Concord, CA 路 Member since 2018 路 56 posts 路 37 votes
I just got a Bigger Pockets email with an article about all the reasons I should not invest out of state. I live in the SF Bay Area and can not afford to buy in state and that article scares the s*^+ out of me.
If I don鈥檛 invest out of state how do I ever become a REI?
Could use some help and advice. I鈥檓 feeling a bit discouraged here. I simply cannot afford California yet.
Any help is appreciated. I鈥檓 going to go have a glass of wine to help calm my nerves. Cheap wine of course because I鈥檓 saving for a down payment on a MFP!! 馃槣
By cheap I don鈥檛 mean cheap because I love wine too much to drink the bad stuff!
@Colleen Prescott I'm also in the Bay Area and I can definitely understand wanting to invest out of state, that's a popular option among investors near us. I would recommend checking out David Greene's book "Long Distance Real Estate Investing". It gives you the tools to feel comfortable investing out of state. And if you need a realtor recommendation out of state, feel free to message me! I've got a large network of realtors I could refer you to. Good luck and happy investing!
BiggerPockets hosts a variety of articles from a variety of perspectives. They don't all agree with each other, and that's ok. One article that says "don't invest out of state" does not mean that an entire company advises you not to buy out of state, especially when that same company has produced a book on long distance investing that was written by Bay Area investor and podcast host @David Greene.
James you beat me to it! I was going to say this exact same thing, but add that she should try Two Buck Chuck to save money. The story behind that winery is fascinating - and it turns out they're making pretty good wine... (https://thehustle.co/how-two-buck-chuck-changed-the-wine-industry)
@Uneeq Khan Estimating rehab costs before purchase. First you need someone to look at the property and provide an assessment. Maybe it's a contractor, a broker, a project manager, you just don't want it to be the seller. You want to have a source of independent comps, someone that can help you get an idea of ARV, rents, or an approximation of retail selling price. You need to understand what holding costs will be, any taxes, insurance, sales commissions. You would need someone with construction experience to get there and assess the property within 2-5 days and provide you with a report on likely costs. If you don't have much of the info that I've mentioned here, then you really are buying blind.
A good methodology is - find tight comps, understand rents. Establish a value that you want to reach. Understand the current state of the property and what needs to go into the rehab to reach the target goal. Add in holding costs. Work backwards from your target value, add all of these things in, then include ROI you need. This gives you the purchase price number that will allow your investment to work.
Out of state is easy, but time consuming to digest the info you need to perform due diligence. But in all honesty it's not that much different than if you were preparing to move to somewhere new yourself. Put yourself as a renter, understand what's in demand and why, then start to figure out what rents are. You'll quickly find some areas work, some don't, and then some "could" with the right deal.
Here's the thing though, your investment involves people. There's a human elelment that's not captured in a spreadsheet or on a website.... If the best and only thing a deal has going for it is a spreadsheet then you're likely to run into trouble when things don't go as planned.
@Colleen Prescott one thing is for certain @engelorumora is an American success story hands down. he came to America 10 years or so ago with just a little jingle in his pocket. maybe a few grand.
and a passion and drive to succeed in real estate. now he is a super star..
@Colleen Prescott I've been investing in Fresno for the last few years, mostly because I live here but i've found really great returns here. turn key units go for roughly 70k/unit and up, many B- and C properties with value add go for 60-75 k depending on shape and area etc. If you'd like to talk fresno I'd be more than happy to answer specific questions for you.
@Uneeq Khan Estimating rehab costs before purchase. First you need someone to look at the property and provide an assessment. Maybe it's a contractor, a broker, a project manager, you just don't want it to be the seller. You want to have a source of independent comps, someone that can help you get an idea of ARV, rents, or an approximation of retail selling price. You need to understand what holding costs will be, any taxes, insurance, sales commissions. You would need someone with construction experience to get there and assess the property within 2-5 days and provide you with a report on likely costs. If you don't have much of the info that I've mentioned here, then you really are buying blind.
