First STR : Davenport, FL vs NW Arkansas

[Thivya Ashok Kumar]

Hey everyone 👋

I’m exploring two regions for my first short-term rental investment and wanted to hear real experiences and perspectives from those who’ve hosted or owned there.

Markets I’m comparing:

• Davenport, FL (Disney / Orlando corridor)
• Northwest Arkansas (Fayetteville / Prairie Grove / Siloam Springs area)

If you’ve operated in either market, I’d love to hear:

• How’s occupancy and seasonality been lately?
• Are regulations tightening or still friendly toward STRs?
• What do you like or dislike about running an STR there?
• Any advice for someone deciding between these two areas?

Thanks in advance and I really value firsthand insights more than what spreadsheets say!