My husband and I recently bought a house in Seattle, Washington (specifically Ballard neighborhood). We are trying to weigh the pros and cons of doing a short-term rental (STR) or medium-term rental (MTR).
Is there a way to do STR and MTR depending on the season of the year? Is there a property management software that does both short-term rentals and medium-term rentals? If so, which ones would you recommend to do STR and MTR?
Real Estate Agent · Sammamish, 🌧️ Seattle Investor-Agent | 🤑 Helped 400+ Clients Invest in Real Estate | 🏘️ Owns 23 WA Rentals & Airbnbs | 🏗️ Built 5 DADU's | 📈 You Can Do It Too · Member since 2016 · 725 posts · 3k+ votes
In my opinion you really don't need rental software if you have less than 2 units on MTR or LTR model. If you want to set something up go with a lightweight solution like Cozy (Appartments.com) or Avail. For STR's you should definitely use rental software - we like Hospitable and Guesty.
PS - what were you planning on doing when purchasing it? I'd stay the course with whatever your original numbers and investing strategy was when you were acquiring the property, unless something significant has changed.
There are tons of PMS, most of them do the same thing or very similar functions.
If you're wanting to STR some of the year and MTR the rest, the only thing you would be doing different is setting different nightly min/max during those parts of the year. Any PMS can do this. Most have free trials.
My husband and I own two STR, but keep the posting up on furnished finder too. We have gotten a couple of inquires through furnished finder, but most of our month+ rentals are being booked through Airbnb. We do give a discount to those who want to stay longer (10% off for 30+ days bookings). Would be happy to meet up and show you what we have done!
My husband and I recently bought a house in Seattle, Washington (specifically Ballard neighborhood). We are trying to weigh the pros and cons of doing a short-term rental (STR) or medium-term rental (MTR).
Is there a way to do STR and MTR depending on the season of the year? Is there a property management software that does both short-term rentals and medium-term rentals? If so, which ones would you recommend to do STR and MTR?
Thanks in advice for the advice!
Kind Regards,
Jennifer
Hi Jennifer. FYI- It's critical that if you are going to do "MTR's", you use a LTR lease agreement. STR's don't need this. This isn't good or bad, it just is required, since MTR's are actually legally LTR's. I recommend you privately reach out to a few BP STR PM's and ask what they recommend for management software. Just be careful about the lease agreement on those MTR's, as (to my knowledge) the Online providers don't do this automatically. You need to have tenants sign the agreements and collect them, manually.
Yes you could do both. You could just require longer minimum stays on Vrbo and Airbnb during certain times. Chances you get this to line up perfectly are slim.
Don't confuse yourself. There are short-term rentals (30 days or less) and long-term rentals (more than 30 days). Long-term rentals are rented one month at a time, or for a fixed period of time (three months, six months, 8.5 months, etc.).
Even if it is furnished with utilities included, it is still a long-term rental. MTR was created by some YouTuber that wanted to trick people into thinking it was something new even though people have used furnished, long-term rentals forever.
Long-term rentals have different laws and use different leases that short-term rentals. You need to be aware of this and prepared.
If you rent it short-term, then you can also advertise long-term rates on the same website. But I also recommend advertising it on other websites like Zillow, facebook marketplace, apartments.com, zumper, furnishedfinder, etc. Most people on STR sites are looking for short-term. You will probably get more interest for long-term by advertising on long-term sites. My point is, advertise on both if you are looking for both.
We use Streamline PMS and they have options for STR and MTR, however Streamline is a very sophisticated expensive software designed for medium to large property managers.
If you are self managing 1 unit (or a few) you should be able to use the settings on Airbnb/VRBO to make specific length of stay requirements/pricing etc. It will probably be a pain in the neck but then again so is implementing PMS
Hey @Jennifer F., so being in Seattle can be problematic. I wouldn't do a MTR anywhere in Seattle with the current climate. Once you hit 30 days, they have full tenants rights. You could easily get someone in there who just decides not to leave or pay. The city will side with the tenant and you could be really stuck.
Bottom line is that Seattle is one of the most tenant friendly cities in the US. So many people have had "renters" in their places not paying a dime for 3 years now. If you market it as a vacation rental (Ballard has some cool stuff depending on where it is located) I think you would do better and it would be safer.