A good methodology is - find tight comps, understand rents. Establish a value that you want to reach. Understand the current state of the property and what needs to go into the rehab to reach the target goal. Add in holding costs. Work backwards from your target value, add all of these things in, then include ROI you need. This gives you the purchase price number that will allow your investment to work.
Thank you for the info. What is holding cost? Is that the cost of monthly mortgage payments from purchase date to rent date?
I couldn't agree more with the reality of the problem you're bringing to light here, but being a CA investor, property provider, and acting as a consultant for a ton of other CA investors looking to go out of state I see the problem from a different angle.
The investors themselves are not the problem. OOS Investors from expensive markets may have a higher perceived value of these properties and often times buy them and hold them with excess trust in the companies that sell and manage these properties... and they should not be faulted for this. They are passive investors who aim to only be a source of funds. To ensure their success, they should figure out how to find a good property and good team to bring consistent returns to them... but the issue I've witnessed firsthand, many times over, is the provider of the property.
These property providers (often local, but sometimes out of state as well like myself) have varying levels of integrity. I've seen a ton of people living in Indiana and Ohio cities start up businesses to sell properties to hands off investors out of state, and they'll buy distressed property on the cheap, do the bare minimum to get it sold to an OOS investor, and fail to perform. As providers, even if not written in agreement, we are implicitly acting as agents, advising buyers, and are obligated to represent our investors' best interests.
Businesses who buy, improve, sell, and manage properties are popping up left and right to realize a legitimate demand... which is FINE.. but many are in for the short run and they, in turn, are blighting their own cities in exchange for a short term financial gain.
Now for OOSI's that don't utilize providers & professional management and allow their properties to lay barren- I 100% agree with you that they are at fault.
@Colleen Prescott I don't want to bother you but Alabama is a great cheap wine state:). It is landlord friendly, low taxes, insurance and easy to see a good return. If you want to see some examples I can send you a few of what our current owners are doing!
@Account Closed I respectfully disagree. They should be faulted for blindly following the advice of a property provider.
When working with a new property provider--and by new, I mean either newly established or just new to you--you still have to do your own due diligence. I'm sure there are plenty of providers trying to sell off properties in East Cleveland to OOSI for $5k a pop. But if you threw that deal up here on BP, you'll get a plethora of local investors telling you that's an F-neighborhood that should be avoided at all costs. Take the deal to a REIA meeting for a 2nd (and 3rd and 4th) opinion.
These same investors can help vet a property provider. An investor can ask around about that provider's reputation. That provider should also be able to provide references. Once they build some trust with the provider, then they can let the provider do the due diligence work.
At the end of the day, it's the investor's name on the property, not the provider's.
@Colleen Prescott. Out of state investing can be a good way to get started. That being said, working within a 1-2 hour driving range of where you live can be much better. Knowing what I know now, id stay closer to home and partner with one or two other people and go do bigger deals, using all cash.
@Uneeq Khan any cost you have that is associated with owning the property from the time of purchase to the time you sell it. This actually includes the rehab. I like to think of the rehab as a cost all it's own, and then identify the other costs I have to own or carry the property - and consider those as holding costs.
@Colleen Prescott they just want to throw people off investing out of state is great return on your money you see people will travel to go party out in Miami or different countries but they won't invest. You see the problem there don't follow the crowd think out the box so many people invest out of state. I know I do and I am just starting conquer the country you have the whole country to travel around why limit yourself. You will regret later on
@Nicole Heasley Beitenman Now that you put it that way, I think you're right. I would still like to see mutual responsibility, however. Especially when a provider is doing that to their own city, which I see happening soooo often :(
@Myesha Kendrix check out Lisa Phillips real estate investing for beginners it's a great book and she deals with lower-income rental homes Etc. So like 30,000 20000 thousand and up home. Restoring the hood and you also check out Hood estate on Instagram
@James Free thank you! I think I just had a momentary freak out. I have people coming at me from every which way telling me that this is a bad idea. I also have people who are incredibly supportive of course they are bigger Pockets listeners!
