Pitfalls to Turn Key Rental Properties

Pitfalls to Turn Key Rental Properties

Flipper/Rehabber · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2016 · 174 posts · 251 votes

I've been surprised by how many people are getting ripped off by turnkey rental providers. Most without even knowing they're getting ripped off. Granted, there some providers that are good but many aren't. The question always has to be asked "why would a provider not just sell their inventory on the MLS?" Wouldn't there be a bigger pool of buyers and therefore potentially a higher price?

What's most shocking is how buyers overlook key issues.  Such as the depreciation in real dollars "adjusted for inflation" or rentability of a property.  This is a zillow snap shot of two areas in a market where I have several properties.  The first is a hot spot for turnkey providers and second is not (the second is where I prefer to buy.) 

Basically the same sized area, both all single family homes.  The first area is where a provider can advertise high yields but very few owner occupants will buy there.  The second is very desirable for owner occupants and homes sell and rent very quickly.  Where would you rather own a rental?

The turn key provider can buy a lot more inventory in the first area, mark it up and still sell it to investors.  In the second area turn key providers can't get inventory because the markets hot and it's desirable.  How many turn key buyers think or want to be invested in area two but unbeknownst to them are investing in area one?  

Put yourself in the shoes of the turnkey provider.  Where are you going to make more money?  Said another way, where do you have to sell in order to stay in business when it's a sellers market (today.) 

I'm considering writing an ebook on what to look for when considering out of state turnkey investments.  I'd love to hear from investors considering this path and what their concerns are about turnkey investing so I could address these concerns in the ebook.  

Thank you,

George

5Reply
96 views

Most Popular Reply

CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
9y

@George Gammon

George - I think you are TRYING to make a very good argument.... I am not familiar with the area that is in debate here, so I can't say yes or no to either side of the debate..

What I can and would say is:

1. Whenever you go "out-of-state", you are buying into something that you don't really understand... Period...You are exposing yourself to all kinds of risks that you won't if you were to stay local....Could be the turnkey company, could be PM, could be RE agent....Anything.....

2. Whether it is the turnkey company, or PM, or RE agent.... No one is going to safeguard YOUR financial interest like yourself... It is NOT even their job...If they sell you something for market price, they are all ethical...If they sell you something for above market, why did you buy it? 

So, all in all, if you want to invest out of state, know your risk and don't complain later.... That is why I do NOT invest beyond 2 hours of driving...If the local price is too high, like is now in San Francisco, I will wait......

See this reply in the discussion

20 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2015 · 222 posts · 121 votes
    9y

    I find this interesting as I sell many properties in both areas mentioned here.  As a turnkey provider, we offer properties in all areas A, B and C and describe them as such. A grade - mostly homeowners, newer homes. B grade - mix of home owners and renters. C grade- mostly renters, older homes.  Based off of that description and investors expectations/goals, I can point them to an investment that is right for them.  Not everyone is financially ready for the high priced A grade rental. The upside of owning many rental homes in one area like the one mentioned in the first picture (Ruskin) is that you can screen all of the tenants very thoroughly and stay very in tune with the market as a whole. I have continuously watched the homes in this particular area appreciate by tens of thousands in the past couple years alone. I'd love to hear more of your thoughts!

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2016 · 174 posts · 251 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    I find this interesting as I sell many properties in both areas mentioned here.  As a turnkey provider, we offer properties in all areas A, B and C and describe them as such. A grade - mostly homeowners, newer homes. B grade - mix of home owners and renters. C grade- mostly renters, older homes.  Based off of that description and investors expectations/goals, I can point them to an investment that is right for them.  Not everyone is financially ready for the high priced A grade rental. The upside of owning many rental homes in one area like the one mentioned in the first picture (Ruskin) is that you can screen all of the tenants very thoroughly and stay very in tune with the market as a whole. I have continuously watched the homes in this particular area appreciate by tens of thousands in the past couple years alone. I'd love to hear more of your thoughts!

     First Mackaylee, I appreciate your feedback.  I have no doubt that the A, B and C descriptions of each property are fully disclosed.  What I'm not sure of is if investors, who purchase these properties, know the amount of rental inventory that's around where they're buying or the fact that their property will most likely depreciate in real terms.  This is a huge part of the analysis of a property most overlook.  Let's use Ruskin as an example.  