@Jennifer F., in general, STR/MTR yield me more cash flow compared to LTR. Keep in mind that you need to pay utilities and it takes more time to manage compared to LTR!
@Jennifer F. For STR's, Guesty for Hosts does a good job at synchronizing your calendar on all STR sites along with sending automated messages that you set up. It's also a good scheduling tool with your cleaners. I'd also encourage you to set up with Pricelabs so you can dynamically price your property according to your competition and how well your property performs. For MTR's & LTR's I've been using RentRedi. If you're a BP Pro member you can use this for free. It's a pretty good tool, the only con I have experienced so far is the amount of time it takes for the platform to process payments and deposit into your account.
If you are pivoting between STR and MTR, just be sure to check your local regulations for any STR ordinances! Otherwise, it is simple to toggle between the strategies. You'll simply be adjusting your minimum stay.
I do agree with the other posters that you will need to send a lease for longer stays, so familiarize yourself with how to send one electronically. I use Apartments.com and Avail.co and they are both very user-friendly. Best of luck!
Real Estate Agent · Sammamish, 🌧️ Seattle Investor-Agent | 🤑 Helped 400+ Clients Invest in Real Estate | 🏘️ Owns 23 WA Rentals & Airbnbs | 🏗️ Built 5 DADU's | 📈 You Can Do It Too · Member since 2016 · 725 posts · 3k+ votes
In my opinion you really don't need rental software if you have less than 2 units on MTR or LTR model. If you want to set something up go with a lightweight solution like Cozy (Appartments.com) or Avail. For STR's you should definitely use rental software - we like Hospitable and Guesty.
PS - what were you planning on doing when purchasing it? I'd stay the course with whatever your original numbers and investing strategy was when you were acquiring the property, unless something significant has changed.
My husband and I do both STR and MTR with fully furnished units, and sometimes within the same unit. From our experience, it's not very difficult to switch from one to the other. E.g. Use STR to fill in vacancies between MTR, or during the summer when rates are highest.
I've listed some of the pros and cons below.
STR Pros - Higher rates, higher upside if fully occupied - More flexibility to adjust rates depending on time of year
Cons - More time consuming (both from filling vacancies and preparing for and onboarding new tenants) - Potentially, more volatility in cashflow
MTR Pros - Less volatility, steadier cashflow - Less time spent finding new tenants - Attract different types of tenants like traveling nurses, who are high quality
Cons - Can't command as high of rates as STR, but still higher than LTR - Harder to take advantage of seasonal increases in rates during Seattle summers
For my short term, I use Hostaway and love it. They have features for both STR and MTR. It can be rather expensive / cost prohibitive at just 1 unit, but it still can be very beneficial.
What are you looking for your property management software to do? In my experience most people end up using a combination of systems. Property management can mean anything from managing your listing, calendar, guest messaging, messages to team members, guest vetting, collecting payments, managing leases, issuing refunds, manages taxes due, tracking maintenance requests etc etc. I use a combo of Airbnb & VRBO, Furnished Finder, Hospitable, Keycheck and Avail.co. for my MTR and STR. Many people pivot between MTR and STR so long as their jurisdiction allows it.
Yes you can. Both short-term rentals and midterm rentals are quite saturated though. The peak seasons are spring and summer. Winters are pretty bad for all types of rentals. Desperate STR and MTR owners will price their rentals even below the unfurnished long term rental rate due to oversupply. You can also look into just operating it as a long-term rental.
STR and MTR are the best methods to still have cash flow where interest rates are at. I do recommend staying outside of Seattle to scale your STR and MTR methods, that's due to heavy regulations in Seattle.
I personally have a triplex In Edgewood WA, I run all three units as MTRs. The cash flow and income continue to exceed all expectations. The cash on cash returns, when you FHA owner-occupied for a year, is the best way to leverage your down payment. I also recommend reading the book (30 Day Stay) the author is from Seattle and makes great points about the benefits of MTR vs STR.
Airbnb and VRBO have a calendar link where you don't need to use platforms like Gustily. You won't need a third-party platform till you have a large number of MTRs and STRs. I highly recommend outsourcing the cleaning and turnover and managing the rest yourself. If you need a recommendation for cleaners let me know, the company I'm using does a great job.
Let me know when you are ready to find another property or if have any questions in general would love to connect.