I just need to keep doing what I鈥檓 doing and I know I will be successful! It鈥檚 jumping in that鈥檚 the hardest part!
It's important to consider where your advice is coming from! Often times, people who tell you not to do it are going off some anecdote of someone they know who failed. If they haven't achieved the goals you hope to achieve for themselves, then take it with a grain of salt. That's not to say they are wrong necessarily but it's always better to hear from people who have actually TAKEN ACTION!
I've helped out of state investors from all over the country invest out of state. Its so interesting how on BP they give advice that is just absolutely....I wouldnt say trash...but close to it. An article that says "What to watch out for investing out of state" would be more appropriate. I just hate advice that thinks just because they haven't done it well, others can't. Just be mindful if something scares you that badly.
I've only invested long distance - thats as natural to me as breathing, personally. I've helped Californians, Texans, Floridians, New Yorkers successfully do it - they are in my sub30k mastermind group on facebook (in my bio).
Sometimes, I get a little angry that articles like that have an arrogance to say NO ONE should invest out of state, when in fact, it really should show the pitfalls...and even better, show a SOLUTION to those pitfalls. That's where these articles fail. There arent many obstacles at this point we can't work around. This type of advice has stopped thousands from investing. Im not saying they are doing it to make sure they get more for themselves, but its really sad how it can really shut down people's ability to get into the market.
All this to say - I DO see a lot of people who buy cheap, but aren't making sure they are accurately vetting the market, property, or neighborhood. That is a problem, and risky. But its QUITE easy to fix those issues if you look at those items in advance and learn how to be discerning between each deal.
Anything in real estate is dangerous if you don't have the right education and team. educate yourself on out of state investing and build the right team. Possibly go to a state where you have friends or family which can possibly help with the process. NEtwork network and you'll find a way. best of luck.
I don't know if you're familiar with the beige book but if you're not it tells you whats going economically throughout the US. I know firsthand cities like Chicago and Miami allow you to scoop up some decent properties for far less than the California going rate.
I just got a Bigger Pockets email with an article about all the reasons I should not invest out of state. I live in the SF Bay Area and can not afford to buy in state and that article scares the s*^+ out of me.
If I don't invest out of state how do I ever become a REI?
Could use some help and advice. I鈥檓 feeling a bit discouraged here. I simply cannot afford California yet.
Any help is appreciated. I鈥檓 going to go have a glass of wine to help calm my nerves. Cheap wine of course because I鈥檓 saving for a down payment on a MFP!! 馃槣
By cheap I don鈥檛 mean cheap because I love wine too much to drink the bad stuff!
Hi Colleen,
My sincere apologies if you feel discouraged because of my article.
I don't like being politically correct and my blogs are not about making friends or gaining more followers.
I prefer them to "kick folks up the A$$" to be honest.
Why? Because if I don't, then the world of real estate will.
You can definitely invest successfully out of state but the likelihood of succeeding is much lower than if you invest closer to where you are based (This is just my opinion).
My best tip for anyone buying out of state would be to spend more time doing due diligence on the people they are looking to work with rather then the stats/demographics of a particular area.
It's "the people" that will either make or break your investments.
Also, buy a plane ticket and visit the area multiple times if need be.
Thanks and I wish you much success with your endeavors
ps. "Quilt" Cabernet Sauvignon is my favorite. $40 bottle and it will give the $200 bottles a run for their money all day long hehe
@Colleen Prescott one thing is for certain @engelorumora is an American success story hands down. he came to America 10 years or so ago with just a little jingle in his pocket. maybe a few grand.
and a passion and drive to succeed in real estate. now he is a super star..
Thanks for your kind words Jay,
I moved here in September of 2012 (Just over 6 years)
Does that make me an even bigger superstar? hehe
You have been a great mentor of mine for many years now.
Its the bay area itself that's probably why your nerves are jangled. The driving is stressful, the pace is stressful, the place isn't even remotely worth the price whether you buy or rent. Poor thing, I feel sorry for you. Come to Ohio, or Indiana, or Arkansas just about anywhere would be better on your nerves.