    A turnkey provider could sell a property there for 50k that has a market rent of 800 a month...great return.  But what's the chance of getting it rented consistently when there's literally 30 others, exactly like what you just purchased, for rent within walking distance?  It's like buying an apartment in a 300 unit apartment building that has 50 vacancies.  

    Your correct, not everyone is financially ready for a grade A rental but everyone should be financially educated enough to not put their hard earned money at excessive risk.  Imagine the investor that only has 10k to his or her name use it to buy a property in Ruskin and desperately need the monthly rent to make the mortgage payment.  How realistic is that going to be if there 30 other identical homes vacant in the same neighborhood?  Look at the rental price difference in the photo above.  You know as well as I do those homes are all extremely similar in size and floor plan.  What's happening is investors who bought there are desperate so they drop their rents and forgo maintenance.  Not a good position for a newby who isn't ready for a "high priced grade A rental."  

    Again, my point is they know the obvious pro's and con's but are oblivious to the rental inventory they're buying into.  I can't imagine anyone buying there after seeing how much rental inventory is already there and currently vacant.  Would you put your money to work in Ruskin? 

    Next is the issue of appreciation.  On this point you're 1. incorrect about prices increasing and 2. looking at nominal prices not real prices.  

    Regarding nominal prices they've not increased in the last 2 years.  In fact they haven't increased in 4 years since the bottom of the market in 2012.  I know this well because I started investing in this market heavily in 2012.  I analyzed the Ruskin area extensively for months.  At the end of 2012 you could buy a normal 3 bed 2 bath for the same price you can get it for now.  This makes sense because how could prices increase?  In order for this to happen there'd have to be demand.  What investor is going to buy there knowing the area and existing rental inventory?...very few.  And you know as well as I do there's zero demand from owner occupants there.  Even if you wanted to buy and live in the area you'd go over to Grand View or up closer to Raytown.  

    And real prices are what most investors overlook but are most important.  The question isn't "what's the price then and now?" but how much purchasing power did I have then and how much do I have now.  Using Ruskin again for an example:  As you know, most of those homes were built around 1960.  Around that time you could've purchased a house for about 15k.  Now you could buy that same home for 50k, almost a 300% increase...in nominal terms.  This doesn't mean you have 300% more purchasing power, which is all that matters.  In 1960 15k had the purchasing power of 122k in todays dollars.  So in terms of purchasing power, which again, is all that matters.  That home depreciated by over 50%.  This is what very few investors, if any I've seen, consider when buying homes from turnkey providers...they see, and are sold, a 300% gain when in reality they've taken a 50% loss.  

    Those are some of my thoughts.  I'm curious how much inventory your company currently has for sale in Lees Summit or Blue Springs?    

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @George Gammon not everyone's investment criteria is the same. Just because yours is more A class, owner occupied neighborhoods, there are those that want C class with higher COC returns. The fact that a turn key company sells C class properties doesn't mean they are ripping off unsuspecting investors. There were a lot of turn key operators selling D class properties in the hood to unsuspecting Australians but most of those people have been pushed out of the market. I agree with you about Ruskin Heights but I don't consider it a C class area. Some people say it's improving but I still consider it more of a D class area. We sell a lot of turn key properties in South Kansas City in both B and C class neighborhoods. Some of these neighborhoods have a high percentage of owner occupants but it varies neighborhood to neighborhood. The Kansas City rental market is hot right now and things are renting fast. There's plenty of demand for rentals in C class areas. There's actually a larger pool of renters for the working class $900-$1000 rent range than the $1200 + range.

  • Real Estate Investor · fresno, CA · Member since 2016 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    9y
    I would be worried about repairs and how legit they might be. Could it be that management company over inflates repairs to get kickback from their local contractors , so I guess it would be integrity of management companies
  • Real Estate Investor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2015 · 222 posts · 121 votes
    9y

    @George Gammon I appreciate the information you have come up with.  Our leasing team has no trouble renting out in Ruskin, even with the competition. I would assume it's because we provide better quality rehabs and more amenities.  We have also sold to home buyers in the area so you are false when you assume "zero demand from owner occupants there".  

