EPDM Rubber Roof VS SBS Modified Bitumen Self Adhering

[Leandro Herbstein]

Hi BP Community, 

I just purchased a foreclosure in Walton, Upstate NY as a getaway from NYC and while I knew the roof needed to be fixed, I just found out that some areas of the roof need to be entirely replaced as they have a very low pitch and currently have shingles (Not sure why they did that in the first place).  This is all new to me, so I am learning as I go.  

My question is - Do I go for the EPDM rubber roof or the GAF self-adhesive Modified Bitumen roof option? So far I got two contractors and one prefers rubber and the other mod bit. Both seem to make compelling arguments, so it's hard to make a decision and the more I research online the more confused I am since I have found articles and videos suggesting one over the other.   

I would REALLY appreciate some feedback as I have NO CLUE.  

Thanks! 

Leandro 

[Ralph Hughes]

Hi Leandro

Both the options have their own pros and cons and also both are used extensively these day. EPDM is long lasting, easy to install but comes in Black and white option only whereas GAF self-adhesive Modified Bitumen option has more elegant and attractive way as it comes in different colours. in terms of durability i would prefer EPDM method. Whereas, if you looking to save money and more aesthetic roofing option you can opt for modified bitumen roofing.