simon · Answer

Hi - I actually put together a Top 10 List of this exact topic, here is what we came up with after seeing thousands of DSCR Loans over the last few years:

Common Obstacle #1 - Appraisal Value Comes in Low

Common Obstacle #2 – Appraisal Comes Back with Subject-To Requirements or Deferred Maintenance >$2,000

Common Obstacle #3: DSCR Ratio Dips Below Threshold When Final Numbers Replace Estimates

Common Obstacle #4: Interest Rates Move Higher (No Rate Lock) or Lock Expires

Common Obstacle #5 – Title Issues for DSCR Loans

Common Obstacle #6 – Signing Issues for DSCR Loans

Common Obstacle #7 – Large Deposit Sourcing for DSCR Loans

Common Obstacle #8 – Entity Documentation Issues for DSCR Loans

Common Obstacle #9 – Surprise at the Closing Table for a DSCR Loan

Common Obstacle #10: Post-Close Servicing Scares for DSCR Loans

DSCR loan pitfalls or fine print to be aware of?

DSCR loan pitfalls or fine print to be aware of?

Most Popular Reply

11 Replies