    I agree with you, real prices are important. But again, I think it would be safe for you to agree that not all investors have the same goals as yourself.  I always recommend a mixed portfolio of homes but like Mike said, there's not a huge demand for rent $1,200+. 

    We have a lot of inventory in Blue Springs, Lees Summit, Raytown, Independence, Grandview and Kansas City.  

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2016 · 174 posts · 251 votes
    9y

    @Mike D'Arrigo @Account Closed

    Both of you say all investors don't have the same goals.  I agree.  But I think it's safe to say all investors do share the goal of not losing money.  

    My point isn't about investors preferring A, B or C areas, it's that most turnkey providers are selling inventory that wouldn't sell well, or at the same price, on the open market.  AND most buyers of turnkey properties aren't factoring in real depreciation into their numbers or the fact that they're buying into an area that is saturated with rentals (or will be soon.)  The later is by no means the fault of the turnkey provider, it's the buyers responsibility to educate themselves.  

    I do think that turnkey providers occasionally have inventory in areas that have more tailwind than headwind, regardless of A, B, C, but they're far and few between in a sellers market (in a buyers market it's different.)  It's up to the buyer to know enough to select the right properties and understand the interests of the turnkey provider may not be aligned with their own.  

    I think it would behove investors to ask themselves "why is this turnkey provider selling me this property instead of putting it on the MLS and opening it up to countless buyers that could potentially offer a price higher than what's listed?" Or said another way, if you owned a great rental in a great area would you A. put it on the MLS and see how high a price you can get or B. Sell it at a set price to one buyer? Assuming the set price isn't higher than the market price why wouldn't you put it on the MLS and see how high of a price you can get?

    Selling at a set price to an investor without trying to sell it on the open market first doesn't make a lot of sense, so why are they doing it?  

    I'm currently in the KC market all day every day.  I've bought and sold well over a million dollars of property here, in the past few years, just investing for myself.  (And by the way, I own property in A, B and C neighborhoods so it's not that I'm bias towards A or B properties.  Theres good C areas with more tailwind and bad C areas with tremendous headwind)  I can tell you from boots on the ground experience KC investors are tripping over themselves to buy good properties in good areas regardless of A, B, or C.  The key phrase there being "good properties" in "good areas."

    Just last week I looked at a property in a good B area that would've been a great rehab/rental. I went to look at it within an hour of hitting the MLS and there were 5 other people looking at it when I got there. I submitted my offer that day and my agent said they'd already received over 10 offers and I'd need to submit a "highest and best offer." I offered 10k over the asking price...I wasn't even close. It sold for 20k+ over asking price of 50k. At that buy price there would've been little to no margin in the rehab for a flip so most likely a local investor was buying it to rent and was happy with 5k in built in equity.

    My point is local investors are so hungry for deals, and yield, they're paying high prices and falling over themselves to do so.  Why then would a turnkey provider sell a property at a set price to an out of state investor if they could flip it to a local investor in 30 minutes and potentially have a bidding war?  

    Is it possible the turnkey providers are selling inventory that local investors just don't want or at a price local investors aren't willing to pay?  It's the job of the investors to dig into these questions.

    Another thing investors need to understand, and think through, is the business model of property management.  

    As an example: Let's say a property manager runs 400 properties and that requires 1 employee per 100 properties (probably conservative.)  This hypothetical company would have 4 employees, maybe a receptionist, a full time maintenance person and let's say a leasing agent...6 or 7 employees total.  Let's assume these employees make 36k a year so that's 3k a month.  Total payroll would be around 20k per month.  Then they need an office, another 2k a month and phones, internet, computers, fax, banking, office supplies, insurance, vehicles, misc. legal and accounting fees etc.  As someone who was an entrepreneur for 15 years, running countless businesses of all types, I'd say their fixed expenses are between 27k and 32k a month.  

    Remember our hypothetical property manager manages 400 properties, at 8% of gross rents collected.  Let's assume they're in KC and the average rent collected is $1000 a month...That's 32,000 a month in revenue for a company that has 27,000 to 32,000 a month in expenses.  Not exactly a cash cow.  

    Thinking through this it's easy to see how a property manager most likely won't make profit on the 8% fee, that just covers the monthly nut, but on up charging for maintenance and evictions.  

