Besides Interest Rates, What Keeps You Working With the Same Lending Partner?

Question

Communication? Reliability? Speed? Flexibility? What matters most to you?

Vijay Friedman · Answer

@Linda MurrayFor me, responsiveness and consistency are at the top of the list. A lender who communicates clearly, closes on time, and is upfront when a deal has challenges is usually worth far more than saving a small amount on rate. Reliability tends to build long-term partnerships.

Frank McGovern · Answer

@Stuart Udis nailed it. I value partnership. That comes with every other trait here. I text my main contact at the lender. Sometimes on Saturdays at 8pm. He works deals for me knowing I perform and what my goals are. This is huge. I don't want headaches, I want execution.

in addition, the point about already having tons of information on me and prior deals is huge. I don't want to waste time answering questions for someone new.

Olayinka Oyewole · Answer

"Reliability" It is rare to find someone to trust and who is actually good at he/she does.

Ravi Kaku · Answer

From what I've seen working with investors, reliability is usually #1.

A slightly lower rate doesn't help if a lender misses a closing, changes terms at the last minute, or doesn't understand how investment deals work. Most experienced investors I've worked with value predictability over saving a fraction of a point.

The qualities that seem to matter most are:

• Clear and proactive communication.
• Speed when time matters.
• Consistent underwriting with no surprises.
• Flexibility to understand the deal, not just check boxes.
• Confidence that the lender will perform on every transaction.

I'm curious if everyone else feels the same. If you had to rank them, would you put reliability ahead of pricing, or is there something else that's even more important?

Stuart Udis · Answer

Relationship lending is one of the most undervalued aspects of the business. It's not about chasing the lowest rate or the easiest approval process. It's about partnering with lenders who will stand by you when things don't go according to plan.

That trust is built over time, which is why community and regional banks deserve far more attention than they often receive. Put in the effort to build real relationships with them.  If you consistently do what you say you're going to do, communicate openly, and repay your loans, you'll find your ability to originate new deals eventually outpaces the strength of your balance sheet because its more about the relationship than checking specific boxes on an application.

In my experience, the best lenders aren't just capital providers, they're long-term partners who understand the realities of the business and are willing to work through challenges alongside the borrower. Or alternatively, willing to buy into an investment thesis that may not have strong comparables to support the project but believe in the thesis behind the housing product you want to deliver. I originate tens of millions in loans today with the same bankers who originated the first $100K loans for me 13 years ago. Had I not put the effort in with the relationship-based community banks early on,  I doubt I would have been able to fund many of the transactions that were critical to my growth as a real estate investor/developer.

Jimmy Lieu · Answer

For me it's communication and reliability, hands down. A lender who answers the phone, gives realistic timelines, and keeps me updated throughout underwriting is worth far more than saving an eighth of a point on the rate. Deals can fall apart quickly when there's poor communication or last-minute surprises. Speed and consistency are right behind that, especially if you're buying investment properties where timing matters. A lender who closes on time and does what they say they'll do is someone I'll keep coming back to. Happy to connect and answer any questions you have!

Andrew Postell · Answer

@Linda Murray good question and @Ashley Kehr hit on something.  The 2 biggest complaints in the lending industry are "I can't get ahold of my Loan Officer" and "they keep asking me for the same things over and over again". Now, this is a super important question and it doesn't just apply to lenders.  How do you know that a contractor is any good?  An electrician?  A title company?  Anything?  Even if they do have 20 years experience...how do you know really?  And while nothing is foolproof the most consistent method of finding good vendors is relying on OTHER real estate investors that have worked with those vendors.  This is why we network with other real estate investors - kind of like what you are doing here!

So, let's try some local real estate meetup groups. Meetup.com is a good resource for those but some of the groups will also post here on Bigger Pockets Marketplace too. Even facebook might have some good local groups for you. Some of those facebook groups have thousands of members. The priority is consistent recommendations from active investors.  Oh, eventbrite too. But post locally for this. That’s the best bet.

Bryce Alexander · Answer

Great question, and Jay's 30-year banker relationship says it all. Beyond rate, what keeps investors with me is predictability: honest prepay disclosure up front, no surprise on the prepayment structure at lock, and quick honest answers including a fast no when a deal does not work. Rate matters, but a lender who tells you early that your 2-year prepay is actually pricing as a 5-year saves you more heartburn than a few basis points ever will. Speed and reliability compound over a portfolio, because the lender who already knows how you operate closes your next one faster. Glad to be a second set of eyes on any scenario.

Besides Interest Rates, What Keeps You Working With the Same Lending Partner?

Most Popular Reply