    I'd then pose the question to investors "Is it remotely possible some turnkey providers (offering property management), that sell the majority of their properties in unattractive areas, where maintenance and evictions are a much bigger issue, do so because the money is made on the maintenance and evictions?"  And if the money's made on maintenance and evictions that means it'll be tough for the investor the type of return they're hoping for.  I'm not implying they charge investors for un needed maintenance, I'm saying these properties will be prone to maintenance issues because of the area and type of tenant and some turnkey providers bank on this.  

    To me, the take away is many turnkey providers wouldn't sell to out of state investors if they weren't getting higher than market prices up front or planning on making it up on the back end with excessive maintenance and evictions.  

    When you consider that, along with the likely depreciation of the asset and excessive rental supply in many of the turnkey areas it's prudent for investors to proceed with caution.  

    Hopefully it's obvious I've refrained from mentioning any turnkey providers.  In the first post I went so far is to not even mention the city.  My goal isn't to throw turnkey providers under the bus (again, occasionally they will have some great inventory) it's to encourage investors to educate themselves better, think through the business model and use this to your advantage to make sure you're buying a property that fits your needs and wants exactly.  

  • Real Estate Investor · Kansas City, MO · Member since 2015 · 222 posts · 121 votes
    9y

    Your assumptions are bold. I can't speak for anyone else but we do put our properties on the MLS and many do sell to home buyers. Our in-house PM actually LOSES money every month for the amount of staff we have. We over higher and over deliver. I agree, most PMs have to upcharge on everything and only make money by doing evictions, turn outs, etc. Our PM is an added service to our investors and like I said loses money every month because we take great care of our investors and our tenants. Our highest priority is tenant retention. In house property management is not a money maker. We don't take on any outside properties either because we don't know the rehab standards or the tenant screening. Keeping everything in house makes for great communication. Again, your assumptions are bold but I don't blame you because that's how most companies operate. However, sometimes there's that goldmine in the middle of it all that truly has the investors in mind. Again, I can't speak for everyone, only my company.

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @George Gammon I don't think that you can assume that C class properties don't have any appreciation potential. Turn key properties that we sold in Indianapolis and Kansas City 2 or 3 years ago now sell for $10K more than they did then. That won't continue indefinitely but the appreciation rates they are seeing on the higher end won't either. I do agree though that an A class property usually offers more exit options. I'm not understanding why selling on the MLS is so important to you. There's a very good reason that turn key companies don't sell on the MLS. They don't need to. Successful turn key companies have a well established investor base that they sell to and currently have more demand then inventory. There's no need to pay a 6% commission when they can sell there properties themselves before the rehab is even done. I don't agree that a turn key company can put a property on the MLS and get multiple offers above their asking price. That's true in some markets for retail, owner occupied properties where buyers buy on emotion. Smart investors buy based on numbers and don't get in to bidding wars on a turn key property that isn't going to have the margin to do so. The example you cite is for a non rehabbed property that needs work. Investors will bid those up if there is margin to do so but only to the point where the numbers don't work. Turn keys are different however. They are sold at market value and don't have the margin to bid prices up. Also, another reason turn key companies don't list they're properties on the MLS is because they're goal is to turn their money quickly. They price their properties to sell and they don't want to haggle over price unlike a retail transaction. I second what @Account Closed said about owner occupancy. These neighborhoods are not all rentals. Some of these neighborhoods are old, established neighborhoods with long term home owners and those are the real gems for investors.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2016 · 174 posts · 251 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @George Gammon I appreciate the information you have come up with.  Our leasing team has no trouble renting out in Ruskin, even with the competition. I would assume it's because we provide better quality rehabs and more amenities.  We have also sold to home buyers in the area so you are false when you assume "zero demand from owner occupants there".  

    I agree with you, real prices are important. But again, I think it would be safe for you to agree that not all investors have the same goals as yourself.  I always recommend a mixed portfolio of homes but like Mike said, there's not a huge demand for rent $1,200+. 

    We have a lot of inventory in Blue Springs, Lees Summit, Raytown, Independence, Grandview and Kansas City.  

    Forgive me Machaylee but I'm skeptical.  You have "no trouble renting in Ruskin?" Seems hard to believe in an area that has multiple vacancies on every street regardless of the quality of rehab (how much rehab can be done and still sell a house for 50K?  It maybe possible you and I have different definitions of "no trouble." 

    Regarding the owner occupants I'm even more skeptical.  I don't know of a bank in KC that will lend in that area, on a house under 75k.  Maybe I just haven't met with the right bank?  But assuming that's the case, the "owner occupants" you're selling to maybe just have 50k in cash saved up?  I find that incredibly difficult to believe.  

    You recommend a mixed portfolio of homes.  What are your qualifications for making recommendations?  My intent is not to be rude but to ask an valid question.  A question that I think is extremely reasonable considering your statement "there's not huge demand for rent $1,200+."  This just isn't true.  All my properties, and every other local investors I know, in that range rent within days with current rent increases.  

    To further the point. According to your website, you have 1 house for sale in Blue Springs, 1 in Lees Summit where rents are 1200+.  This is because theres an incredible amount of local investor demand there and inventory is very hard to find, not because the rental market for $1,200+ is soft, quite the opposite...Let's be honest.  

    I'd also like to point out, according to your website, you have 1 house for sale in Blue Springs, 1 house for sale in Lees Summit (maybe we have a different definition of "a lot?") and 34 houses for sale in or around Ruskin area where maintenance and evictions will be far more likely...see above post.  

  • CA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @George Gammon

    George - I think you are TRYING to make a very good argument.... I am not familiar with the area that is in debate here, so I can't say yes or no to either side of the debate..

    What I can and would say is:

    1. Whenever you go "out-of-state", you are buying into something that you don't really understand... Period...You are exposing yourself to all kinds of risks that you won't if you were to stay local....Could be the turnkey company, could be PM, could be RE agent....Anything.....

    2. Whether it is the turnkey company, or PM, or RE agent.... No one is going to safeguard YOUR financial interest like yourself... It is NOT even their job...If they sell you something for market price, they are all ethical...If they sell you something for above market, why did you buy it? 

    So, all in all, if you want to invest out of state, know your risk and don't complain later.... That is why I do NOT invest beyond 2 hours of driving...If the local price is too high, like is now in San Francisco, I will wait......

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2016 · 174 posts · 251 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Mike D'Arrigo:

    @George Gammon I don't think that you can assume that C class properties don't have any appreciation potential. Turn key properties that we sold in Indianapolis and Kansas City 2 or 3 years ago now sell for $10K more than they did then. That won't continue indefinitely but the appreciation rates they are seeing on the higher end won't either. I do agree though that an A class property usually offers more exit options. I'm not understanding why selling on the MLS is so important to you. There's a very good reason that turn key companies don't sell on the MLS. They don't need to. Successful turn key companies have a well established investor base that they sell to and currently have more demand then inventory. There's no need to pay a 6% commission when they can sell there properties themselves before the rehab is even done. I don't agree that a turn key company can put a property on the MLS and get multiple offers above their asking price. That's true in some markets for retail, owner occupied properties where buyers buy on emotion. Smart investors buy based on numbers and don't get in to bidding wars on a turn key property that isn't going to have the margin to do so. The example you cite is for a non rehabbed property that needs work. Investors will bid those up if there is margin to do so but only to the point where the numbers don't work. Turn keys are different however. They are sold at market value and don't have the margin to bid prices up. Also, another reason turn key companies don't list they're properties on the MLS is because they're goal is to turn their money quickly. They price their properties to sell and they don't want to haggle over price unlike a retail transaction. I second what @Account Closed said about owner occupancy. These neighborhoods are not all rentals. Some of these neighborhoods are old, established neighborhoods with long term home owners and those are the real gems for investors.

     1.  I'm not saying C areas don't have appreciation potential.  Often they have more appreciation potential.  There are also areas that have an extremely low potential for appreciation and higher potential for depreciation.  The majority of turnkey inventory I've seen in KC falls into this later category.  Again, I'm by no means saying all turnkey inventory is garbage, I am saying buyers need to further educate themselves on the intricacies of these areas and not rely on the "advice" of the turnkey providers.

    2. I make a point of the MLS because you offer what you have for sale to a larger pool of buyers. Larger pool of buyers, at times, equals a higher price. Don't most sellers want the highest price for what they're selling?

    3.  They're not saving 6%, they're saving 3% because they'll keep the sell side commission.  I think that would be more than made up for by offering it to an entire country of buyers as opposed to just one.  

    4. Your right, most turnkey providers can't get multiple offers on the MLS because the majority of their inventory is undesirable. This is my point.

    5. Regarding the quick sale. In a buyers market I get it. In a sellers market, like what we have today, I'm a tough sell. Every house I've sold myself, on the MLS, lately has sold with in days. And I'm supposed to believe turnkey providers prefer to sell at a lower price if it means not haggling? And in this market how much haggling is done when you're getting full price offers?

    6.  Mike to say Ruskin (the area Mackaylee is referring to) is a "gem for investors" is laughable.  In all honesty it's a **** hole that every local investor I know would't touch.  

    I'll reiterate my opinion with the emphasis on the fact that this is my opinion only, for what its worth.  

    Most turnkey providers sell inventory that local investors, who have the local knowledge, don't want.  They do this because it offers inventory that they can flip at times, like now, when the market is hot and deals in good areas are far and few between.  They also benefit on the back end because these properties tend to have more maintenance issues and evictions which is where the money is made on property management.  THAT IS NOT TO SAY they have no good inventory, occasionally they absolutely do (especially in a buyers market), or there's no good inventory in "C" areas, but all "C" areas aren't created equal...investors need to understand these points better.  Because at the end of the day it's their money and their responsibility. 

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @George Gammon I wholeheartedly agree that investors have to due their own diligence and not just rely on someone else's word at least until they have a trusted relationship with them. It's important to keep in mind that everyone has their own definition of a neighborhood class and what is a C class to one might be a D class to another. These areas in Kansas City can vary neighborhood to neighborhood so investors have to really understand the nuances of the area. Just to clarify, I share your views on Ruskin Heights. We don't do anything in that area at all. Personally, I don't consider it C class.

  • Rental Property Investor · Honolulu, HAWAII (HI) · Member since 2011 · 4k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y
    It's good to get a lot of things fixed up front but the cap ex "wave" will come at some point. Plus who ever is a proponent to 1031s is near sighted. I don't like them because you can't scale into a syndication so you are forced to constantly time purchases and sales. Good luck with that. Pay the tax man and move on.
  • Rental Property Investor · Shawnee Mission, KS · Member since 2014 · 205 posts · 136 votes
    9y

    Ruskin Heights is a 'D' area, I personally don't even consider it.   But there are some very decent 'C' cash-flow areas not far from there where I do own, and I know there are some decent turnkey providers working in those areas.  The challenge to the purchaser is to know which locations will work in the long run.  

    If you can get a referral you trust for a provider, then consider doing business with them. I also suggest just looking at MLS listings in the area you are considering purchasing as well, so you can compare prices to the Turnkey offering.

    Be sure to verify the market rent for the house on rentometer or other websites, as the proforma will often have a top-of-market rent. Also check the proforma for capex layaway and realistic vacancy & pm costs.  Lease up fees, credit loss, and rehab expenses are significant and may be missing or under represented.   

    The only one guaranteed to profit in your turnkey purchase is the turnkey company. Do your homework, and being here on BiggerPockets is a good start to that. The original point that the OP made is valid - there are many ways to be taken in on a turnkey deal. Be careful. Also I will say if you are going to be doing all this research anyway, consider buying nice houses off the MLS as an option and invest your time finding an experienced agent you can work with.

  • Sherman Oaks, CA · Member since 2013 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y

    The main reason some tk providers don't list on the mls is they would never get the price some out of state sucker will pay. One promoter even says don't look at the mls as there are no deals. Actually, what most investors would see that the house next door is for sale for thousands less. I would say this is common not the exception. Next time you buy a tk ...do yourself two favors, check the mls and check what the the tk seller paid. You just might prevent yourself from being that next sucker. ( Not all but some tk promoters operate exactly like the above ) 

  • Investor · Hawaiian Gardens, CA · Member since 2015 · 308 posts · 386 votes
    9y

    I'm a turnkey investor who has bought in Kansas City last year, off of E 89th in Raytown. I did my research and saw there's some crime in that area, but the vacancies are lower. My turnkey provider purchased the property at auction for ~70k (estimate). Renovated the property, and listed the price for sale at 110k, 5bd 3ba, rents for 1300$. It appraised for 100k, and they brought down the price to 100k accordingly. I continue to give them my business as my property manager.

    Why didn't I just buy this at auction myself? I work full time as a Registered Nurse and love my job, I'm not a real estate agent, and don't want to be. I don't have the cash for auction, or the time to fly over there.

    I'm sure my provider made good money off me, and I'm fine with that. Currently, my mortgage impound account is for <600$/mo (taxes and insurance included) and it rents for 1300$. I'm pleased with my returns and I'm well aware of the area.

  • Rental Property Investor · Overland Park, KS · Member since 2016 · 205 posts · 85 votes
    9y

    @Cliff Harrison and @George Gammon I agree on the classification of areas.  

    One of the issues with rating properties A, B, or C is that it is entirely subjective. I flip homes and rent homes all over KC.  I would say that if you set the bar with Fairway, PV as A’s. There are then parts of Olathe, Shawnee, Merriam that are C+ or B-. If something in JoCo is a C+, Ruskin is a D on its best day. I would say most of that area is "F", with a few streets that are acceptable D's.  

    But I see lots of people selling to out of town investors claiming it is a C area. Fudging area information to out-of-towners makes it easy to get #smokingdeals and be a #celebrity at the local REIA or in local Facebook Groups.

  • Rental Property Investor · Overland Park, KS · Member since 2016 · 205 posts · 85 votes
    9y

    @Derrick Dill if you are spending over $100k in the KC market and charging $1300 rent, it is impossible to be in a "D" area.  

    The lower areas of KC are below $50k FIXED and bringing $600 or less in rent.  

    Sounds like you have a good provider selling quality properties in quality areas.  

  • New York City, NY · Member since 2016 · 470 posts · 348 votes
    9y

    @Account Closed You said "Our in-house PM actually LOSES money every month for the amount of staff we have", which basically means that your company is willing to take a loss on the PM side in order to keep bringing in new business and ensure that your clients are able to achieve a high return.

    So, in the future, if new business slows (due to economic factors or whatever other reason), you guys would be forced to increase your PM fees (or fire some of your PM staff and thus provide a lower quality of PM service). Otherwise you would go out of business if your PM keeps operating at a loss. Either of those solutions would significantly decrease your clients' returns.

    So it sounds like you guys are willing to take a loss on the PM side in order to help prop up your clients' returns, which doesn't necessarily sound like a sound long-term business model to me?

    Taken to an extreme, this is actually more or less the definition of a Ponzi scheme (a scheme in which a continual influx of new money is used to subsidize earlier investors). Now, I say that tongue in cheek, because you guys certainly aren't running a Ponzi scheme. I'm sure your investors would at least break even (or see a small return) even if you charged market rate PM fees, so you're not actually reliant on new business to fund prior investors' returns, but merely to enhance those returns. But it is slightly analogous.

    Not trying to be confrontational here, just trying to better understand what you meant by that comment. Could you expound on that pls?

  • Rental Property Investor · Los Angeles, CA · Member since 2016 · 141 posts · 123 votes
    7y
    Originally posted by @George Gammon:

    @Mike D'Arrigo @Account Closed

    Both of you say all investors don't have the same goals.  I agree.  But I think it's safe to say all investors do share the goal of not losing money.  

    My point isn't about investors preferring A, B or C areas, it's that most turnkey providers are selling inventory that wouldn't sell well, or at the same price, on the open market.  AND most buyers of turnkey properties aren't factoring in real depreciation into their numbers or the fact that they're buying into an area that is saturated with rentals (or will be soon.)  The later is by no means the fault of the turnkey provider, it's the buyers responsibility to educate themselves.  

    I do think that turnkey providers occasionally have inventory in areas that have more tailwind than headwind, regardless of A, B, C, but they're far and few between in a sellers market (in a buyers market it's different.)  It's up to the buyer to know enough to select the right properties and understand the interests of the turnkey provider may not be aligned with their own.  

    I think it would behove investors to ask themselves "why is this turnkey provider selling me this property instead of putting it on the MLS and opening it up to countless buyers that could potentially offer a price higher than what's listed?" Or said another way, if you owned a great rental in a great area would you A. put it on the MLS and see how high a price you can get or B. Sell it at a set price to one buyer? Assuming the set price isn't higher than the market price why wouldn't you put it on the MLS and see how high of a price you can get?

    Selling at a set price to an investor without trying to sell it on the open market first doesn't make a lot of sense, so why are they doing it?  

    I'm currently in the KC market all day every day.  I've bought and sold well over a million dollars of property here, in the past few years, just investing for myself.  (And by the way, I own property in A, B and C neighborhoods so it's not that I'm bias towards A or B properties.  Theres good C areas with more tailwind and bad C areas with tremendous headwind)  I can tell you from boots on the ground experience KC investors are tripping over themselves to buy good properties in good areas regardless of A, B, or C.  The key phrase there being "good properties" in "good areas."

    Just last week I looked at a property in a good B area that would've been a great rehab/rental. I went to look at it within an hour of hitting the MLS and there were 5 other people looking at it when I got there. I submitted my offer that day and my agent said they'd already received over 10 offers and I'd need to submit a "highest and best offer." I offered 10k over the asking price...I wasn't even close. It sold for 20k+ over asking price of 50k. At that buy price there would've been little to no margin in the rehab for a flip so most likely a local investor was buying it to rent and was happy with 5k in built in equity.

    My point is local investors are so hungry for deals, and yield, they're paying high prices and falling over themselves to do so.  Why then would a turnkey provider sell a property at a set price to an out of state investor if they could flip it to a local investor in 30 minutes and potentially have a bidding war?  

    Is it possible the turnkey providers are selling inventory that local investors just don't want or at a price local investors aren't willing to pay?  It's the job of the investors to dig into these questions.

    Another thing investors need to understand, and think through, is the business model of property management.  

    As an example: Let's say a property manager runs 400 properties and that requires 1 employee per 100 properties (probably conservative.)  This hypothetical company would have 4 employees, maybe a receptionist, a full time maintenance person and let's say a leasing agent...6 or 7 employees total.  Let's assume these employees make 36k a year so that's 3k a month.  Total payroll would be around 20k per month.  Then they need an office, another 2k a month and phones, internet, computers, fax, banking, office supplies, insurance, vehicles, misc. legal and accounting fees etc.  As someone who was an entrepreneur for 15 years, running countless businesses of all types, I'd say their fixed expenses are between 27k and 32k a month.  

    Remember our hypothetical property manager manages 400 properties, at 8% of gross rents collected.  Let's assume they're in KC and the average rent collected is $1000 a month...That's 32,000 a month in revenue for a company that has 27,000 to 32,000 a month in expenses.  Not exactly a cash cow.  

    Thinking through this it's easy to see how a property manager most likely won't make profit on the 8% fee, that just covers the monthly nut, but on up charging for maintenance and evictions.  

    I'd then pose the question to investors "Is it remotely possible some turnkey providers (offering property management), that sell the majority of their properties in unattractive areas, where maintenance and evictions are a much bigger issue, do so because the money is made on the maintenance and evictions?"  And if the money's made on maintenance and evictions that means it'll be tough for the investor the type of return they're hoping for.  I'm not implying they charge investors for un needed maintenance, I'm saying these properties will be prone to maintenance issues because of the area and type of tenant and some turnkey providers bank on this.  

    To me, the take away is many turnkey providers wouldn't sell to out of state investors if they weren't getting higher than market prices up front or planning on making it up on the back end with excessive maintenance and evictions.  

    When you consider that, along with the likely depreciation of the asset and excessive rental supply in many of the turnkey areas it's prudent for investors to proceed with caution.  

    Hopefully it's obvious I've refrained from mentioning any turnkey providers.  In the first post I went so far is to not even mention the city.  My goal isn't to throw turnkey providers under the bus (again, occasionally they will have some great inventory) it's to encourage investors to educate themselves better, think through the business model and use this to your advantage to make sure you're buying a property that fits your needs and wants exactly.  

     Great observations about TK and out of state rentals! I am also in KC and realized this a couple months into the market.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.